Cognitive orientation and the prediction of decisions in a medical examination context

Abstract

From the theory of cognitive orientation (Kreitler and Kreitler 1976, 1982) we derived that scores of cognitive orientation would predict the decision of women to go or not to go to a medical examination for cancer. We tested three alternative methods in addition to the standard method recommended by Kreitler and Kreitler. These four methods represent different assumptions which one can derive from the theory. On the basis of 25 interviews we developed the preliminary questionnaire of beliefs associated with the examination for early detection of cancer. The data of Study 1(N = 72) were used for item analysis as well as testing retest reliability and predicting decisions. In Study 2 (N = 142) the results could be replicated. The Likert‐scales for assessing the four components of cognitive orientation proved to be highly retest reliable. Predictions of decisions could be made nearly equally well by each of the four methods derived from the theory of cognitive orientation.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Drechsler

Bruner

Kreitler

(1987). ‘Cognitive antecedents of coronary heart disease’, Social Science and Medicine, 24:581–588.

Haye

De la Westhoff

(1987). ‘Psychologische Vorschläge zur Erhöhung der Teilnahme an Krebsfüherkennungs‐Untersuchungen [Psychological suggestions for increasing participation in the programme for early detection of cancer],’ Mitteilungsdienst der Gesellschaft zur Bekämpfung der Krebskrankheiten Nordrhein‐Westfalen e. V., 15:27–29.

Hornung

(1986).Krebs: Wissen, Einstellungen und präventives Verhalten der Bevölkerung [Cancer: People's knowledge, attitudes, and preventive behaviour], Huber, Bern.

Kreitler

(1976). The Theory of Cognitive Orientation and Behavior, Springer, New York.

Kreitler

(1982). ‘The theory of cognitive orientation: widening the scope of behavior prediction’. In: Maher, B. and Maher, W.B. (Eds). Progress in Experimental Personality Research, Vol. II, pp.101–169, Academic Press, New York.

Kreitler

Carasso

(1987). ‘Cognitive orientation as predictor of pain relief following acupuncture’, Pain, 28:323–341.

Verres

(1986). Krebs und Angst: Subjektive Theorien von Laien über Entstehung, Vorsorge, Früherkennung, Behandlung und die psychosozialen Folgen von Krebserkran‐kungen[Cancer and anxiety: Laymen's subjective theories about the nature, prevention, early detection, cure and psychosocial consequences of suffering from cancer], Springer, Berlin.

Westhoff

(1985). Erwartungen und Entscheidungen [Expectations and decisions], Springer, Berlin.

Westhoff

(1989). ‘ Expectations and decisions’. In: Upmeyer, A. (Ed), Attitudes and Behavioral Decisions, Springer, New York, pp.183–216.

10.

Westhoff

Berka

H.‐H.

(1987). ‘Bedingungen des Zusammenhangs zwischen Erwartungen und Verhalten’ [Prerequisites of the relation between expectations and decisions], Schweizerische Zeitschrift für Psychologie und ihre Anwendungen, 45:209–217.

11.

Westhoff

de la Haye

(1987).Erwartungen und Überzeugungen von Frauen zur Krebsfrüherkennungsuntersuchung' [Women's expectations and beliefs concerning the examination for the early detection of cancer], Psychotherapie, Psychosomatik, Medizi‐nische Psychologie, 37:423–128.

12.

Zakay

(1976). 'Decision by Meaning: A Decision Making Model Based on the Cognitive Orientation Theory', Unpublished Ph.D. Dissertation, Tel‐Aviv University, Israel.