DSM‐IV personality disorders and the Five‐Factor Model of personality: a multi‐method examination of domain‐ and facet‐level predictions

Abstract

The personality disorder classification system (Axis II) in the various versions of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manuals of Mental Disorders (DSM) has been the target of repeated criticism, with conceptual analysis and empirical evidence documenting its flaws. In response, many have proposed alternative approaches for the assessment of personality psychopathology, including the application of the Five‐Factor Model of personality (FFM). Many remain sceptical, however, as to whether domain and facet traits from a model of general personality functioning can be successfully applied to clinical patients with personality disorders (PDs). In this study, with a sample of psychiatric patients (n = 115), personality disorder symptoms corresponding to each of the 10 PDs were successfully predicted by the facet and domain traits of the FFM, as measured by a semi‐structured interview, the Structured Interview for the Five Factor Model (SIFFM; Trull & Widiger, 1997) and a self‐report questionnaire, the Revised NEO Personality Inventory (NEO PI‐R; Costa and McCrae, 1992). These results provide support for the perspective that personality psychopathology can be captured by general personality dimensions. The FFM has the potential to provide a valid and scientifically sound framework from which to assess personality psychopathology, in a way that covers most of the domains conceptualized in DSM while transcending the limitations of the current categorical approach to these disorders. Copyright © 2005 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alden

L. E.

Laposa

J. M.

Taylor

C. T.

Ryder

A. G.

(2002).Avoidant personality disorder: Current status and future directions. Journal of Personality Disorders, 16,1–29.

American Psychiatric Association (APA). (1980). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders(3rd ed.). Washington, DC: Author.

American Psychiatric Association (APA). (2000). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders(4th edn., Text Revision). Washington, DC: Author.

Axelrod

S. R.

Widiger

T. A.

Trull

T. J.

Corbitt

E. M.

(1997).Relations of five‐factor model antagonism facets with personality disorder symptomatology. Journal of Personality Assessment, 69,297–313.

Bagby

R. M.

Bindseill

K. D.

Rector

N. A.

Schuller

D. R.

Joffe

R. J.

Young

L. T.

Seeman

M. V.

Cooke

R. G.

(1997).The relationship between the five‐factor model of personality and unipolar, bipolar, and schizophrenia. Psychiatry Research, 70,83–94.

Bagby

R. M.

Costa

P. T.

McCrae

R. R.

Livesley

W. J.

Kennedy

S. H.

Levitan

R. D.

Levitt

A. J.

Joffe

R. T.

Young

L. T.

(1999).Replicating the five factor model of personality in a psychiatric sample. Personality and Individual Differences, 27,1135–1139.

Bagby

R. M.

Schuller

D. R.

Marshall

M. B.

Ryder

A. G.

(2004).Depressive Personality Disorder: Rates of comorbidity with personality disorders and relations to the Five‐Factor Model of Personality. Journal of Personality Disorders, 18,542–554.

Blais

M. A.

(1997).Clinician ratings of the five‐factor model of personality and the DSM‐IV personality disorders. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 185,388–393.

Bornstein

R. F.

(2003).Behaviorally referenced experimentation and symptom validation: A paradigm for 21st century personality disorder research. Journal of Personality Disorders, 17,1–18.

10.

Briggs

S. R.

Cheek

J. M.

(1986).The role of factor analysis in the development and evaluation of personality scales. Journal of Personality, 54,106–148.

11.

Campbell

D. T.

Fiske

D. W.

(1959).Convergent and discriminant validation by the multitrait–multimethod matrix. Psychological Bulletin, 56,81–105.

12.

Carey

K. B.

(1994).Use of the Structured Clinical Interview for DSM‐III‐R Personality Questionnaire in the presence of severe axis I disorders: A cautionary note. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 182,669–671.

13.

Clark

L. A.

(1990). Toward a consensual set of symptom clusters for the assessment of personality disorder. In J. N. Butcher , & C. D. Spielberger (Eds.), Advances in personality assessment(Vol. 8). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.

14.

Clark

L. A.

Livesley

W. J.

Morey

(1997).Personality disorder assessment: The challenge of construct validity. Journal of Personality Disorders, 11,205–231.

15.

Clark

L. A.

McEwen

J. L.

Collard

L. M.

Hickok

L. G.

(1993).Symptoms and traits of personality disorder: Two new methods for their assessment. Psychological Assessment, 5,81–91.

16.

Cloninger

C. R.

(1987).A systematic method for clinical description and classification of personality variants. Archives of General Psychiatry, 44,573–588.

17.

Cloninger

C. R.

Svrakic

D. M.

Przybeck

T. R.

(1993).A psychobiological model of temperament and character. Archives of General Psychiatry, 50,975–990.

18.

Costa

P. T.

McCrae

R. R.

(1992). Revised NEO Personality Inventory: Professional manual. Odessa, FL: Psychological Assessment Resources.

19.

Costa

P. T.

McCrae

R. R.

(1994). ‘Set like plaster’? Evidence for the stability of adult personality. In T. Heatherton , & J. Weinberger (Eds.), Can personality change? (pp.21–40). Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.

20.

Costa

P. T.

Widiger

T. A.

(2002). Personality disorders and the five‐factor model of personality(2nd ed.). Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.

21.

Dyce

J. A.

O'Connor

B. P.

(1998).Personality disorders and the five‐factor model: A test of the facet‐level predictions. Journal of Personality Disorders, 12,31–45.

22.

Ekselius

Lindstrom

von Knorring

Bodlund

Kullgren

(1994).SCID II interviews and the SCID Screen questionnaire as diagnostic tools for personality disorders in DSM‐III‐R. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 90,120–123.

23.

First

M. B.

Gibbon

Spitzer

R. L.

Williams

J. B. W.

Benjamin

L. S.

(1997a). Structured Clinical Interview for DSM‐IV Axis II Personality Disorders. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press.

24.

First

M. B.

Gibbon

Spitzer

R. L.

Williams

J. B. W.

Benjamin

L. S.

(1997b). Structured Clinical Interview for DSM‐IV Axis II Personality Disorders Self‐Report. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press.

25.

First

M. B.

Spitzer

R. L.

Gibbon

Williams

J. B.

W. (1995). Structured Clinical Interview for DSM‐IV Axis I Disorders—Patient edition (Version 2.0). New York: New York Biometrics Research Department.

26.

Frances

Widiger

T. A.

(1986). Methodological issues in personality disorder diagnosis. In T. Millon , & G. L. Klerman (Eds.), Contemporary directions in psychopathology: Toward the DSM‐IV(pp.381–400). New York, NY: Guilford Press.

27.

Haigler

E. D.

Widiger

T. A.

(2001).Experimental manipulation of NEO‐PI‐R items. Journal of Personality Assessment, 77,339–358.

28.

Harkness

A. R.

(1992).Fundamental topics in the personality disorders: Candidate trait dimensions from lower regions of the hierarchy. Psychological Assessment, 4,251–259.

29.

Harkness

A. R.

McNulty

J. L.

Ben‐Porath

Y. S.

(1995).The Personality Psychopathology Five (PSY‐5): Constructs and MMPI‐2 scales. Psychological Assessment, 7,104–114.

30.

Huprich

S. K.

(2003).Evaluating NEO Personality Inventory—Revised profiles in veterans with personality disorders. Journal of Personality Disorders, 17,33–44.

31.

Hyer

Braswell

Albrecht

Boyd

Boudewyns

Talbert

(1994).Relationship of NEO‐PI to personality styles and severity of trauma in chronic PTSD victims. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 50,699–707.

32.

Jacobsberg

Perry

Frances

(1995).Diagnostic agreement between the SCID‐II screening questionnaire and the personality disorder examination. Journal of Personality Assessment, 65,428–433.

33.

Jang

K. L.

McCrae

R. R.

Angleitner

Riemann

Livesley

W. J.

(1998).Heritability of facets‐level traits in a cross‐cultural twin sample: Support for a hierarchical model of personality. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 74,1556–1565.

34.

John

O. P.

Srivastava

(1999). The big five trait taxonomy: History, measurement, and theoretical perspectives. In L. A. Pervin , & O. P. John (Eds.), Handbook of personality: Theory and research(2nd ed., pp.102–138). New York: Guilford.

35.

Livesley

W. J.

(1991).Classifying personality disorders: Ideal types, prototypes, or dimensions? Journal of Personality Disorders, 5,52–59.

36.

Livesley

W. J.

(1995). Past achievements and future directions. In W. J. Livesley (Ed.), The DSM‐IV personality disorders(pp.497–505). New York: Guilford.

37.

Livesley

W. J.

(1998).Suggestions for a framework for an empirically based classification of personality disorder. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, 43,137–147.

38.

Livesley

W. J.

Jackson

D. N.

Schroeder

M. L.

(1989).A study of the factorial structure of personality psychopathology. Journal of Personality Disorders, 3,292–306.

39.

Livesley

W. J.

Jackson

D. N.

Schroeder

M. L.

(1991).Dimensions of personality psychopathology. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, 36,557–562.

40.

Lynam

D. R.

Widiger

T. A.

(2001).Using the five‐factor model to represent the DSM‐IV personality disorders: An expert consensus approach. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 110,401–412.

41.

McCrae

R. R.

Allik

(2002). The Five‐Factor Model across cultures. New York: Kluwer–Plenum.

42.

McCrae

R. R.

Costa

P. T.

(1997).Personality trait structure as a human universal. American Psychologist, 52,509–516.

43.

McCrae

R. R.

Costa

P. T.

(1999). A five‐factor theory of personality. In L. A. Pervin , & O. P. John (Eds.), Handbook of personality: Theory and research(2nd ed., pp.130–153). New York: Guilford.

44.

Miller

J. D.

Pilkonis

P. A.

Morse

J. Q.

(2004a).Five factor model prototypes for personality disorders: The utility of self‐reports and observer ratings. Assessment, 11,127–138.

45.

Miller

J. D.

Reynolds

S. K.

Pilkonis

P. A.

(2004b).The validity of the five‐factor model prototypes for personality disorders in two clinical samples. Psychological Assessment, 16,310–322.

46.

Millon

Davis

R. D.

Millon

Wenger

Van Zuilen

M. H.

Fuchs

Millon

R. B.

(1994). Disorders of personality. DSM‐IV and beyond. New York: Wiley.

47.

Morey

L. C.

Gunderson

Quigley

B. D.

Lyons

(2000).Dimensions and categories: The ‘Big Five’ factors and the DSM personality disorders. Assessment, 7,203–216.

48.

Neal

L. A.

Fox

Carroll

Holden

Barnes

(1997).Development and validation of a computerized screening test for personality disorders in DSM‐III‐R. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 95,351–356.

49.

Nunnally

J. C.

Bernstein

I. H.

(1994). Psychometric theory(3rd ed.). New York: McGraw‐Hill.

50.

Reynolds

S. K.

Clark

L. A.

(2001).Predicting dimensions of personality disorder from domains and facets of the five‐factor model. Journal of Personality, 69,199–222.

51.

Ryder

A. G.

Bagby

R. M.

Schuller

D. R.

(2002).The overlap of depressive personality disorder and dysthymia: A categorical problem with a dimensional solution. Harvard Review of Psychiatry, 10,337–352.

52.

Shiner

R. L.

(1998).How shall we speak of children's personalities in middle childhood? A preliminary taxonomy. Psychological Bulletin, 124,308–322.

53.

Trull

T. J.

Useda

J. D.

Costa

P. T.

McCrae

R. R.

(1995).Comparison of the MMPI‐2 Personality Psychopathology Five (PSY‐5), the NEO‐PI, and NEO‐PI‐R. Psychological Assessment, 7,508–516.

54.

Trull

T. J.

Widiger

T. A.

(1997). Structured interview for the five‐factor model of personality: Professional manual. Odessa, FL: Psychological Assessment Resources.

55.

Trull

T. J.

Widiger

T. A.

Burr

(2001).A structured interview for the assessment of the five‐factor model of personality: Facet‐level relations to the Axis II personality dimensions. Journal of Personality Disorders, 69,175–198.

56.

Trull

T. J.

Widiger

T. A.

Useda

J. D.

Holcomb

Doan

B. T.

Axelrod

S. R.

Stern

B. L.

Gershuny

B. S.

(1998).A structured interview for the assessment of the five‐factor model of personality. Psychological Assessment, 10,229–240.

57.

Westen

Arkowitz‐Westen

(1998).Limitations of axis II in diagnosing personality pathology in clinical practice. American Journal of Psychiatry, 155,1767–1771.

58.

Westen

Shedler

(1999a).Revising and assessing axis II: I—Developing a clinically and empirically valid assessment method. American Journal of Psychiatry, 156,258–272.

59.

Westen

Shedler

(1999b).Revising and assessing axis II: II—Toward an empirically based and clinically useful classification of personality disorders. American Journal of Psychiatry, 156,273–285.

60.

Widiger

T. A.

Frances

A. J.

(2002). Toward a dimensional model for the personality disorders. In P. T. Costa, Jr. , & T. A. Widiger (Eds.), Personality disorders and the five‐factor model of personality(pp.23–44). Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.

61.

Widiger

T. A.

Trull

T. J.

Clarkin

J. F.

Sanderson

Costa

P. T.

(1994). A description of the DSM‐III‐R and DSM‐IV personality disorders with the five‐factor model of personality. In P. T. Costa, Jr. , & T. A. Widiger (Eds.), Personality disorders and the five‐factor model of personality(pp.41–56). Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.

62.

Widiger

T. A.

Trull

T. J.

Clarkin

J. F.

Sanderson

Costa

P. T.

(2002). A description of the DSM‐IV personality disorders with the five‐factor model of personality. In P. T. Costa, Jr. , & T. A. Widiger (Eds.), Personality disorders and the five‐factor model of personality(2nd ed., pp.9–99). Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.

63.

Yang

Dai

Yao

Cai.

Gao

McCrae

R. R.

Costa

P. T.

(2002). Personality disorders and the five‐factor model of personality in Chinese psychiatric patients. In P. T. Costa, Jr. , & T. A. Widiger (Eds.), Personality disorders and the five‐factor model of personality(pp.215–221). Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.