Broad versus narrow traits: Conscientiousness and honesty–humility as predictors of academic criteria

Abstract

Recent research has suggested that the six–dimensional personality model, and especially the dimension Honesty–Humility/Integrity, adds incremental validity to the prediction of important criteria. We expected both this dimension and the dimension Conscientiousness to explain incremental variance in two academic criteria, namely grade point average (GPA) and counterproductive academic behaviour (CAB). In addition, we expected the more specific, so–called narrow traits of Conscientiousness and Honesty–Humility/Integrity to be stronger predictors of academic criteria than the broad traits. To test these expectations, two studies were conducted using the HEXACO Personality Inventory Revised (HEXACO–PI–R) and the Multicultural Personality Test—Big Six (MPT–BS). The results confirmed our expectations and suggest that academic criteria may be predicted with greater accuracy by focusing on the narrow traits of Conscientiousness and Honesty–Humility/Integrity. Copyright © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Keywords

Conscientiousness Honesty-Humility Integrity bandwidth-fidelity grade point average counterproductive academic behaviour

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ashton

M. C.

(1998).Personality and job performance: The importance of narrow traits.Journal of Organizational Behavior,19,289–303.

Ashton

M. C.

, & Lee

(2005).Honesty–Humility, the Big Five, and the Five–Factor Model.Journal of Personality,73,1321–1353.

Ashton

M. C.

, & Lee

(2007).Empirical, theoretical, and practical advantages of the HEXACO model of personality structure.Personality and Social Psychology Review,11,150–166.

Ashton

M. C.

, & Lee

(2008).The prediction of Honesty–Humility–related criteria by the HEXACO and Five–Factor Models of personality.Journal of Research in Personality,42,1216–1228.

Ashton

M. C.

, & Lee

(2009).The HEXACO–60: A short measure of the major dimensions of personality.Journal of Personality Assessment,91,340–345.

Ashton

M. C.

, Lee

, Perugini

, Szarota

, De Vries

R. E.

, Di Blas

, et al.(2004).A six–factor structure of personality–descriptive adjectives: Solutions from psycholexical studies in seven languages.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,86,356–366.

Berry

C. M.

, Sackett

P. R.

, & Wiemann

S. A.

(2007).A review of recent developments in integrity test research.Personnel Psychology,60,271–301.

Butler

A. B.

(2007).Job characteristics and college performance and attitudes: A model of work–school conflict and facilitation.Journal of Applied Psychology,92,500–510.

Chamorro–Premuzic

, & Furnham

(2003a).Personality predicts academic performance: Evidence from two longitudinal university samples.Journal of Research in Personality,37,319–338.

10.

Chamorro–Premuzic

, & Furnham

(2003b).Personality traits and academic examination performance.European Journal of Personality,17,237–250.

11.

Conard

M. A.

(2006).Aptitude is not enough: How personality and behavior predict academic performance.Journal of Research in Personality,40,339–346.

12.

Conte

J. M.

, & Jacobs

R. R.

(2003).Validity evidence linking polychronicity and Big Five personality dimensions to absence, lateness, and supervisory performance ratings.Human Performance,16,107–129.

13.

Costa

P. T.

, & McCrae

R. R.

(1992).NEO Personality Inventory—Revised (NEO–PI–R) and NEO Five–Factor Inventory (NEO–FFI) professional manual.Odessa, FL:Psychological Assessment Resources.

14.

Cronbach

L. J.

, & Gleser

C. C.

(1965).Psychological tests and personnel decisions (2nd ed.).Urbana:University of Illinois Press.

15.

De Vries

R. E.

, Ashton

M. C.

, & Lee

(2009).De zes belangrijkste persoonlijkheidsdimensies en de HEXACO Persoonlijkheidsvragenlijst [The six most important personality dimensions and the HEXACO Personality Inventory].Gedrag & Organisatie,22,232–274.

16.

De Vries

R. E.

, De Vries

, De Hoogh

, & Feij

(2009).More than the Big Five: Egoism and the HEXACO model of personality.European Journal of Personality,23,635–654.

17.

De Vries

R. E.

, De Vries

, & Feij

J. A.

(2009).Sensation seeking, risk–taking, and the HEXACO model of personality.Personality and Individual Differences,47,536–540.

18.

Duckworth

A. L.

, & Seligman

M. E. P.

(2005).Self–discipline outdoes IQ in predicting academic performance of adolescents.Psychological Science,16,939–944.

19.

Fallon

J. D.

, Avis

J. M.

, Kudisch

J. D.

, Gornet

T. P.

, & Frost

(2000).Conscientiousness as a predictor of productive and counterproductive behaviors.Journal of Business and Psychology,15,339–349.

20.

Furnham

, & Chamorro–Premuzic

(2004).Personality and intelligence as predictors of statistics examination grades.Personality and Individual Differences,37,943–955.

21.

Furnham

, & Monsen

(2009).Personality traits and intelligence predict academic school grades.Learning and Individual Differences,19,28–33.

22.

Goff

, & Ackerman

P. L.

(1992).Personality–intelligence relations: Assessment of typical intellectual engagement.Journal of Educational Psychology,84,537–552.

23.

Hakstian

A. R.

, Farrell

, & Tweed

R. G.

(2002).The assessment of counterproductive tendencies by means of the California Psychological Inventory.International Journal of Selection and Assessment,10,58–86.

24.

Hong

R. Y.

, Paunonen

S. V.

, & Slade

H. P.

(2008).Big Five personality factors and the prediction of behavior: A multitrait–multimethod approach.Personality and Individual Differences,45,160–166.

25.

Johnson

J. W.

(2000).A heuristic method for estimating the relative weight of predictor variables in multiple regression.Multivariate Behavioral Research,35,1–19.

26.

Kennedy

E. J.

, Lawton

, & Plumlee

E. L.

(2002).Blissful ignorance: The problem of unrecognized incompetence and academic performance.Journal of Marketing Education,24,243–252.

27.

LeBreton

J. M.

, & Tonidandel

(2008).Multivariate relative importance: Extending relative weight analysis to multivariate criterion spaces.Journal of Applied Psychology,93,329–345.

28.

Lee

, & Ashton

M. C.

(2004).Psychometric properties of the HEXACO Personality Inventory.Multivariate Behavioral Research,39,329–358.

29.

Lee

, & Ashton

M. C.

(2008).The HEXACO personality factors in the indigenous personality lexicons of English and 11 other languages.Journal of Personality,76,1001–1053.

30.

Lee

, Ashton

M. C.

, & De Vries

R. E.

(2005).Predicting workplace delinquency and integrity with the HEXACO and Five–Factor models of personality structure.Human Performance,18,179–197.

31.

Lee

, Ashton

M. C.

, & Shin

K. H.

(2005).Personality correlates of workplace anti–social behavior.Applied Psychology: An International Review,54,81–98.

32.

Lee

, Ogunfowora

, & Ashton

M. C.

(2005).Personality traits beyond the Big Five: Are they within the HEXACO space?Journal of Personality,73,1437–1463.

33.

Marcus

, Lee

, & Ashton

M. C.

(2007).Personality dimensions explaining relationships between integrity tests and counterproductive behavior: Big Five, or one in addition?Personnel Psychology,60,1–34.

34.

Marcus

, Wagner

, Poole

, Powell

D. M.

, & Carswell

(2009).The relationship of GMA to counterproductive work behavior revisited.European Journal of Personality,23,489–507.

35.

NOA.(2009).Handleiding Multiculturele Persoonlijkheids Test – Big Six [Manual Multicultural Personality Test – Big Six].Amsterdam:NOA BV.

36.

Noftle

E. E.

, & Robins

R. W.

(2007).Personality predictors of academic outcomes: Big Five correlates of GPA and SAT scores.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,93,116–130.

37.

Nonis

, & Swift

C. O.

(2001).An examination of the relationship between academic dishonesty and workplace dishonesty: A multicampus Investigation.Journal of Education for Business,77,69–77.

38.

O'Connor

M. C.

, & Paunonen

S. V.

(2007).Big Five personality predictors of post–secondary academic performance.Personality and Individual Differences,43,971–990.

39.

Ones

D. S.

, & Viswesvaran

(1996).Bandwidth–fidelity dilemma in personality measurement for personnel selection.Journal of Organizational Behavior,17,609–626.

40.

Ones

D. S.

, Viswesvaran

, & Reiss

A. D.

(1996).Role of social desirability in personality testing for personnel selection: The red herring.Journal of Applied Psychology,81,660–679.

41.

Ones

D. S.

, Viswesvaran

, & Schmidt

F. L.

(1993).Comprehensive meta–analysis of integrity test validities: Findings and implications for personnel selection and theories of job performance.Journal of Applied Psychology,78,679–703.

42.

Paunonen

S. V.

(2003).Big Five factors of personality and replicated predictions of behavior.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,84,411–424.

43.

Paunonen

S. V.

, & Ashton

M. C.

(2001a).Big Five factors and facets and the prediction of behavior.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,81,524–539.

44.

Paunonen

S. V.

, & Ashton

M. C.

(2001b).Big Five predictors of academic achievement.Journal of Research in Personality,35,78–90.

45.

Paunonen

S. V.

, & Hong

R. Y.

(2010).Self–efficacy and the prediction of domain–specific cognitive abilities.Journal of Personality,78,339–360.

46.

Paunonen

S. V.

, Rothstein

M. G.

, & Jackson

D. N.

(1999).Narrow reasoning about the use of broad personality measures for personnel selection.Journal of Organizational Behavior,20,389–405.

47.

Poropat

A. E.

(2009).A meta–analysis of the Five–Factor Model of personality and academic performance.Psychological Bulletin,135,322–338.

48.

Reisert

, & Conte

J. M.

(2004).Relationships between Conscientiousness sub–factors and constructive and destructive behavioral intentions.Journal of Business and Psychology,19,69–84.

49.

Richardson

, & Abraham

(2009).Conscientiousness and achievement motivation predict performance.European Journal of Personality,23,589–605.

50.

Robins

R. W.

, & Beer

J. S.

(2001).Positive illusions about the self: Short–term benefits and long–term costs.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,80,340–352.

51.

Robinson

S. L.

, & Bennett

R. J.

(1995).A typology of deviant workplace behaviors: A multidimensional scaling study.Academy of Management Journal,38,555–572.

52.

Sackett

P. R.

, Burris

L. R.

, & Callahan

(1989).Integrity testing for personnel selection: An update.Personnel Psychology,42,491–529.

53.

Salgado

J. F.

(2002).The Big Five personality dimensions and counterproductive behaviors.International Journal of Selection and Assessment,10,117–125.

54.

Schmidt

F. L.

, & Hunter

J. E.

(1998).The validity and utility of selection methods in personnel psychology: Practical and theoretical implications of 85 years of research findings.Psychological Bulletin,124,262–274.

55.

Schneider

R. J.

, Hough

L. A.

, & Dunnette

M. D.

(1996).Broadsided by broad traits: How to sink science in five dimensions or less.Journal of Organizational Behavior,17,639–655.

56.

Schouwenburg

H. C.

, & Groenewoud

J. T.

(2001).Study motivation under social temptation; effects of trait procrastination.Personality and Individual Differences,30,229–240.

57.

Ziegler

, Danay

, Schölmerich

, & Bühner

(2010).Predicting academic success with the Big 5 rated from different points of view: Self–rated, other rated and faked.European Journal of Personality,24,1–15.