Heritability in the Era of Molecular Genetics: Some Thoughts for Understanding Genetic Influences on Behavioural Traits

Abstract

Genetic influences on behavioural traits are ubiquitous. When behaviourism was the dominant paradigm in psychology, demonstrations of heritability of behavioural and psychological constructs provided important evidence of its limitations. Now that genetic influences on behavioural traits are generally accepted, we need to recognise the limitations of heritability as an indicator of both the aetiology and likelihood of discovering molecular genetic associations with behavioural traits. We review those limitations and conclude that quantitative genetics and genetically informative research designs are still critical to understanding the roles of gene–environment interplay in developmental processes, though not necessarily in the ways commonly discussed. Copyright © 2011 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Keywords

genetic influences twin study heritability

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Agrawal

, Sartor

C. A.

, Lynskey

M. T.

, Grant

J. D.

, Pergadia

M. L.

, Grucza

, et al. (2009). Evidence for an interaction between age at first drink and genetic influences on DSM–IV alcohol dependence symptoms. Alcoholism, Clinical and Experimental Research, 33, 2047–2056.

Bäckström

, Björklund

, & Larsson

M. R.

(2008). Five–factor inventories have a major general factor related to social desirability which can be reduced by framing items neutrally. Journal of Research in Personality, 43, 335–344.

Barabasi

A.–L.

(2007). Network medicine: from obesity to the “diseaseome”. The New England Journal of Medicine, 357, 404–407.

Bouchard

T. J.

Jr. (2009). Genetic influences on human intelligence (Spearman's g): how much? Annals of Human Biology, 36, 1–17.

Butcher

L. M.

, Davis

O. S.

, Craig

I. W.

, & Plomin

(2008). Genome–wide quantitative trait locus association scan of general cognitive ability using pooled DNA and 500 K single nucleotide polymorphism microarrays. Genes, Brains and Behavior 7, 435–446.

Carey

(1988). Inference about genetic correlations. Behavior Genetics, 18, 329–345.

Caspi

, McClay

, Moffitt

T. E.

, Mill

, Martin

, Craig

I. W.

, et al. (2002). Role of genotype in the cycle of violence in maltreated children. Science, 297, 851–854.

Chakravarti

(1999). Population genetics – making sense out of sequence. Nature Genetics, 21 (supplement), 56–60.

Costa

P. T.

, & McCrae

R. R

. (1992). Revised NEO Personality Inventory (NEO–PI–R) and NEO Five–Factor Inventory (NEO–FFI). Professional Manual. Odessa, FL: Psychological Assessment Resources, Inc.

10.

Coventry

W. L.

, & Keller

M. C.

(2005). Estimating the extent of parameter bias in the classical twin design: a comparison of parameter estimates from extended twin–family and classical twin designs. Twin Research and Human Genetics, 8, 214–223.

11.

Crnokrak

, & Roff

D. A.

(1995). Dominance variance: associations with selection and fitness. Heredity, 75, 530–540.

12.

Davey–Smith

(2010). Mendelian randomization for strengthening causal inference in observational studies: Application to gene x environment interactions. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 5, 527–546.

13.

Deary

I. J.

, Penke

, & Johnson

(2010). The neuroscience of human intelligence differences. Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 11, 201–211.

14.

Eyre–Walker

(2010). Genetic architecture of a complex trait and its implications for fitness and genome–wide association studies. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 107, 1752–1756.

15.

Flint

, & Mackay

T. F. C.

(2009). Genetic architecture of quantitative traits in mice, flies, and humans. Genome Research, 19, 723–733.

16.

Finkel

, Reynolds

C. A.

, McArdle

J. J.

, Hamagami

& Pedersen

N. L.

(2007). Genetic variance in processing speed drives variation in aging of spatial and memory abilities. Developmental Psychology, 45, 820–834.

17.

Fraga

M. F.

, Ballestar

, Paz

M. F.

, Ropero

, Setien

, Ballestar

M. L.

, et al. (2005). Epigenetic differences arise during the lifetime of monozygotic twins. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 102, 10604–10609.

18.

Gärtner

, & Baunack

(1981). Is the similarity of monozygotic twins due to genetic factors alone? Nature, 292, 646–647.

19.

Genetic Investigation of Anthropocentric Traits Consortium (2010). Hundreds of variants clustered in genetic loci and biological pathways affect human height. Nature, doi:10.1038/nature09410.

20.

Gerhart

& Kirschner

(2007). The theory of facilitated variation. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 104, 8582–8589.

21.

Gibson

& Dworkin

(2004). Uncovering cryptic genetic variation. Nature Reviews Genetics, 5, 681–690.

22.

Goh

K.–I.

, Cusick

M. E.

, Valle

, Childs

, Vidal

, & Barabasi

A.–L.

(2007). The human disease network. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 104, 8685–8690.

23.

Gottesman

I. I.

, & Gould

T. D.

(2003). The endophenotype concept in psychiatry: etymology and strategic intentions. The American Journal of Psychiatry, 160, 636–645.

24.

Gudbjartsson

D. F.

, Walters

G. B.

, Thorleifsson

, Stefansson

B. V.

, Halldorsson

, Zusmanovich

S. P.

, et al. (2008). Many sequence variants affecting diversity of adult human height. Nature Genetics, 40, 609–615.

25.

Hartl

D. L.

, & Clark

A. G.

(1997). Principles of population genetics. Sunderland, MA: Sinauer Associates, Inc.

26.

Hicks

B. M.

, South

S. C.

, DiRago

A. C.

, Iacono

W. G.

, & McGue

(2009). Environmental adversity and increasing genetic risk for externalizing disorders. Archives of General Psychiatry, 66, 640–648.

27.

Hill

W. G.

, Goddard

M. E.

, & Visscher

P. M.

(2008). Data and theory point mainly to additive genetic variance for complex traits. PLoS Genetics, 4, 1–10.

28.

Iles

M. M

. (2008). What can genome–wide association studies tell us about the genetics of common disease? PLoS Genetics, 4, e33, 1–9.

29.

International Schizophrenia Consortium (2008). Rare chromosomal deletions and duplications increase risk of schizophrenia. Nature, 455, 237–241.

30.

Irons

D. E.

, McGue

, Iacono

W. G.

, & Oetting

W. S.

(2007). Mendelian randomization: a novel test of the gateway hypothesis and models of gene–environment interplay. Development and Psychopathology, 19, 1181–1195.

31.

Iyengar

S. K.

, & Elston

R. C.

(2007). The genetic basis of complex traits: rare variants of “common gene, common disease”? Methods in Molecular Biology, 376, 71–84.

32.

Jablonka

, & Lamb

M. J.

(2008). Soft inheritance: challenging the modern synthesis. Genetics and Molecular Biology, 31, 389–395.

33.

Johnson

(2007). Genetic and environmental influences on behavior: capturing all the interplay. Psychological Review, 114, 423–440.

34.

Johnson

(in press). What do genes have to do with cognition? In Kreitler

(Ed.), Cognition and Motivation. New York: Cambridge University Press.

35.

Johnson

, Bouchard

T. J.

Jr. , McGue

, Segal

N. L.

, Tellegen

, Keyes

, & Gottesman

I. I.

(2007). Genetic and environmental influences on the Verbal–Perceptual–Image Rotation (VPR) model of the structure of mental abilities in the Minnesota Study of Twins Reared Apart. Intelligence, 35, 542–562.

36.

Johnson

, Deary

I. J.

, & Iacono

W. G.

(2009a). Genetic and environmental influences underlying educational attainment. Intelligence, 37, 466–478.

37.

Johnson

, Deary

I. J.

, McGue

, & Christensen

(2009b). Genetic and environmental links between cognitive and physical functions in old age. Journal of Gerontology – Series B, 64, 65–72.

38.

Johnson

, Gangestad

S. W.

, Segal

N. L.

, & Bouchard

T. J.

Jr. (2008). Heritability of fluctuating asymmetry in a human twin sample. American Journal of Human Biology, 20, 651–658.

39.

Johnson

, Turkheimer

, Gottesman

I. I.

, & Bouchard

T. J.

Jr. (2009c). Beyond heritability: twin studies in behavioral research. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 18, 217–220.

40.

Kaminsky

Z. A.

, Tang

, Wang

S. C.

, Plak

, Oh

G. H. T.

, Wong

G. H. C.

, et al. (2009). DNA methylation profiles in monzygotic and dizygotic twins. Nature Genetics, 41, 241–245.

41.

Keller

M. C.

, Medland

S. E.

, Duncan

L. E.

, Hatemi

P. K.

, Neale

M. C.

, Maes

H. H. M.

, Eaves

L. J.

(2009). Modeling extended twin family data I: Description of the Cascade Model. Twin Research and Human Genetics, 12, 8–18.

42.

Keller

M. C.

, & Miller

G. F.

(2006). Resolving the paradox of common, harmful, heritable mental disorders: which evolutionary genetic models work best? The Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 29, 385–452.

43.

Kendler

K. S.

, & Myers

(2010). The genetic and environmental relationship between major depression and the Five–Factor Model of personality. Psychological Medicine, 40, 801–806.

44.

Kim

, Krege

J. H.

, Kluckman

K. D.

, Hagaman

J. R

, Hodgin

J.B.

, Best

C. F.

, et al. (1995). Genetic control of blood pressure and the angiotensinogen locus. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 92, 2735–2739.

45.

Krege

J. H.

, Kim

H. S.

, Moyer

J. S.

, Jennette

J. C.

, Peng

, Hiller

S. K.

, & Smithies

(1997). Angiotensin–converting–enzyme gene mutations, blood pressures, and cardiovascular homeostasis. Hypertension, 29, 150–157.

46.

Kumar

R. A.

, KaraMohamed

, Sudi

, Conrad

D. F.

, Brune

, Badner

J. A.

, et al. (2008). Recurrent 16p11.2 microdeletions in autism. Human Molecular Genetics, 17, 628–638.

47.

Laurie

C. C.

, Chasalow

S. D.

, LeDeaux

J. R.

, McCarroll

, Bush

, Hauge

, et al. (2004). The genetic architecture of long–term response to selection for oil concentration in the maize kernel. Genetics, 168, 2141–2155.

48.

Le Rouzic

, & Carlborg

(2007). Evolutionary potential of hidden genetic variation. Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 23, 33–37.

49.

Lettre

, Jackson

A. U.

, Gieger

, Schumacher

F. R.

, Berndt

S. I.

, Sanna

, et al. (2008). Identification of ten loci associated with height highlights new biological pathways in human growth. Nature Genetics, 40, 584–591.

50.

Lykken

D. T.

(1982). Research with twins – the concept of emergenesis. Psychophysiology, 19, 361–373.

51.

Maher

(2008). The case of the missing heritability. Nature, 456, 18–21.

52.

Manolio

T. A.

, Collins

F. S.

, Cox

N. J.

, Goldstein

D. B.

, Hindorff

L. A.

, Hunter

D. J.

, et al. (2009). Finding the missing heritability of complex diseases. Nature, 461, 747–753.

53.

McCaffery

J. M.

, Papandonatos

G. D.

, Bond

, Lyons

M. J.

, & Wing

R. R.

(2009). Gene x environment interaction of vigorous exercise and body mass index among male Vietnam–era twins. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 89, 1011–1018.

54.

McClellan

, & King

M. C.

(2010). Why it is time to resequence. Cell, 142, 353–355.

55.

McCrae

R. R.

, Costa

P. T.

, Ostendorf

, Angleitner

, Hrebickova

, Avia

M. D.

, et al. (2000). Nature over nurture: Temperament, personality, and life span development. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 78, 173–186.

56.

McCrae

R. R.

, Kurtz

J. E.

, Yamagata

, & Terracciano

, (2010). Internal consistency, retest reliability, and their implications for personality scale validity. Personality and Social Psychology Review, doi:10.1177/10888868310366253.

57.

Medland

S. E.

, & Keller

M. C.

(2009). Modeling extended twin family data II. Power associated with different family structures. Twin Research and Human Genetics, 12, 19–25.

58.

Merilä

, & Sheldon

B. C.

(1999). Genetic architecture of fitness and non–fitness traits: empirical patterns and development of ideas. Heredity, 83, 103–109.

59.

Mill

, Tang

, Kaminsky

, Khare

, Yazdanpanah

, Bouchard

, et al. (2008). Epigenetic profiling reveals DNA–methylation changes associated with major psychosis. American Journal of Human Genetics, 82, 696–711.

60.

Miller

G. F.

(2007). Sexual selection for moral virtues. The Quarterly Review of Biology, 82, 97–125.

61.

Mitchell

K. J.

(in press). The genetics of neurodevelopmental disease. Current Opinion in Neurobiology.

62.

Morrow

E. M.

, Yoo

S. Y.

, Flavell

S. W.

, Kim

T. K.

, Lin

Y. X.

, Hill

R. S.

, et al. (2008). Identifying autism loci and genes by tracing recent shared ancestry. Science, 321, 218–223.

63.

Musek

(2007). A general factor of personality: evidence for the big one in the five–factor model. Journal of Research in Personality, 41, 1213–1233.

64.

Neale

M. C.

, Rushton

J. P.

, & Fulker

D. W.

(1986). Heritability of item responses on the Eysenck Personality Questionnaire. Personality and Individual Differences, 7, 771–779.

65.

Pak

(2004). The biological standard of living in the two Koreas. Economics and Human Biology, 2, 511–521.

66.

Penke

(2010). Bridging the gap between modern evolutionary psychology and the study of individual differences. In Buss

D. M.

& Hawley

P. H.

(Eds.): The evolution of personality and individual differences (pp. 243–279). New York: Oxford University Press.

67.

Penke

, Denissen

J. J. A.

, & Miller

G. F.

(2007a). Evolution, genes, and inter–disciplinary personality research – Response. European Journal of Personality, 21, 639–665.

68.

Penke

, Denissen

J. J. A.

, & Miller

G. F.

(2007b). The evolutionary genetics of personality. European Journal of Personality, 21, 549–587.

69.

Perlman

, Johnson

, & Iacono

W. G.

(2009). The heritability of P300 amplitude in 18–year–olds is robust to adolescent alcohol use. Psychophysiology, 46, 962–969.

70.

Plomin

, & DeFries

J. C.

(1980). Genetics and intelligence: recent data. Intelligence, 4, 15–24.

71.

Plomin

, DeFries

J. C.

, McClearn

G. E.

, & McGuffin

(2007). Behavioral Genetics, 5th Edition. New York: Worth.

72.

Plomin

, & Foch

T. T.

(1980). A twin study of objectively assessed personality in childhood. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 39, 680–688.

73.

Purcell

(2002). Variance component models for gene–environment interaction in twin analysis. Twin Research, 5, 554–571.

74.

Riemann

, & Kandler

(2010). Construct validation using multitrait–multimethod twin data: the case of a general factor of personality. European Journal of Personality, 24, 258–277.

75.

Roberts

B. W.

, & Jackson

J. J.

(2008). Sociogenomic personality psychology. Journal of Personality, 76, 1523–1544.

76.

Robinson

G. E.

(2004). Beyond nature and nurture. Science, 304, 397–399.

77.

Robinson

G. E.

, Grozinger

C. M.

, & Whitfield

C. W.

(2005). Sociogenomics: Social life in molecular terms. Nature Reviews Genetics, 6, 257–266.

78.

Rushton

J. P.

(1985). Differential K theory: The sociobiology of individual and group differences. Personality and Individual Differences, 6, 441–452.

79.

Rushton

J. P.

, Bons

T. A.

, & Hur

Y.–M.

(2008). The genetics and evolution of the general factor of personality. Journal of Research in Personality, 42, 1173–1185.

80.

Rushton

J. P.

, Brainerd

C. J.

, & Pressley

(1983). Behavioral development and construct validity: the principle of aggregation. Psychological Bulletin, 94, 18–38.

81.

Scarr

& Weinberg

R. A.

(1983). The Minnesota Adoption Studies – genetic–differences and malleability. Child Development, 54, 260–267.

82.

Schwekendiek

(2008). Height and weight differences between North and South Korea. Journal of Biosocial Sciences, doi:10.1017/S002193200800299X.

83.

Sebat

, Lakshmi

, Malhotra

, Troge

, Lese–Martin

, Walsh

, et al. (2007). Strong association of de novo copy number mutations with autism. Science, 316, 445–449.

84.

Spinath

F. M.

, Angleitner

, Borkenau

, Riemann

, & Wolf

(2002a). German Observational Study of Adult Twins: a multimodal investigation of personality, temperament, and cognitive ability. Twin Research, 5, 372–375.

85.

Spinath

F. M.

, Ronald

, Harlaar

, Price

& Plomin

(2003). Phenotypic g early in life: on the etiology of general cognitive ability in a large population sample of twin children aged 2 to 4 years. Intelligence, 31, 195–210.

86.

Spinath

F. M.

, Wolf

, Angleitner

, Borkenau

, & Riemann

(2002b). Genetic and environmental influences on objectively assessed activity level in adults. Personality and Individual Differences, 33, 633–635.

87.

Stefansson

, Rujescu

, Cichon

, Pietilainen

O. P.

, Ingason

, Steinberg

, et al. (2008). Large recurrent microdeletions associated with schizophrenia. Nature, 455, 232–236,

88.

Stirling

D. G.

, Réale

, & Roff

D. A.

(2002). Selection, structure and heritability of behavior. Journal of Evolutionary Biology, 15, 277–289.

89.

Tellegen

, & Waller

N. G.

(2008). Exploring personality through test construction: Development of the Multidimensional Personality Questionnaire. In Boyle

G. J.

, Matthews

, & Saklofske

D. H.

, Handbook of Personality Theory and Testing, Vol. II, Personality Measurement and Assessment (pp. 261–292). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

90.

Turkheimer

(2000). Three laws of behavior genetics and what they mean. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 9, 160–164.

91.

Visscher

P. M.

, Hill

W. G.

, & Wray

N. R.

(2008). Heritability in the genomics era – concepts and misconceptions. Nature Reviews Genetics, 9, 255–266.

92.

Waddington

C. H.

(1953). Genetic assimilation of an acquired character. Evolution, 7, 118–126.

93.

Waddington

C. H.

(1957). The strategy of the genes. New York: Macmillan.

94.

Wallace

, Cesarini

, Lichtenstein

, & Johannesson

(2007). Heritability of ultimate game responder behavior. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 104, 15631–15634.

95.

Walsh

, McClellan

J. M.

, McCarthy

S. E.

, Addington

A. M.

, Pierce

S. B.

, Cooper

G. M.

, et al. (2008). Rare structural variants disrupt multiple genes in neurodevelopmental pathways in schizophrenia. Science, 320, 539–543.

96.

Waterland

R. A.

& Jirtle

R. L.

(2003). Transposable elements: Targets for early nutrition effects on epigenetic gene regulation. Molecular and Cellular Biology, 23, 5293–5300.

97.

Weaver

I. C. G.

, Cervoni

, Champagne

F. A.

, D'Alessio

A. C.

, Sharma

, Seckl

J. R.

, et al. (2004). Epigenetic programming by maternal behavior. Nature Neuroscience, 7, 847–854.

98.

Weedon

M. N.

, & Frayling

T. M.

(2008). Reaching new heights: insights into the genetics of human stature. Trends in Genetics, 24, 595–603.

99.

Weedon

M. N.

, Lango

, Lindgren

C. M.

, Wallace

, Evans

D. M.

, Mangino

, et al. (2008). Genome–wide association analysis identifies 20 loci that influence adult height. Nature Genetics, 40, 575–583.

100.

Wicherts

J. M.

, & Johnson

(2009). Group differences in the heritability of items and test scores. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London – Series B, 276, 2675–2683.

101.

Wong

A. H. C.

, Gottesman

I. I.

, & Petronis

(2005). Phenotypic differences in genetically identical organisms: the epigenetic perspective. Human Molecular Genetics, 14, R11–R18.

102.

Wood

A. C.

, Rijsdijk

, Saudino

K. L.

, Asherson

, & Kuntsi

(2008). High heritability for a composite index of children's activity level measures. Behavior Genetics, 38, 266–276.

103.

, Roos

J. L.

, Levy

, Van Rensburg

E. J.

, Gogos

J. A.

, & Karayiorgou

(2008). Strong association of de novo copy number mutations with sporadic schizophrenia. Nature Genetics, 40, 880–885.

104.

York

T. P. F.

, Miles

, Kendler

K. S.

, Jackson–Cook

, Bowman

M. L.

, & Eaves

(2005). Epistatic and environmental control of genome–wide gene expression. Twin Research, 8, 5–15.