Reconnecting Theory and Practice in Pluralistic Contexts: Issues and Aristotelian Considerations

Abstract

The purpose of this article is to contribute, from a research practitioner perspective, to the theory–practice gap debate in organization studies, focusing on pluralistic contexts such as project organizing. The current debate is introduced; then the features of the two main philosophical traditions (i.e., modernism and postmodernism) are critically summarized. Then, propositions to reconnect theory and practice according to the Aristotelian premodern ethical and practical philosophy are discussed. Some key implications in the following areas are outlined: roles played by practitioners and scholars; emancipatory praxeological style of reasoning; closing the “phronetic gap”; and the development of “good practice,” ethics, and politics.

Keywords

Aristotle practice theory modern postmodern project organizing

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ahola

, Ruuska

, Artto

, & Kujala

(2014). What is project governance and what are its origins? International Journal of Project Management, 32(8), 1321–1332.

Alvesson

, & Deetz

(2000). Doing critical management research. London Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.

Alvesson

, & Spicer

(2012). A Stupidity-Based Theory of Organizations. Journal of Management Studies, 49(7), 1194–1220.

Alvesson

, & Sandberg

(2014). Habitat and Habitus: Boxed-in versus Box-Breaking Research. Organization Studies, 35(7), 967–987.

Appignanesi

, Garratt

, Curry

, & Sardar

(1995). Postmodernism for beginners. Cambridge, England: Icon Books.

Aram

J. D.

, & Salipante

P. F.

Jr. (2003). Bridging scholarship in management: Epistemological reflections. British Journal of Management, 14(3), 189–205.

Aristotle. (1926a). Nicomachean ethics, Rackham

, Ed., (Trans. by Harris Rackham). The Perseus project. Retrieved from http://www.perseus.tufts.edu/cgi-bin/ptext?lookup=Aristot.+Nic.+Eth.+

Aristotle. (1926b). On rhetoric: A theory of civic discourse. In Freese

J. H.

, (Ed.). Retrieved from http://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Aristot.+Rh.+1.1.1&redirect=true)

Aristotle. (1944). Politics. Aristotle in 23 Volumes, Vol. 21, translated by H. Rackham. Cambridge, MA, Harvard University Press; London, England: William Heinemann Ltd. Retreived from http://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus:text:1999.01.0058

10.

Balck

(1994). Projects as elements of a new industrial pattern: A division of project management. In Cleland

D. I.

, & Gareis

(Eds.), Global Project Management Handbook (pp. 2-1–2-11). New York, NY: McGraw-Hill International Editions.

11.

Blomquist

, Hällgren

, Nilsson

, & Söderholm

(2010). Project-as-practice: In search of project management research that matters. Project Management Journal, 41(1), 5–16.

12.

Bourdeau

(1882). Théorie des Sciences. Paris, France: Garnier-Baillière.

13.

Bourgault

, Robert

, & Yan

(2006). Teaching undergraduate engineering students about project management: Going off the beaten track. Paper presented at the 2006 PMI Research Conference, July, Montreal, Canada.

14.

Boxenbaum

, & Rouleau

(2011). New knowledge products as bricolage: Metaphors and scripts in organizational theory. Academy of Management Review, 36(2), 272–296.

15.

Bredillet

C.N.

(2003). Genesis and role of standards: Theoretical foundations and socio-economical model for the construction and use of standards. International Journal of Project Management, 21(6), 463–470.

16.

Bredillet

C.N.

(2004, July). Understanding the very nature of project management: A praxeological approach. Paper presented at the 2004 PMI Research Conference: Innovations, London, England.

17.

Bredillet

, Tywoniak

, & Dwivedula

(2015). What is a good project manager? An Aristotelian perspective. International Journal of Project Management, 33(2), 254–266.

18.

Brown

(2012). The “practice turn,” phronesis and classical realism: Toward a phronetic international political theory? Millennium: Journal of International Studies, 40, 439–456.

19.

Brown

J.S.

, & Duguid

(1991). Organizational learning and communities of practice: Toward a unified view of working, learning and innovation. Organization Science, 2(1), 40–57.

20.

Brunsson

, Bengt

& Associates (2000). A world of standards. Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.

21.

Carr

, & Kemmis

(1986). Becoming critical: Education, knowledge and action research. London, England: Falmer Press.

22.

Castoriadis

(1991). Philosophy, politics, autonomy. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

23.

Chia

(1995). From modern to postmodern organizational analysis. Organizational Studies, 16(4), 579–604.

24.

Cicmil

(2006). Understanding project management practice through interpretative and critical research perspectives. Project Management Journal, 37(2), 27–37.

25.

Cicmil

, & Hodgson

(2006). Making projects critical: An introduction. In Hodgson

, & Cicmil

(Eds.), Making projects critical (pp. 1–25). Basingstoke, New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan.

26.

Cicmil

, Hodgson

, Lindgren

, & Packendorff

(Eds.). (2009). Project management behind the façade. Special issue of ephemera: Theory and politics, 9(2), 78–194. Contributions retrieved from http://www.ephemeraweb.org/journal/index.htm 9(2) May 2009

27.

Cicmil

, Williams

, Thomas

, & Hodgson

(2006). Rethinking project management: Researching the actuality of projects. International Journal of Project Management, 24(8), 675–686.

28.

Clegg

, Flyvbjerg

, & Haugaard

(2014). Reflections on phronetic social science: a dialogue between Stewart Clegg, Bent Flyvbjerg and Mark Haugaard. Journal of Political Power, 7(2), 275–306.

29.

Corley

K. G.

, & Gioia

D.A.

(2011). Building theory about theory building: What Constitutes a Theoretical Contribution? Academy of Management Review, 38(1), 12–32.

30.

Denis

J-L.

, Langley

, & Rouleau

(2007). Strategizing in pluralistic contexts: Rethinking theoretical frames. Human Relations, 60(1), 179–215.

31.

Dionysiou

, & Tsoukas

(2013). Understanding the (re)creation of routines from within: A symbolic interactionist perspective. Academy of Management Review, 38(2), 181–205.

32.

Duska

R.F.

(1993). Aristotle: A pre-modern post-modern? Implications for business ethics. Business Ethics Quarterly, 3(3), 227–249.

33.

Eikeland

(2006). Phrónêsis, Aristotle, and action research. International Journal of Action Research, 2(1), 5–53.

34.

Eikeland

(2007). From epistemology to gnoseology: Understanding the knowledge claims of action research. Management Research News, 30(5), 344–358.

35.

Eikeland

(2008). The ways of Aristotle: Aristotelian phrónêsis, Aristotelian philosophy of dialogue, and action research. Studies in vocational and continuing education, vol. 5, Bern, Switzerland: Peter Lang.

36.

Eikeland

(2012). Action research: Applied research, intervention research, collaborative research, practitioner research, or praxis research? International Journal of Action Research, 8(1), 9–44.

37.

Eikeland

, & Nicolini

(2011). Turning practically: Broadening the horizon. Journal of Organizational Change Management, 24(2), 164–174.

38.

Falcon

(2014, Spring). Aristotle on causality, The Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy, Edward , Zalta

(Ed.), Retrieved from <http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/spr2014/entries/aristotle-causality/>

39.

Feldman

M. S.

, & Orlikowski

W.J.

(2011). Theorizing practice and practicing theory. Organization Science, 22(5), 1240–1253.

40.

Feyerabend

(1987). Farewell to reason. London, England: Verso.

41.

Flyvbjerg

(2004). Phronetic planning research: Theoretical and methodological reflections. Planning Theory & Practices, 5(3), 283–306.

42.

Flyvbjerg

, Bruzelius

, & Rothengatter

(2003). Megaprojects and risk: An anatomy of ambition. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.

43.

Flyvbjerg

, Landman

, & Schram

S.F.

(Eds.). (2012). Real social science: Applied Phronesis. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.

44.

Foucault

(1977). Discipline and punish: The birth of the prison. London, England: Penguin Books.

45.

Frankenberg

(1988). Gramsci, culture and medical anthropology: Kundry and Parsifal? Or rat's tail to sea serpent? Medical Anthropology Quarterly, 2(4), 324–337.

46.

Gadamer

H-G

(1975). Truth and method. Garrett Barden and John Cumming, trs. New York, NY: Seabury.

47.

Giddens

(1979). Central problems in social theory: Action, structure and contradiction in social analysis. Basingstoke, England: Macmillan.

48.

Giddens

(1984). The constitution of society. Cambridge, England: Polity.

49.

Giddens

(1990). The consequences of modernity. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.

50.

Gomez

P-Y

(2006). Informations et conventions: Le cadre du modèle general. Revue Français e de Gestion, 32(160), 217–240.

51.

Habermas

(1971). Theorie und praxis. Frankfurt am Main, Germany: Suhrkamp.

52.

Habermas

(1973). Theory and practice. John Viertel, tr. Boston, MA: Beacon Press.

53.

Hacking

(1995). “The looping effects of human kinds.” In Sperber

, Premack

, & Premack

A. J.

(Eds.). Causal cognition: An interdisciplinary approach (pp. 351–383), Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.

54.

Hacking

(2002). Inaugural Lecture: Chair of Philosophy and History of Scientific Concepts at the College de France, 16 January 2001. Economy and Society, 31(1), 1–14.

55.

Hällgren

, & Lindahl

(2012). How do you do? On situating old project sites through practice-based studies. International Journal of Managing Projects in Business, 5(3), 335–344.

56.

Hällgren

, & Söderholm

(2011). Projects-as-practice: New approach, new insights. In Morris

P. W. G.

, & Pinto

J. K.

, and Söderlund

(Eds.). The Oxford handbook of project management (pp. 500–518). Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.

57.

Hernes

, & Bakken

(2003). Implications of Self-Reference: Niklas Luhmann's Autopoiesis and Organization Theory. Organization Studies, 24(9), 1511–1535.

58.

Hodgson

(2002). Disciplining the professional: The case of project management. Journal of Management Studies, 39(6), 803–821.

59.

Hodgson

, & Cicmil

(2007). The politics of standards in modern management: Making “the project” a reality. Journal of Management Studies, 44(3), 431–450.

60.

Jackson

M.C.

(2003). Systems thinking: Creative holism for managers. Chichester, England: Wiley.

61.

Keynes

J.M.

(1937). The general theory of employment. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 51(2), 209–223.

62.

Kieser

, & Nicolai

A.T.

(2005). Success factor research: Overcoming the trade-off between rigor and relevance? Journal of Management Inquiry, 14(3), 275–279.

63.

Kondrat

M.E.

(1992). Reclaiming the practical: Formal and substantive rationality in social work practice. Social Service Review, 66(2), 237–255.

64.

Kraaijenbrink

(2010). Rigor and relevance under uncertainty: Toward frameworks as theories for practice. Working Paper. Retrieved from http://www.philosophyofbusiness.org/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/downloads/2011/05/Rigor-and-relevance-under-uncertainty-Kraaijenbrink-20-12-2010.pdf

65.

Kraut

(2014, Summer). Aristotle's ethics, The Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy, Zalta

Edward N.

(Ed.), Retrieved from <http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2014/entries/aristotle-ethics/>

66.

Kurtz

C. F.

, & Snowden

D.J.

(2003). The new dynamics of strategy: Sense-making in a complex and complicated world. IBM Systems Journal, 42(3), 462–483.

67.

Lalonde

P-L.

, Bourgault

, & Findeli

(2012). An empirical investigation of the project situation: PM practice as an inquiry process. International Journal of Project Management, 30(4), 418–431.

68.

Le Moigne

J-L

(2007). Do the ethical aims of research and intervention in education and training not lead us to a “new discourse on the study method of our time?” Educational Sciences Journal, 4, 115–126.

69.

Linder

, Wald

(2010). Success factors of knowledge management in temporary organizations. International Journal of Project Management, 29(7), 877–888.

70.

MacIntyre

A.C.

(1985). After virtue. (2nd ed.), London, England: Duckworth.

71.

March

J. J. G.

, & Sutton

R.J.

(1997). Organizational performance as a dependent variable. Organization Science, 8(6), 698–706.

72.

Maturana

R. H.

, & Varela

F.J.

(1998). The tree of knowledge: The biological roots of human understanding, revised ed. Boston, MA: Shambhala Publications.

73.

Midler

, & Lundin

(1998). Projects as arenas for renewal and learning processes. Norwell, MA: Kluwer Academic Publishers.

74.

Miller

K.D.

(2009). Organizational risk after modernism. Organizational Studies. 30(2-3), 157–180.

75.

Nussbaum

M.C.

(1990). Love's knowledge: Essays on philosophy and literature. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

76.

Ostrowski

(1967). Réponse à un appel. Mathématiques et Sciences Humaines, 19, 21–26.

77.

Packendorff

(1995). Inquiring into the temporary organization: New directions for project management research. Scandinavian Journal of Management, 11(4), 319–333.

78.

Pascal

, & Bertram

(2012, February). Praxeological research within a learning community: Developing evidence based practice. Paper presented at the 2nd BECERA Conference, Center for Research in Early Childhood Learning Circle, Birmingham, AL. Retrieved from http://www.slideshare.net/CREC_APT/praxeology-keynote-becera-2012

79.

Perminova

, Gustafsson

, & Wikström

(2008). Defining uncertainty in projects: A new perspective. International Journal of Project Management, 26, 73–79.

80.

Petruszewycz

(1965). À propos de la praxéologie. Mathématiques et Sciences Humaines, 11, 11–18.

81.

Pitsis

T. S.

, Clegg

S. R.

, Marton

, & Rura-Polley

(2003). Constructing the Olympic dream: A future perfect strategy of project management. Organization Science, 14(5), 574–590.

82.

Polanyi

(1966). The tacit dimension. London, England: Cox & Wyman Ltd.

83.

Puranam

, Alexy

, & Reitzig

(2014). What's “new” about new form of organizing?. Academy of Management Review, 39(2), 162–180.

84.

Reckwitz

(2002). Toward a theory of social practices: A development in cultural theorizing. European Journal of Social Theory, 5(2), 243–263.

85.

Sandberg

, & Tsoukas

(2011). Grasping the logic of practice: Theorizing through practical rationality. Academy of Management Review, 36(2), 338–360.

86.

Schatzki

T.R.

(2005). Peripheral vision: The sites of organizations. Organization Studies, 26(3), 465–484.

87.

Schön

D.A.

(1987). Educating the reflective practitioner. Washington, DC: American Educational Research Association.

88.

Schön

D.A.

(1983). The reflective practitioner: How professionals think in action. New York, NY: Basic Books.

89.

Schram

S.F.

(2004). Beyond paradigm: Resisting to the assimilation of phronetic social science. Politics & Society, 32(3), 417–433.

90.

Schütz

(1964). Collected papers, vol. 2. In Brodersen

Arvid

(Ed.), Studies in social theory. The Hague. The Netherlands: Nijhoff.

91.

Shotter

, & Tsoukas

(2014). In search of phronesis: Leadership and the art of judgment. Academy of Management Learning & Education, 13(2), 224–243.

92.

Söderlund

, & Geraldi

(2012). Classics in project management: Revisiting the past, creating the future. International Journal of Managing Projects in Business, 5(4), 559–577.

93.

Solomon

(1992). Business ethics and excellence. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

94.

Stacey

R.D.

(2012). Tools and techniques of leadership and management: Meeting the challenge of complexity. Milton Park, England: Routledge.

95.

Statler

(2014). Developing wisdom in a business school? Critical reflections on pedagogical practice. Management Learning. 45(3), 1–21.

96.

Strang

J.V.

(1998, August). Ethics as politics: On Aristotelian ethics and its context. Paper presented at the Twentieth World Congress of Philosophy, Boston, MA.

97.

Taylor

(1993). “To follow a rule …” In Calhoun

C. J.

, Lipuma

, & Postone

(Eds.), Bourdieu: Critical perspectives (pp. 45–60). Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

98.

Toulmin

(1990). Cosmopolis: The hidden agenda of modernity. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

99.

Tsoukas

(2010). Practice, strategy making and intentionality: A Heideggerian onto-epistemology for strategy-as-practice. In Golsorkhi

D. G.

, Rouleau

, Seidl

, & Vaara

(Eds.), Cambridge handbook of strategy as practice (pp. 47–62), Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.

100.

Tsoukas

, & Chia

(2002). On organizational becoming: Rethinking organizational Change. Organization Science, 13(5), 567–582.

101.

Tsoukas

, & Cummings

(1997). Marginalization and recovery: The emergence of Aristotelian themes in organization studies. Organization Studies, 18(4), 655–683.

102.

Turner

, & Zolin

(2012). Forecasting success on large projects: Developing reliable scales to predict multiple perspectives by multiple stakeholders over multiple time frames. Project Management Journal, 43(5), 87–99.

103.

Vaara

, & Whittington

(2012). Strategy-as-practice: Taking social practices seriously. The Academy of Management Annals, 6(1), 285–336.

104.

van Marrewijk

, Clegg

S. R.

, Pitsis

T. S.

, & Veenswijk

(2008). Managing public–private megaprojects: Paradoxes, complexity, and project design. International Journal of Project Management, 26(6), 591–600.

105.

Van de Ven

A. H.

, & Johnson

P.E.

(2006). Knowledge for theory and practice. Academy of Management Review, 31(4), 802–821.

106.

Vazquez

A.S.

(1977). The philosophy of praxis. London, England: Merlin Press.

107.

Warry

(1992). The eleventh thesis: Applied anthropology as praxis. Human Organization, 51(2), 155–163.

108.

Weisinger

J. Y.

, & Salipante

P.F.

(2000). Cultural knowing as practicing: Extending our conceptions of culture. Journal of Management Inquiry, 9(4), 376–390.

109.

Whittington

(2006). Completing the practice turn in strategy. Organization Studies, 27(5), 613–634.

110.

Winter

, Smith

, Morris

, & Cicmil

(2006). Directions for future research in project management: The main findings of a UK government-funded research network. International Journal of Project Management, 24(8), 638–649.