Toe-to-thumb transfer is an established procedure for reconstruction of traumatic thumb amputations. The four types of toe-to-thumb transfers are the second toe, the great toe, the wrap-around great toe and the trimmed great toe transfers. The purpose of this study is to conduct a systematic review of the literature to compare outcomes amongst different methods of toe-to-thumb transfers.
Methods
A literature search using ‘toe-to-thumb transfer’ combined with ‘thumb injury’ and ‘thumb reconstruction’ as keywords and limited to humans and the English language identified 633 studies. Studies were included in the review if they: (1) present primary data, (2) report three or more toe-to-thumb transfers for isolated complete traumatic thumb amputation between the metacarpophalangeal joint and the interphalangeal joint (both excluded) and (3) present functional outcome data.
Results
Twenty-five studies representing 450 toe-to-thumb transfers met the inclusion criteria. They included 101 second toe transfers, 196 great toe transfers, 122 wrap-around transfers and 31 trimmed toe transfers. The mean survival rate was 96.4%. No statistically significant differences could be detected between the four transfers with regards to survival, arc of motion, total active motion, grip and pinch strength and static two-point discrimination.
Conclusions
All four types of toe transfer procedures have predictably high survival rates and good patient satisfaction scores. The current data are inadequate to make any comments with regards to donor site morbidity. Till such data are available, an evidence-based recommendation for the superiority of a specific type of toe-to-thumb transfer cannot be made.
AdaniRCardonLJCastagnettiCPinelliM. Distal thumb reconstruction using a mini wrap-around flap from the great toe. J Hand Surg Br.1999;24:437–42.
2.
AdaniRMarcoccioITaralloLFregniU. The aesthetic mini wrap-around technique for thumb reconstruction. Tech Hand Up Extrem Surg.2005;9:42–6.
3.
BarcaFSantiATartoniPLLandiA. Gait analysis of the donor foot in microsurgical reconstruction of the thumb. Foot Ankle Int.1995;16:201–6.
4.
BrownCJMackinnonSEDellonALBainJR. The sensory potential of free flap donor sites. Ann Plast Surg.1989;23:135–40.
5.
BunckeGMBunckeHJLeeCK. Great toe-to-thumb microvascular transplantation after traumatic amputation. Hand Clin.2007;23:105–15.
6.
ChungKCWeiFC. An outcome study of thumb reconstruction using microvascular toe transfer. J Hand Surg Am.2000;25:651–8.
7.
CobbettJR. Free digital transfer. Report of a case of transfer of a great toe to replace an amputated thumb. J Bone Joint Surg Br.1969;51:677–9.
8.
DoiK. Microsurgical thumb reconstruction—report of six cases with a wrap-around free flap from the big toe and an iliac bone graft. Ann Acad Med Singapore.1982;11:225–30.
9.
DoiKKuwataNKawaiS. Reconstruction of the thumb with a free wrap-around flap from the big toe and an iliac-bone graft. J Bone Joint Surg Am.1985;67:439–45.
10.
DoiKHattoriYDhawanV. The wrap-around flap in thumb reconstruction. Tech Hand Up Extrem Surg.2002;6:124–32.
11.
FinsethFBunckeHJ. Thumb and digit reconstruction: toe-to-hand microvascular composite tissue transplantation. Int Surg.1981;66:13–8.
12.
FrykmanGKO'BrienBMMorrisonWAMacLeodAM. Functional evaluation of the hand and foot after one-stage toe-to-hand transfer. J Hand Surg Am.1986;11:9–17.
13.
GilbertA. Toe transfers for congenital hand defects. J Hand Surg Am.1982;7:118–24.
14.
GuYDChengDSZhangGMChenXMXuJGYangXB. Long-term results of toe transfer: retrospective analysis. J Reconstr Microsurg.1997;13:405–8.
15.
GulgonenAGudemezE. Toe-to-hand transfers: more than 20 years follow-up of five post-traumatic cases. J Hand Surg Br.2006;31:2–8.
16.
HarashinaT. Analysis of 200 free flaps. Br J Plast Surg.1988;41:33–6.
17.
HaugheyBHWilsonEKluweL. Free flap reconstruction of the head and neck: analysis of 241 cases. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg.2001;125:10–7.
18.
HuangDWangHGWuWZZhangHRLinH. Functional and aesthetic results of immediate reconstruction of traumatic thumb defects by toe-to-thumb transplantation. Int Orthop.2011;35(4):543–7.
19.
JengCMichelsonJMizeiM. Sensory thresholds of normal human feet. Foot Ankle Int.2000;21:501–4.
20.
JenkinsMBambergerHBBlackLNowinskiR. Thumb joint flexion. What is normal? J Hand Surg Br.1998;23:196–7.
21.
KhouriRKShawWW. Reconstruction of the lower extremity with microvascular free flaps: a 10-year experience with 304 consecutive cases. J Trauma.1989;29:1086–94.
22.
LeeCKBunckeGM. Great toe-to-thumb microvascular transplantation. Clin Plast Surg.2007;34:223–31.
23.
LeeKSChaeIJHahnSB. Thumb reconstruction with a free neurovascular wrap-around flap from the big toe: long-term follow-up of thirty cases. Microsurgery.1995;16:692–7.
24.
LeeKSParkJWChungWK. Thumb reconstruction with a wraparound free flap according to the level of amputation. Microsurgery.2000;20:25–31.
25.
LeeKSParkJWChungWK. Thumb reconstruction with a wraparound free flap according to the level of amputation. J Hand Surg Am.2000;25:644–50.
26.
LiptonHAMayJWJrSimonSR. Preoperative and postoperative gait analyses of patients undergoing great toe-to-thumb transfer. J Hand Surg Am.1987;12:66–9.
27.
ListerGDKalismanMTsaiTM. Reconstruction of the hand with free microneurovascular toe-to-hand transfer: experience with 54 toe transfers. Plast Reconstr Surg.1983;71:372–86.
28.
LowdonIMNunleyJAGoldnerRDUrbaniakJR. The wraparound procedure for thumb and finger reconstruction. Microsurgery.1987;8:154–7.
29.
LutzBSWeiFC. Basic principles on toe-to-hand transplantation. Chang Gung Med J.2002;25:568–76.
30.
MinamiAUsuiMKatohHIshiiS. Thumb reconstruction by free sensory flaps from the foot using microsurgical techniques. J Hand Surg Br.1984;9:239–44.
31.
MorrisonWAO'BrienBMMacLeodAM. Thumb reconstruction with a free neurovascular wrap-around flap from the big toe. J Hand Surg Am.1980;5:575–83.
32.
MorrisonWAO'BrienBMMacLeodAM. The surgical repair of amputations of the thumb. Aust N Z J Surg.1980;50:237–43.
33.
MorrisonWAO'BrienBMMacLeodAM. Experience with thumb reconstruction. J Hand Surg Br.1984;9:223–33.
34.
NunleyJAGoldnerRDUrbaniakJR. Thumb reconstruction by the wrap-around method. Clin Orthop Relat Res.1985;195:97–103.
35.
PatradulAKitidumrongsookPNgarmukosCParkpianV. Microsurgical toe to thumb transplantation for traumatic thumb loss. J Med Assoc Thai.2000;83:77–84.
36.
PoppenNKNorrisTRBunckeHJJr. Evaluation of sensibility and function with microsurgical free tissue transfer of the great toe to the hand for thumb reconstruction. J Hand Surg Am.1983;8:516–31.
37.
RayECShermanRStevanovicM. Immediate reconstruction of a nonreplantable thumb amputation by great toe transfer. Plast Reconstr Surg.2009;123:259–67.
38.
ReigstadAHetlandKRWaageSByeKRokkumM. Transfer of the second toe for reconstruction of the hand after trauma. Scand J Plast Reconstr Surg Hand Surg.1992;26:105–10.
39.
RossonGDBunckeGMBunckeHJ. Great toe transplant versus thumb replant for isolated thumb amputation: critical analysis of functional outcome. Microsurgery.2008;28:598–605.
40.
SabapathySRVenkatramaniHBharathiRR. Functional evaluation of a great toe transfer and the osteoplastic technique for thumb reconstruction in the same individual. J Hand Surg Br.2003;28:405–8.
41.
SchweitzerG. Laxity of metacarpophalangeal joints of fingers and interphalangeal joint of the thumb: a comparative inter-racial study. S Afr Med J.1970;44:246–9.
42.
ShawSJMorrisMA. The range of motion of the metacarpophalangeal joint of the thumb and its relationship to injury. J Hand Surg Br.1992;17:164–6.
43.
SongcharoenPThanapipatsiriSMahaisavariyaBChotigavanichC. Thumb reconstruction with a big toe microvascular wrap-around flap: a report of fifteen cases. Ann Acad Med Singapore.1995;24:46–50.
44.
StupkaIVeselyJHyzaPMolitorMKucerovaKDvorakZ. Long term results of digital reconstruction using toe-to-finger transfers. Eur J Plast Surg.2004;27:271–82.
45.
TsaiTMFalconerD. Modified great toe wrap for thumb reconstruction. Microsurgery.1986;7:193–8.
46.
TsaiTMMcCabeSBeattyME. Second toe transfer for thumb reconstruction in multiple digit amputations including thumb and basal joint. Microsurgery.1987;8:146–53.
47.
ValauriFABunckeHJ. Thumb reconstruction—great toe transfer. Clin Plast Surg.1989;16:475–89.
48.
ValauriFABunckeHJ. Thumb and finger reconstruction by toe-to-hand transfer. Hand Clin.1992;8:551–74.
49.
VitkusKVitkusMKrivulinA. Long-term measurement of innervation density in second toe-to-thumb transfers receiving immediate postoperative sensory reeducation. Microsurgery.1989;10:245–7.
50.
WeiFCEl-GammalTA. Toe-to-hand transfer. Current concepts, techniques, and research. Clin Plast Surg.1996;23:103–16.
51.
WeiFCMaHS. Delayed sensory reeducation after toe-to-hand transfer. Microsurgery.1995;16:583–5.
52.
WeiFCChenHCChuangCCNoordhoffMS. Reconstruction of the thumb with a trimmed-toe transfer technique. Plast Reconstr Surg.1988;82:506–15.
53.
WeiFCChenHCChuangCCChenSH. Microsurgical thumb reconstruction with toe transfer: selection of various techniques. Plast Reconstr Surg.1994;93:345–51. discussion 52–7.
54.
WooSHKimJSSeulJH. Immediate toe-to-hand transfer in acute hand injuries: overall results, compared with results for elective cases. Plast Reconstr Surg.2004;113:882–92.
55.
XuLGuYDXuJGRuiYJShouKS. Microsurgical treatment for bilateral thumb defect: five case reports. Microsurgery.2003;23:547–54.
56.
YangDYGuYD. The report of free second toe transfer for thumb reconstruction in 4 cases. Chin J Surg.1977;15:1–3.
57.
YoshidaRHouseHOPattersonRMShahMAViegasSF. Motion and morphology of the thumb metacarpophalangeal joint. J Hand Surg.2003;28:753–7.
58.
YoshimuraMNomuraSYamauchiSUmedaSUenoTIwaiY. Toe-to-hand transfer: experience with thirty-eight digits. Aust N Z J Surg.1980;50:248–54.
