Outcomes of Open and Endoscopic Carpal Tunnel Release: A Meta-Analysis

Abstract

Background

Currently, there are two genres of surgical treatment of carpal tunnel syndrome, open versus endoscopic. The goal of our study is to analyze published data by comparing outcomes of surgical treatment for carpal tunnel syndrome and determine if one approach is superior to the other (open versus endoscopic).

Methods

A meta-analysis of retrospective series of Carpal tunnel release including >20 patients, with results measuring outcomes based on at least six of the following nine parameters (paresthesia relief, scar tenderness, two-point discrimination, thenar muscle weakness, Semmes—Weinstein/SW monofilament testing, return to work time, grip and pinch strength, and complications).

Results

Endoscopic carpal tunnel approach showed statistically superior outcomes in eight of the nine categories investigated. Only in the category of complications (mean occurrence of 1.2% in the open release versus 2.2% in the endoscopic release group) was the endoscopic group inferior.

Conclusion

This suggests that the endoscopic release is superior to the open release, particularly in experienced hands.

Keywords

Carpal tunnel syndrome Endoscopic carpal tunnel release Outcomes

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Akalin

Peker

Senocak

. Treatment of carpal tunnel syndrome with nerve and tendon gliding exercises. Am J Phys Med Rehabil. 2002;81(2):108–13.

Armstong

Flynn

Davies

. Endoscopic carpal tunnel release. J Hand Surg (Br). 1997;22(4):505–7.

Atroshi

Johnsson

Ornstein

. Endoscopic carpal tunnel release: prospective assessment of 255 cases. J Hand Surg (Br). 1997;22(1):42–7.

Brown

Keyser

Rothenberg

. Endoscopic carpal tunnel release. J Hand Surg (Am). 1992;17(6):1009–11.

Bruser

Richter

Larkin . The operative treatment of carpal tunnel syndrome and its relevance to endoscopic release. Eur J Plast Surg. 1999;22:80–4.

Chow

. Endoscopic release of the carpal ligament: a new technique for carpal tunnel syndrome. Arthroscopy. 1989;5(1):19–24.

Chow

. The Chow technique of endoscopic release of the carpal ligament for carpal tunnel syndrome: four years of clinical results. Arthroscopy. 1993;9:301–14.

Chow

. Endoscopic carpal tunnel release. Two-portal technique. Hand Clin. 1994;10(4):637–46.

Citron

Bendall

. Local symptoms after open carpal tunnel release. A randomized prospective trial of two incisions. J Hand Surg (Br). 1997;22(3):317–21.

10.

Einhorn

Leddy

. Pitfalls of endoscopic carpal tunnel release. Orthop Clin North Am. 1996;27(2):373–80.

11.

Erhard

Ozalp

Citron

. Carpal tunnel release by the Agee endoscopic technique. J Hand Surg (Br). 1999;24(5):583–5.

12.

Evans

. Endoscopic carpal tunnel release—the hand doctor dilemma. J Hand Surg (Br). 1994;19:3–4.

13.

Fissette

Onkelinx

. Treatment of carpal tunnel syndrome. Hand. 1979;11:206–10.

14.

Gelberman

Rydevik

Pess

. Carpal tunnel syndrome. A scientific basis for clinical care. Orthop Clin North Am. 1988;19:115–23.

15.

Gellman

Kan

Gee

. Analysis of pinch and grip strength after carpal tunnel release. J Hand Surg (Am). 1989;14 (5):863–4.

16.

Klein

Kotsis

Chung

. Open carpal tunnel release using a 1-centimeter incision: technique and outcomes for 104 patients. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2003;111(5):1616–22.

17.

Kulick

Gordillo

Javidi

. Long-term analysis of patients having surgical treatment for carpal tunnel syndrome. J Hand Surg (Am). 1986;11(1):59–66.

18.

Kuschner

Lane

. Endoscopic versus open carpal tunnel release: big deal or much ado about nothing? Am J Orthod. 1997;26(9):591–6.

19.

Leach

Esler

Scott

. Grip strength following carpal tunnel decompression. J Hand Surg (Br). 1993;18(6):750–2.

20.

Learmonth

. The principle of decompression in the treatment of certain diseases of peripheral nerves. Surg Clin N Am. 1933;13:905–13.

21.

Lee

W.P.A

Strickland

. Safe carpal tunnel release via a limited palmar incision. Plast Reconstr Surg. 1998;101:418–23.

22.

Litin

Prickman

. Carpal tunnel syndrome. Mayo Clin Updat. 1993;9:1–2.

23.

Malaviya

. Open carpal tunnel release: do not take it casually. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2008;120(5):1862.

24.

Mirza

King

Tanveer

. Palmar uniportal extrabursal endoscopic carpal tunnel release. Arthroscopy. 1995;11:82–90.

25.

Nagle

Fischer

Harris

. A multicenter prospective review of 640 endoscopic carpal tunnel releases using the transbursal and extrabursal chow techniques. Arthroscopy. 1996;12:139–43.

26.

Nagle

Harris

Foley

. Prospective review of 278 endoscopic carpal tunnel releases using the modified chow technique. Arthroscopy. 1994;10:259–65.

27.

Nolan

. Carpal tunnel syndrome: past, present, and future. Contemp Surg. 1998;52:160.

28.

Okutsu

Ninomiya

Takatori

Ugawa

. Endoscopic management of carpal tunnel syndrome. Arthroscopy. 1989;5(1):11–8.

29.

Paget

. Lectures on surgical pathology. Philadelphia: Lindsay & Blakiston; 1854.

30.

Petitti

. Approaches to heterogeneity in meta-analysis. Stat Med. 2001;20:3625–33.

31.

Phalen

. The carpal-tunnel syndrome. J Bone Joint Surg (Am). 1966;48:211–28.

32.

Rab

Grunbeck

Beck

. Intra-individual comparison between open and 2-portal endoscopic release in clinically matched bilateral carpal syndrome. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2006;59:730–6.

33.

Senn

. The many modes of meta. Drug Inf J. 2000;34:535–49.

34.

Serra

J.M.R

Benito

Monner

. Carpal tunnel release with short incision. Plast Reconstr Surg. 1997;99:129–35.

35.

Shurr

Blair

Bassett

. Electromyographic changes after carpal tunnel release. J Hand Surg (Am). 1986;11(6):876–80.

36.

Silverman

. Where is the evidence? Debates in modern medicine. Oxford, New York, Tokyo: Oxford University Press; 1998, pp. 102–105.

37.

Szabo

. Statistical analysis as related to hand surgery. J Hand Surg (Am). 1997;22(3):376–85.

38.

Tanaka

Wild

Seligman

. The US prevalence of self-reported carpal tunnel syndrome:1988 National Health Interview Survey Data. Am J Public Health. 1994;84:1846–8.

39.

Thoma

Beltri

Haines

Duku

. A systematic review of reviews comparing the effectiveness of endoscopic and open carpal tunnel decompression. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2004;113(4):1184–91.

40.

Thurston

Lam

. Results of open carpal tunnel release: comprehensive, retrospective study of 188 hands. Aust N Z J Surg. 1997;67:283–8.

41.

Tse

Hurst

Al-Yafi

. Early major complications of endoscopic carpal tunnel release: a review of 1,200 cases. Can J Plast Surg. 2003;11(3):131–4.

42.

Wilson

. Double incision open technique for carpal tunnel release: an alternative to endoscopic release. J Hand Surg (Am). 1994;19(6):907–12.