Evangelical Christian college students navigate campus buoyed by Christian privilege but may encounter silencing or othering tied to their religious beliefs, a feeling of incompatibility with their campus climate, and conflations of their religious and political beliefs that are inaccurate and discouraging. Unsupportive campus climates can discourage evangelical students from having productive exchanges across difference and deepening their own worldview commitments, which is concerning due to their general lack of interfaith participation that challenges stereotypes and unnuanced assumptions.
Purpose
This study explores how evangelical Christians perceive their campus climates and whether those perceptions are different based on other social identity intersections with gender, race, sexuality, and political affiliation. In addition to individual characteristics, how the campus environment and various curricular and co-curricular experiences moderate evangelical students’ perceptions of the worldview climate is examined.
Methods
A sample of 1235 evangelical college students was examined via means, standard deviations, and ranges for six campus climate measures, one-way ANOVAs to examine whether those measures differed by different identity dimensions, and then multilevel modeling to better understand the role of campus experiences in evangelicals’ perceptions of their campus climate.
Results
Evangelical students’ campus climate perceptions were generally positive; more provocative encounters were reported by women than men and evangelical Asian students indicated more divisiveness, more insensitivity, and less space for support than their peers. Political affiliation also revealed several significant differences in perceived campus climate. Interfaith engagement through pre-college activities, formal and informal activities, and friendships were connected to perceptions of campus climate, with those reporting more engagement being more likely to have productive encounters across difference and to report insensitivity or divisiveness. Religious affiliation was the most significant institutional characteristic.
Conclusions and Implications
This study illuminates how collegiate experiences and campus environments exacerbate or attenuate evangelical Christian students’ perceptions of the campus climate, and the results indicate that effective teaching practices where true interfaith experiences happen and that create inclusive space for evangelical students in the classroom are key to fostering development, especially in light of the social status ambiguity evangelical college students may be experiencing during their college years.
AhmadiSColeDQuayeSJHarperSREngaging religious minority studentsStudent engagement in higher education: Theoretical perspectives and practical approaches for diverse populations2015New York, NYRoutledge171–186
2.
BalmerREvangelical. Encyclopedia of evangelicalism: Revised and expanded edition2004Waco, TXBaylor University Press
3.
BeamanLGThe myth of pluralism, diversity, and vigor: The constitutional privilege of Protestantism in the United States and CanadaJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion200343311–32510.1111/1468-5906.00183
4.
BlumenfeldWJWeberGNRankinSChamness MillerPMikulecEIn our own voice: Campus climate as a mediating factor in the persistence of LGBT students, faculty, and staff in higher educationQueering classrooms: Personal narratives and educational practices to support LGBTQ youth in schools2016Charlotte, NCInformation Age Publishing Inc
5.
BowmanNASmallJLDo college students who identify with a privileged religion experience greater spiritual development? Exploring individual and institutional dynamicsResearch in Higher Education2010517595–61410.1007/s11162-010-9175-2
6.
BrookfieldSRacializing criticality in adult educationAdult Education Quarterly2003533154–16910.1177/0741713603251212
7.
BryantANA portrait of evangelical Christian students in college2007Brooklyn, NYSocial Science Research Council
8.
BryantANThe developmental pathways of evangelical Christian studentsReligion and Education20083521–2610.1080/15507394.2008.10012417
9.
BryantANThe impact of campus context, college encounters, and religious/spiritual struggle on ecumenical worldview developmentResearch in Higher Education2011525441–45910.1007/s11162-010-9205-0
10.
Bryant RockenbachANMayhewMJHow the collegiate religious and spiritual climate shapes students’ ecumenical orientationResearch in Higher Education201354461–47910.1007/s11162-013-9282-y
11.
CarterDFHurtadoSBridging key research dilemma: Quantitative research using a critical eyeNew Directions for Institutional Research200713325–3510.1002/ir.202
12.
CohenJCohenPWestSGAikenLSApplied multiple regression/correlation analysis for the behavioral sciences20033Mahwah, NJLawrence Erlbaum
13.
ColeDAhmadiSPerspectives and experiences of Muslim women who veil on college campusesJournal of College Student Development200344147–6610.1353/csd.2003.0002
14.
ColeDAhmadiSReconsidering campus diversity: An examination of Muslim students' experiencesThe Journal of Higher Education2010812121–13910.1080/00221546.2010.11779045
CressCMIkedaEKDistress under duress: The relationship between campus climate and depression in Asian American college studentsNASPA Journal200340274–9710.2202/1949-6605.1224
17.
DunneGBeyond critical thinking to critical being: Criticality in higher education and lifeInternational Journal of Educational Research20157186–9910.1016/j.ijer.2015.03.003
18.
Eckel, P., Hill, B., Green, M., and Mallon, B. (1999). Taking charge of change: A primer for colleges and universities. On Change Occasional Paper, No. 3. Washington, DC: American Council on Education.
19.
EdwardsSCritical reflections on the interfaith movement: A social justice perspectiveJournal of Diversity in Higher Education2018112164–18110.1037/dhe0000053
20.
EdwardsSBuilding solidarity with religious minorities: A Reflective practice for aspiring allies, accomplices, and coconspiratorsReligion and Education202010.1080/15507394.2020.1815933
21.
Joshi, K.Y. 2020. White Christian privilege: The illusion of religious equality in America. NYU Press.
22.
GloriaAMRobinson KurpiusSEThe validation of the cultural congruity scale and the university environment scale with Chicano/a studentsHispanic Journal of Behavioral Science199618533–55010.1177/07399863960184007
23.
Hall, R. M., & Sandler, B. R. (1984). Out of the classroom: A chilly campus climate for women? Washington, D.C.: Project on the Status and Education of Women, Association of American Colleges.
24.
HammondPhillip E.HunterJames DavisonOn maintaining plausibility: The worldview of evangelical college studentsJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion198423322110.2307/1386038
25.
HurtadoSylviaClayton-PedersenAlma RAllenWalter RechardeMilemJeffrey FEnhancing Campus Climates for Racial/Ethnic Diversity: Educational Policy and PracticeThe Review of Higher Education1998213279–30210.1353/rhe.1998.0003
26.
Kendi, I.X. 2016. Stamped from the beginning: The definitive history of racist ideas in America. Hachette, UK.
27.
LeeJJChanging worlds, changing selves: The experience of the religious self among Catholic collegiansJournal of College Student Development2002433341–356
28.
LovePGCultural barriers facing lesbian, gay, and bisexual students at a Catholic collegeThe Journal of Higher Education1998693298–32310.2307/2649190
29.
LoweryJWUnderstanding the legal protections and limitations upon religion and spiritual expression on campusThe College Student Affairs Journal2004232146–157
30.
Magolda, P. & Ebben Gross, K. (2009). It's all about Jesus! Faith as an oppositional subculture. Sterling, VA: Stylus.
31.
MarsdenGMThe soul of the American university: From protestant establishment to established nonbelief1994New YorkOxford University Press
32.
MayhewMJA multi-level examination of college and its influence on ecumenical worldview developmentResearch in Higher Education2012533282–31010.1007/s11162-011-9231-6
33.
MayhewMJEngbergMEDiversity and moral reasoning: How negative diverse peer interactions affect the development of moral reasoning in undergraduate studentsThe Journal of Higher Education2010814459–48810.1080/00221546.2010.11779061
34.
MayhewMJBowmanNARockenbachABSilencing whom?: Linking campus climates for religious, spiritual, and worldview diversity to student worldviewsThe Journal of Higher Education2014852219–245
35.
MayhewMJBryant RockenbachANAchievement or arrest? The influence of the collegiate religious and spiritual climate on students’ worldview commitmentResearch in Higher Education20135463–8410.1007/s11162-012-9262-7
36.
MayhewMJRockenbachANBowmanNALoMAStarkeMRiggers-PiehlTExpanding perspectives on evangelicalism: How non-evangelical students appreciate evangelical ChristianityReview of Religious Research2017592207–23010.1007/s13644-017-0283-8
37.
MayhewMJRockenbachANBowmanNASeifertTAWolniakGCPascarellaETTerenziniPTHow college affects students: 21st century evidence that higher education works20163San FranciscoJossey-Bass
38.
MayhewMJRockenbachANDahlLSOwning faith: First-year college-going and the development of students’ self-authored worldview commitmentsThe Journal of Higher Education2020916977–100210.1080/00221546.2020.1732175
39.
MayhewMJSimonoffJSNon-white, no more: Effect coding as an alternative to dummy coding with implications for higher education researchersJournal of College Student Development2015562170–17510.1353/csd.2015.0019
40.
MoranCDThe public identity work of evangelical Christian studentsJournal of College Student Development2007484418–43410.1353/csd.2007.0040
41.
MoranCDLangDJOliverJCultural incongruity and social status ambiguity: The experiences of evangelical Christian student leaders at two midwestern public universitiesJournal of College Student Development200748123–3810.1353/csd.2007.0004
42.
NielsenJCSmallJLFour pillars for supporting religious, secular, and spiritual student identitiesJournal of College and Character2019202180–18610.1080/2194587X.2019.1591285
43.
ParkJJRace on campus: Debunking myths with data2018Cambridge, MAHarvard Education Press
44.
ParkJJDizonJPMRace, religion and spirituality for Asian American studentsNew Directions for Student Services2017201716039–4910.1002/ss.20242
45.
PetersonMWSpencerMGUnderstanding academic climate and cultureNew Directions for Institutional Research19901990683–1810.1002/ir.37019906803
46.
RaudenbushSWBrykASHierarchical linear models: Applications and data analysis methods20022Newbury Park, CASage
47.
Riggers-PiehlTALehmanKJModeling the relationship between campus spiritual climate and the sense of belonging for Christian, Muslim, and Jewish studentsReligion & Education2016433247–27010.1080/15507394.2016.1175843
48.
RockenbachANHudsonTDMayhewMJCorreia-HarkerBPMorinSAssociatesFriendships matter: The role of peer relationships in interfaith learning and development2019Chicago, ILInterfaith Youth Core
49.
RockenbachANMayhewMJCorreia-HarkerBPMorinSDahlLAssociatesBest practices for interfaith learning and development in the first year of college2018Chicago, ILInterfaith Youth Core
50.
Rockenbach, A. N., M.J. Mayhew, B.P. Correia-Harker, S. Morin, L. Dahl, and Associates. 2017. Navigating pluralism: How students approach religious difference and interfaith engagement in their first year of college. Interfaith Youth Core.
51.
SanfordNWhere colleges fail: A study of the student as a person1967San FranciscoJossey-Bass10.2307/40223966
52.
SeifertTAUnderstanding Christian privilege: Managing the tensions of spiritual pluralityAbout Campus20071210–1710.1002/abc.206
53.
Shapses-WertheimSFrom a privileged perspective: How white undergraduate students make meaning of cross-racial interaction (Unpublished doctoral dissertation)2014New York, NYNew York University
54.
SmidtCWilsonJMEvangelical and mainline protestants at the turn of the millenniumFrom pews to polling places: Faith and politics in the American religious mosaic2007Washington, DCGeorgetown University Press29–51
55.
SmidtCReassesing the concept and measurement of evangelicals: The case for the RELTRAD approachJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion2019584833–823 10.1111/jssr.12633
SpeckBWRespect for religious differences: The case of Muslim studentsNew Directions for Teaching and Learning19977039–4610.1002/tl.7004
58.
Weber, J. (2017). Evangelical vs. Born Again: A survey of what Americans say and believe beyond politics. Christianity Today. Retrieved from https://www.christianitytoday.com.
