In 2012, the long-simmering tension between American women religious sisters and Catholic Church leadership was brought into sharp focus when the largest group of American sisters—the Leadership Conference of Women Religious—was reprimanded by the Vatican's Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. The Doctrinal Assessment and subsequent Apostolic Visitation concluded that American religious sisters embraced a secular and radical feminist spirit that was incompatible with Church doctrine.
Purpose
While American women religious were publicly criticized, this conflict is not a unique American phenomenon. In fact, it is representative of the gendered challenges that women religious and lay women continue to negotiate around the globe. In many respects, religious sisters are the faces of the Church to many faithful—as teachers, social workers, advocates, and ministers—yet their structural position as women prevents them from leadership or decision-making power in the Church they serve.
Methods
In this research, I explore how sisters navigate these gendered boundaries in the Catholic Church in their day to day ministries. Specifically, I analyze in-depth, semi-structured interviews with 23 Sisters of St. Joseph of Philadelphia.
Results
Sisters in this congregation employ various forms of feminist agency to assert their power within the Church's confining structures. I find that individual sisters in the congregation use resistance and empowerment agency to claim space for their own voices in ministry. These actions do not directly challenge the sisters’ own subordination in the Church, but instead focus their individual and collective agency on satisfying the unmet pastoral needs of the faithful. Through these accumulative actions, other sisters are empowered to contest gendered institutional Church boundaries and individual clergy who reproduce them.
Conclusions and implications
These sites of empowerment and resistance agency are liminal spaces that point toward greater inclusion of women religious in the institutional Catholic Church, especially as they increasingly meet the ministerial needs of the faithful. Religious sisters in this congregation act with socially-just consciences, standing with the marginalized, and are empowered to increase their spheres of influence in the locations where they minister.
AckerJoanHierarchies, jobs, bodies: a theory of gendered organizationsGender & Society199042139–15810.1177/089124390004002002
2.
AllenMarciaMcCarthyMCZollmanMALiving it Twice: Sources of Support and InspirationPower of sisterhood: women religious tell the story of the apostolic visitation2014Lanham, MDUniversity Press of America125–146
3.
AuneKristinFeminist spirituality as lived religion: how UK feminists forge Religio-spiritual livesGender & Society2015291122–14510.1177/0891243214545681
4.
AvishaiOritDoing religion’ in a secular world: women in conservative religions and the question of agencyGender & Society2008224409–43310.1177/0891243208321019
5.
AvishaiOritTheorizing gender from religion cases: agency, feminist activism, and masculinitySociology of Religion2016773261–27910.1093/socrel/srw020
6.
AvishaiOritJafarAfshanRinaldoRachelA Gender lens on religionGender & Society20152915–2510.1177/0891243214548920
7.
BartunekJean MChanging interpretive schemes and organizational restructuring: the example of a religious orderAdministrative Science Quarterly1984293355–37210.2307/2393029
8.
BlauFrancine DFerberMarianne AWinklerAnne EThe Economics of Women, Men, and Work2006Upper Saddle River, NJPearson/Prentice Hall
9.
BriggsKenneth ADouble Crossed: Uncovering the Catholic Church's Betrayal of American Nuns2006New YorkDoubleday
10.
BrighamErinWomen religious and the public voice of CatholicismJournal of Feminist Studies in Religion2015312109–12610.2979/jfemistudreli.31.2.109
11.
BrockMegan PResisting the catholic church's role of the nun as self-sacrificing womanFeminism & Psychology2010204473–49010.1177/0959353509359138
12.
BrowningMelissaReimer-BarryEmilyPreaching, sexuality, and women religious: listening to prophetic voices at the margins of religious lifeTheology & Sexuality201319169–8810.1179/1355835814Z.00000000020
13.
Bruno-JofréRosaMacDonaldHeidiSmythElizabeth MVatican II and Beyond: The Changing Mission and Identity of Canadian Women Religious2017MontrealMcGill-Queen's University Press10.2307/j.ctt1xp3w79
14.
BurkeKelsy CWomen's agency in gender-traditional religions: a review of four approachesSociology Compass201262122–13310.1111/j.1751-9020.2011.00439.x
15.
ByrnePatriciaSisters of St. Joseph: An Americanization of a French traditionUS Catholic Historian198653/4241–272
16.
CarbineRosemary PCreating communities of justice and peace: sacramentality and public Catholicism in the United StatesJournal for the Academic Study of Religion2016292182–20210.1558/jasr.v29i2.30938
17.
CocoAngelaCatholics, Conflicts and Choices : An Exploration of Power Relations in the Catholic Church2014New YorkRoutledge10.4324/9781315729022
18.
ConnollyMary BethFraser. Women of Faith: The Chicago Sisters of Mercy and the Evolution of a Religious Community2014Bronx, NYFordham University Press10.2307/j.ctt13wzwmk
19.
CotterElizabeth MThe general chapter in a religious institute2008BernPeter Lang AG
20.
CummingsKathleen SprowsNew Women of the Old Faith: Gender and American Catholicism in the Progressive Era2009Chapel HillUniversity of North Carolina Press
21.
DolanJay PIn Search of an American Catholicism: A History of Religion and Culture in Tension2002New York, NYOxford University Press10.1093/0195069269.001.0001
22.
EbaughHelen RoseWomen in the Vanishing Cloister: Organizational Decline in Catholic Religious Orders in the United States1993New BrunswickRutgers University Press
23.
EnglandPaulaEmerging Theories of Care WorkAnnual Review of Sociology200531381–39910.1146/annurev.soc.31.041304.122317
24.
FiorenzaElisabeth SchüsslerCritical Feminist Studies in ReligionCritical Research on Religion.20131143–5010.1177/2050303213476112
25.
GervaisChristine L. MBeyond the Altar: Women Religious, Patriarchal Power, and the Church2018Waterloo, OntarioWilfrid Laurier University Press
26.
GiorgiSimonaGuiderMargaret EBartunekJean MProductive resistance: a study of change, emotions, and identity in the context of the apostolic visitation of U.S. women religious, 2008–2012Research in the Sociology of Organizations201441259–30010.1108/S0733-558X20140000041016
27.
HallDavidLived Religion in America: Toward a History of Practice1997Princeton, NJPrinceton University Press
28.
HenoldMary JCatholic and Feminist: The Surprising History of the American Catholic Feminist Movement2008Chapel Hill, NCUniversity of North Carolina Press
29.
HochschildArlieThe Managed Heart: Commercialization of Human Feeling1983Berkeley, CAUniversity of California Press
30.
HuntMary EFeminist Theo-politics: religions and powerFeminist Theology20009259–1710.1177/096673500000002502
31.
JacobsJerryGersonKathleenThe Time Divide: Work, Family and Gender Inequality2005Cambridge, CAHarvard University Press10.2307/j.ctv1q16rx7
32.
JohnsonMaryPatricia WittbergSCGautierMary LNew generations of catholic sisters: the challenge of diversity2014New YorkOxford University Press10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199316847.001.0001
33.
KanterRosabeth MossMen and Women of the Corporation1977New YorkBasic Books
34.
KatzensteinMary FainsodFaithful and fearless: moving feminist protest inside the church and military1998Princeton, NJPrinceton University Press
35.
KoehlingerAmy LThe new nuns: racial justice and religious reform in the 1960s2007Cambridge, MassHarvard University Press10.2307/j.ctv22jntmq
36.
KvaleSteinarBrinkmannSvendInterviews learning the craft of qualitative research interviewing2008Thousand Oaks, CASage Publications
37.
LundgrenKari JThe apostolic visitation and the rhetoric of the “good nun”: identity norms in discourse representing American catholic sistersWomen's Studies in Communication2016393326–34610.1080/07491409.2016.1192077
38.
MahmoodSabaThe Politics of Piety: The Islamic Revival and the Feminist Subject2005Princeton, NJPrinceton University Press
39.
MangionCarmenCatholic Nuns and Sisters in a Secular Age2020ManchesterManchester University Press10.7765/9781526140470
40.
MascarenhasMridulaProphetic and deliberative responses to the doctrinal voice: a study of the rhetorical engagement between catholic nuns and church hierarchyJournal of Communication & Religion201739439–54
41.
McCarthyMargaret CainZollmannMary AnnPower of sisterhood: women religious tell the story of the apostolic visitation2014Lanham, MDUniversity Press of America
42.
McNayLoisGender and agency: reconfiguring the subject in feminist and social theory2000Malden, MAPolity Press
43.
MillsAlbert JRyanCatherineContesting the spiritual space: patriarchy, nureaucracy, and the gendering of women's religious ordersTamara Journal of Critical Organisation Inquiry20011460
44.
MorganDavid LGivenLisa MSnowball SamplingThe SAGE encyclopedia of qualitative research methods2008Thousand Oaks, CASAGE Publications Inc816
45.
MurphyRyan PPromises unfulfilled: American religious sisters and gender inequality in the post-Vatican II Catholic ChurchSocial Compass2014614594–61010.1177/0037768614547487
46.
Murphy, Ryan P. 2017. Breaking Through the Glass Cloister: The Sisters of St. Joseph of Philadelphia, Social Justice, and Gender Consciousness After Vatican II. PhD dissertation. Department of Sociology, Temple University.
QuiñonezLora AnnTurnerMary DanielThe Transformation of American Catholic Sisters1992PhiladelphiaTemple University Press
51.
ReskinBarbara FBringing the men back in: sex differentiation and the devaluation of women's workGender & Society19882158–8110.1177/089124388002001005
52.
SchneidersSandra MProphets in their own country: women religious bearing witness to the gospel in a troubled church2011Maryknoll, NYOrbis Books
53.
SmithChristianVaidyanathanBrandonAmmermanNancy TatomCasanovaJoséDavidsonHilaryEcklundElaine HowardEvansJohn HGorskiPhilip SKoniecznyMary EllenSpringsJason ATrinitapoliJennyWhitnahMeredithRoundtable on the sociology of religion: twenty-three theses on the status of religion in American sociology—a Mellon working-group reflectionJournal of the American Academy of Religion2013814903–93810.1093/jaarel/lft052
54.
ThompsonMargaret SusanCircles of sisterhood: formal and informal collaboration among American nuns in response to conflict with Vatican KyriarchyJournal of Feminist Studies in Religion201632263–8210.2979/jfemistudreli.32.2.06
55.
WallBarbara MannInto Africa: a transnational history of catholic medical missions and social change2015New BrunswickRutgers University Press10.36019/9780813566238
56.
WeberMaxEconomy and Society: An Outline of Interpretive Sociology1978Oakland, CaliforniaUniv of California Press
57.
WittbergPatriciaThe rise and fall of catholic religious orders: a social movement perspective1994Albany, NYState University of New York Press
