This experimental study utilised a sample of 131 online panel members to examine how service failure severity and perceived employee effort influence consumers’ postrecovery negative WOM and trust evaluations in the context of a 100% satisfaction guarantee. In this study, while the promised guarantee compensation is forthcoming, the failure remains uncorrected. Findings indicate that while the level of effort does not influence negative WOM when a major problem eventuates, high versus low levels of effort are appreciated for a minor failure. Evaluations of trust are enhanced when employees display a high versus a low level of effort across both minor and severe failure conditions. Overall, findings suggest that it would be unwise for organisations offering a “100% satisfaction or your money back” guarantee to rely too heavily on economic compensation to recover from service failures; the failure itself must also be rectified.
BeardonW.O.MasonJ.B.An investigation of influences on consumer complaint reportsKinnearT.C.Advances in Consumer Research1984Association for Consumer ResearchProvo, UT
3.
BellC.R.ZemkeR.E.Service breakdown: the road to recoveryManagement Review7610198732–35
4.
BerryL.L.On Great Services: A Framework for Action1995Free PressNew York, NY
5.
BerryL.L.ParasuramanA.Marketing Services: Competing Through Quality1991Free PressNew York, NY
6.
BitnerM.J.Evaluating service encounters: the effect of physical surroundings and employee responsesJournal of Marketing542199069–82
7.
BitnerM.J.BoomsB.H.TetreaultM.S.The service encounter: diagnosing favourable and unfavourable incidentsJournal of Marketing541199071–85
8.
Björlin-LidénS.SkålénP.The effect of service guarantees on service recoveryInternational Journal of Service Industry Management141200336–48
9.
BlodgettJ.G.HillD.J.TaxS.S.The effects of distributive, procedural, and interactional justice on postcomplaint behaviourJournal of Retailing7321997185–210
10.
BoshoffC.An experimental study of service recovery optionsInternational Journal of Service Industry Management82199711–30
11.
BoshoffC.LeongJ.Empowerment, attribution and apologising as dimensions of service recoveryInternational Journal of Service Industry Management91199824–47
12.
BrownS.W.CowlesD.L.TutenT.L.Service recovery: its value and limitations as a retail strategyInternational Journal of Service Industry Management75199632–46
13.
CallanR.MooreJ.Service guarantees: a strategy for service recoveryJournal of Hospitality and Tourism Research221199856–71
14.
CavanaR.Y.DelahayeB.L.SekaranU.Applied Business Research: Qualitative and Quantitative Methods2001John Wiley and SonsMilton, Queensland
15.
CengizE.BünyaminE.KurtaranA.The effects of failure recovery satisfaction on customer behaviours via complaintBanks and Bank Systems232007173–196
16.
ChoongP.Preventing or fixing a problem? A marketing manager's dilemma revisitedJournal of Services Marketing152200199–108
CookT.C.CampbellD.T.Quasi-Experimentation: Design and Analysis Issues for Field Settings1979Rand McNallyChicago, IL
19.
DabholkarP.A.Consumer evaluations of new technology-based self-service options: an investigation of alternative models of service qualityInternational Journal of Research in Marketing131199629–51
20.
DavidowM.Organisational responses to customer complaints: what works and what doesn'tJournal of Service Research532003225–250
21.
DavisJ.P.EisenhardtK.M.BinghamC.B.Developing theory through simulation methodsAcademy of Management Review3222007480–499
22.
DolinskyA.L.A consumer complaint framework with resulting strategiesJournal of Services Marketing83199427–39
23.
DonathN.How Israeli hotel chain ISROTEL developed its service guaranteeManaging Service Quality72199787–91
24.
DoneyP.M.CannonJ.P.An examination of the nature of trust in buyer–seller relationshipsJournal of Marketing61199735–71
25.
DwyerF.R.ShurrP.H.OhS.Developing buyer–seller relationshipsJournal of Marketing512198711–27
26.
EatonB.The Problems and Pitfalls of Net Survey Methodologies1997Creative Research Systems, Inc.Petaluma, CA
27.
EvansJ.R.MathurA.The value of online surveysInternet Research1522005195–219
28.
EvansM.R.J.ClarkD.J.KnutsonB.J.The 100-per cent unconditional money-back guaranteeCornell Hotel and Restaurant Administration Quarterly376199656–61
29.
FirnstahlT.W.My employees are my service guaranteeHarvard Business Review674198928–30
30.
FisherJ.E.GarrettD.E.ArnoldM.J.FerrisM.E.Dissatisfied customers who complain to the better business bureauJournal of Consumer Marketing1661999576–589
31.
FolkesV.S.Consumer reactions to product failure: an attributional approachJournal of Consumer Research1041984398–409
32.
FolkesV.S.KoletskyS.GrahamJ.L.A field study of causal inferences and consumer reaction: the view from the airportJournal of Consumer Research1341987534–539
33.
GillyM.C.GelbB.D.Post-purchase consumer processes and the complaining consumerJournal of Consumer Research931982323–328
34.
GraysonK.A.AmblerT.The dark-side of long term relationships in marketing servicesJournal of Marketing Research36132–1411999
35.
GrönroosC.Internal marketing – an integral part of marketing theoryDonnellyJ.H.G.WilliamR.Marketing of Services1981American Marketing AssociationChicago, Il
36.
GrönroosC.Services Management and Marketing: Managing the Moments of Truth in Service Competition1990Lexington BooksLexington, MA
37.
HairJ.F.BlackW.C.BabinB.J.AndersonR.E.TathamR.L.Multivariate Data Analysissixth ed.2006Prentice HallUpper Saddle River, NJ
38.
HalsteadD.DrögeC.CooperM.B.Product warranties and lost purchase service: a model of consumer satisfaction with complaint resolutionJournal of Services Marketing71199333–40
39.
HartC.W.L.The power of unconditional service guaranteesHarvard Business Review664198854–62
40.
HartC.W.L.Extraordinary Guarantees1993American Management AssociationNew York, NY
41.
HartC.W.L.Extraordinary Guarantees – Achieving Breakthrough Gains in Quality and Customer Satisfaction1998Spire GroupBrookline, MA
42.
HartC.W.L.HeskettJ.L.SasserE.E.J.The profitable art of service recoveryHarvard Business Review6741990148–156
43.
HartC.W.L.SchlesingerL.A.MaherD.Guarantees come to professional service firmsSloan Management Review333199219–29
44.
HaysJ.M.HillA.V.A longitudinal study of the effect of a service guarantee on service qualityProduction and Operations Management1042001405–423
45.
HillA.V.GeursS.E.HaysJ.M.JohnsonG.J.SwansonR.A.Service guarantees and strategic service quality performance metrics at Radisson Hotels worldwideJournal of Strategic Performance Measurement262199827–31
46.
HocuttM.A.BowersM.R.The impact of service guarantees on consumer responses in the hotel industryJournal of Hospitality and Leisure Marketing13120055–23
47.
HoffmanK.D.KelleyS.W.RotalskyH.M.Tracking service failures and employee recovery effortsJournal of Services Marketing92/3199549–61
48.
HogreveJ.GremlerD.D.Twenty years of service guarantee researchJournal of Service Research1142009322–343
49.
JohnstonR.Service failure and recovery: impact, attributes and processSwartzT.A.BowenD.E.BrownS.W.Advances in Services Marketing and Management1995JAI PressGreenwich, CT
50.
KahnermanD.TverskyA.Prospect theory: an analysis of decision under riskEconometrica4721979263–291
51.
KaiserH.A second generation little jiffyPsychometrika351970401–415
52.
KandampullyJ.ButlerL.Service guarantees: a strategic mechanism to minimise customers’ perceived risk in service organisationsManaging Service Quality1122001112–120
53.
KeaveneyS.M.Customer switching behaviour in service industries: an exploratory studyJournal of Marketing592199571–82
54.
KelleyS.W.DavisM.A.Antecedents to customer expectations for service recoveryJournal of the Academy of Marketing Science221199452–61
55.
KelleyS.W.HoffmanK.D.DavisM.A.A typology of retail failures and recoveriesJournal of Retailing6941993429–452
56.
KnauerV.Increasing Customer Satisfaction1992United States Office of Consumer AffairsPueblo, CO
57.
LauG.T.NgS.Individual and situational factors influencing negative word-of-mouth behaviourCanadian Journal of Administrative Sciences1832001163–178
58.
LevesqueT.J.McDougallG.H.G.Service problems and recovery strategies: an experimentCanadian Journal of Administrative Sciences171200020–37
59.
LewisB.R.SpyrakopolousS.Service failures and recovery in retail banking: the consumer's perspectiveInternational Journal of Bank Marketing191200237–47
60.
LichtensteinD.R.BeardonW.O.Contextual influences on perceptions of merchant-supplied reference pricesJournal of Consumer Research161198955–66
61.
LovelockC.H.PattersonP.G.WalkerR.H.Services Marketing: An Asia Pacific Perspectivethird ed.2004Prentice HallFrenchs Forrest, N.S.W
MathwickC.Understanding the online consumer: a typology of online relational norms and behaviourJournal of Interactive Marketing161200240–55
64.
MattilaA.S.The effectiveness of service recovery in a multi-industry settingJournal of Services Marketing1572001583–596
65.
MaxhamJ.G.IIINetemeyerR.G.A longitudinal study of complaining customers′ evaluations of multiple service failures and recovery effortsJournal of Marketing664200257–71
66.
McCaskeyD.A good night – 100% guaranteeThe Hospitality Review16April200116–21
67.
McCollR.MattssonJ.MorleyC.The effects of service guarantees on service evaluations during a voiced complaint and recoveryJournal of Consumer Satisfaction, Dissatisfaction and Complaining Behaviour18200522–50C
68.
McColloughM.A.BerryL.L.YadavM.S.An empirical investigation of customer satisfaction after service failure and recoveryJournal of Service Research322000121–137
69.
McDougallG.H.LevesqueT.J.The effectiveness of recovery strategies after service failure: an experiment in the hospitality industryJournal of Hospitality and Leisure Marketing52/3199827–49
70.
McQuilkenL., BednallD., 2008. Service recovery in a service guarantee context. In: SpanjardD. et al. (Eds.), Proceedings of the Australian and New Zealand Academy of Marketing Conference.University of Western Sydney, Sydney.
71.
MillerJ.L.CraigheadC.W.KarwanK.R.Service recovery: a framework and empirical investigationJournal of Operations Management1842000387–400
72.
MohrL.A.BitnerM.J.The role of employee effort in satisfaction with service transactionsJournal of Business Research3231995239–252
73.
MorganR.M.HuntS.D.The commitment-trust theory of relationship marketingJournal of Marketing583199420–38
74.
NooteboomB.BergerH.NoorderhavenN.G.Effects of trust and governance on relational riskAcademy of Management Journal4021997308–338
75.
OstromA.L.IacobucciD.The effects of guarantees on consumers’ evaluation of servicesThe Journal of Services Marketing1251998362–378
76.
ParasuramanA.ZeithamlV.A.BerryL.L.A conceptual model of service quality and its implications for future researchJournal of Marketing94198541–50
77.
ReicheldF.F.SchefterP.E-loyalty: your secret weapon on the webHarvard Business Review7842000105–113
78.
RoseM.D., 1990. No strings attached. Chief Executive60 (July/August), 30–33.
79.
RotteK.ChandrashekaranM.TaxS.S.GrewalR.Forgiven but not forgotten: covert uncertainty in overt responses and the paradox of defection-despite-trustJournal of Consume Psychology1632006283–294
80.
RustR.SubramanianB.WellsM.Making complaints a management toolMarketing Management13199241–45
81.
SarelD.MarmortsteinH.Improving the effectiveness of banks’ service guarantees: the role of implementationJournal of Financial Services Marketing532001215–226
82.
SinghJ.Consumer complaint intentions and behaviour: definitional and taxonomical issuesJournal of Marketing521198893–107
83.
SinghJ.WilkesR.E.When consumers complain: a path analysis of the key antecedents of consumer complaint response elementsJournal of the Academy of Marketing Science2441996350–365
84.
SirdeshmukhD.SinghJ.SabolB.Customer trust, value, and loyalty in relational exchangesJournal of Marketing661200215–37
85.
SmithA.K.BoltonR.N.An experimental investigation of customer reactions to service failure and recovery encounter: paradox or peril?Journal of Services Research11199865–81
86.
SmithA.K.BoltonR.N.WagnerJ.A model of customer satisfaction with service encounters involving failure and recoveryJournal of Marketing Research3631999356–372
SparksB.A.McColl-KennedyJ.R.Justice strategy options for increased customer satisfaction in a services recovery settingJournal of Business Research5432001209–218
89.
SpechtN.FichtelS.MeyerA.Perception and attribution of employees’ effort and abilitiesInternational Journal of Service Industry Management1852007534–554
90.
SumC.-C.LeeYang-SangHaysJ.M.HillA.V.Modelling the effects of a service guarantee on service quality using alternative conditional expectations (ACE)Decision Sciences3332002347–383
91.
SusskindA.M.I told you so! Restaurant customers’ word-of-mouth communication patternsCornell Hotel and Restaurant Administration Quarterly432200175–85
92.
SwanJ.E.OliverR.L.Postpurchase communication by consumersJournal of Retailing6521989513–516
93.
TARP Australia, 1995. Study of Consumer Complaint Behaviour in Australia. The American Express/SOCAP (Society of Consumer Affairs Professional in Business Australia Inc.).
94.
TaxS.S.BrownS.W.Recovering and learning from service failuresSloan Management Review401199875–88
95.
TaxS.S.BrownS.W.ChandrashekaranM.Customer evaluations of service complaint experiences: implications for relationship marketingJournal of Marketing622199860–76
96.
ThalerR.Mental accounting and consumer choiceMarketing Science431985199–214
97.
TucciL.A.TalagaJ.Service guarantees and consumers’ evaluation of servicesJournal of Services Marketing111199710–18
98.
TverskyA.KahnermanD.Advances in prospect theory: cumulative representation of uncertaintyJournal of Risk and Uncertainty541992297–323
99.
VroomV.H.Some Personality Determinants of the Effects of Participation1960Prentice HallEnglewood Cliffs, NJ
100.
WebsterC.SundaramD.S.Service consumption criticality in failure recoveryJournal of Business Research4121998153–159
101.
WeinerB.Human Motivation1980Holt, Rinehart and WinstonNew York
102.
WeinerB.An Attributional Theory of Motivation and Emotion1986Springer-VerlagNew York, NY
103.
WeunS.BeattyS.E.JonesM.A.The impact of service failure severity on service recovery evaluations and post-recovery relationshipsJournal of Services Marketing1822004133–146
104.
WidmierS.JacksonD.W.Examining the effects of service failure, customer compensation, and fault on customer satisfaction with salespeopleJournal of Marketing Theory and Practice101200263–73
105.
WilsonP.McNamaraJ.R.How perceptions of a simulated physician-patient interaction influences intended satisfaction and complianceSocial Science and Medicine161919821699–1704
106.
WirtzJ.Development of a service guarantee modelAsia Pacific Journal of Management151199815–75
107.
WirtzJ.MattilaA.S.Consumer responses to compensation, speed of recovery and apology after service failureInternational Journal of Service Industry Management1522004150–166
108.
WirtzJ.KumD.LeeK.S.Should a firm with a reputation for outstanding service quality offer a service guarantee?Journal of Services Marketing1462000502–512
109.
WoodT.Total quality management: learning from other industriesRestaurants USA132199316–19
110.
ZeithamlV.BerryL.L.ParasuramanA.The nature and determinants of customer expectations of serviceJournal of the Academy of Marketing Science2119931–11
111.
ZemkeR.BellC.Service recovery: doing it right the second timeTraining276199042–48
