Immigration,Imagined Communities,and Collective Memories of Asian American Experiences: A Content Analysis of Asian American Experiences in Virginia U.S. History Textbooks ∗
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online January, 2015
Immigration,Imagined Communities,and Collective Memories of Asian American Experiences: A Content Analysis of Asian American Experiences in Virginia U.S. History Textbooks ∗
This study explores how Asian American experiences are depicted in four high school U.S. history textbooks and four middle school U.S. history textbooks used in Virginia. The analytic framework was developed from the scholarship of collective memories and histories of immigration in Asian American studies. Content analysis of the textbooks suggests the overall narrative of Asian American history in U.S. history textbooks aligns with the grand narrative of American history, that is, the “story of progress.” This major storyline of Asian Americans – that they suffered from nativist racism and discrimination for a long time, overcame these obstacles through their hard work and efforts, and achieved the American dream – fits well into the master narrative of American progress, highlighting the process of their belonging to the U.S. as citizens. This storyline misrepresents the realities and diversity among Asian ethnic groups and their migration histories as well as the fluid nature of their identities across national borders. These findings stress the continued challenges in representing Asian American experiences as well as other marginalized groups in U.S. history textbooks.
AguirreA.LioS.Spaces of mobilization: The Asian American/Pacific Islander struggle for social justiceSocial Justice35220081–17
2.
AldridgeD.The limits of master narratives in history textbooks: An analysis of representations of Martin Luther King, JrTeachers College Record10842006662–686
3.
AnS.Learning U.S. history in an age of transnational migrationJournal of Curriculum Studies4162009763–787
4.
AnchetaA.Race, rights, and the Asian American experience1998Rutgers UniversityNew Jersey
5.
AndersonB.Imagined communities: Reflections on the origin and spread of nationalism1991Verso BooksNew York City, NY
6.
AndersonC.B.Misplaced multiculturalism: Representations of American Indians in U.S. history academic content standardsCurriculum Inquiry4242012497–509
7.
AndersonC.B.MetzgerS.Slavery, the Civil War era, and African American representation in U.S. History: An analysis of four States’ academic standardsTheory and Research in Social Education3932011393–415
8.
AppleM.Official knowledge: Democratic education in a conservative age1996RoutledgeNew York, NY
9.
AzumaE.Between two empires: Race, history, and transnationalism in Japanese America2005Oxford University PressOxford, UK
10.
BanksJ.A.BanksC.A. M.Multicultural education: Issues and perspectives1993Allyn & BaconBoston
11.
BartonK.C.LevstikL.Teaching history for the common good2004RoutledgeNew York
12.
BennettC.I.Comprehensive multicultural education7th ed.2010Allyn & BaconNeedham Heights, MA
13.
BrownA.L.BrownK.D.Strange fruit indeed: Integrating contemporary textbook representations of racial violence toward African AmericansTeachers College Record1121201031–67
14.
BrownK.D.BrownA.L.Silenced memories: An examination of the sociocultural knowledge on race and racial violence in official school curriculumEquity & Excellent in Education4322010139–154
15.
ChanS.Asian American historiographyPacific Historical Review6531996363–399
16.
ChanS.The changing contours of Asian-American historiographyRethinking History1112007125–147
17.
ChappellD.Training Americans: Ideology, performance, and social studies textbooksTheory and Research in Social Education3822010248–269
18.
ChinC.Asian Americans and California state textbooksSocial Studies Review233198446–54
19.
CoolidgeM.R.Chinese immigration1909Henry HoltNew York City, NY
20.
DanielsR.Westerners from the East: Oriental immigrants reappraisedPacific Historical Review3541966373–383
21.
Darling-HammondL.The flat world and education: How America's commitment to equity will determine our future2010Teachers College PressNew York, NY
22.
EpsteinT.Interpreting national history: Race, identity, and pedagogy in classrooms and communities2009RoutledgeNew York & London
23.
EpsteinT.MayorgaE.NelsonJ.Teaching about race in an urban history class: The effects of culturally responsive teachingJournal of Social Studies Research35120112–21
FosterS.Pride and prejudice: Treatment of immigrant groups in United States history textbooks, 1890–1930Education and Culture17120121–7
26.
GonzalesM.H.RiedelE.WilliamsonI.AveryP.G.SullivanJ.L.BosA.Variations of citizenship education: A content analysis of rights, obligations and participation concepts in high school civic textbooksTheory and Research in Social Education3232004301–325
27.
Harada, V. H. (2000). The treatment of Asian Americans in U.S. history textbooks published 1994–1996. Retrieved from ERIC Clearinghouse for Social Studies/Social Science Education (ED448072).
28.
HawkinsJ.BuckendorfM.A current analysis of the treatment of Japanese Americans internment in United States history textbooksJournal of International Social Studies11201034–42
29.
HilurnJ.FitchettP.G.The new gateway, an old paradox: Immigrants and involuntary Americans in North Carolina history textbooksTheory and Research in Social Education401201235–65
30.
HongW.-P.Reading school textbooks as a cultural and political text: Representations of Asia in geography textbooks used in the United StatesJournal of Curriculum Theorizing251200986–99
31.
HowardT.C.“Does race really matter?”: Secondary students’ sconstructions of racial dialogue in the social studiesTheory & Research in Social Education3242004484–502
32.
HsuM.Transnationalism and Asian American studies as a migration-centered projectJournal of Asian American Studies1122008185–197
33.
Japanese American Citizens LeagueAn unnoticed struggle: A concise history of Asian American civil rights issues2008Japanese American Citizens LeagueSan Francisco
34.
Jo, J. (2004). Transforming identity (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina
35.
JohnsonK.HingB.National identity in a multicultural nation: The challenge of immigration law and immigrantsMichigan Law Review103520051347
36.
JournellW.Setting out the (un)welcome mat: A portrayal of immigration in state standards for American historyThe Social Studies10042009160–168
37.
JournellW.Standardizing citizenship: The potential influence of state curriculum standards on the civic development of adolescentsPS: Political Science & Politics4322010351–358
38.
KingJ.E.Culture-centered knowledge: Black studies, curriculum transformation, and social actionBanksJ.A.BanksC.A. M.Handbook of research on multicultural education2001Jossey-BassSan Francisco265–290
39.
KnollT.Becoming Americans: Asian sojourners, immigrants, and refugees in the Western United States1982Coast to Coast BooksPortland, OR
40.
KrippendorfK.Content analysis: An introduction to its methodology2nd ed.2004SageThousand Oaks, CA
41.
Ladson-BillingsG.New directions in multicultural education: Complexities, boundaries, and critical race theoryBanksJ.A.BanksC.A. M.Handbook of research on multicultural education2nd ed.2005Jossey-BassSan Francisco50–65
42.
LeeR.H.The Chinese in the United States of America1960Hong Kong University PressHong Kong
43.
LeeS.J.Unraveling the model minority stereotype1996Teachers College PressNew York, NY
44.
LeeS.J.Up against whiteness2006Teachers College Columbia UniversityNew York, NY
45.
Lei, J. (2001). Claims to belonging and difference (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin
46.
LewJ.The other” story of model minorities: Korean American high school dropouts in an urban contextAnthropology & Education Quarterly3532004303–323
47.
LoewenJ.W.Lies my teachers told me: Everything your American textbook got wrong1995/2007 Touchstone BooksOld Tappan, NJ
48.
LoweL.Immigrant acts: On Asian American cultural politics1996Duke University PressDurham, NC
49.
MarkusH.R.KitayamaS.Models of agency: Sociocultural diversity in the construction actionMurphy-BermanV.BermanJ.Cross-cultural differences in perspectives on the self2004University of Nebraska PressLincoln, NE1–57
50.
MartellC.C.Race and histories: Examining culturally relevant teaching in the U.S. history classroomTheory and Research in Social Education411201365–88
51.
MartellC.C.Hashimoto-MartellE.A.Throwing out the textbook: A teacher research study of changing texts in the history classroomHickmanH.PorfilioB.J.The new politics of the textbook: Critical analysis in the core content areas2012SenseBoston305–320
52.
MerryfieldM.Reconceptualizing social studiesWilliamS.B.Critical issues in social studies for the 21st century2001Information Age PublishingGreenwich, CT179–208
53.
MinP.Social science research on Asian AmericansBanksJ.BanksA.Handbook of research on multicultural education2004MacmillanNY332–345
54.
MitchellK.ParkerW.I pledge allegiance to… flexible citizenship and shifting scales of belongingTeachers College Record11042008775–804
55.
Mo, K. (2000). Citizenship education for Korean American youth (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). Berkeley, CA: University of California
56.
NgaiM.Impossible subjects: Illegal aliens and the making of modern America2004Princeton University PressNew York
57.
NgaiM.Transnationalism and the transformation of the “Other”: Response to the presidential addressAmerican Quarterly571200559–65
58.
NgaiM.Asian American history: Reflections on the de-centering of the fieldJournal of American Ethnic History251200697–108
59.
NoddingsN.Social studies and feminismTheory & Research in Social Education2031992230–241
60.
OgawaM.Treatment of Japanese–American internment during World War II in U.S. history textbooksInternational Journal of Social Education191200435–47
61.
OngA.Flexible citizenship: The cultural logics of transnationality1999Duke University PressDurham, NC
62.
ParkG.C.“Are we ‘real’ Americans?”: Cultural production of “Forever foreigners” at a diversity eventEducation and Urban Society4342011451–467
63.
RainsF.V.The color of social studies: A post-social studies reality checkRossE.W.The social studies curriculum: Purposes, problems, and possibilities3rd ed.2006State University of New York PressAlbany137–156
64.
RomanowskiM.Impressions of the democratic ideals of justice and equality in U.S. history textbooks: The treatment of Japanese Americans during World War IIJournal of Social Studies Research191199531–49
65.
SalinasC.Educating late arrival high school immigrant students: A call for a more democratic curriculumMulticultural Perspectives81200620–27
66.
SchmidtS.J.Am I a woman? The normalization of woman in U.S. historyGender and Education2472012707–724
67.
SchreierM.Qualitative content analysis in practice2012SageLos Angeles, CA
68.
SeixasP.Theorizing historical consciousness2004University of Toronto PressToronto, CA
SpringJ.Deculturalization and the struggle for equality: a brief history of the education of dominated cultures in the United States2008McGraw-HillBoston
71.
StearnsP.N.SeixasP.WineburgS.Knowing, teaching, and learning history: National and international perspectives2000New York University PressNew York
72.
SungB.L.Mountain of gold: The story of the Chinese in America1967MacMillanNew York City, NY
73.
TakakiR.A history of Asian Americans: Strangers from a different shore1989/1998 Back Bay BooksNew York, NY
74.
TyackD.Monuments between covers: The politics of textbooksAmerican Behavioral Scientist4261999922–932
van HoverS.HicksD.StoddardJ.LisantiM.From a roar to a murmur: Virginia's history & social science standards, 1995-2009Theory & Research in Social Education381201080–113
77.
VanSledrightB.Narratives of nation-state, historical knowledge, and school history educationReview of Research in Education3212008109–146
78.
WertschJ.W.Voices of collective memory2002Cambridge University PressCambridge, U.K; New York
79.
WertschJ.W.O'ConnorK.Multivoicedness in historical representation: American college students’ accounts of the origins of the U.SJournal of Narrative and Life History441994295–310
80.
WillsJ.S.Who needs multicultural education? White students, U.S. history, and the construction of a usable pastAnthropology & Education Quarterly2731996365–389
81.
WongM.G.Book Review. Strangers from a different shore: A history of Asian Americans by Ronald TakakiJournal of American Ethnic History111199198–99
82.
ZimmermanJ.Whose America?: Culture wars in the public schools2005Harvard University PressCambridge, MA
83.
ZuercherR.The treatment of Asian minorities in American history textbooksIndiana Social Studies Quarterly22196919–27(Autumn)
