This qualitative study examined how social studies teachers implemented experiential instructional techniques by closely analyzing videotaped lessons taught over four years in third through 12th grade classrooms across 16 school districts. Data analysis indicated that of the 438 lessons, only 14 involved experiential instructional techniques, and their implementation generally failed to reflect the potential benefits of this instructional approach. Twelve of the experiential exercises (a) lacked a clear instructional purpose related to the content; (b) did reflect an instructional purpose, but it was ultimately thwarted by the activity's unanticipated dynamism; or (c) encouraged the development of significant misconceptions about the content, while one of the two lessons without these problems demonstrated the strategy's use for reinforcement of factual recall rather than critical thinking. Implications for social studies education research and practice are considered.
AldrichC.Learning by doing: a comprehensive guide to simulations, computer games, and pedagogy in e-learning and other educational experiences2005PfeifferSan Francisco, CA
2.
AldrichC.The complete guide to simulations and serious games: how the most valuable content will be created in the age beyond Gutenberg to Google2009PfeifferSan Francisco, CA
3.
ArnoldT.Make your history class hop with excitement (at least once a semester): designing and using classroom simulationsHistory Teacher3121998193–204
BaranowskiM.Single session simulations: the effectiveness of short congressional simulations in introductory American government classesJournal of Political Science Education21200633–49
6.
BartonK.LevstikL.Teaching history for the common good2004RoutledgeNew York, NY
7.
Ben-PeretzM.Identifying with horror: teaching about the holocaust: a response to Simon Schweber's simulating survivalCurriculum Inquiry3322003189–198
BlagaJ.J.A study of teachers’ perceptions and utilization of simulations in public secondary social studies classrooms in Ohio(Unpublished doctoral dissertation)1978The Ohio State UniversityColumbus, OH
10.
Bornstein-GroveM.HamelF.L.The Makah whale hunt: a social studies symposium in the classroomSocial Education7742013201–205
11.
ButlerJ.T.Games and simulations: Creative educational alternativesTechTrends334198820–23
12.
ByrnesD.A.KigerG.The effect of a prejudice – reduction simulation on attitude changeJournal of Applied Social Psychology2041990341–356
13.
CharmazK.Constructing grounded theory: a practical guide through qualitative analysis2006SageLos Angeles, CA
14.
CleggA.Jr.Games and simulations in social studies educationShaverJ.P.Handbook of research on social studies teaching and learning1991Macmillan Publishing CompanyNew York, NY523–529
15.
CoffeyA.AtkinsonP.Making sense of qualitative data: complementary research strategies1996SageThousand Oaks, CA
16.
ColellaV.Participatory simulations: building collaborative understanding through immersive dynamic modelingJournal of the Learning Sciences942000371–500
17.
CreswellJ.W.Qualitative inquiry and research design: choosing among five approaches3rd ed.2013SageThousand Oaks, CA
18.
CrookallD.Serious games, debriefing, and simulation/gaming as a disciplineSimulation & Gaming4162010898–920
19.
DeLeonA.P.Are we simulating the status quo? Ideology and social studies simulationTheory and Research in Social Education3632008256–277
20.
DeweyJ.Experience and education1938/1997 Simon & SchusterNew York, NY
21.
DiCamilloL.GradwellJ.M.Using simulations to teach middle grades U.S. history in an age of accountabilityRMLE Online35720121–16
22.
DiCamilloL.GradwellJ.M.To simulate or not to simulate? Investigating myths about social studies simulationsThe Social Studies1042013155–160
JoyceB.WeilM.CalhounE.Models of teaching8th ed.2009Allyn and BaconBoston, MA
28.
Kawashima-GinsbergK.Do discussions, debate, and simulations boost NAEP Civics performance?2013Tufts UniversityMedford, MARetrieved from
29.
KolbD.A.Experiential learning: Experience as the source of learning and development1984Prentice-HallNew Jersey
30.
KolbA.Y.KolbD.A.Experiential learning theory: a dynamic, holistic approach to management learning, education and developmentArmstrongS.J.FukamiC.Handbook of management learning, education, and development2008SageLondon42–68
LarsonB.E.KeiperT.A.Instructional strategies for middle and high school2011RoutledgeNew York, NY
33.
LeeP.ShemiltD.The concept that dares not speak its name: should empathy come out of the closet?Teaching History143201139–49
34.
LeighE.SpindlerL.Simulations and games as chaordic learning contextsSimulations & Gaming351200453–69
35.
LewinK.Field theory and learningCartwrightD.Field Theory in the Social Science: Selected Theoretical Papers1942/1951 Social Science PaperbacksLondon
36.
MaitlesH.McKelvieE.“Why does wearing a yellow bib make us different?”: a case study of explaining discrimination in a west of Scotland secondary (high) schoolJournal for Critical Education Policy Studies812010245–261
37.
MarshallC.RossmanG.B.Designing qualitative research5th ed.2011SageThousand Oaks, CA
38.
McCallJ.Navigating the problem space: the medium of simulation games in the teaching of historyHistory Teacher46120129–28
39.
MilesM.B.HubermanA.M.Qualitative data analysis: an expanded sourcebook2nd ed1994SageThousand Oaks, CA
40.
National Council for the Social Studies (NCSS). 2008. A vision of powerful teaching and learning in the social studies: building social understanding and civic efficacy: a position statement of national council for the social studies. Retrieved from: 〈http://www.socialstudies.org/positions/powerful〉.
41.
RobinsonA.SchurJ.Advocating for abolition: staging an abolitionist society conventionSocial Education7442010178–183
StephensJ.M.FeinbergJ.ZackJ.Those who do: Social studies teachers’ use of role play and simulations and the making of 21st century citizensPasseJ.FitchettP.G.The status of social studies: views from the field2013Information Age PublishersCharlotte, NC259–279
46.
Teachers’ Curriculum InstituteBring learning alive! Methods to transform middle and high school social studies instruction2010TCIRancho Cordova, CA
47.
ThiemanG.Y.CaranoK.T.From the field: how Oregon social studies teachers are preparing students for the 21st centuryOregon Journal of the Social Studies1120133–20
48.
WeinbergC.R.The discomfort zone: Reenacting slavery at Connor PrairieThe Organization of American Historians Magazine of History, 2322009Retrieved from
49.
Wright-MaleyC.In defense of simulating complex and tragic historical episodes: a measured response to the outcry over a New England slavery simulationCanadian Social Studies471201418–25
50.
Wright-Maley, C. Overcoming the “Babel problem”: defining simulations for the social studies. Paper presented at the meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Philadelphia, PA, 2014b, April.
51.
Wright-Maley, C. 2014c. Two successful approaches to implementing simulations in the social studies. Paper presented at the meeting of the College and University Faculty Association of the National Council for the Social Studies Conference, Boston, MA, November.
52.
Wright-MaleyC.Beyond the “Babel problem”: defining simulations for the social studiesThe Journal of Social Studies Research201510.1016/j.jssr.2014.10.001
53.
YinR.K.Case study research: design and methods4th ed.2009SageLos Angeles, CA
