Anecdotal evidence has long lamented the status of social studies in elementary classrooms as observed by preservice teachers. As standardized testing has risen for mathematics and language arts, social studies has been pushed aside. In the aftermath of accountability legislation such as No Child Left Behind, research indicates that social studies is less visible in elementary classrooms due to an instructional focus on tested content areas (e.g. math, language arts, reading). In this study, approximately 90 elementary preservice teachers enrolled in a social studies methods course responded to a survey and indicated the frequency and quality of lessons they observed over the course of a single semester. Findings report that preservice elementary teachers witnessed few, if any, lessons in social studies in the elementary classroom. Implications for teacher education are discussed.
Allison, E. R., & Goldston, J. M. (2013). A survey of preservice teachers’ observations of elementary science instruction during their clinical fieldwork. In Paper presented at The Association for Science Teacher Education. Charleston, SC.
2.
AppleM.W.BeaneJ.A.Democratic schools: lessons in powerful education2nd ed.2007HeinemannPortsmouth, NH
3.
BaileyG.ShawE.L.Jr.HollifieldD.The devaluation of social studies in the elementary gradesJournal of Social Studies Research302200618–29
4.
BolickC.M.AdamsR.WilloxL.The marginalization of elementary social studies in teacher educationSocial Studies Research and Practice5220101–22
5.
Boyle-BaiseM.HsuM.C.JohnsonS.SerriereS.C.StewartD.Trying to revalue elementary social studies: dilemmas and insightsSocial Studies Research and Practice622011135–150
6.
Boyle-BaiseM.McIntyreD.J.What kind of experience? Preparing teachers in PDS or community settings?Cochran-SmithM.Feiman-NemserS.McIntyreD.J.Handbook of research on teacher education: enduring questions in changing contexts2008Routledge and the Association of Teacher EducatorsNew York307–329
7.
BurroughsS.GroceE.WebeckM.L.Social studies education in the age of testing and accountabilityEducational Measurement: Issues and Practice243200513–20
8.
CastroA.J.Themes in the research on preservice teachers’ views of cultural diversity: implications for researching millennial preservice teachersEducational Researcher3932010198–210
9.
Cochran-SmithM.Feiman-NemserS.McIntyreJ.D.Handbook of research on teacher education: enduring questions in changing contexts2008RoutledgeNew York
10.
CreswellJ.W.Educational research: planning, conducting, and evaluating quantitative and qualitative research2011PearsonUpper Saddle River, New Jersey
11.
Darling-HammondL.BransfordJ.Preparing teachers for a changing world: what teachers should learn and be able to do2005John Wiley and SonsSan Francisco
12.
Evers HollowayJ.ChiodoJ.J.Social studies is being taught in elementary school: a contrarian viewThe Journal of Social Studies Research3322009235–261
13.
Feiman-NemserS.BuchmannM.Pitfalls of experience in teacher preparationTeachers College Record871198553–65
14.
FitchettP.G.HeafnerT.L.A national perspective on the effects of high-stakes testing and standardization on elementary social studies marginalizationTheory and Research in Social Education3812010114–130
15.
GradwellJ.M.Teaching in spite of, rather than because of, the testGrantS.G.Measuring history: cases of state-level testing across the United States2006Information Age PublishingGreenwich, CT157–193
16.
GrantS.G.SalinasC.Assessment and accountability in the social studiesLevstikL.TysonC.Handbook of research in social studies education2nd ed.2008RoutledgeNew York219–236
17.
HeafnerT.L.GoodA.J.O'ConnorK.A.PasseJ.RockT.ByrdS.P.Fact or fiction: is social studies “history” in North Carolina's elementary schools?Social Studies Research and Practice232007502–509
18.
HeafnerT.L.LipscombG.B.RockT.C.To test or not to test?: the role of testing in elementary social studies a collaborative study conducted by NCPSSE and SCPSSESocial Studies Research and Practice122006145–164
19.
LanahanB.K.YeagerE.A.Practicing teachers as elementary social studies methods instructors: issues in preparing preservice elementary teachersSocial Studies Research and Practice32200810–28
20.
LaveJ.WengerE.Situated learning: legitimate peripheral participation1991Cambridge University PressNew York
21.
MathisonS.FreemanM.Teachers working with standards and state testingMathisonS.RossE.W.Defending public schools: the nature and limits of standards-based reform and assessmentvol. 42004PraegerWestport, CT81–91
22.
MilnerA.R.SondergeldT.A.DemirA.JohnsonC.C.CzerniakC.M.Elementary teachers’ beliefs about teaching science and classroom practice: an examination of pre/post nclb testing in scienceJournal of Science Teacher Education232012111–132
23.
MunbyH.RussellT.MartinA.K.Teachers’ knowledge and how it developsRichardsonV.Handbook of research on teaching3rd ed.2001American Educational Research AssociationWashington, D.C.877–904
24.
Ochoa-BeckerA.S.Democratic education for social studies: an issues-centered decision making curriculum2007Information Age PublishingGreenwich, CT
25.
OwensW.T.The challenges of teaching social studies methods to preservice elementary teachersThe Social Studies8831997113–120
26.
PaceJ.L.Inequalities in history-social science teaching under high-stakes accountability: interviews with fifth-grade teachers in CaliforniaSocial Studies Research and Practice31200824–40
27.
RichardsonV.PlacierP.Teacher changeRichardsonV.Handbook of research on teaching3rd ed.2001American Educational Research AssociationWashington, D.C.905–947
28.
RodgerC.R.ScottK.H.The development of the personal self and professional identity in learning to teachCochran-SmithM.Feiman-NemserS.McIntyreD.J.Handbook of research on teacher education: enduring questions in changing contexts3rd ed.2008RoutledgeNew York732–755
29.
RosaenC.Florio-RuaneS.The metaphors by which we teach: experience, metaphor, and culture in teacher educationCochran-SmithM.Feiman-NemserS.McIntyreD.J.Handbook of research on teacher education: enduring questions in changing contexts2nd ed.2008RoutledgeNew York706–731
30.
ShulmanL.S.Knowledge and teaching: foundations of the new reformWilsonS.M.The wisdom of practice: essays on teaching, learning, and learning to teach1987/2004 Jossey-BassSan Francisco219–248
31.
SilvaD.Y.MasonT.C.Developing pedagogical content knoweldge for civics in elementary teacher educationTheory and Research in Social Education3132003366–397
32.
SleeterC.E.StillmanJ.Navigating accountability pressuresSleeterC.E.Facing accountability in education: democracy and equity at risk2007Teachers College PressNew York13–29
33.
TannerL.No child left behind is just the tip of the icebergThe Social Studies991200841–45
34.
VoglerK.E.LintnerT.LipscombG.B.KnopfH.HeafnerT.L.RockT.C.Getting of the back burner: impact of testing elementary social studies as part of a state-mandated accountability programJournal of Social Studies Research312200720–34
35.
WadeR.Social studies for social justice2007Teachers College PressNew York
36.
Winstead-FryS.On borrowed time: how four elementary preservice teachers learned to teach social studies in the NCLB eraSocial Studies Research and Practice41200931–41
37.
ZeichnerK.M.TabachnickB.R.Are the effects of university teacher education “washed out” by school experiences?Journal of Teacher Education32219817–11
