In recent decades we witnessed ongoing debates about the objectives of history education, with different underlying epistemological perspectives. This qualitative study explored prospective history teachers' beliefs about these objectives of history education. Prospective history teachers of six universities starting a teacher educational programme were invited to answer an open-ended questionnaire about history education. Six objectives were found: (1) memorising; (2) critical/explanatory; (3) constructivist; (4) perspective-taking; (5) moral; and (6) collective-identity objectives. Almost all prospective teachers mentioned several of these objectives. A distinction between two epistemological perspectives on historical knowledge representation (factual or interpretive), was used as a framework for categorising the different objectives. More than half of the respondents mentioned objectives of history education that represent history as factual and objectives that represent history as interpretive. We propose that in actual practice most history teachers are combining epistemologically opposing objectives for pedagogical, political and religious motives.
AdlerS.A field study of selected student teacher perspectives towards social studiesTheory and Research in Social Education121198413–30
2.
AnkersmitF.R.Historical representation: FR Ankersmit2001Stanford University Press
3.
BainR.MirelJ.Setting up camp at the great instructional divide: Educating beginning history teachersJournal of Teacher Education5732006212–219
4.
BartonK.C.Students’ ideas about historyLevstikL.S.TysonC.A.Handbook of research in social studies education2008RoutledgeNew York239–258
5.
BartonK.C.LevstikL.S.Why don't more history teachers engage students in interpretation?Social Education6762003358
6.
BartonK.C.LevstikL.S.Teaching history for the common good2004ErlbaumMahwah, NJ
7.
BartonK.C.LevstikL.S.HistoryArthurJ.HahnC.DaviesI.Handbook of education for citizenship and democracy2008SageLondon
8.
BekermanZ.ZembylasM.Fearful symmetry: Palestinian and Jewish teachers confront contested narratives in integrated bilingual educationTeaching and Teacher Education2632010507–515
9.
Beyen, M. (2006). Canons in dialoog. Bijdragen en mededelingen betreffende geschiedenis der Nederlanden (BMGN) [Canons in dialogue. Contributions and statements regarding history of the Netherlands] (Vol. 121, pp. 93–98).
10.
Board of Examinations (2013). History HAVO and VWO, syllabus national exam 2015, based on domain A and B of the curriculum (2013) [College voor Examens (2013). Geschiedenis HAVO & VWO, syllabus centraal examen 2015 op basis van domein A en B van het examenprogramma] 〈http://www.examenblad.nl〉 Retrieved 18.09.13.
11.
BoeijeH.Analysis in qualitative research2010SageLondon
12.
BowenG.,A.Grounded theory and sensitizing conceptsInternational Journal of Qualitative Methods5320061–9
13.
BreisachE.Historiography: Ancient, medieval, & modern2nd ed.1993University of Chicago PressChicago, IL
14.
BrownleeJ.SchrawG.BerthelsenD.Personal epistemology and teacher education: An emerging fieldBrownleeJ.SchrawG.BerthelsenD.Personal epistemology and teacher education2011RoutledgeLondon3–21
15.
CarrD.Narrative and the real world: An argument for continuityHistory and Theory1986117–131
16.
CarreteroM.Constructing patriotism. Teaching of history and historical memory in globalized world2011Information Age PublishingCharlotte, NC
17.
CarreteroM.BermudezA.Constructing historiesValsinerJ.Oxford handbook of culture and psychology2012OUPUSA625–649
18.
CarreteroM.LópezC.GonzálezM.P.Rodríguez-MoneoM.Students historical narratives and concepts about the nationCarreteroM.AsensioM.Rodríguez-MoneoM.History education and the construction of national identities2012Information Age PublishingCharlotte, NC153–171
19.
Cognitive and instructional processes in history and the social sciencesCarreteroM.VossJ.F.1994Lawrence Erlbaum AssociatesNew Jersey
20.
CharmazK.Constructing grounded theory. A practical guide through qualitative analysis2006SageLondon
21.
ChiodoJ.BrownT.Student perceptions of teaching: Assessing their mental images of teaching social studiesJournal of Social Studies Research311200712–26
22.
ClarkA.Teaching the nation's story: Comparing public debates and classroom perspectives on history education in Australia and CanadaJournal of Curriculum Studies4162009745–762
23.
CohenL.ManionL.MorrisonK.Research methods in education2007RoutledgeNew York, NY
24.
CroceB.History as a story of Liberty1941George Allen & UnwinLondon
25.
CubanL.ForewordVan SledrightB.In search of America's past: Learning to read history in elementary school2002Teachers College PressNew Yorkvi–vii
26.
Debates in history teachingDaviesI.2011RoutledgeAbingdon, UK
27.
De canon van Nederland (2006–2007). The canon of the Netherlands (Vols. A–C). Amsterdam, The Netherlands: Amsterdam University Press. 〈http://www.entoen.nu/en〉 Retrieved 18.09.13.
28.
Den HeyerK.AbbottL.Reverberating echoes: Challenging teacher candidates to tell and learn from entwined narrations of Canadian historyCurriculum Inquiry4152011610–635
29.
DonnellyA.Interpreting differences: the educational aims of teachers of science and history, and their implicationsJournal of Curriculum Studies311199917–41
30.
DorsmanL.JonkerE.RibbensK.Het zoet en het zuur, geschiedenis in Nederland. [The sweet and sour, history in the Netherlands]2000Wereldbibliotheek BVAmsterdam, The Netherlands
31.
ElgströmO.HellsteniusM.Curriculum debate and policy changeJournal of Curriculum Studies4362011717–738
32.
EvansR.J.In defence of history1997GrantaLondon
33.
EvansR.W.Lessons from history: Teacher and student conceptions of the meaning of historyTheory and Research in Social Education1631988203–225
34.
EvansR.W.Teacher conception of historyTheory and Research in Social Education1731989210–240
35.
EvansR.W.Teachers’ conceptions of history revisited: Ideology, curriculum and student beliefTheory and Research in Social Education1821990101–138
36.
FallaceT.NeemJ.N.Historiographical thinking: Towards a new approach to preparing history teachersTheory and Research in Social Education3332005329–346
37.
GlaserB.G.StraussA.L.The discovery of grounded theory1967Aldine Publishing CompanyChicago, IL
38.
GoodmanJ.AdlerS.Becoming an elementary social studies teacher: A study of perspectivesTheory and Research in Social Education13219851–20
39.
GottliebE.WineburgS.Between veritas and communitas: Epistemic switching in the reading of academic and sacred historyJournal of the Learning Sciences21201284–129
40.
GreverM.Plurality, narrative and the historical canonGreverM.StuurmanS.Beyond the canon: History for the twenty-first century2007Palgrave MacmillanBasingstoke, UK31–47
41.
GreverM.JonkerE.RibbensK.StuurmanS.Controverses rond de canon. [Controversies around the canon]2006Van GorcumAssen, The Netherlands
42.
Hartzler-MillerC.Making sense of “best practice” in teaching historyTheory and Research in Social Education292001672–695
43.
HavekesH.CoppenP.A.LuttenbergJ.Van BoxtelC.Knowing and doing history: a conceptual framework and pedagogy for teaching historical contextualisationInternational Journal of Historical Learning, Teaching and Research111201272–93
44.
HeussA.Verlust der geschichte1959Vandenhoeck & RuprechtGöttingen, Germany
45.
History Examinations (2006). Report pilot CHMV/history examinations havo. [Geschiedenis examineren (2006). Rapport pilotproject CHMV/examen geschiedenis havo]. Amsterdam.
IggersG.G.Historiography in the twentieth century: From scientific objectivity to the postmodern challenge1997Wesleyan University PressHanover
48.
JamesJ.H.Teachers as protectors: Making sense of preservice teachers' resistance to interpretation in elementary history teachingTheory and Research in Social Education3632008172–205
49.
JenkinsK.Re-thinking history2003RoutledgeLondon
50.
JonkerE.De geesteswetenschappelijke carrousel. [The humanities carousel]2006Amsterdam University PressAmsterdam, The Netherlands
51.
JonkerE.Reflections on history education: Easy and difficult historiesJournal of Educational Media, Memory, and Society41201295–110
52.
KingP.M.KitchenerK.S.The reflective judgment model: Twenty years of research on epistemic cognitionHoferB.K.PintrichP.R.Personal epistemology: The psychology of beliefs about knowledge and knowing2002Lawrence Erlbaum AssociatesMahwah, NJ37–61
53.
KleinS.E.E.Teaching history in the Netherlands: Teachers’ experiences of a plurality of perspectivesCurriculum Inquiry4052010614–634
54.
KockaJ.Gesellschaftliche Funktionen der GeschichtswissenschaftOelmüllerW.Wozu noch Geschichte?1977Wilhelm FinkMunich11–33
55.
KossoP.The philosophy of historyTuckerA.Companion to the philosophy of history and historiography2009Wiley-BlackwellChichester, UK; Malden, MA7–25
56.
LampertM.BallD.Aligning teacher education with contemporary K-12 reform visionsDarling-HammondL.SykesG.Teaching as the learning profession: Handbook of policy and practice1999Jossey-Bass PublishersSan Francisco, CA33–53
57.
LeeP.Putting principles into practice: Understanding historyDonovanS.BransfordJ.How students learn: History, mathematics and science in the classroom2005National Academies PressWashington, D.C31–78
58.
LeeP.AshbyR.Progression in historical understanding among students ages 7–14SternsP.SeixasP.WineburgS.Knowing, teaching, and learning history2000NYU PressNew York, NY199–222
59.
LeeP.ShemiltD.A scaffold, not a cage: Progression and progression models in historyTeaching History113200313–24
60.
LévesqueS.In search of a purpose for school historyJournal of Curriculum Studies3732005349–358
61.
LevisohnJ.A.Negotiating historical narratives: An epistemology of history for history educationJournal of Philosophy of Education44120101–21
62.
LowenthalD.The past is a foreign country1985Cambridge University PressCambridge, UK
63.
LowenthalD.The heritage crusade and the spoils of history1998Cambridge University PressCambridge,UK
64.
MaggioniL.ParkinsonM.The role of teacher epistemic cognition, epistemic beliefs and calibration in instructionEducational Psychology Review2042008445–461
65.
MaggioniB.Van SledrightB.AlexanderP.Walking on the borders: A measure of epistemic cognition in historyJournal of Experimental Education7732009187–213
66.
MartellC.C.Learning to teach history as interpretation: A longitudinal study of beginning teachersJournal of Social Studies Research37201317–31
67.
MayerH.Learning to teach young people how to think historically: A case study of one student teacher's experienceSocial Studies972200669–76
68.
McDiarmidG.W.Understanding history for teaching: A study of the historical understanding of prospective teachersCognitive and Instructional Processes in History and the Social Sciences1591994185
69.
MuhrT.ATLAS.ti – the knowledge workbench: Visual qualitative data, analysis, management, model building: Short user's manual1997Scientific Software DevelopmentBerlin
70.
NewallP.Historiographic objectivityTuckerA.Companion to the philosophy of history and historiography2009Wiley-BlackwellChichester, UK; Malden, MA7–25
71.
For love of country?: A new democracy forum on the limits of patriotismNussbaumM.CohenJ.2002Beacon PressBoston, MA
72.
OsborneK.Teaching history in schools: A Canadian debateJournal of Curriculum Studies3552003585–626
73.
PeckC.SeixasP.Benchmarks of historical thinking: First stepsCanadian Journal of Education31420081015–1038
74.
PerryW.G.Forms of intellectual and ethical development in the college years: A scheme1970Holt, Rinehart & WinstonNew York, NY
75.
PintrichP.R.Future challenges and directions for theory and research on personal epistemologyPintrichP.R.Personal epistemology: The psychology of beliefs about knowledge and knowing2002Lawrence Erlbaum AssociatesMahwah, NJ389–414
76.
PlumbJ.H.The death of the past1970MacmillanLondon
77.
RibbensK.A narrative that encompasses our history: Historical culture and history teachingGreverM.StuurmanS.Beyond the canon. History for the twenty-first century2007Palgrave MacmillanBasingstoke, UK63–76
78.
Commissie Historische en Maatschappelijke Vorming (CHMV) (2001) Verleden, heden en toekomst [past, present and future]de RooyP.2001SLOEnschede
79.
RüsenJ.The development of narrative competence in historical learning: An ontogenetic hypothesis concerning moral consciousnessHistory and Memory12198935–59
80.
RüsenJ.Historical consciousness: Narrative structure, moral function, and ontogenetic developmentSeixasP.Theorizing historical consciousness2004University of Toronto PressToronto, ON63–85
81.
Schommer-AikensM.Explaining the epistemological belief system: Introducing the embedded systemic model and coordinated research approachEducational Psychologist391200419–29
82.
SegallA.Critical history: Implications for history/social studies educationTheory & Research in Social Education2731999358–374
83.
SeixasP.The community of inquiry as a basis for knowledge and learning: The case of historyAmerican Educational Research Journal3021993305–324
84.
SeixasP.Student teachers thinking historicallyTheory and Research in Social Education2631998310–341
85.
SeixasP.Schweigen! Die kinder! Or, does postmodern history have a place in the schoolsStearnsP.SeixasP.WineburgS.Knowing, teaching and learning history: National and international perspectives2000New York University PressNew York, NY19–37
86.
SeixasP.ClarkP.Murals as monuments: Students’ ideas about depictions of civilization in British ColumbiaAmerican Journal of Education11022004146–171
87.
Seixas, P., & Peck, C. (2004). Teaching historical thinking. Challenges and prospects for Canadian social studies (pp. 109–117).
88.
SouthgateB.History: What & why, ancient, modern, and postmodern perspectives1996RoutledgeLondon
89.
SpruitR.J.P. Coen, dagen en daden in dienst van de VOC. [J.P. Coen, days and deeds in the service of the VOC]1987De HaanHouten, The Netherlands
90.
StearnsP.N.SeixasP.C.WineburgS.Knowing, teaching, and learning history: National and international perspectives2000NYU Press
91.
SymcoxL.WilschutA.National history standards. The problem of the canon and the future of teaching history2009Information Age PublishersCharlotte, NC
92.
ThelenD.Memory and American historyJournal of American History75419891117–1129
93.
ThorntonS.J.Teacher as curricular-instructional gatekeeper in social studiesShaverJ.P.Handbook of research on social studies teaching and learning1991MacmillanNew York237–248
94.
Thornton, S.J. (2005). Incorporating internationalism into the social studies curriculum. Educating citizens for global awareness (pp. 81–92).
95.
ToshJ.The pursuit of history: Aims, methods, and new directions in the study of modern history2006Pearson EducationHarlow, UK
96.
TuckerA.Our knowledge of the past2004Cambridge University PressCambridge
97.
Van BoxtelC.GreverM.Between disenchantment and high expectations: history education in the Netherlands (1968–2008)ErdmannE.HasbergW.Facing, mapping, bridging diversity: foundation of a European discourse on history education. Part 1: History education international, 12011Wochenschau WissenschaftSchwalbach83–116
98.
Van DrieJ.Van BoxtelC.Historical reasoning: Towards a framework for analyzing students’ reasoning about the pastEducational Psychological Review202200887–110
99.
Van HoverS.D.YeagerE.A.Challenges facing beginning history teachers: A exploratory studyInternational Journal of Social Education19120048–26
100.
Van HoverS.YeagerE.“I Want to Use My Subject Matter to…”: The role of purpose in one US secondary history teacher's instructional decision makingCanadian Journal of Education2007670–690
101.
Van SledrightB.Fifth graders investigating history in the classroom: Results from a researcher-practitioner design experimentElementary School Journal10322002131–160
102.
Van SledrightB.Narratives of nation-state, historical knowledge, and school history educationReview of Research in Education3212008109–146
103.
Van SledrightB.The challenge of rethinking history education: on practices, theories, and policy2010RoutledgeNew York
104.
Van SledrightB.ReddyK.Changing epistemic beliefs? An exploratory study of cognition among prospective history teachersRevista Tempo E Argumento 06 11201428–68
105.
VinsonK.D.The “traditions” revisited: Instructional approach and high school social studies teachersTheory & Research in Social Education261199850–82
106.
Von BorriesB.Methods and aims of teaching history in Europe: A report on youth and historyStearnsP.N.SeixasP.WineburgS.Knowing, teaching, and learning history: National and international perspectives2000New York University PressNew York246–261
107.
WertschJ.V.Mind as action1998Oxford University Press
108.
WhiteH.The content of the form: Narrative discourse and historical representation1987The John Hopkins University PressBaltimore, MA
109.
WilsK.VerschaffelT.Longing for the present in the history of history educationPaedagogica Historica4862012793–799
110.
WilschutA.H.J.History at the mercy of politicians and ideologies: Germany, England, and the Netherlands in the 19th and 20th centuriesJournal of Curriculum Studies4252009693–723
111.
WilschutA.H.J.Canonical standards or orientational frames of reference?SymcoxL.WilschutA.National history standards, the problem of the canon and the future of teaching history2009Information Age PublishingNorth Carolina117–141
112.
WilsonE.K.KonopakB.C.ReadenceJ.E.Pre-service teachers in secondary social studies: Examining conceptions and practicesTheory and Research in Social Education2231994364–379
113.
WilsonS.M.WineburgS.S.Wrinkles in time: Using performance assessments to understand the knowledge of history teachersAmerican Educational Research Journal3041993729769
114.
WineburgS.storical thinking and other unnatural acts: Charting the future of teaching the pastHi2001Temple University PressPhiladelphia, PA
115.
YilmazK.Social studies teachers’ conceptions of history: Calling on historiographyJournal of Educational Research10132008158–175
116.
ZanazanianP.MoisanS.Harmonizing two of history teaching's main social objectives: Franco-Québécois history teachers and their predispositions to catering to narrative diversityEducation Sciences22012255–275
