Understanding historical empathy is a bourgeoning subfield of social studies education research. Students demonstrate historical empathy by analyzing sources 1) to determine historical context, 2) identify perspectives of historical figures, and 3) make affective connections to historical content. Therefore, the purpose of this research is to examine primary sources from educational leaders and organizations during the Progressive Era in American public school education in order to trace the origins of historical empathy as an implicit goal in the social studies curriculum. Our guiding research question is “How does the work of Progressive Era organizations and educational leaders impact how Americans viewed historical empathy?” We purposefully selected documents from Progressive Era organizations and certain leaders whose work formed a strong foundation of social studies education history. We conclude with an examination of the importance of historical empathy today in order to demonstrate the importance of historical empathy as a curricular aim of social studies education.
BohanC.H.Historical and international dimensions of history education: The work of the Committee of TenDickinsonA.GordonP.LeeP.J.International review of history education: Raising standards in history educationVolume 32001Woburn PressLondon56–72
3.
BohanC.H.Early vanguards of progressive education: The Committee of Ten, the Committee of Seven, and social studies educationJournal of Curriculum and Supervision19200373–94
4.
BohanC.H.Digging trenches: Nationalism and the first national report on elementary history curriculumTheory & Research in Social Studies Education332005266–291
5.
BohanC.H.A rebellious Jersey girl: Rachel Davis DuBois, intercultural education pioneerTottenS.PedersenJ.Addressing social issues in the classroom and beyond: The pedagogical efforts of pioneers in the field2007Information Age PublishingCharlotte
6.
BohanC.H.Committee of eightProvenzoE.F.Jr.Encyclopedia of the social and cultural foundations of educationVolume 12009Sage PublicationsThousand Oaks, CA147–148
7.
Barton, K.C. (1996). Did the devil just run out of juice? Historical perspective taking among elementary students. New York, New York: Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association. ERIC Document Reproduction Service. No. ED 401 203.
8.
BartonK.C.LevstikL.S.Teaching history for the common good2004Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc.Mahwah, New Jersey
9.
BlakeC.Historical empathy: A response to Foster and YeagerInternational Journal of Social Education131199825–31
10.
Boyle-BaiseL.GoodmanJ.The influence of Harold O. Rugg: Conceptual and pedagogical considerationsThe Social Studies1001200931–40
11.
BradleyA.A time to intervene: A historical overview of pedagogical responses to an unjust societyThe Vermont Connection282200770–79
12.
BrooksS.Historical empathy in the social studies classroom: A review of the literatureThe Journal of Social Studies Research3322009213–234
13.
BrooksS.Historical empathy as perspective recognition and care in one secondary social studies classroomTheory and Research in Social Studies Education3922011166–202
14.
CaseR.Key elements of a global perspectiveSocial Education5761993318–325
ColbyS.R.Energizing the history classroom: Historical narrative inquiry and historical empathySocial Studies Research and Practice33200860–79
17.
DavisO.L.Jr.Rachel Davis DuBois: Intercultural education pioneerCroccoM.S.DavisO.L.Jr.Bending the future to their will: Civic women, social education, and democracy1999Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc.Lanham
18.
DavisO.L.Jr.In pursuit of historical empathyDavisO.L.YeagerE.A.FosterS.J.Historical empathy and perspective taking in the social studies2001Roman and LittlefieldMaryland
19.
DavisO.L.Jr.Harold Rugg, the engineer, and the social studiesEducation Review15320121–13
20.
DeweyJ.Experience and educationMilsonA.J.BohanC.H.GlanzerP.L.NullJ.W.American education thought, essays from 1640-19401938Information Age Publishing, Inc.Charlotte, North Carolina
21.
DornC.Treason in the textbooks: Reinterpreting the Harold Rugg textbook controversy in the context of wartime schoolingPedagogica Historica4442008457–479
22.
DuBoisR.D.Get together Americans: Friendly approaches to racial and cultural conflicts through the neighborhood-home festival1942Harper & BrothersNew York
23.
DuBoisR.D.OkoroduduC.All this and something more: Pioneering in intercultural education1984Dorrance & Company, Inc.Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania
24.
Duhlberg, N. (2002). Engaging in history: Empathy and perspective-talking in children's historical thinking, New Orleans, L.A.: Annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association (pp. 1–48). ERIC Document Reproduction service, No. ED 474 135.
25.
DunnA.W.The social studies in secondary education: Report of the committee on social studies of the commission on the reorganization of secondary education of the National Education Association1916Department of the Interior Bureau of EducationWashington, D.C
26.
EliotC.W.The function of education in democratic societyMilsonA.J.BohanC.H.GlanzerP.L.NullJ.W.American education thought, essays from 1640-19401898Information Age Publishing, Inc.Charlotte, North Carolina
27.
EndacottJ.L.Negotiating the process of historical empathyTheory and Research in Social Studies Education42120144–34
28.
EndacottJ.L.BrooksS.An updated theoretical and practical model for promoting historical empathySocial Studies Research and Practice81201341–58
29.
EvansR.W.The social studies wars: What should we teach the children?2004Teachers College PressNew York
30.
FallaceT.The racial and cultural assumptions of the early social studies educators, 1901–1922WoyshnerC.BohanC.H.Histories of social studies and race2012Palgrave MacmillanNew York1865–2000
31.
FlingF.M.Review, The newspaper and the historian by Lucy Maynard SalmonPolitical Science Quarterly3941924709–711
32.
FosterS.J.Using historical empathy to excite students about the study of history: Can you empathize with Neville Chamberlain?The Social Studies90199918–24
33.
Graham, B.A. (2005). Schooling America: How the public schools meet the nation's changing needs. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
34.
JamesJ.A.Proposals of the Committee of Eight: A restatement of James Alton James, of Northwestern University, Chairman of the CommitteeThe Social Studies100119094–5
35.
JensenJ.Developing historical empathy through debate: An action research studySocial Studies Research and Practice31200855–67
JonesT.J.Social studies in the Hampton curriculum1906Hampton Institute PressHampton, VA
38.
KohlmeierJ.The power of a woman's story: A three step approach to historical significance in high school world historyInternational Journal of Social Education201200564–80
39.
LalS.1930s Multiculturalism: Rachel DuBois and the Bureau for Intercultural EducationThe Radical Teacher69200418–22
40.
LeeP.AshbyR.Empathy, perspective taking, and rational understandingDavisO.L.YeagerE.A.FosterS.J.Historical empathy and perspective taking in the social studies2001Roman and LittlefieldMaryland
41.
LeeP.ShemiltD.The concept that dares not speak its name: Should empathy come out of the closet?Teaching History143201139–49
42.
MacKenzieJ.C.Report of the Committee of TenThe School Review231894146–155
43.
MarcusA.S.MetzgerS.A.PaxtonR.J.StoddardJ.D.Teaching history with film: Strategies for secondary social studies2010RoutledgeNew York
44.
MetzgerS.A.The borders of historical empathy: Students encounter the Holocaust through filmJournal of Social Studies Research3442012387–410
45.
MontaltoN.A History of the intercultural education movement1982Garland Publishing, Inc.New York
46.
MrazM.Harold O. Rugg and the foundations of social studiesInternational Journal of Social Studies Education19120041–7
47.
National Education Association Madison ConferenceReport of the committee on secondary school studies appointed at the meeting of the National Education Association July 9, 18921892Government Printing Office. Cornell University LibraryWashington, D.CRetrieved from 〈https://archive.org/stream/cu31924030593580#page/n3/mode/2up〉
48.
NelsonJ.L.Defining social studiesStanleyW.B.Critical issues in social studies research for the 21st century2001Information Age PublishingGreenwich
49.
NelsonM.R.Building a science of society: The social studies and Harold Rugg (Unpublished Dissertation)1975Stanford UniversityStanford, CA.
50.
NoddingsN.Education moral people: A caring alternative to character education2002Teacher's College PressNew York
51.
NovickP.That noble dream: The ‘objectivity question’ and the American historical profession1988Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
52.
PerrottaK.AMore than a feeling: A study on factors that promote historical empathy in middle and secondary social studies classes with the “Elizabeth Jennings Project” (Unpublished Dissertation)2016Georgia State UniversityAtlanta, GA
53.
PitkinV.E.An appraisal of the intercultural education movementThe High School Journal3131948112–118
54.
ReeseW.J.Origins of progressive educationHistory of Education Quarterly41120011–24
55.
ReeseW.J.History, education, and the schools2007Palgrave MacMillanNew York
56.
RiisJ.A.How the other half lives: Studies among the tenements of New York1901Dover Publications, Inc.New York.
57.
Ross, E. W., Matheson, S., Vinson, K.D. (2014). Social studies curriculum and teaching in the era of standardization in Ross, E.W. The social studies curriculum: Purposes, problems, and possibilities, 4thEdition. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press.
58.
RuggH.An introduction to American civilization: A study of economic life in the United States1929Ginn & CompanyNew York
59.
RuggH.MendenhallJ.E.Teacher's guide for an introduction to American civilization1929Ginn & CompanyNew York
60.
SavageB.D.Broadcasting freedom: Radio, war, and the politics of race1999University of North Carolina PressChapel Hill1938–1948
61.
SaxeD.W.Social studies in schools: A history of the early years1991State University of New York PressAlbany, NY
ThorntonS.J.NCSS: The early yearsDavisO.L.NCSS in Retrospect1996National Council for the Social StudiesWashington, D.C
64.
VinovskisM.A.History and educational policymaking1999Yale University PressNew Haven, CT
65.
VinsonK.D.RossE.W.In search of the social studies curriculum: Standardization, diversity, and a conflict of appearancesStanleyW.B.Critical issues in social studies research for the 21st century2001Information Age PublishingGreenwich
66.
YilmazK.Historical empathy and its implications for classroom practices in schoolsThe History Teacher4032007331–337
