Jewish Quotas in Clinical Psychology? The Journal of Clinical Psychology and the Scandal of 1945

Abstract

In 1945 Frederick Thorne, editor of the Journal of Clinical Psychology, proposed to limit the acceptance of Jewish applicants to clinical psychology graduate schools. A public scandal erupted over this proposed limit, which was modeled on Jewish quotas in medical education. Criticized by the mass media and most psychologists, Thorne's proposal was repudiated by the Eastern Psychological Association and the Society for the Psychological Study of Social Issues. Using private correspondence, oral histories, and published articles, this mostly forgotten episode in the history of clinical psychology is recreated. It is argued that the 1945 campaign against Jewish quotas prepared activists for the 1950s campaign against racial segregation and the Brown v. Board of Education Supreme Court case. Because the participants in 1945 came from all specialties in psychology, it is suggested that this story is of significance to the field as a whole, rather than just to historians of social issues.

Keywords

anti-Semitism history social issues Frederick Thorne Society for the Psychological Study of Social Issues

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Allport

(1945). Letter to Carl Rogers, May 28 1945. Gordon Allport Papers. Harvard University Archives, Cambridge, MA.

American Anthropological Association. (1939). Statement of the American Anthropological Association. In League of American Writers., “We hold these truths”: Statements on anti-Semitism by 54 leading American writers, statesmen, educators, clergymen and trade unionists (pp. 125–126). New York: League of American Writers.

Anti-Semitism again. (1945, February 19), New Republic, p. 247.

Beck

S. J.

(1945). Letter to Frederick Thorne, March 5, 1945. SPSSI Papers. Archives for the History of American Psychology, Akron, OH.

Benjamin

L. T.

(1993). The Eastern Psychological Association. In Pate

J. L.

& Wertheimer

, No small part: A history of regional organizations in American Psychology (pp. 69–95). Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.

Benjamin

L. T.

(2005). A history of clinical psychology as a profession in America (and a glimpse at its future). Annual Review of Clinical Psychology, 1, 1–30.

Benjamin

L. T.

, & Baker

D. B.

(2004). From séance to science: A history of the profession of psychology in America. Belmont, CA: Thomon.

Benjamin

L. T.

, & Crouse

E. M.

(2002). The American Psychological Association's response to Brown v. Board of Education. American Psychologist, 57, 38–50.

Bos

, Park

D. W.

, & Pietikainen

(2005). Strategic self-marginalization: The case of psychoanalysis. Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences, 41, 207–224.

10.

Brand

J. L.

(1963). Albert Deutsch: The historian as social reformer. Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences, 16, 148–157.

11.

Cameron

(1945a). Letter to Daniel Katz, May 25, 1945. SPSSI Papers, Box 187, folder “Thorne Incident, 1945.” Archives for the History of American Psychology, Akron, OH.

12.

Cameron

(1945b). Letter to Frederick Thorne, March 16, 1945. C. M. Louttit Papers. Yale University Archives, New Haven, CT.

13.

Capshew

J. H.

, & Hilgard

E. R.

(1992). The power of service: World War II and professional reform in the American Psychological Association. In Evans

R. B.

, Sexton

V. S.

, & Cadwallader

T. C.

, The American Psychological Association: A historical perspective (pp. 149–175). Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.

14.

Deutsch

(1937). The mentally ill in America: A history of their care and treatment from colonial times. Garden City, NY: Doubleday.

15.

Deutsch

(1945a January 30). Dental Assn. asks Columbia to adopt racism. PM, p. 11.

16.

Deutsch

(1945b January 31). Dental groups blast “race quota” report. PM, p. 11.

17.

Deutsch

(1945c, April 6). Psychology journal urges “race quota” in schools. PM, pp. 1, 9.

18.

Deutsch

(1945d, April 8). Psychologists attack proposal for quotas on Jewish students. PM, p. 9.

19.

Deutsch

(1948). The shame of the states. New York: Harcourt, Brace.

20.

Deutsch

(1955). Letter to “Bea,” October 3, 1955. Albert Deutsch Papers. American Psychiatric Association, Arlington, VA.

21.

Deutsch

(1957a). Letter to Julius Schreiber, September 26, 1957. Albert Deutsch Papers. American Psychiatric Association, Arlington, VA.

22.

Deutsch

(1957b). Letter to Richard Swigart, September 19, 1957. Albert Deutsch Papers. American Psychiatric Association, Arlington, VA.

23.

Deutsch

(n.d.). Discrimination in Professional Schools. Undated speech, circa 1948. Albert Deutsch Papers. American Psychiatric Association, Arlington, VA.

24.

Deutsch

, & O'Connor

(1941a, January 20). Army nurses… needed, and badly; but hundreds of qualified Negroes are turned down. PM, p. 11.

25.

Deutsch

, & O'Connor

(1941b, August 4). Study of mental hospitals reveals appalling cruelty. PM, p. 10.

26.

Deutsch

, & O'Connor

(1942, January 8). U.S. needs M.D.'s but –. PM, p. 11.

27.

Dodson

D. W.

(1946, July) Religious prejudice in colleges. American Mercury, 63, pp. 5–13.

28.

Dorfman

, Wilcox

, Douglas

, Klinesmith

M. A.

, Muench

G. A.

, Reid

D. K.

, (1945). Letter to the Eds. of the Journal of Clinical Psychology, April 9, 1945. C. M. Louttit Papers. Yale University Archives, New Haven, CT.

29.

Duncan

(1945, March 19). Clinical psychology and anti-Semitism. New Republic, p. 390.

30.

Duncan

O. D.

(1974). Autobiographical statement, January 1974. Unpublished manuscript.

31.

Faterson

(1945). Letter to David Shakow, April 9, 1945, Box M1352, folder “Thorne, EC1, EPA.” David Shakow Papers. Archives for the History of American Psychology, Akron, OH.

32.

Finison

L. J.

(1976). Unemployment, politics, and the history of organized psychology. American Psychologist, 31, 747–755.

33.

Freedman

J. O.

(2000, December 1). Ghosts of the past: Anti-semitism at elite colleges. Chronicle of Higher Education, pp. B7–B10.

34.

Friedman

L. J.

(1990). Menninger: The family and the clinic. New York: Knopf.

35.

Gallagher

N. L.

(1999). Breeding better Vermonters. Hanover, NH: University Press of New England.

36.

Gilmore

G. E.

(2008). Defying Dixie: The radical roots of civil rights, 1919–1950. New York: Norton.

37.

Grob

G. N.

(1986). Psychiatry and social activism: The politics of a specialty in postwar America. Bulletin of the History of Medicine, 60, 477–501.

38.

Grob

G. N.

(1994). The mad among us. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

39.

Group for the Advancement of Psychiatry. (1957). Psychiatric aspects of school desegregation. New York: Author.

40.

Hall

N. S.

(1926, July 17). Is the Jew a college outcast? Liberty, pp. 37; 40–42.

41.

Halperin

E. C.

(2001). The Jewish problem in U.S. medical education, 1920–1955. Journal of the History of Medicine, 56, 140–167.

42.

Hamilton

S. W.

, Hunt

W. A.

, Kinder

E. L.

, Louttit

C. M.

, Sears

R. R.

, Seidenfeld

M. A.

et. al. (1945). Editorial comment. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 1, 245–246.

43.

Harris

(1993). “Don't be unconscious, join our ranks”: Psychology, politics and communist education. Rethinking Marxism, 6(1), 44–76.

44.

Harris

(1998). Psychiatry and psychology. In Buhle

M. J.

, Buhle

, & Georgakas

, Encyclopedia of the American left (2nd ed., pp. 644–647). New York: Oxford University Press.

45.

Harris

, & Nicholson

(1999). Goodwin Watson. In Garraty

J. A.

& Carnes

M. C.

, American national biography (Vol. 22, pp. 791–793). New York: Oxford University Press.

46.

Harris

(1945). Letter to Frederick Thorne, April 2, 1945. C. M. Louttit Papers. Yale University Archives, New Haven, CT.

47.

Hartley

E. L.

(1945a). Letter to Ernest Hilgard, April 16, 1945. SPSSI Papers, Box 187, folder “Thorne Incident, 1945.” Archives for the History of American Psychology, Akron, OH.

48.

Hartley

E. L.

(1945b). Letter to SPSSI Race Relations Committee, March 22, 1945. SPSSI Papers. Archives for the History of American Psychology, Akron, OH.

49.

Hilgard

E. R.

, Newcomb

, Katz

Gundlach

, Lippitt

, English

, (1945). Letter to editorial board, Journal of Clinical Psychology, May 10, 1945. C. M. Louttit Papers. Yale University Archives, New Haven, CT.

50.

Holmes

D. R.

(1989). Stalking the academic communist: Intellectual freedom and the firing of Alex Novikoff. Hanover, NH: University Press of New England.

51.

Horner

H. H.

(1944). The needs of dental education. Journal of Dental Education, 9, 93–105.

52.

Huston

. (1946). Let there be light. Washington, DC: U.S. Army Pictorial Service. [Written by John Huston and Charles Kaufman. Produced by the Army Pictorial Service, United States Army Signal Corps].

53.

Hunt

W. A.

(1975). Clinical psychology in 1944–45. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 31, 173–178.

54.

Jackson

(2005). Social scientists for social justice: Making the case against segregation. New York: New York University Press.

55.

Katz

(1945). Memo to SPSSI council, April 24, 1945. SPSSI Papers. Archives for the History of American Psychology, Akron, OH.

56.

Kenworthy

M. E.

(1956). Letter to Julius Schreiber, July 10, 1956. Albert Deutsch Papers. American Psychiatric Association, Arlington, VA.

57.

Kenworthy

M. E.

(1962). In memoriam: Albert Deutsch (1905–1961). American Journal of Psychiatry, 118, 1064–1068.

58.

Kingdon

(1945). Discrimination in medical colleges. The American Mercury, 61, 391–399.

59.

Krawiec

T. S.

(1979). Frederick C. Thorne (1909–1978). American Psychologist, 34, 715.

60.

Kuznick

P. J.

(1987). Beyond the laboratory: Scientists as political activists in 1930's America. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

61.

LeRoy

. (1945). The house I live in [Motion picture]. United States: RKO Pictures.

62.

Levi

(2003). The Jewish quota in the faculty of medicine, University of Toronto: Generational memory sustained by documentation. Historical Studies in Education/Revue d'histoire de L'education, 15, 131–138.

63.

Louttit

C. M.

(1945a). Letter to Frederick C. Thorne, March 22, 1945. C. M. Louttit Papers. Yale University Archives, New Haven, CT.

64.

Louttit

C. M.

(1945b). Letter to Morris Krugman, March 20, 1945. C. M. Louttit Papers. Yale University Archives, New Haven, CT.

65.

McCoy

A. W.

(2007). Science in Dachau's shadow: HEBB, Beecher, and the development of CIA psychological torture and modern medical ethics. Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences, 43, 401–417.

66.

Mead

(1943). And keep your powder dry: An anthropologist looks at America. New York: Morrow.

67.

Meyerowitz

(2004). Hooker, Evelyn. In Ware

, Notable American women: A biographical dictionary completing the twentieth century. Cambridge MA: Belknap.

68.

Milkman

(1997). PM: A new deal in journalism, 1940–1948. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.

69.

Miller

D. N.

, Gilman

, & Martens

M. P.

(2007). Wellness promotion in the schools: Enhancing students’ mental and physical health. Psychology in the Schools, 45, 5–15.

70.

Miller

J. G.

(1946). Clinical psychology in the Veterans Administration. American Psychologist, 1, 181–189.

71.

Murphy

. (1945). Human nature and enduring peace: Third yearbook of the Society for the Psychological Study of Social Issues. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.

72.

New York City, Mayor's Committee on Unity. (1946). Report on inequality of opportunity in higher education. New York: Author.

73.

Rand

(1943). The fountainhead. Indianapolis, IN: Bobbs-Merrill Co.

74.

Reider

(1956). Letter to Albert Deutsch, January 10, 1956. Albert Deutsch Papers. American Psychiatric Association, Arlington, VA.

75.

Reisman

J. M.

(1976). A history of clinical psychology. New York: Wiley.

76.

Rogers

C. R.

(1945a). Letter to C. M. Louttit, April 10, 1945. C. M. Louttit Papers. Yale University Archives, New Haven, CT.

77.

Rogers

C. R.

(1945b). Letter to Frederick Thorne, May 10, 1945. SPSSI Papers. Archives for the History of American Psychology, Akron, OH.

78.

Rogers

C. R.

(1945c). Memo to Board of Eds., Journal of Clinical Psychology, April 9, 1945. C. M. Louttit Papers. Yale University Archives, New Haven, CT.

79.

Roosevelt

(1945). My day. Newspaper column wired to United Features Syndicate, May 22, 1945. Electronic ed. of the Eleanor Roosevelt Papers, Franklin D. Roosevelt Library, Hyde Park, NY.

80.

Rosenbaum

(2004). Eugene Leonard Hartley (1912–2002). American Psychologist, 59, 121.

81.

Routh

D. K.

(2000). The field of clinical psychology: A response to Thorne. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 56, 275–286.

82.

Samelson

(1978). From “race psychology to studies in prejudice”: Some observations on the thematic reversal in social psychology. Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences, 14, 265–278.

83.

Sargent

, & Harris

(1986). Academic freedom, civil liberties, and SPSSI. Journal of Social Issues, 42, 43–67.

84.

Sears

R. R.

(1945). Letter to Frederick C. Thorne, March 19, 1945. C. M. Louttit Papers. Yale University Archives, New Haven, CT.

85.

Shaffer

(1987). Jews, reds and violets: Anti-Semitism and anti-radicalism at New York University, 1916–1929. Journal of Ethnic Studies, 15, 47–83.

86.

Society for the Psychological Study of Social Issues. (1939). Statement by the Society for the Psychological Study of Social Issues. In League of American Writers., “We hold these truths”: Statements on anti-Semitism by 54 leading American writers, statesmen, educators, clergymen and trade unionists (pp. 124–125). New York: League of American Writers.

87.

Sokoloff

(1992). The rise and decline of the Jewish quota in medical school admissions. Bulletin of the New York Academy of Medicine, 68, 497–518.

88.

Thorne

F. C.

(1945a). Editorial comment. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 1, 164–165.

89.

Thorne

F. C.

(1945b). Ed.'s note. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 1, 166.

90.

Thorne

F. C.

(1945c). The field of clinical psychology: Past, present and future. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 1, 1–20.

91.

Thorne

F. C.

(1945d). Letter to Carl R. Rogers, March 27, 1945. C. M. Louttit Papers. Yale University Archives, New Haven, CT.

92.

Thorne

F. C.

(1945e). Letter to Carl R. Rogers, April 11, 1945. C. M. Louttit Papers. Yale University Archives, New Haven, CT.

93.

Thorne

F. C.

(1945f). Letter to C. M. Louttit, March 19, 1945. C. M. Louttit Papers. Yale University Archives, New Haven, CT.

94.

Thorne

F. C.

(1945g). Letter to Daniel Katz. May 16, 1945. SPSSI Papers. Archives for the History of American Psychology, Akron, OH.

95.

Thorne

F. C.

(1945h). Letter to Gordon W. Allport, May 1, 1945. SPSSI Papers. Archives for the History of American Psychology, Akron, OH.

96.

Thorne

F. C.

(1966). Oral History of Frederick C. Thorne, March 18, 1966. Archives for the History of American Psychology, Akron, OH.

97.

Thorne

F. C.

(1972). Toward better self-understanding. In Krawiec

T. S.

, The psychologists (Vol. 1, pp. 240–273). New York: Oxford University Press.

98.

Thorne

F. C.

(1977). A humanistic psychologist enters the world of finance: An autobiographical perspective. Journal of Community Psychology, 5, 92–98.

99.

Thorne

F. C.

& Krawiec

T. S.

(1981). A road not taken: The editorial opinions of Frederick C. Thorne. Brandon, VT: Clinical Psychology Publishing Company.

100.

Watson

C. G.

, & Wood

P. T.

(1994). Frederick Thorne and the founding of the Journal of Clinical Psychology. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 50, 4–6.

101.

Watson

(1937, October). Orientation. Social Frontier, 20–26.

102.

Watson

(1939). Anti-semitism in American psychology. In League of American Writers., “We hold these truths”: Statements on anti-Semitism by 54 leading American writers, statesmen, educators, clergymen and trade unionists (pp. 103–105). New York: League of American Writers.

103.

Weaver

C. M.

, Borkowski

J. G.

, & Whitman

T. L.

(2008). Violence breeds violence: Childhood exposure and adolescent conduct problems. Journal of Community Psychology, 36, 96–112.

104.

Wilkie

C. A.

(1945). Geographical and racial imbalance. The Journal of the Dental Society of the State of New York, 11, 78–81.

105.

Winston

A. S.

(1996). “As his name indicates”: R. S. Woodworth's letters of reference and employment for Jewish psychologists in the 1930s. Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences, 32, 30–43.

106.

Winston

A. S.

(1998). “The defects of his race”: E. G. Boring and antisemitism in American psychology, 1912–1953. History of Psychology, 1, 27–51.

107.

Yerkes

R. M.

(1945). Letter to Frederick C. Thorne, March 2, 1945. Robert M. Yerkes Papers. Yale University Archives, New Haven, CT.