We believe that the information system (IS) discipline has a major and urgent problem to contend with: the general public appears to believe that there are ‘no jobs in IS’ because of offshoring. They see the offshoring of IS jobs as an inevitable consequence of economic and competitive pressures to drive down labor costs, which leads them to conclude that there is no future in IS. In particular, the discipline is suffering from the erosion of its student base and in this article we explore some of the reasons as to why this is occurring; focussing specifically on the role offshoring may be playing on the perception that there are no jobs in IS. Despite fairly robust figures showing that there are virtually as many IS jobs now as ever before, the public's perception appears to be at odds with this. We thus examine where these beliefs may have come from and in our stakeholder action plan we suggest some radical solutions to align perception with reality.
AbrahamT., BeathC., BullenC., GallagherK., GolesT., KaiserK., and SimonJ. (2006). IT Workforce Trends: Implications for IS programs, Communications of the AIS17: 1147–1170.
2.
AkbulutA., and LooneyC. (2007). Inspiring Students to Pursue Computing Degrees, Communications of the ACM50(10): 67–71.
3.
AlterS. (2003). 18 Reasons Why IT-Reliant Work Systems Should Replace ‘The IT Artifact’ as the Core Subject Matter of the IS Field, Communications of the AIS12: 366–395.
4.
AsprayW., MayadasF., and VardiM. (2006). Globalization and Offshoring of Software: A report of the ACM job migration task force, ACM Report, ACM 0001-0782/06/0200.
5.
BenbasatI., and ZmudR. (1999). Empirical Research in Information Systems: The practice of relevance, MIS Quarterly23(1): 3–16.
6.
BlinderA. (2006). Offshoring: The next industrial revolution, Foreign Affairs, March/April.
7.
BradshawD. (2006). IT Back on the MBA Agenda, The Financial Times, 23 July.
8.
BullenC., AbrahamT., GallagherK., KaiserK., and SimonJ. (2007). Changing IT Skills: The impact of sourcing strategies on in-house capability requirements, Journal of Electronic Commerce in Organizations5(2): 24–46.
9.
CarrN. (2003). IT Doesn't Matter, Harvard Business Review81(5), May.
10.
CederlundJ., KauffmanR., KohliR., MarkusM.L., MelvilleN., and PavlouP. (2007). Global Sourcing of IT Services: Necessary evil or blessing in disguise?Communications of the AIS19: 278–293.
11.
CurtisB., KellnerM., and OverJ. (1992). Process Modeling, Communications of the ACM35(9): 75–90.
12.
DavenportT., and MarkusM. L. (1999). Rigor vs Relevance Revisited: Response to Benbasat and Zmud, MIS Quarterly23(1): 19–23.
13.
DavisG., Ein-DorP., KingW., and TorkzadehR. (2006). IT Offshoring: History, prospects and challenges, Journal of the Association for Information Systems7(11): 770–795.
14.
DeardoffA.V. (2006). Comment on Mankiw and Swagel, The Politics and Economics of Offshore Outsourcing, Journal of Monetary Economics53: 1057–1061.
15.
DeSanctisG. (2003). The Social Life of Information Systems Research. A Response to Benbasat and Zmud's Call for Returning to the IT Artifact, Journal of the Association for Information Systems4(7): 360–376.
16.
DibbernJ., GolesT., HirschheimR., and JayatilakaB. (2004). Information Systems Outsourcing: A survey and analysis of the literature, Database35(5): 6–102.
17.
EngardioP., ArndtM., and FoustD. (2006). The Future of Outsourcing: How its transforming whole industries and changing the way we work, Business Week, 30 January.
18.
FarrellD. (2004). Beyond Offshoring: Assess your company's global potential, Harvard Business Review82(12): 82–90.
19.
FergusonE. (2004). Impact of Offshore Outsourcing on CS/IS Curricula, in Proceedings of the Central Plains Conference of the Consortium for Computing Science in Colleges, Warrensburg, MO: Central Missouri State University, April 2–3, 68–77.
20.
Financial Times (2004). IT Review, 1 December.
21.
FominV., KingJ.L., LyttinenK., and McGannS. (2005). Diffusion and Impacts of E-Commerce in the United States of America: Results from an industry survey, Communications of the AIS16: 559–603.
22.
FriedmanT. (2005). The World is Flat: A brief history of the twenty-first century, New York: Farrar, Straus & Giroux.
23.
GeorgeJ., ValacichJ., and ValorJ. (2005). Does Information Systems Still Matter: Lessons for a maturing discipline, Communications of the AIS16: 219–232.
24.
GoelN. (2008). Into its Own: Sourcing as a profession, Global Services, 4th June.
GopalA., BeaubienL., and MarconT. (2002). Old Wolf, New Wool Suit: India, IT, and the legacy of colonialism, in Proceedings of the 23rd International Conference on Information Systems, 525–532.
27.
GrangerM.J., DickG., JacobsonC.M., and Van SlykeC. (2007). Information Systems Enrollments: Challenges and strategies, Journal of Information Systems Education18(3): 303–311.
28.
HarrisonA., and McMillanM. (2006). Dispelling Some Myths About Offshoring, Academy of Management Perspectives20(4): 6–22.
29.
HirschheimR., and KleinH. (2003). Crisis in the IS Field? A Critical Reflection on the State of the IS Discipline, Journal of the Association of Information Systems4(5): 237–293.
30.
HirschheimR., LoebbeckeC., NewmanM., and ValorJ. (2007). The Implications of Offshoring on the IS Discipline in the West: Where perception meets reality, Communications of the AIS:20(31): 824–835.
IvesB. (2005). Unpublished survey on the state of IS majors at their various universities, University of Houston, Working Paper.
33.
IvesB., ValacichJ., WatsonR., and ZmudR. (2002). What Every Business Student Needs to Know about Information Systems, Communications of the AIS9(30): 467–477.
34.
JoshiK., and MudigondaS. (2008). An Analysis of India's Future Attractiveness as an Offshore Destination for IT and IT-Enabled Services, Journal of Information Technology23(4): 215–227.
35.
KingJ.L., and LyytinenK. (eds.) (2006). Information Systems: The state of the field, Chichester: J. Wiley & Sons.
36.
KingW. (2004). Outsourcing and the Future of IT, Information Systems Management21(4): 83–84.
37.
KotlarskyJ., and OshriI. (2008). Country Attractiveness for Offshoring and Offshore Outsourcing: Additional considerations, Journal of Information Technology23(4): 228–231.
38.
KrishnaS., SahayS., and WalshamG. (2004). Managing Cross-Cultural Issues in Global Software Outsourcing, Communications of the ACM47(4): 62–66.
39.
LacityM., and RottmanJ. (2008). Offshore Outsourcing of IT Work, Basingstoke: Palgrave.
40.
LacityM., and RudramuniyaiahP. (2009). Funny Business: Public opinion on outsourcing and offshoring as reflected in US and Indian political cartoons, Communications of the AIS24(13): 199–224.
41.
LeeY., and LeeS. (2006). The Competitiveness of the Information Systems Major: An analytic hierarchy process, Journal of Information Systems Education17(2): 211–221.
42.
LooneyC., and AkbulutS. (2007). Combating the IS Enrollment Crisis: The role of effective teachers in introductory IS courses, Communications of the AIS19(38): 781–805.
43.
LucasH. (1999). The State of the Information Systems Field, Communications of the AIS5(1): 1–5.
44.
LuftmanJ., and HiraR. (2008). Is There a Tech Talent Shortage?InformationWeek, 14 January, pp. 37–46.
45.
MankiwN.G., and SwagelP. (2006). The Politics and Economics of Offshore Outsourcing, Journal of Monetary Economics53: 1027–1056.
46.
MannC.L. (2005). Offshore Outsourcing and the Globalization of US Services: Why now, how important, and what policy implications, institute of international economics, WP 3802–9.
47.
ManningS., MassaniS., and LewinA.Y. (2008). A Dynamic Perspective on Next Generation Offshoring: The global sourcing of science and engineering talent, Academy of Management Perspectives22(3): 35–54.
48.
MarkusM.L. (1999). Thinking the Unthinkable: What happens if the IS field as we know it goes away? in CurrieW., and GalliersR. (eds.) Rethinking MIS, Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 175–203.
49.
MarkusM.L. (2005). Introduction to the 2004 AIS Award Papers on Innovation in Information Systems Education, Communications of the Association for Information Systems15(16): 286–288.
McGeeM. (2006a). What's in it For Them?InformationWeek, 17 July, pp. 32–44.
52.
McGeeM. (2006b). You vs Offshoring, InformationWeek, 24 April, pp. 44–53.
53.
McGeeM. (2006c). Tech Worker Surveys Show Happy Days Are Here Again, InformationWeek, 2nd August.
54.
MelaoN., and PiddM. (2000). A Conceptual Framework for Understanding Business Processes and Business Process Modeling, Information Systems Journal10(2): 105–129.
NicholsonB., and SahayS. (2001). Some Political and Cultural Issues in the Globalization of Software Development: Case experience from Britain and Indian, Information and Organization11(1): 25–43.
59.
NicholsonB., and SahayS. (2004). Embedded Knowledge and Offshore Software Development, Information and Organization14(4): 329–365.
60.
NobleJ. (2007). High Five: Offshore outlook, InformationWeek, 9th April, p. 17.
US Bureau of Labor Statistics (2004). Occupational Employment Projections to 2012, Monthly Labor Review, February.
75.
US Bureau of Labor Statistics (2008). Occupational Outlook Handbook 2008–2009 Edition, (accessed 26th January 2009).
76.
van WelsumD., and ReifX. (2005). We Can Work It Out – The Globalization of ICT-Enabled Services, DSTI Information Economy Working Paper, DSTI/ICCP/PRELIMINARY, Paris: OECD.
77.
Wall Street Journal (2007). The IT Industry Desperately Needs to Get Cooler, 9th July.
78.
WeidenbaumM. (2005). Outsourcing Pros and Cons, Business Horizons48: 311–315.
79.
WeitzelT., EckhardtA., and LaumerS. (2009). A Framework for Recruiting IT Talent: Lessons from siemens, MISQ Executive8(4): 175–189.
80.
WillcocksL., and LacityM. (2006). Global Sourcing of Business and IT Services, London: Palgrave.
81.
WillcocksL., OshriI., and RottmanJ. (2009). Editors’ Comments, MISQ Executive8(4): iii–iiv.
82.
WilliamsJ. (2006). The Post-Welfare State University, American Literary History18(1): 190–216.
