This paper presents some experiments in calibrating a retail location model designed for the Kristiansand region in southern Norway. The form and behaviour of the model under extremes of its parameter values is first investigated, and then some calibration methods proposed by Hyman are tested. The need for a more general method is evident and a search procedure based on the Fibonacci numbers is outlined. A generalisation of this method, based on the golden section number, is derived and this method is used to explore the sensitivity of the model's goodness-of-fit to changes in parameter values. A fundamental result of these explorations shows that there is no unique fit for retail models with two parameters, and this result is likely to hold for other models of spatial interaction.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AvrielM.WildeD. J., 1966, “Optimality proof for the symmetric Fibonacci search technique”, Fibonacci Quarterly, 4, 265–269
2.
BattyM., 1970, “Some problems of calibrating the Lowry model”, Environment and Planning, 2, 95–114
3.
BellmanR., 1957, Dynamic Programming (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
4.
BerryB. J. L., 1967, Geography of Market Centers and Retail Distribution (Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ)
5.
BlackJ., 1966, “Some retail sales models”, a paper presented to the Urban Studies Conference, Oxford
6.
BoxM. J.DaviesD.SwannW. H., 1969, Non-Linear Optimisation Techniques, ICI Monograph number 5 (Oliver and Boyd, Edinburgh)
7.
BroadbentT. A., 1970, “Notes on the design of operational models”, Environment and Planning, 2, 469–476
8.
Cordey-HayesM., 1968, “Retail location models”, CES-WP-16, Centre for Environmental Studies, London
DaviesR. L., 1970, “Variable relationships in central place and retail potential models”, Regional Studies, 4, 49–61
11.
DraperN. R.SmithH., 1966, Applied Regression Analysis (John Wiley, New York)
12.
EilonS.TilleyR. D. R.FowkesT. R., 1969, “Analysis of a gravity demand model”, Regional Studies, 3, 115–122
13.
EvansA. W., 1971, “The calibration of trip distribution models with exponential or similar cost functions”, Transportation Research, 5, 15–38
14.
HoggattV. E., 1969, Fibonacci and Lucas Numbers (Houghton Mifflin Company, Boston, Mass.)
15.
HuffD. L., 1963, “A probabilistic analysis of shopping center trading areas”, Land Economics, 39, 81–90
16.
HuffD. L., 1964, “Defining and estimating a trading area”, Journal of Marketing, 28, 34–38
17.
HymanG. M., 1969, “The calibration of trip distribution models”, Environment and Planning, 1, 105–112
18.
KrolakP.CooperL., 1963, “An extension of Fibonacci search to several variables”, Communications of ACM, 6, 639–641
19.
LakshmananT. R.HansenW. G., 1965, “A retail market potential model”, Journal of American Institute of Planners, 31, 134–143
20.
McLoughlinJ. B.NixC. K.FootD. H. S., 1966, Regional Shopping Centres: A Planning Report on North West England. Part 2: A Retail Shopping Model, Department of Town and Country Planning, University of Manchester
21.
Ministry of Transport, 1966, Portbury: Reasons for the Minister's Decision not to Authorise the Construction of a New Dock at Portbury, Bristol (HMSO, London)
22.
MischkeC. R., 1968, An Introduction to Computer-Aided Design (Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ)
23.
NEDO, 1970, Urban Models in Shopping Studies, Distributive Trades EDC, National Economic Development Office, London
24.
RhodesT.WhitakerR., 1967, “Forecasting shopping demand”, Journal of Town Planning Institute, 53, 188–192
25.
Scientific Control Systems, 1970, “Non-linear regression”, unpublished note, Scientific Control Systems Ltd., London
26.
SeidmanD. R., 1967, “The construction of an urban growth model”, Report number 1, Technical Supplement, Volume A, Delaware Valley Regional Planning Commission, Philadelphia
27.
SpangH. A., 1962, “A review of minimisation techniques for non-linear functions”, SIAM Review, 4, 343–365
28.
TurnerC. J., 1970, “Severnside shopping model: A discussion of the calibration procedure and results”, Working Paper number 4, Nathaniel Lichfield and Associates, London
