There have been a number of recent criticisms of the methods used to allocate the local authority Rate Support Grant in the UK. A new approach to grant allocation is proposed in this paper, which is based upon mathematical control theory. This method overcomes many criticisms of grant allocation: It allows the explicit identification of grant-allocation goals; it permits the consistent inclusion of constraints; it allows optimal allocation over longer time horizons; and it can incorporate uncertainty in the measurement of local needs and costs. The method is, however, consistent with existing methods of grant allocation and can be implemented within the constraints of existing information bases.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AokiM, 1976Optimal Control and System Theory in Dynamic Economic Analysis (North-Holland, Amsterdam)
2.
BennettR J, 1979Spatial Time Series: Analysis—Forecasting—Control (Pion, London)
3.
BennettR JChorleyR J, 1978Environmental Systems: Philosophy, Analysis and Control (Methuen, London)
4.
BennettR JTanK C, 1978“Stochastic control models of regional economies” in Exploratory and Explanatory Statistical Analysis of Spatial Data Eds BartelsC PKetellapperR H, (Martinus Nijhoff, Leiden, The Netherlands) pp 245–268
5.
ChowG C, 1975Analysis and Control of Dynamic Economic Systems (John Wiley, New York)
6.
Committee of Inquiry into Local Government Finance, 1976Local Government Finance Cmnd 6453 (HMSO, London)
7.
CrippsFGodleyW, 1976Local Government Finance and Its Reform (Department of Applied Economics, University of Cambridge, Cambridge)
KalmanR E, 1960“A new approach to linear filtering and prediction problems”Transactions of the American Society of Mechanical Engineers D: Journal of Basic Engineering8235–45
10.
LeeR C K, 1964Optimal Estimation, Identification and Control (MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass)
11.
PindyckR, 1973Optimal Planning for Economic Stabilisation (North-Holland, Amsterdam)
12.
PontryaginL SBoltyanskiV GGramkrelidzeR VMishchenckoE F, 1962The Mathematical Theory of Optimal Processes (John Wiley, New York)
13.
Resource Allocation Working Party, 1976Report of the Resource Allocation Working Party (Department of Health and Social Security): Sharing Resources for Health in England (HMSO, London)
14.
SalathielD, 1977“The use of social indicators in the distribution of Rate Support Grant” paper presented to the Royal Statistical Society Research Group, London
15.
TanK C, 1979a“Optimal control of linear econometric systems with linear equality constraints on the control variables”International Economic Review20253–258
16.
TanK C, 1979bConstrained Control of Spatial Systems: An Application to Allocation of the Rate Support Grant PhD thesis, Department of Geography, University College London, University of London, London
