There is a long lineage in neighbourhood research that has underpinned sustained academic and policy interest in the UK centred on understanding how spatial ‘clusters’ of neighbourhood-based deprivation might be destabilised. This has seen the privileging of composite indices in the analysis of deprivation, which have been criticised for fostering a common perception that deprived neighbourhoods are homogeneous in terms of their compositions and underlying structures. Such indices have also been criticised for being ineffective at capturing temporal change, providing only static snapshots of deprivation at particular points in time. This paper focuses on patterns of deprived neighbourhood change in the Greater Manchester city-region between 2001 and 2007. It develops a typology of neighbourhood change that is triangulated with three complementary typologies capturing the socioeconomic and demographic compositions of deprived neighbourhoods; the functional roles played by deprived neighbourhoods in redistributing population through migration; and the spatial contexts in which deprived neighbourhoods are located. The analysis reveals that an overreliance on static indices to measure deprivation has long served to conceal complexities in the ways in which deprived neighbourhoods change, owing to their variable structures and contexts. It illustrates the danger that lies in treating all deprived neighbourhoods in the same way.
AnselinL, 2003GeoDa 0.9 User's GuideCenter for Spatially Integrated Social Science, Urbana-Champagne, IL
2.
BateyPBrownP, 2007, “The spatial targeting of urban policy initiatives: A geodemographic assessment tool”Environment and Planning A392774–2793
3.
BeattyCFothergillS, 2002, “Hidden unemployment among men: A case study”Regional Studies36811–823
4.
BondSInsalacoF, 2007Area Classification of Super Output Areas and Datazones Final ReportOffice for National Statistics, London
5.
ChaskinR, 1998, “Neighbourhood as a unit of planning and action: A heuristic approach”Journal of Planning Literature13(11) 11–30
6.
CouchC, 1999, “Housing development in the city centre”Planning Practice and Research1469–86
7.
DCLG, 2009National Evaluation of Housing Market Renewal Pathfinders 2005–2007Department for Communities and Local Government (The Stationery Office, London)
8.
DCLG, 2010Evaluation of the National Strategy for Neighbourhood Renewal: Final ReportDepartment for Communities and Local Government (The Stationery Office, London)
9.
DeasI, 2014, “The search for territorial fixes in subnational governance: City-regions and the disputed emergence of post-political consensus in Manchester, England”Urban Studies512285–2314
10.
DeasIRobsonBWongCBradfordM, 2003, “Measuring neighbourhood deprivation: A critique of the Index of Multiple Deprivation”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy21883–903
11.
FieldhouseE ATyeR, 1996, “Deprived people or deprived places? Exploring the ecological fallacy in studies of deprivation with the Samples of Anonymised Records”Environment and Planning A28237–259
12.
GalsterG, 2001, “On the nature of neighbourhood”Urban Studies382111–2124
13.
GalsterG CQuerciaR GCortesAMalegaR, 2003, “The fortunes of poor neighbourhoods”Urban Affairs Review39205–226
GrigsbyWBaratzMGalsterGMaclennanD, 1987, “The dynamics of neighbourhood change and decline”Progress in Planning281–76
17.
HardingAHarloeMReesJ, 2010, “Manchester's bust regime”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research34981–991
18.
HaughtonGDeasIHincksS, 2014, “Making an impact: When agglomeration boosterism meets antiplanning rhetoric”Environment and Planning A46265–270
19.
HincksSRobsonB, 2010Regenerating Communities First: Neighbourhoods in WalesJoseph Rowntree Foundation, York
20.
HulchanskiD J, 2007The Three Cities Within TorontoUniversity of Toronto, Toronto)
21.
KearnsAParkesA, 2003, “Living in and leaving poor neighbourhood conditions in England”Housing Studies18827–840
22.
KitchenPWilliamsA, 2009, “Measuring neighbourhood social change in Saskatoon, Canada: A geographic analysis”Urban Geography30261–288
23.
LeesL, 2008, “Gentrification and social mixing: Towards an inclusive urban renaissance?”Urban Studies452449–2470
24.
MallachA, 2008Managing Neighbourhood Change: A Framework for Sustainable and Equitable RevitalizationNational Housing Institute, Montclair, NJ)
25.
MeenGNygardCMeenJ, 2013, “The causes of long-term neighbourhood change”, in Understanding Neighbourhood Dynamics: New Insights for Neighbourhood Effects Research Eds van HamMManleyDBaileyNSimposnLMaclennanD (Springer, London) pp 46–62
26.
MIER, 2009Reviewer's ReportManchester Independent Economic Review, Manchester
27.
NobleMWrightGSmithGDibbenC, 2006, “Measuring multiple deprivation at the small-area level”Environment and Planning A38169–185
28.
NormanP, 2010, “Identifying change over time in small area socio-economic deprivation”Applied Spatial Analysis and Policy3107–138
29.
ParkR E, 1936, “Human ecology”American Journal of SociologyXLII1–15
30.
PeckJ, 2012, “Austerity urbanism”City16626–655
31.
RaeA, 2009, “Isolated entities or integrated neighbourhoods? An alternative view of the measurement of deprivation”Urban Studies461859–1878
32.
RaeA, 2012, “Spatially concentrated deprivation in England: An empirical assessment”Regional Studies461183–1199
33.
RobsonBLymperopoulouKRaeA, 2008, “People on the move: Exploring the functional roles of deprived neighbourhoods”Environment and Planning A402693–2714
34.
RussellGStowePTwomeyJRobsonB, 2009Sustainable Communities: Manchester Independent Economic ReviewManchester Independent Economic Review, Manchester
35.
SampsonR J, 2012Greater American City: Chicago and the Enduring Neighbourhood EffectChicago University Press, Chicago, IL)
36.
BaingSchultz AWongC, 2012, “Brownfield residential development: What happens to the most deprived neighbourhoods in England?”Urban Studies492989–3008
37.
SchwirianK P, 1983, “Models of neighbourhood change”Annual Review of Sociology983–102
38.
ShevkyEBellW, 1955Social Area AnalysisStanford University Press, Stanford, CA
39.
SquiresG, 2009The Regeneration of Low Demand Neighbourhoods: The Housing Market Renewal Experience PhD thesis, Department of Planning and Landscape, University of Manchester, Manchester
40.
SuttlesG D, 1972The Social Construction of CommunitiesUniversity of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL)
41.
TemkinKRoheW, 1996, “Neighbourhood change and urban policy”Journal of Planning Education and Research15159–170
42.
TurcuC, 2012, “Local experiences of urban sustainability: Researching housing market renewal interventions in three English neighbourhoods”Progress in Planning78101–150
43.
VickersDReesP, 2007, “Creating the National Statistics 2001 Output Area Classification”Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series A170 Part 2, 379–403
44.
WardK, 2000, “Front rentiers to rantiers: ‘active entrepreneurs’, ‘structural speculators’ and the politics of marketing the city”Urban Studies371093–1107
45.
WebsterC, 2003, “The nature of the neighbourhood”Urban Studies402591–2612
