The existence of ethnic penalties in the operations of the UK labour market is well established, although many studies have focused upon only unemployment and income as measures of labour-market performance. Few have looked at changes in those penalties over time, especially during a period including a major recent recession, and whether they were experienced widely throughout the population—whether people were ‘all in it together’ according to the government's rhetoric defending its post-2010 austerity programme. This paper evaluates that claim's validity by exploring differences among eighteen separate ethnoreligious groups across a wider range of labour-market performance measures: it assesses not only whether there were ethnic penalties throughout the period but also whether they were exacerbated during the recession that began in 2008. Statistical modelling shows that many were indeed exacerbated—in the percentage employed part-time rather than full-time, the percentage overqualified for their chosen jobs, the percentage of older adults who become economically inactive prematurely, and income levels—but not unemployment levels. Muslim groups, especially those from Asia, suffered the most extensive penalties, and the greatest exacerbation of them during the recession.
BeckerG S, 1957The Economics of Discrimination (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL)
5.
BerthoudR, 1998, “Defining ethnic groups: origin or ethnicity?”Patterns of Prejudice3253–63
6.
BerthoudRBlekesauneM, 2007Persistent Employment DisadvantageDepartment for Work and Pensions RP 416 (The Stationery Office, London)
7.
BiegertT, 2014, “On the outside looking in? Transitions out of non-employment in the United Kingdom and Germany”Journal of European Social Policy243–18
8.
BlackabyD HClarkKLeslieD GMurphyP D, 1994, “Black-White male earnings and employment prospects in the 1970s and 1980s: evidence for Britain”Economics Letters46273–279
9.
BlackabyD HLeslieD GMurphyP DO'LearyN C, 1998, “The ethnic wage gap and employment differentials in the 1990s: evidence from Britain”Economics Letters5897–103
10.
BlackabyD HLeslieD GMurphyP DO'LearyN C, 2002, “White/ethnic minority earnings and employment differentials in Britain: evidence from the LFS”Oxford Economic Papers54270–297
11.
BrownM S, 2000, “Religion and economic activity in the South Asian population”Ethnic and Racial Studies231065–1091
12.
CarmichaelFWoodsR, 2000, “Ethnic penalties in unemployment and occupational attainment: evidence for Britain”International Review of Applied Economics1471–97
13.
CarterP L, 2009, “Geography, race and quantification”The Professional Geographer61465–480
ClarkKDrinkwaterS, 2007Ethnic Minorities in the Labour Market: Dynamics and Diversity (Policy Press, Bristol)
16.
de OliveiraM MSantosM CKikerB F, 2000, “The role of human capital and technological change in overeducation”Economics of Education Review19199–206
17.
DixieJ, 1998, “The ethnic and religious questions for 2001 research and responses”Patterns of Prejudice325–14
18.
ElliottR J RLindleyJ K L, 2008, “Immigrant wage differentials, ethnicity and occupational segregation”Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series A171645–671
19.
GallieDFelsteadAGreenFInancH, 2014, “The quality of work in Britain over the economic crisis”International Review of Sociology24207–224
20.
GrootWvan den BrinkH M, 2000, “Overeducation in the labor market: a meta-analysis”Economics of Education Review19149–158
21.
HeathA, 2014, “Patterns of generational change: convergent, reactive or emergent?”Ethnic and Racial Studies371–9
22.
HeathACheungS Y, (Eds), 2007Unequal Chances: Ethnic Minorities in Western Labour Markets (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
23.
HeathALiY, 2008, “Period, life-cycle and generational effects on ethnic minority success in the British labour market”Kölner Zeitschrift fur Soziologie and Sozialpsychologie48277–296
24.
HeathAMcMahonD, 2005, “Social mobility of ethnic minorities”, in Ethnicity, Social Mobility and Public Policy Eds LouryG CModoodTTeleS M (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 393–413
25.
HeathAMartinJ, 2013, “Can religious affiliation explain ‘ethnic’ inequalities in the labour market?”Ethnic and Racial Studies361005–1027
JohnstonR JKhattabNSirkeciIModoodT, 2010, “Ethno-religious categories and measuring occupational attainment in relation to education in England and Wales: a multilevel analysis”Environment and Planning A42578–591
JohnstonR JKhattabNManleyD, 2014b, “It's grim up north: but did it get grimmer with the recession”CMPO Blog 18 March, http://cmpo.wordpress.com/2014/03/18/
30.
KhattabN, 2009, “Ethno-religious background as a determinant of educational and occupational attainment in Britain”Sociology43304–322
31.
KhattabNJohnstonR J, 2013, “Ethnic and religious penalties in a changing British labour market from 2002 to 2010: the case of unemployment”Environment and Planning A451358–1371
32.
LiYHeathA, 2005, “Minority ethnic men in the British labour market (1972-2005)”International Review of Sociology and Social Policy28231–244
33.
LindleyJ K L, 2002a, “Race or religion? The impact of religion on the employment and earnings of Britain's ethnic communities”Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies28427–442
34.
LindleyJ K L, 2002b, “The English language fluency and earnings of ethnic minorities in Britain”Scottish Journal of Political Economy49467–487
35.
LonghiSNicolettiCPlattL, 2012, “Explained and unexplained wage gaps across the main ethno-religious groups in Great Britain”Oxford Economic Papers65471–493
36.
LucasS R, 2001, “Effectively maintained inequality: education transitions, track mobility, and social background effects”American Journal of Sociology61642–1690
37.
MeerNModoodT, 2009, “Refutations of racism in the ‘Muslim question’”Patterns of Prejudice43335–354
38.
ModelSLinL, 2002, “The cost of not being Christian: Hindus, Sikhs and Muslims in Britain and Canada”International Migration Review361061–1092
39.
ModoodTBerthoudRLakeyJNazrooJSmithPVirdeeSBeishonS, 1997Ethnic Minorities in Britain: Diversity and Disadvantage (Policy Studies Institute, London)
40.
PhelpsE S, 1972, “The statistical theory of racism and sexism”American Economic Review52659–661
41.
PlattL, 2011Understanding Inequalities: Stratification and Difference (Polity Press, Cambridge)
42.
PurdamKAfkjhaniRCrockettAOlsenW, 2007, “Religion in the UK: an overview of equality statistics and evidence gaps”Journal of Contemporary Religion22147–168
43.
RafteryA EHoutM, 1993, “Maximally maintained inequality: expansion, reform, and opportunity in Irish education, 1921–1975”Sociology of Education6641–62
44.
RanaJ, 2007, “The story of Islamophobia”Souls: A Critical Journal of Black Politics, Culture and Society9148–161
45.
SillitoeKWhiteH P, 1992, “Ethnic group and the British census: the search for a question”Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series A155141–163
46.
SloaneP JBattuHSeamanP T, 1999, “Overeducation, undereducation and the British labour market”Applied Economics311437–1453
47.
WingfieldA HAlstonR S, 2013, “Maintaining hierarchies in predominantly White organizations: a theory of racial tasks”American Behavioral Scientist58274–287
