Abstract
The economic framework is often very useful in the analysis of energy – environment problems, but it remains inadequate in a number of significant ways. After a brief review of basic theoretical principles, particularly as applied in cost – benefit analysis, some of the limitations of the economic approach are discussed with reference to selected examples in the energy – environment field. The merits of several alternative approaches to problem analysis and policy formulation are also briefly considered.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Arrow
K J
, 1963 Social Choice and Individual Values 2nd edition (John Wiley , Chichester, Sussex ).
2.
Cohen
B L
, 1980 , “Society's valuation of life saving in radiation protection and other contexts” Health Physics 38 33 –51 .
3.
Cotgrove
S
Duff
A
, 1980 , “Environmentalism, middle class radicalism and politics” Sociological Review 28 333 –351 .
4.
Cotgrove
S
Duff
A
, 1981 , “Environmentalism, values and social change” British Journal of Sociology 32 92 –110 .
5.
Evans
N L
Hope
C W
, 1984 Nuclear Power: Futures, Costs and Benefits (Cambridge University Press , Cambridge ).
6.
Fischhoff
B
, 1986 , “Judgemental aspects of risk analysis” in Office of Management and Budget Handbook of Risk Analysis (Plenum , New York ) forthcoming.
7.
Fischhoff
B
Lichtenstein
S
Slovic
P
Derby
S
Keeney
R
, 1982 Acceptable Risk (Cambridge University Press , Cambridge ).
8.
Glyn
A
, 1984 , “When coal not dole is the best choice” The Guardian 28 May, page 8 .
9.
Lindley
D V
, 1971 Making Decisions (John Wiley , Chichester, Sussex ).
10.
Lipsey
R G
, 1983 An Introduction to Positive Economics 6th edition (Weidenfield and Nicolson , London ).
11.
Lovins
A
, 1977 , Soft Energy Paths (Penguin Books , Harmondsworth, Middx ).
12.
Maclean
D
, 1982 , “Ethics and energy” Centre for Philosophy and Public Policy, University of Maryland , Adelphi, MD .
13.
Manners
G
, 1981 Coal in Britain: An Uncertain Future (George Allen and Unwin , Hemel Hempstead, Herts ).
14.
Martin
B
, 1978 , “Soft energy, hard politics” Undercurrents 27 10 –13 .
15.
Mishan
E J
, 1982 Cost-Benefit Analysis 3rd edition (George Allen and Unwin , Hemel Hempstead, Herts ).
16.
Pearce
D W
, 1974 , “Economic and ecological approaches to the optimal level of pollution” International Journal of Social Economics 1 146 –159 .
17.
Pearce
D W
, 1979 , “Social cost-benefit analysis and nuclear futures” Energy Economics 1 66 –71 .
18.
Pearce
D W
Nash
C A
, 1981 The Social Appraisal of Projects (Macmillan , London ).
19.
Robinson
C
Marshall
E
, 1983 , “What future for British coal policy?” Energy Economics Centre, University of Surrey , Guildford, Surrey .
20.
Sagoff
M
, 1982 “Environmental ethics” Centre for Philosophy and Public Policy, University of Maryland , Adelphi, MD .
21.
Sandbach
F
, 1980 Environment, Ideology and Policy (Basil Blackwell , Oxford ).
22.
Sugden
R
Williams
A
, 1978 Practical Cost-Benefits Analysis (Oxford University Press , Oxford ).
23.
Tversky
A
Kahneman
D
, 1974 , “Judgement under uncertainty: Heuristics and biases” Science 185 1124 –1131 .
24.
Watson
S R
Hayward
G M
, 1981 , “A review of some formal methods for decision-making” Engineering Department, Cambridge University , Cambridge .
25.
Wynne
B
, 1975 , “The rhetoric of consensus politics: A critical review of technology assessment” Research Policy 4 108 –158 .