In most studies of service provision in local authorities it is assumed that councils respond directly to service need and fiscal conditions. In this paper it is argued that this is a fallacy as responses are conditioned by the filter of political party control. With a focus on nonmetropolitan counties and metropolitan boroughs and districts, it is shown that relationships between policy variation and socioeconomic conditions vary in Conservative-dominated and Labour-dominated councils. In particular, Conservative councils respond more notably to fiscal resources, whereas Labour authorities are more responsive to service need. Examination of changes in provision show that these patterns have persisted through the 1980s.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AltJ E, 1971, “Some social and political correlates of county borough expenditures”British Journal of Political Science149–62
2.
AuditCommission, 1986Making a Reality of Community Care (HMSO, London)
3.
BahlRJohnsonMWasylenkoM, 1980, “State and local government expenditure determinants: The traditional view and a new approach”, in Public Employment and State and Local Government Finance Eds BahlRBurkheadJJumpB (Ballinger, Cambridge, MA) pp 65–119
4.
BarryN P, 1987The New Right (Croom Helm, Andover, Hants)
5.
BebbingtonA CDaviesB P, 1982, “Patterns of social service provision for the elderly”, in Geographical Perspectives on the Elderly Ed. WarnesA M (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex), pp 355–374
6.
BochelM, 1989Geographical Perspectives on Residential Provision for the Elderly, with Special Reference to the Voluntary Sector PhD thesis, Department of Geographical Sciences, Polytechnic South West, Plymouth, England
7.
BoyneG A, 1985, “Theory, methodology and results in political science—the case of output studies”British Journal of Political Science15473–515
8.
BradshawJ, 1972, “The concept of social need”New Society496 30 March, pp 640–643
9.
BrindleD, 1990, “Funding crisis hits homes for old”Guardian 1 September, page 2
10.
ChapmanP, 1979Unmet Needs and the Delivery of Care: A Study of the Utilisation of Social Services by Old People occasional paper in social administration number 61 (Bedford Square Press, London)
11.
CIPFA, annual Personal Social Services StatisticsChartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy, 3 Robert Street, London WC2N 6BH
12.
CulfA, 1990, “City defies delay in community care”Guardian 8 August, page 4
13.
CurtisS, 1989The Geography of Public Welfare Provision (Routledge, Chapman and Hall, Andover, Hants)
14.
DanzigerJ N, 1976, “Twenty-six outputs in search of a taxonomy”British Journal of Political Science5201–212
15.
DanzigerJ N, 1978Making Budgets (Sage, Beverly Hills, CA)
16.
DaviesB P, 1964, “An index of variation in ‘need’ of county boroughs for old people's homes”Sociological Review125–38
17.
DaviesB P, 1968Social Needs and Resources in Local Services (Michael Joseph, London)
18.
DaviesB P, 1969, “Welfare departments and territorial justice: Some implications for the reform of local government”Social and Economic Administration3235–252
19.
DaviesB P, 1978, “Issues on need”, in Issues in Urban Society Eds DaviesR LHallP G (Penguin Books, Harmondsworth, Middx) pp 216–240
20.
DaviesB PBartonAMcMillanIWilliamsonV, 1971Variations in Services for the Elderly occasional paper in social administration number 40 (Bell and Hyman, London)
21.
DearloveJ, 1973The Politics of Policy in Local Government (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
22.
DearloveJSaundersP, 1984Introduction to British Politics (Polity Press, Cambridge)
23.
DHSS, 1981Care in Action Department of Health and Social Security (HMSO, London)
24.
DSS, 1988Community Care: Agenda for Action Department of Social Security (HMSO, London)
25.
DuncanS SGoodwinM, 1988The Local State and Uneven Development: Behind the Local Government Crisis (Polity Press, Cambridge)
26.
FriedlandR, 1982Power and Crisis in the City: Corporations, Unions and Urban Policy (Macmillan, London)
27.
FriedmanJ J, 1977, “Community action on water pollution”Human Ecology5329–353
28.
FruinD, 1974, “Analyses of need”, in Social Issues and the Social Services Ed. BrownM J (Charles Knight, Tonbridge, Kent) pp 27–56
29.
GreveDPageDGreveS, 1971Homelessness in London (Scottish Academic Press, Edinburgh)
30.
GyfordJ, 1985The Politics of Local Socialism (Allen and Unwin, London)
31.
GyfordJLeachSGameC, 1989The Changing Politics of Local Government (Unwin Hyman, London)
32.
HansenT, 1981, “Transforming needs into expenditure decisions”, in Urban Political Economy Ed. NewtonK (Frances Pinter, London) pp 27–47
33.
HarrisA I, 1971Handicapped and Impaired in Great Britain (HMSO, London)
34.
HoggartK, 1986, “Geography, political control and local government policy outputs”Progress in Human Geography101–23
35.
HoggartK, 1987, “Does politics matter? Redistributive policies in English cities 1949–74”British Journal of Political Science17359–371
36.
HoggartKShrivesE J R, 1991, “Political party influence on preschool services in England, 1977–88”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy995–110
37.
JollyM A S, 1988, “Care for the elderly—an analysis of variations in public sector provision across local authorities in England”, DP-133 (National Institute of Economic and Social Research, London)
38.
KuhnleS, 1981, “Economics, politics, and policy in Norwegian urban communes”, in Urban Political Economy Ed. NewtonK (Frances Pinter, London) pp 63–81
39.
LaffinMYoungK, 1985, “The changing roles and responsibilities of local authority chief officers”Public Administration6341–59
40.
LansleySGossSWolmarC, 1989Councils in Conflict: The Rise and Fall of the Municipal Left (Macmillan Education, Basingstoke, Hants)
41.
LasswellH D, 1958Politics: Who Gets What, When, How (Meridian Press, Elnora, NY)
42.
LeGrandJWinterD, 1977, “Towards an economic model of local government behaviour”Policy and Politics523–39
43.
LipseyD, 1990, “Wandsworth marks a change for the poorer”Sunday Correspondent 6 May, page 17
44.
Mark-LawsonJSavageMWardeA, 1985, “Gender and local politics: Struggles over welfare policies, 1918–39”, in Localities, Class, and Gender The Lancaster Regionalism Group (Pion, London) pp 195–215
45.
MidwinterA, 1984The Politics of Local Spending (Mainstream, Edinburgh)
46.
MoseleyL G, 1968, “Variations in socio-medical services for the aged”Social and Economic Administration2169–183
47.
NewtonKKarranT J, 1985The Politics of Local Expenditure (Macmillan, London)
48.
PageE C, 1985Political Authority and Bureaucratic Power (Harvester Press, Hemel Hempstead, Herts)
49.
PageE CGoldsmithMKousgaardP, 1990, “Time, parties and budgetary change: Fiscal decisions in English cities, 1974–88”British Journal of Political Science2043–61
50.
PattieC J, 1986, “Positive discrimination in the provision of primary education in Sheffield”Environment and Planning A181249–1257
51.
PhillipsD RVincentJ, 1986, “Private residential accommodation for the elderly: Geographical aspects of developments in Devon”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers2150–173
52.
PinchS P, 1979, “Territorial justice in the city: A case study of the social services for the elderly in Greater London”, in Social Problems and the City Eds HerbertD TSmithD M (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 201–223
53.
PinchS P, 1980, “Local authority provision for the elderly: An overview and case study of London”, in Geography and the Urban Environment, Volume Three Eds HerbertD TJohnstonR J (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex) pp 295–343
54.
PinchS P, 1987, “The changing geography of preschool services in England between 1977 and 1983”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy5469–480
55.
PinchS P, 1989, “The restructuring thesis and the study of public services”Environment and Planning A21905–926
56.
SaundersP, 1979Urban Politics: A Sociological Interpretation (Hutchinson Education, London)
SCT, annual Block Grant IndicatorsSociety of County Treasurers; copy available from Honorable Secretary, Society of County Treasurers, County Building, Eastgate, Stafford ST16 2NF
59.
StonecashJ, 1980, “Politics, wealth and public policy”, in The Determinants of Public Policy Eds DyeT RGrayV (D C Heath, Lexington, MA) pp 21–37
60.
TravisA, 1990a, “Patten advised by local Tories on council cuts”Guardian 22 June, page 2
WarnesA MLawC M, 1984, “The elderly population of Great Britain: Locational trends and policy implications”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers937–59
64.
WestonC, 1990, “Schools chief to go in rift with Tory council”Guardian 13 July, page 6
