The 1980s saw a conscious restructuring of economic life in Australia. The direction of that restructuring was derived partly from prescriptions about the virtues of free trade and government deregulation. Another influence has been the view that the economic success of Japan and the Asian ‘dragons’ is because of their adoption of free trade and liberal market regimes. In this paper, evidence from Korea and Taiwan is used to show that this interpretation is seriously flawed. The growth of the dragons was not driven by comparative advantage. Rather, the industries of the dragons were set up independently of their competitiveness; some became competitive by exporting. Industrialisation in the newly industrialised countries (NICs) exemplifies a variety of forms of local initiative by a state: how does it have the will and power to create industrial policy? The development of state policy depends on local class structures and perceptions of the global political and economic environment that nullify attempts simply to copy policy into different social and economic circumstances. The lessons of the economic success of the Northeast Asian NICs are improperly drawn in two respects: these are dirigiste, not free market, economies; and even if that intervention has been for the good it does not follow that similar policies could be applied, much less be successful, in the different place that is Australia. This is the geographic lesson: places differ, and so, therefore, must policies.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AdelmanIMorrisC, 1967Society, Politics and Economic Development: A Quantitative Approach (The Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD)
2.
AlamM S, 1991, “Trade orientation and macroeconomic performance in LDCs: An empirical study”Economic Development and Cultural Change39839–848
3.
AmsdenA H, 1989Asia's Next Giant: South Korea and Late Industrialisation (Oxford University Press, New York)
4.
BalassaB, 1978The Newly Industrializing Countries in the World Economy (Pergamon Press, Elmsford, NY)
5.
BalassaB, 1985, “The role of foreign trade in the economic development of Korea”, in Foreign Trade and Investment: Economic Development in the Newly Industrialising Asian Countries Ed. GalensonW (University of Wisconsin Press, Madison, WI) pp 141–175
6.
BienefeldM, 1988, “The significance of the newly industrialising countries for the development debate”Studies in Political Economy257–39
7.
BradfordC I, 1987, “Trade and structural change: NICs and next tier NICs as transitional economies”World Development15299–316
8.
BradfordC I, 1990, “Policy interventions and markets: Development strategy typologies and policy options”, in Manufacturing Miracles: Paths of Industrialization in Latin America and East Asia Eds GereffiGWymanD L (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ) pp 34–51
9.
ChanSClarkCDavisD R, 1990, “State entrepreneurship, foreign investment, export expansion, and economic growth: Granger causality in Taiwan's development”Journal of Conflict Resolution34102–129
10.
ChenT JTangD P, 1990, “Export performance and productivity growth: The case of Taiwan”Economic Development and Cultural Change38577–585
11.
ChiouC L, 1986, “Politics of alienation and polarisation: Taiwan's Tangwai in the 1980s”Bulletin of Concerned Asian Scholars18(3) 16–28
12.
ChooHKimD, 1981, “Probable size distribution of income in Korea over time and by sectors”, Korea Development Institute, Seoul
13.
CIECD, 1970Taiwan Statistical Data Book (annual publication by Council for International Economic Cooperation and Development, Taipei)
14.
CrocombeG TEnrightM JPorterM E, 1991Upgrading New Zealand's Competitive Advantage (Oxford University Press, Auckland)
15.
CumingsB, 1984, “The origins and development of the Northwest Asian political economy: Industrial sectors, product cycles, and political consequences”International Organisation381–40
16.
DavisR DWardM D, 1990, “The entrepreneurial state: Evidence from Taiwan”Comparative Political Studies23314–333
17.
DeyoF C, 1989, “Labor and development policy in East Asia”Annals of The American Academy of Political and Social Science505152–161
18.
DeyoF C, 1990, “Economic policy and the popular sector”, in Manufacturing Miracles: Paths of Industrialization in Latin America and East Asia Eds GereffiGWymanD L (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ) pp 179–204
19.
DeyoFHaggardSKooH, 1987, “Labor in the political economy of East Asian industrialisation”Bulletin of Concerned Asian Scholars19(2) 42–53
20.
DFAT, 1992Australia and North-East Asia in the 1990s: Accelerating Change Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (Australian Government Publishing Service, Canberra)
21.
DGBAS, annual Statistical Yearbook of the Republic of China (Directorate General of Budget, Accounting and Statistics, Taipei)
22.
DollarD, 1991, “Convergence of South Korean productivity on West German levels 1966–78”World Development19263–273
23.
DollarDSokoloffK, 1990, “Changing comparative advantage and productivity growth in manufacturing industries”, in Korean Economic Development Ed. KwonJ K (Greenwood Press, Westport, CT) pp 129–142
24.
Economic Planning Board, 1981Social Indicators of KoreaEconomic Planning Board, 90 Kyongun-dong, Ononu-gu, Seoul
25.
EDN, annual Economic Yearbook of the Republic of China (Economic Daily News, Taipei)
26.
EnosJ LParkW H, 1988The Adoption and Diffusion of Imported Technology (Croom Helm, Andover, Hants)
27.
ErzanR, 1988, “The profile of protection in developing countries” DP21, United Nations Commission for Trade and Development, Geneva
28.
FelixD, 1989, “Import substitution and late industrialisation: Latin America and Asia compared”World Development171455–1469
29.
FieldsG SWanH, 1989, “Wage-setting institutions and economic growth”World Development171471–1483
30.
FransmanM, 1986, “International competitiveness, technical change and the state: The machine tool industry in Taiwan and Japan”World Development141375–1396
31.
GarnautR, 1989Australia and the Northeast Asian Ascendancy (Australian Government Printing Service, Canberra)
32.
GereffiG, 1990, “Paths of industrialization: An overview”, in Manufacturing Miracles: Paths of Industrialization in Latin America and East Asia Eds GereffiGWymanD L (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ) pp 3–31
33.
GoncalvesRRichteringJ, 1987, “Intercountry comparison of export performance and output growth”The Developing Economies253–18
34.
GunasekeraH D B H, 1989, “Intraindustry specialisation in production and trade in newly industrializing countries: A conceptual framework and some empirical evidence from East Asia”World Development171279–1287
35.
HamiltonC, 1986Capitalist Industrialization in Korea (Westview Press, Boulder, CO)
36.
HamiltonC, 1987, “Price formation and class relations in the development process”Journal of Contemporary Asia172–18
37.
HirataA, 1988, “Promotion of manufactured exports in developing countries”The Developing Economies26422–437
38.
HongW, 1990, “Market distortions and polarization of trade patterns: The Korean experience”, in Korean Economic Development Ed. KwonJ K (Greenwood Press, Westport, CT) pp 115–128
39.
ItoK, 1984, “Development finance and commercial banks in Korea”The Developing Economies22453–475
40.
JenkinsR, 1991, “The political economy of industrialisation: A comparison of Latin American and East Asian industrialising countries”Development and Change22197–231
41.
KavoussiR, 1985, “International trade and economic development: The recent experience of developing countries”Journal of Developing Areas19379–392
42.
KimK S, 1990, “Import liberalisation and its impact in Korea”, in Korean Economic Development Ed. KwonJ K (Greenwood Press, Westport, CT) pp 99–113
43.
KimY S, 1988, “Financial market behavior and balance of payments during the periods of partial financial reform in Korea, 1976–81”The Developing Economies26247–263
44.
KohsakaA, 1987, “Financial liberalisation in Asian NICs: A comparative study of Korea and Taiwan in the 1980s”The Developing Economies25325–345
45.
KooB HParkW A, 1990, “Exchange rate policy in Korea”, in Korean Economic Development Ed. KwonJ K (Greenwood Press, Westport, CT) pp 79–98
46.
KravisBSummersRHestonA, 1980, “International comparisons of real product and its composition 1950–1977”Review of Income and Wealth319–66
47.
KruegerA O, 1985, “The experience and lessons of Asia's super exporters”, in Export-oriented Development Strategies Eds CorboVKruegerA OOssaF (Westview Press, Boulder, CO) pp 187–212
48.
KuoS W YFreiJ C H, 1985, “Causes and roles of export expansion in the Republic of China”, in Foreign Trade and Investment: Economic Development in the Newly Industrialising Asian Countries” Ed. GalensonW (University of Wisconsin Press, Madison, WI) pp 45–84
49.
LairdSNoguesJ, 1988, “Manufactured export performance of the highly indebted countries”The Developing Economies26403–421
50.
LalD, 1983The Poverty of Development Economics (Institute of Economic Affairs, London)
51.
LauniusM A, 1984, “The state and industrial labour in South Korea”Bulletin of Concerned Asian Scholars16(4) 2–10
52.
LinC Y, 1973Industrialisation in Taiwan 1946–1972 (Praeger, New York)
53.
LinC Y, 1989Latin America vs East Asia: A Comparative Development Perspective (M E Sharpe, Armonk, NY)
54.
LindertP H, 1986International Economics (Richard D Irwin, Homewood, IL)
55.
Luedde-NeurathR, 1986Import Controls and Export-oriented Development: A Reassessment of the South Korean Case (Westview Press, Boulder, CO)
56.
MichaelyM, 1977, “Exports and growth: An empirical investigation”Journal of Development Economics449–53
57.
OhnoK, 1989, “A note on the dual-industrial growth and learning effects”The Developing Economies27350–358
58.
OhnoKImaokaH, 1987, “The experience of dual-industrial growth: Korea and Taiwan”The Developing Economies25310–324
59.
Pappas, Carter, Evans, Kook-Telesis, 1990The Global Challenge: Australian Manufacturing in the 1990s (Australian Manufacturing Council, World Trade Centre, Melbourne)
60.
ParkM K, 1987, “Interest representation in South Korea”Asian Survey27903–917
61.
PorterM E, 1990The Competitive Advantage of Nations (The Free Press, New York)
62.
RanisG, 1989, “The role of institutions in transition growth: The East Asian newly industrializing countries”World Development171443–1453
63.
RanisG, 1990, “Contrasts in the political economy of development policy change”, in Manufacturing Miracles: Paths of Industrialization in Latin America and East Asia Eds GereffiGWymanD L (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ) pp 207–230
64.
RheeS, 1988, “Recent industrial adjustments of Korean economy and underlying policy reforms”The Developing Economies26222–246
65.
ScitovskyT, 1986, “Economic development in Taiwan and South Korea 1965–1981”, in Models of Development: A Comparative Study of Economic Growth in South Korea and Taiwan Ed. LauL (Institute for Contemporary Studies, San Francisco, CA)
66.
SingerH WGrayP, 1988, “Trade policy and growth of developing countries: Some new data”World Development16395–403
67.
SteinbergD I, 1988, “Sociopolitical factors and Korea's future economic policies”World Development1619–34
68.
TeubalM, 1984, “The role of technological learning in the exports of manufactured goods: The case of selected capital goods in Brazil”World Development12849–865
69.
TsiangS CChenW L, 1984, “Developments towards trade liberalisation in Taiwan”, Chung-hua Institution for Economic Research, Taipei
70.
TuC HWangW T, 1988, “Trade liberalisation in the Republic of China on Taiwan and the economic effects of tariff reductions” (Korea Development Institute, Seoul)
71.
UN, annual International Trade Statistics Yearbook (United Nations, New York)
72.
UN, annual National Account Statistics (United Nations, New York)
73.
UN, annual Statistical Yearbook (United Nations, New York)
74.
UN, annual Yearbook of National Accounts Satistics (United Nations, New York)
75.
van LiemtG, 1988Bridging the Gap: Four Newly Industrialising Countries and the Changing International Division of Labour (International Labour Office, Geneva)
76.
VosR, 1982, “External dependence, capital accumulation, and the role of the state: South Korea 1960–77”Development and Change1391–121
77.
WadeR, 1990aGoverning the Market (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
78.
WadeR, 1990b, “Industrial policy in East Asia: Does it lead or follow the market?”, in Manufacturing Miracles: Paths of Industrialization in Latin America and East Asia Eds GereffiGWymanD L (Princeton Unversity Press, Princeton, NJ) pp 231–266
79.
WebberM J, 1992, “Enter the dragon”, WP-92-2, Monash—Melbourne Joint Project on Comparative Asian—Australian Development; copy available from author
80.
WhiteheadL, 1990, “Political explanations of macroeconomic management: A survey”World Development181133–1146
81.
World Bank, 1987World Development Report (The World Bank, Washington, DC)
