Much contemporary skilled international migration involves the transient movement of skills between a migrant's country of origin and the destination. This paper shows that international circulation amongst Hong Kong doctors is neither new nor random. A survey of Hong Kong doctors with overseas work experience was undertaken by the authors to examine the factors influencing the length of employment overseas and the propensity to return. Statistical analysis of the results indicates that holding a foreign passport, previous overseas training, and the country of destination were key factors in detennining the length of residence abroad and propensity to return to Hong Kong. In the light of the changing importance for Hong Kong professionals of obtaining residency rights abroad, and given the widely varying immigration policies of the main destination countries in relation to issues such as recognition of Hong Kong qualifications, it is suggested that professional groups such as doctors choose their migration destinations in line with a predetermined migration strategy for either temporary emigration or for longer-term resettlement overseas. The survey results are of wider significance in the understanding of changing patterns of skill exchange involving the upper echelons of the populations of newly industrialising countries.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BainesD, 1991Emigration from Europe 1815-1930 (Macmillan Education, Basingstoke, Hants)
2.
BorjasG, 1989, “Economic theory and international migration”International Migration Review23457–485
3.
BoydM, 1989, “Family and personal networks in international migration: recent developments and new agendas”International Migration Review23638–670
4.
BrewsterC, 1988, “The management of expatriates”, monograph 2, Human Resources Research Centre, Cranfield Institute of Technology, Cranfield
5.
Capmas, 1988Characteristics of Out and Returning Egyptian Migration (Capmas, Cairo) (in Arabic)
6.
CeraseF, 1970, “Nostalgia or detachment”, in The Italian Experience in the United States Eds TomasiSEngelM (Center for Migration Studies, New York) pp 217–239
7.
ClarkW A V, 1986Human Migration (Sage, Beverly Hills, CA)
8.
EricksonC J, 1990, “Emigration from the British Isles to the USA in 1841: part II: who were the English emigrants?”Population Studies4421–40
9.
FindlayA, 1989, “Arab return migration from the Gulf Cooperation Council States”, WP-43, World Employment Programme (International Labour Office, Geneva)
10.
FindlayA, 1990, “A migration channels approach to the study of high level manpower movements”International Migration2815–24
11.
FindlayALiLJowettJSkeldonRBrownM, 1993, “Emigration of Hong Kong doctors”, DP-93/3, Applied Population Research Unit, University of Glasgow, Glasgow
12.
FoekenD, 1980, “Return migration to a marginal rural area in north-western Ireland”Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geografie71114–120
13.
GlazierI ADe RosaL (Eds), 1986Migration Across Time and Distance. Population Mobility in Historical Context (Holmes and Meier, New York)
14.
HayM J, 1980, “A structural equations model of migration in Tunisia”Economic Development and Cultural Change28345–358
15.
IPM, 1992Emigration from Hong Kong: 1992 Organisational SurveyHong Kong Institute of Personnel Management, 3rd Floor, Hong Kong Jewellery Building, 178–180 Queen's Road Central, Hong Kong
16.
IredaleR, 1990, “New assessment procedures for overseas trained medical practitioners in Australia”, OP-24, Centre for Multicultural Studies, University of Wollongong, Wollongong
17.
JonesH, 1990Population Geography (PCP, London)
18.
KeePSkeldonR, forthcoming, “Hong Kong migration to Australia: the background”, in Reluctant Exiles? Migration from Hong Kong and the New Overseas Chinese Ed. SkeldonR (M E Sharpe, Armont, New York)
19.
KhaleelA, 1986Returning Labour from Abroad and Its Impact on Domestic Labour Markets (Capmas, Cairo)
20.
KingR, 1986, “Return migration and regional economic development”, in Return Migration and Regional Economic Problems Ed. KingR (Croom Helm, And over, Hants) pp 1–37
21.
KritzMCacesF, 1992, “Science and technology transfers and migration flows”, in International Migration Systems Eds KritzeMLinL LZlotnikH (Clarendon Press, Oxford) pp 221–244
22.
KwongP C K, 1990, “Emigration and manpower shortage”, in The Other Hong Kong Report 1990 Eds WongR Y CChengJ Y S (The Chinese University Press, Hong Kong) pp 297–337
23.
LelievreEPaddisonRFindlayABoyleM, 1993, “Toujours en mouvement? L'experience Europeene de la mobilite des competences”, paper presented to the IUSSP Congress, Montreal, August; copy available from the author, Applied Population Research Unit, Department of Geography and Topographic Science, University of Glasgow, Glasgow
24.
LemonA, 1980, “Migrant labour in Western Europe and southern Africa”, in Studies in Overseas Settlement and Population Eds LemonAPollockN (Longman, Harlow, Essex) pp 127–158
25.
MillerK A, 1985Emigrants and Exiles. Ireland and the Exodus to North America (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
26.
MorrisonP, 1973, “Theoretical issues in the design of population mobility models”Environment and Planning5125–134
27.
ParnwellM, 1993Population Movements and the Third World (Routledge, London)
28.
PetrasE, 1981, “The global labour market in the world economy”, in Global Trends in Migration Eds KritzM MKeelyC BTomasiS M (Center for Migration Studies, New York) pp 44–63
29.
ProtheroR MChapmanM (Eds), 1985Circulation in Third World Countries (Routledge and Kegan Paul, London)
30.
SaltJ, 1984, “High level manpower movements in N W Europe and the role of careers”International Migration Review17633–651
31.
SaltJ, 1989, “A comparative overview of international trends and types, 1950–1980”International Migration Review23431–456
32.
SassenS, 1988The Mobility of Labour and Capital (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
33.
SegalG, 1993The Fate of Hong Kong (Simon and Schuster, New York)
34.
SimonJ L, 1989The Economic Consequences of Immigration (Basil Blackwell, Oxford)
35.
SkeldonR, 1990Population Mobility in Developing Countries (Belhaven Press, London)
36.
SkeldonR, 1990/91, “Emigration and the future of Hong Kong”Pacific Affairs63500–523
37.
SkeldonR (Ed.), forthcoming Reluctant Exiles? Migration from Hong Kong and the New Overseas Chinese (M E Sharpe, Armont, NY)
38.
TangS, 1991Hong Kong Emigrants in Canada Overseas SurveyHong Kong Institute of Personnel Management, 3rd Floor, Hong Kong Jewellery Building, 178–180 Queen's Road Central, Hong Kong
39.
WarnesA, 1992, “Migration and the life course”, in Migration Processes and Patterns Eds ChampionA GFieldingA J (Belhaven Press, London) pp 175–187
40.
WoodsR, 1983, “Towards a general theory of migration”, in Contemporary Studies of Migration Eds WhitePVan der KnaapB (Geo Books, Norwich) pp 1–6
