The Spatiotemporal Dynamics of AIDS and TB in the New York Metropolitan Region from a Sociogeographic Perspective: Understanding the Linkages of Central City and Suburbs
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online July, 1995
The Spatiotemporal Dynamics of AIDS and TB in the New York Metropolitan Region from a Sociogeographic Perspective: Understanding the Linkages of Central City and Suburbs
Empirical and theoretical analyses based on observed patterns of incidence of AIDS and tuberculosis, on rates of poverty, and on statistics describing a ‘Markov infection’ driven by the ‘commuting field’ around Manhattan, strongly suggest that urban and suburban epicenters within a twenty-four-county metropolitan region, covering eighteen million people and more than 7600 square miles, may be significantly and increasingly linked to outlying affluent areas through a process driven by fundamental social, geographic, and economic structures. AIDS and TB rates outside the epicenter of New York City are found to display similar patterns of spread in space and time, and have been strongly coupled to rates of infection within it for some time, a circumstance which will continue and may intensify as ‘heterosexual AIDS’ becomes more predominant and as multiple drug-resistant forms of TB evolve within disintegrating inner city minority communities. The work reported here, involving a relatively large area and a high population, strongly contradicts the findings of a recent National Research Council report on the social impact of AIDS, which, based on a severely constrained scale of analysis, concluded that the concentration of disease within marginalized urban communities implies many geographical areas and strata of the population are and will remain untouched by the AIDS epidemic. The hyperconcentration of infection in urban epicenters is not containment, but rather a principal force behind further spread. This work, in part a technology transfer from community ecology of ideas on refugia and reservoirs, adds significantly to a growing body of evidence which strongly implies that wide-spread urban reform is an essential, but largely unrecognized, component for any realistic national programs to control AIDS, multiple-drug-resistant TB, and other infectious diseases.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AblerRAdamsJGouldP, 1971Spatial Organization: The Geographer's View of the World (Prentice-Hall, New York)
2.
AndersonRMayR, 1992, “Understanding the AIDS pandemic”Scientific American May, pp 58–66
3.
AndersonRMayRBoilyMGarnettGRowleyJ, 1991, “The spread of HIV-1 in Africa: Sexual contact patterns and predicted demographic impact of AIDS”Nature (London)352581–589
4.
AryaOReesETurnerC, 1984, “Epidemiology of Pennicillinase producing neisseria gonorrhoeae in Liverpool from 1977 to 1982”Journal of Infectious Diseases870–78
5.
BaileyN T J, 1975The Mathematical Theory of Infectious Diseases (Hafner, New York)
6.
BartholomewD, 1982Stochastic Models for Social Processes (John Wiley, New York)
7.
BrandtA, 1987No Magic Bullet; A Social History of Venereal Disease in the United States Since 1880 (Oxford University Press, New York)
8.
CassettiEFanC, 1991, “The spatial spread of the AIDS epidemic in Ohio: Empirical analyses using the expansion method”Environment and Planning A231589–1596
9.
CataniaJCoatesTStallRTurnerHPetersonJHearstNDolciniMHudesEGagnonJWileyJGrovesR, 1992, “Prevalence of AIDS-related risk factors and condom use in the United States”Science2581101–1106
10.
CliffAHaggettPOrdJVerseyG, 1981Spatial Diffusion: An Historical Geography of Epidemics in an Island Community (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
11.
CowleyG, 1993, “The future of AIDS: New research suggests HIV is not a new virus but an old one”Newsweek 22 March, 47–51
12.
EwaldP, 1991, “Transmission modes and the evolution of virulence with special reference to cholera, influenza and AIDS”Human Nature21–30
13.
EwaldP, 1993, “The evolution of virulence”Scientific American268 (4) 86–93
14.
GardnerLBrundageJBurkeDMcNeilJVisintineRMillerR, 1989, “Spatial diffusion of the human immunodeficiency virus infection epidemic in the United States, 1985–87”Annals of the American Association of Geography7925–34
15.
GouldP, 1991, “Modeling the geographic diffusion of the AIDS epidemic”Science2511022
HawkinsBThomasMHochbergM, 1993, “Refuge theory and biological control”Science2621429–1432
19.
KabelJ, 1992A Geographic Perspective on Aids in the United States: Past, Present and Future PhD thesis, Graduate School, College of Earth and Mineral Sciences, Pennsylvania State University, Philadelphia, PA
20.
KemenyJSnellJ, 1976Finite Markov Chains (Springer-Verlag, New York)
21.
KuLSonensteinFPleckJ, 1993, “Young men's risk behaviors for HIV infection and sexually transmitted diseases, 1988 through 1991”American Journal of Public Health831609–1615
22.
LevinS, 1989, “Ecology in theory and applications”, in Applied Mathematical Ecology Eds LevinSHalamTGrossL (Springer-Verlag, New York)
23.
McCordCFreemanH, 1990, “Excess mortality in Harlem”New England Journal of Medicine322173–179
24.
NievesE, 1992, “For better business, prostitutes leave Manhattan for Jersey City”New York Times Metro Section, 22 September, page B1
25.
NRC, 1993, “The social impact of AIDS in the United States”, The National Academy of Sciences, Washington, DC
26.
PedersenP, 1970, “Innovation diffusion within and between national urban systems”Geographical Analysis2203–254
27.
PielouE C, 1979Biogeography (John Wiley, New York)
28.
PotteratJRothenbergRWoodhouseDMuthJFogleJ, 1985, “Gonorrhea as a social disease”Sexually Transmitted Diseases1225–32
29.
RiceRRobertsPHandsfieldHHolmesK, 1991, “Sociodemographic distribution of gonorrhea incidence: Implications for prevention and behavioral research”American Journal of Public Health811252–1257
30.
RossM, 1990, “Psychovenerology”, in Behavioral Aspects of AIDS Ed. OstrowD (Plenum, New York) pp 19–39
31.
RothenbergR, 1983, “The geography of gonorrhea: Empirical demonstration of core group transmission”American Journal of Epidemiology117688–693
32.
RothenbergR, 1991, “Those other STDs”American Journal of Public Health811250–1251
33.
RothenbergRPotteratJ, 1988, “Temporal and social aspects of gonorrhea transmission: The force of infectivity”Sexually Transmitted Disease1588–95
34.
Smallman-RaynorMCliffA, 1991, “Civil war and the spread of AIDS in Central Africa”Epidemiology and Infection10769–79
35.
Smallman-RaynorMCliffAHaggettP, 1992London International Atlas of AIDS (Basil Blackwell, London)
36.
WallaceD, 1994a, “The resurgence of tuberculosis in New York City: A mixed hierarchically-and spatially-diffusing epidemic”American Journal of Public Health841000–1002
37.
WallaceD, 1994b, “Housing destruction, poverty and the New York City tuberculosis epidemic”, submitted; copy available from the author
38.
WallaceR, 1988, “A synergism of plagues: ‘planned shrinkage’, contagious housing destruction and AIDS in the Bronx”Environmental Research471–33
39.
WallaceR, 1990, “Urban desertification, public health and public order: ‘planned shrinkage’, violent death, substance abuse and AIDS in the Bronx”Social Science and Medicine31801–813
40.
WallaceR, 1991a, “Expanding coupled shock fronts of urban decay and criminal behavior: How US cities are becoming ‘hollowed out’”Journal of Quantitative Criminology7333–347
41.
WallaceR, 1991b, “Traveling waves of HIV infection in a low dimensional ‘socio-geographic’ network”Social Science and Medicine32847–853
42.
WallaceR, 1991c, “Social disintegration and the spread of AIDS: Thresholds for propagation along sociogeographic networks”Social Science and Medicine331155–1164
43.
WallaceR, 1993a, “A fractal model of HIV transmission on complex sociogeographic networks: Towards analysis of large data sets”Environment and Planning A25137–145
44.
WallaceR, 1993b, “Social disintegration and the spread of AIDS II: Meltdown of sociographic structure in urban minority neighborhoods”Social Science and Medicine37887–896
45.
WallaceRFulliloveM, 1991, “AIDS deaths in the Bronx 1983–1988: Spatiotemporal analysis from a sociogeographic perspective”Environment and Planning A231701–1720
46.
WallaceRFulliloveMWallaceD, 1992, “Family systems and de-urbanization: Implications for substance abuse”, in Substance Abuse, A Comprehensive Textbook Eds LowinsonJRuizPMillmanR (Williams and Wilkins, Baltimore, MD) pp 944–955
47.
WallaceRPittmanJ, 1992Recurrence of Contagious Urban Desertification and the Social Thanatology of New York City to appear
48.
WallaceRWallaceD, 1990, “Origins of public health collapse in New York City: The dynamics of planned shrinkage, contagious urban decay and social disintegration”Bulletin of the New York Academy of Medicine66391–443
49.
WallaceRWallaceD, 1991, “Contagious urban decay and the collapse of public health”Health/PAC Bulletin13 (Summer) 8–16
50.
WallaceRWallaceD, 1993a, “Inner-city disease and the public health of the suburbs: The sociogeographic dispersion of point-source infection”Environment and Planning A251707–1723
51.
WallaceRWallaceD, 1993b, “The coming crisis of public health in the suburbs”Milbank Quarterly71543–563
52.
YoonC, 1993, “What might cause parasites to become more virulent”Science2591402
53.
YorkeJHethcoteH, 1978, “Dynamics and control of the transmission of gonorrhea”Sexually Transmitted Disease551–56
54.
YoumansG, 1979Tuberculosis (W B Saunders, Philadelphia, PA)
55.
ZenilmanJBonnerMSharpKRabbJAlexanderE, 1988, “Penicillinase-producing neisseria gonorrhoeae in Dade County, Florida: Evidence of core group transmission and the impact of illicit antibiotics”Sexually Transmitted Diseases1845–56
56.
ZimmermanH LPotteratJ JDukesR LMuthJ BZimmermanH PFogleJ SPrattsC I, 1990, “Epidemiologic differences between chlamydia and gonorrhea”American Journal of Public Health801338–1342
