Sweden's research-intensive electronics industries have thrived by developing export-market niches that rely greatly on continuous innovation and substantial expenditures in R&D. Over the past two decades, three R&D-intensive sectors (telecommunications equipment, electronic instruments, and computing-equipment manufacturing) have experienced a progressive territorial distribution, that has made them less reliant on the metropolitan concentration of the capital for their outsourcing and research arrangements. In this article we explore the relationship between R&D intensity, territorial distribution, subcontracting, and establishment performance in the R&D-intensive electronics industries. The export performance of these industries is considered first, along with its relationship with employment characteristics and territorial location. An analysis of the territorial distribution, and its relationship with establishment downsizing and subcontracting, provides insights on the significance of lower costs and higher R&D intensity for small-scale operations. Statistical analyses of R&D intensity and performance variables that include labour skills, plant size, production costs, fixed capital assets, and profitability, with establishment-level survey data, provide important insights on the effects of subcontracting and any spatial differences resulting thereof.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AcsZ JAudretschD B, 1991, “R&D, firm size, and innovative activity”, in Innovation and Technological Change: An International Comparison Eds AcsZ JAudretschD B (Harvester Wheatsheaf, New York) pp 39–59
2.
AllenR C, 1983, “Collective invention”Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization41–24
3.
AlterCHageJ, 1992Organizations Working Together: Coordination in Interorganizational Networks (Sage, Newbury Park, CA)
4.
AmsdenA J, 1990Asia's Next Giant (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
5.
AnderssonA EAnderstigCHårsmanB, 1990, “Knowledge and communications infrastructure and regional economic change”Regional Science and Urban Economics20359–376
6.
AnderssonA EBattenD FKarlssonC (Eds), 1989Knowledge and Industrial Organization (Springer, Berlin)
7.
AxelrodR, 1984The Evolution of Cooperation (Basic Books, New York)
AydalotP, 1984, “Reversals of spatial trends in French industry since 1974”, in New Spatial Dynamics and Economic Crisis Ed. LambooyJ G (Finnpublishers, Tampere, Finland) pp 41–63
10.
BadaraccoJ, 1991The Knowledge Link: How Firms Compete Through Strategic Alliances (Harvard Business School Press, Cambridge, MA)
11.
BadeF-JKunzmannK R, 1991, “Deindustrialization and regional development in the Federal Republic of Germany”, in Industrial Change and Regional Economic Transformation: The Experience of Western Europe Eds RodwinLSazanamiH (Harper Collins Academic, London) pp 70–104
12.
BeckoucheP, 1991, “French high tech and space: A double cleavage”, in Industrial Change and Regional Development: The Transformation of New Industrial Spaces Eds BenkoGDunfordM (Belhaven Press, London) pp 205–225
13.
BengtssonT (Ed.), 1994Population, Economy, and Welfare in Sweden (Springer, Berlin)
14.
BojeT POlsson-HortS E (Eds), 1993Scandinavia in a New Europe (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
15.
BosworthB PRivlinA M (Eds), 1987The Swedish Economy (Brookings Institution, Washington, DC)
16.
BosworthD LJacobsDLewisJ A, 1990New Technologies, Shared Facilities and the Innovatory Firm (Avebury, Aldershot, Hants)
17.
BraunEMacDonaldS, 1982Revolution in Miniature: The History and Impact of Semiconductor Electronics (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
18.
BraunerhjelmP, 1991Svenska underleverantörer och småföretag i det nya Europa: Struktur, kompetens och internationaliseringIndustriens Utredningsinstitut, Storgatan 19, Box 5501, 11451 Stockholm
19.
BruscoS, 1982, “The Emilian model: Productive decentralization and social integration”Cambridge Journal of Economics6167–184
20.
CarlssonB, 1989, “The evolution of manufacturing technology and its impact on industrial structure: An international study”Small Business Economics121–37
21.
CarlssonB, 1992, “The rise of small business: Causes and consequences”, in Singular Europe: Economy and Polity of the European Community After 1992 Ed. AdamsW J (University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor, MI) pp 145–170
22.
CheshireP C, 1991, “Problems of regional transformation and deindustrialization in the European Community”, in Industrial Change and Regional Economic Transformation: The Experience of Western Europe Eds RodwinLSazanamiH (Harper Collins Academic, London) pp 237–267
23.
ClarkK, 1989, “Project scope and project performance: The effect of parts strategy and supplier involvement on product development”Management Science351247–1262
24.
CoaseR, 1937, “The nature of the firm”Economica4386–405
25.
CohenW MKlepperS, 1992, “The anatomy of industry R&D intensity distributions”American Economic Review82773–799
26.
ColeR E, 1989Strategies for Learning: Small Group Activities in American, Japanese and Swedish Industry (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
27.
DalumBFagerbergJJørgensenU, 1988, “Small open economies in the world market for electronics: The case of the Nordic countries”, in Small Countries Facing the Technological Revolution Eds FreemanCLundvallB-Å (Frances Pinter, London) pp 113–138
28.
DavelaarE JNijkampP, 1989, “The role of metropolitan milieu as an incubation centre for innovations: A Dutch case study”Urban Studies26517–525
29.
DoughertyD C, 1989Strategic Organization Planning: Downsizing for Survival (Quorum Books, New York)
30.
EisenhardtK MSchoonhovenC B, 1990, “Organizational growth: Linking founding team, strategy, environment, and growth among US semiconductor ventures, 1978–1988”Administrative Science Quarterly35504–529
31.
ElamMBörjesonM, 1991, “Workplace reform and the stabilization of flexible production in Sweden”, in The Politics of Flexibility: Restructuring State and Industry in Britain, Germany and Scandinavia Eds JessopBKastendiekHNielsenKPedersenO K (Edward Elgar, Aldershot, Hants) pp 314–336
32.
EliassonGFölsterSLindbergTPousetteTTayinazE, 1990The Knowledge-based Information Economy (Almqvist and Wiksell, Stockholm)
33.
FarrellJ, 1987, “Information and the Coase theorem”Journal of Economic Perspectives1113–129
34.
FischerM MNijkampP, 1988, “The role of small firms in regional revitalization”Annals of Regional Science1228–42
35.
ForsgrenM, 1989Managing the Internationalisation Process: The Swedish Case (Routledge, London)
36.
FournierS FAxelssonS, 1993, “The shift from manufacturing to services in Sweden”Urban Studies30285–298
37.
FritschM, 1992, “Regional differences in new firm formation: Evidence from West Germany”Regional Studies26233–242
38.
GarofoliG, 1991, “The Italian model of spatial development in the 1970s and 1980s”, in Industrial Change and Regional Development: The Transformation of New Industrial Spaces Eds BenkoGDunfordM (Belhaven Press, London) pp 85–101
39.
GrabherG (Ed.), 1993The Embedded Firm: On the Socio-economics of Industrial Networks (Routledge, London)
40.
GranstrandOSigurdsonJ (Eds), 1985Technological Innovation and Industrial Development in Telecommunications: The Role of Public Buying in the Telecommunication Sector in the Nordic Countries (Nordforsk, Stockholm)
41.
HadeniusA, 1986A Crisis of the Welfare State? Opinions About Taxes and Public Expenditure in Sweden (Almqvist and Wiksell, Stockholm)
42.
HagedoornJ, 1993, “Understanding the rationale of strategic technology partnering: Interorganizational modes of cooperation and sectoral differences”Strategic Management Journal14371–385
43.
HagströmP, 1987, “Linking new information systems to corporate strategy and structure: The SKF experience”, RP-87-11, Institute of International Business at the Stockholm School of Economics, Box 6501, 11383 Stockholm
44.
HåkansonL, 1990, “International decentralization of R&D: The organizational challenges”, in Managing the Global Firm Eds BartlettC ADozYHedlundG (Routledge, London) pp 256–278
45.
HåkansonLDanielsonL, 1985, “Structural adjustment in a stagnating economy: Regional manufacturing employment in Sweden, 1975–1980”Regional Studies19329–342
46.
HåkansonLNobelR, 1989, “Overseas research and development in Swedish multinationals”, RP-89-3, Institute of International Business at the Stockholm School of Economics, Box 6501, 11383 Stockholm
47.
HåkansonLZanderU, 1988, “International management of R&D: The Swedish experience”R&D Management18217–226
HåkanssonH, 1989Corporate Technological Behaviour: Co-operation and Networks (Routledge, London)
50.
HansenN M, 1990, “Innovative regional milieux, small firms, and regional development: Evidence from Mediterranean France”Annals of Regional Science24107–123
51.
HansenN M, 1991, “Factories in Danish fields: How high-wage, flexible production has succeeded in peripheral Jutland”International Regional Science Review14109–132
52.
HansenN M, 1992, “Competition, trust, and reciprocity in the development of innovative regional milieux”Papers in Regional Science7195–106
53.
HargraveA, 1985Silicon Glen: Reality or Illusion? (Mainstream, Edinburgh)
54.
HellgrenBMelinL, 1991, “Corporate strategies in Nordic firms facing Europe: Acquisitions and other collaborative strategies”, in Corporate and Industry Strategies for Europe: Adaptations to the Single Market in a Global Industrial Environment Eds MattssonL-GStymneB (North-Holland, Amsterdam) pp 327–352
55.
HendersonJ, 1991The Globalisation of High Technology Production: Society, Space and Semiconductors in the Restructuring of the Modern World (Routledge, London)
56.
HounshellD ASmithJ K, 1988Science and Corporate Strategy (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
57.
HowellsJ R L, 1984, “The location of research and development: Some observations and evidence from Britain”Regional Studies1813–29
58.
IllerisS, 1986, “New firm creation in Denmark: The importance of the cultural background”, in New Firms and Regional Development in Europe Eds KeebleDWeverE (Croom Helm, London) pp 141–150
59.
ImrieR F, 1986, “Work decentralization from large to small firms: A preliminary analysis of subcontracting”Environment and Planning A18949–966
60.
JohannissonBGustavssonB Å, 1984, “Småföretagande på småort: Nätverksstrategier i informationssamhället”, Centre for Small-scale Enterprises at Växjö University College, Växjö
61.
JohansenL NKolbergJ E, 1985, “Welfare state regression in Scandinavia? The development of the Scandinavian welfare states from 1970 to 1980”, in The Welfare State and Its Aftermath Eds EisenstadtS NAhimeirO (Croom Helm, London) pp 143–176
62.
JohanssonB, 1988The Future Labour Market: Dynamic Competition and RegionsCouncil of Job Security, Swedish Employers' Association, Södra Blasieholmen 4A, 10330 Stockholm
63.
JohanssonBKarlssonC, 1986, “Industrial applications of information technology: Speed of introduction and labour force competence”, in Technological Change, Employment and Spatial Dynamics Ed. NijkampP (Springer, Berlin) pp 401–428
64.
JohanssonBKarlssonC, 1987, “Processes of industrial change: Scale, location and type of job”, in Regional Labour Markets Eds FischerM MNijkampP (North-Holland, Amsterdam) pp 139–165
65.
JohanssonBStrömqvistU, 1988Technology Diffusion and Import Substitution: The Role of the Stockholm Region in Technical ChangeOffice of Regional Planning and Urban Transportation, Stockholm County Council, Box 1111, 10269 Stockholm
66.
KaplinskyR, 1987Microelectronics and Employment Revisited: A Review (International Labour Organisation, Geneva)
67.
KarlssonC, 1988aInnovation Adoption and the Product Life CycleDepartment of Economics, University of Umeå, Umeå
68.
KarlssonC, 1988b, “The role of small and medium-sized manufacturing plants in regional employment: A Swedish perspective”, in Small and Medium Size Enterprises and Regional Development Eds GiaoutziMNijkampPStoreyD J (Routledge, London) pp 181–199
69.
KarlssonCLarssonJ, 1989, “Product and price competition: A characterization”, CERUM WP-1989-3, Department of Economics, University of Umeå, Umeå
70.
KarlssonCLarssonJ, 1990, “Product and price competition in a regional context”Papers of the Regional Science Association6983–99
71.
KarlssonCLarssonJ, 1993, “A macro-view of the Gnosjö entrepreneurial spirit”Entrepreneurship and Regional Development5117–140
72.
KatzensteinP J, 1985Small States in World Markets (Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY)
73.
KeebleDOwensP LThompsonC, 1983, “The urban—rural manufacturing shift in the European Community”Urban Studies20405–418
74.
KelleyM RBrooksH, 1991, “External learning opportunities and the diffusion of process innovations to small firms: The case of programmable automation”Technological Forecasting and Social Change39103–125
75.
KleinknechtAPootT P, 1992, “Do regions matter for R&D?”Regional Studies26221–232
76.
KleinknechtAPootT PReijnenJ O N, 1991, “Formal and informal R&D and firm size”, in Innovation and Technological Change: An International Comparison Eds AcsZ JAudretschD B (Harvester Wheatsheaf, New York) pp 94–108
77.
KrätkeS, 1991, “Cities in transformation: The case of West Germany”, in Industrial Change and Regional Development: The Transformation of New Industrial Spaces Eds BenkoGDunfordM (Belhaven Press, London) pp 250–272
78.
KrugmanP, 1991Geography and Trade (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)
79.
LarssonS, 1990Elektronikindustri och rumslig arbetsdelningDepartment of Economic and Social Geography, Uppsala University, Uppsala
80.
LarssonSLundmarkM, 1991Kista: Företag i nätverk eller statusadress?Department of Economic and Social Geography, Uppsala University, Uppsala
81.
SmithLawton H, 1991, “Advanced technology industry in Oxfordshire: Location of markets and competitors”Urban Studies28205–218
82.
LecoqBMaillatD, 1990, “La dynamique régionale en Mediterranée: Une approche en termes de milieu”Revue d'Economie Régionale et Urbaine4543–557
83.
LeusE B H MPellenbargP H, 1991, “Production subcontracting in the Netherlands: A survey of developments”, in Complexes, Formations and Networks Eds de SmidtMWeverE, Netherlands Geographical Studies 132, Faculty of Geographical Sciences, University of Utrecht, Utrecht, pages 103–110
84.
LindbeckAMolanderPPerssonTPeterssonOSandmoASwedenborgBThygesenN, 1994Turning Sweden Around (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)
85.
LorangePRoosJ (Eds), 1987The Challenge of Cooperative VenturesInstitute of International Business, Stockholm School of Economics, Stockholm
86.
LorangePRoosJ, 1991, “Why some strategic alliances succeed and others fail”Journal of Business Strategy1225–30
87.
LorenzE, 1988, “Neither friends nor strangers: Informal networks of subcontracting in French industry”, in Trust: Making and Breaking Co-operative Relations Ed. GambettaD (Basil Blackwell, Oxford) pp 194–210
88.
LundbergE, 1985, “The rise and fall of the Swedish model”Journal of Economic Literature231–36
89.
LundqvistLPerssonL O (Eds), 1993Visions and Strategies in European Integration: A North European Perspective (Springer, Berlin)
90.
LundvallB-Å, 1985Product Innovation and User—Producer Interaction (Aalborg University Press, Aalborg)
91.
MaleckiE J, 1991Technology and Economic Development (John Wiley, New York)
92.
MartinR, 1990, “Flexible futures and post-Fordist places”Environment and Planning A221276–1280
93.
MathiasPDavisJ A (Eds), 1991Innovation and Technology in Europe: From the Eighteenth Century to the Present (Blackwell, Oxford)
94.
MattssonL-G, 1987, “Management of strategic change in a ‘markets-as-networks’ perspective”, in The Management of Strategic Change Ed. PettigrewA (Basil Blackwell, Oxford) pp 234–256
95.
MilesI, 1988Home Informatics: Information Technology and the Transformation of Everyday Life (Frances Pinter, London)
96.
MilneS, 1990, “New forms of manufacturing and their spatial implications: The UK electronic consumer goods industry”Environment and Planning A22211–232
97.
MohnenPNadiriM IPruchaI, 1986, “R&D, production structure, and rates of return in the US, Japanese and German manufacturing sectors”European Economic Review30749–771
98.
MolleWKlaassenL H, 1985Industrial Mobility and Migration in the European Community (Gower, Aldershot, Hants)
99.
MønstedM, 1987, “Flexibility and growth in small manufacturing enterprises: The case of Denmark”, Institute for Industrial Research and Social Development at the Copenhagen School of Economics and Social Science, Copenhagen
100.
MooreBTylerPElliottD, 1991, “The influence of regional development incentives and infrastructure on the location of small and medium-sized companies in Europe”Urban Studies281001–1026
101.
MoweryD C, 1983, “Industrial research and firm size, survival, and growth in American manufacturing, 1921–46: An assessment”Journal of Economic History43953–980
102.
NoamE, 1992Telecommunications in Europe (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
103.
NordhaugO, 1993Human Capital in Organizations: Competence, Training, and Learning (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
104.
NordströmK A, 1991The Internationalization Process of the Firm in a New PerspectiveInstitute of International Business, Stockholm School of Economics, Stockholm
105.
OakeyR PThwaitesA TNashP A, 1980, “The regional distribution of innovative manufacturing establishments in Britain”Regional Studies14235–253
106.
OECD, 1992Competing in the Electronics Industry: The Experience of Newly Industrialising Economies (Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, Washington, DC)
107.
O'FarrellP NMoffatL A RHitchensD M W N, 1993, “Manufacturing demand for business services in a core and peripheral region: Does flexible production imply vertical disintegration of business services?”Regional Studies27385–400
108.
OhlssonL, 1991, “Comparative advantage strategies for Swedish industry facing the 1990s”, in Corporate and Industry Strategies for Europe: Adaptations to the Single Market in a Global Industrial Environment Eds MattssonL-GStymneB (North-Holland, Amsterdam) pp 75–96
109.
PakesASchankermanM, 1984, “An exploration into the determinants of research intensity”, in R&D, Patents and Productivity Ed. GrilichesZ (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL) pp 209–232
110.
ParkheA, 1993, “Strategic alliance structuring: A game theoretic and transaction cost examination of interfirm cooperation”Academy of Management Journal36794–829
111.
PatelPPavittK, 1987, “Is Western Europe losing the technological race?”Research Policy1659–85
112.
PavittKRobsonMTownsendJ, 1987, “The size distribution of innovative firms in the UK: 1945–1983”Journal of Industrial Economics35291–316
113.
PedersenP O, 1989The Role of Small Enterprises and Small Towns in the Developing Countries—and in the DevelopedCentre for Development Research, Ny Kongensgade 9, DK-1472 Copenhagen
114.
PhelpsN A, 1993, “Branch plants and the evolving spatial division of labour: A study of material linkage change in the Northern region of England”Regional Studies2787–101
115.
PornschlegelH (Ed.), 1992Research and Development in Work and Technology (Springer, Berlin)
116.
PorterM E, 1990The Competitive Advantage of Nations (The Free Press, New York)
117.
PowellW W, 1990, “Neither market nor hierarchy: Network forms of organization”Research in Organization Behavior12295–336
118.
PrattenC, 1991The Competitiveness of Small Firms (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
119.
RingPvan de VenA, 1992, “Structuring cooperative relationships between organizations”Strategic Management Journal13483–498
120.
QuévitM, 1992, “The regional impact of the internal market: A comparative analysis of traditional industrial regions and lagging regions”Regional Studies26349–360
121.
SandbergÅBromsGGripASteenJSundströmLUllmarkP, 1992Technological Change and Co-determination in Sweden (Temple University Press, Philadelphia, PA)
122.
SandholtzW, 1992High Tech Europe: The Politics of International Cooperation (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
123.
SchererF M, 1992International High Technology Competition (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
SegersJ P, 1993, “Strategic partnering between new technology-based firms and large established firms in the biotechnology and micro-electronics industries in Belgium”Small Business Economics5271–281
126.
SengenbergerWLovemanG WPioreM J (Eds), 1990The Re-emergence of Small Enterprises: Industrial Restructuring in Industrialised Countries (International Institute for Labour Studies, Geneva)
127.
SilverbergGSoeteL (Eds), 1994The Economics of Growth and Technical Change: Technologies, Nations, Agents (Edward Elgar, Brookfield, VT)
128.
SnickarsF, 1991, “Regional perspectives on the deindustrialization of Sweden”, in Industrial Change and Regional Economic Transformation: The Experience of Western Europe Eds RodwinLSazanamiH (Harper Collins Academic, London) pp 202–233
129.
SoeteLDosiG, 1983Technology and Employment in the Electronics Industry (Frances Pinter, London)
130.
SoeteLvon TunzelmannN, 1987Convergence of Technologies and the European Market for Telecommunications Equipment (Brookings Institution, Washington, DC)
131.
SölvellÖZanderIPorterM E, 1991Advantage Sweden (Norstedts, Stockholm)
132.
Statistiska Centralbyrån, 1972–92Data och-elektronikindustrin i SverigeStatistiska Centralbyrån, Karlavägen 100, 11581 Stockholm
133.
Suarez-VillaL, 1991, “The evolution of regional economies: Sectoral restructuring and regional development over the long term”, in Regional Science: Retrospect and Prospect Eds BoyceD ENijkampPSheferD (Springer, Berlin) pp 279–316
134.
Suarez-VillaL, 1993, “The dynamics of regional invention and innovation: Innovative capacity and regional change in the twentieth century”Geographical Analysis25147–164
135.
Suarez-VillaLRouraCuadrado J R, 1993, “Thirty years of Spanish regional change: Interregional dynamics and sectoral transformation”International Regional Science Review15121–156
136.
Suarez-VillaLFischerM M, 1995, “Technology, organization and export-driven R&D in Austria's electronics industry”Regional Studies2919–42
137.
Suarez-VillaLHanP-H, 1990a, “The rise of Korea's electronics industry: Technological change, growth, and territorial distribution”Economic Geography66273–292
138.
Suarez-VillaLHanP-H, 1990b, “International trends in electronics manufacturing and the strategy of industrialization”Rivista Internazionale di Scienze Economiche e Commerciali37381–407
139.
Suarez-VillaLHanP-H, 1991, “Organizations, space and capital in the development of Korea's electronics industry”Regional Studies25327–343
140.
Suarez-VillaLHasnathS A, 1993, “The effect of infrastructure on invention: Innovative capacity and the dynamics of public construction investment”Technological Forecasting and Social Change44333–358
141.
SusmanG I (Ed.), 1992Integrating Design and Manufacturing for Competitive Advantage (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
142.
SwannG M P, 1986Quality Innovation: An Economic Analysis of Rapid Improvements in Microelectronic Components (Frances Pinter, London)
143.
SwedenborgB, 1979The Multinational Operations of Swedish Firms: An Analysis of Determinants and Effects (Almqvist and Wiksell, Stockholm)
144.
ThoburnJ TTakashimaM, 1992Industrial Subcontracting in the UK and Japan (Avebury, Aldershot, Hants)
145.
TiltonT, 1990The Political Theory of Swedish Social Democracy (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
146.
ToddD, 1989The World Electronics Industry (Routledge, London)
147.
TörnqvistG, 1970, “Contact systems and regional development”, Lund Studies in Geography series B 35, Department of Geography, University of Lund, Lund
148.
TörnqvistG, 1978, “Swedish industry as a spatial system”, in Contemporary Industrialization: Spatial Analysis and Regional Development Ed. HamiltonF E I (Longman, Harlow, Essex) pp 86–109
149.
TörnqvistG (Ed.), 1986The Swedish Economy in a Geographical Perspective (Liber Förlag, Stockholm)
150.
TurokI, 1993a, “Inward investment and local linkages: How deeply embedded is ‘Silicon Glen’?”Regional Studies27401–417
151.
TurokI, 1993b, “Contrasts in ownership and development: Local versus global in Silicon Glen”Urban Studies30365–386
152.
VahlneJ-EHörnellE, 1986Multinationals: The Swedish Case (Croom Helm, London)
153.
von HippelE, 1976, “The dominant role of users in the scientific instruments innovation process”Research Policy5212–239
154.
von HippelE, 1988The Sources of Innovation (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
