Sharecropping is neglected in the analysis of land use and rural change in modern western economies. Notwithstanding the Marxist classification of sharecropping as a form of wage labor, it is conceptualized in this paper as simple commodity production, based on the unity of household and enterprise. The organization of sharecropping is examined with the use of this conceptualization, although the review incorporates economic and other perspectives. Sharemilking in New Zealand is used to evaluate this framework at two scales, on representative dairy farms of average size and on large dairy farms owned by corporations. It is found to be a mutually beneficial relationship that promotes efficient production and high output. It also facilitates intergenerational transfer, provides a rung on the dairying ladder, and contributes to the reproduction of family-based dairying in New Zealand. Sharemilking is also the preferred means for recent corporate entrants to the industry to operate their large dairy farms. Currently, sharemilking is playing a role in the penetration of agriculture by capital.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AstonTPhilpinC (Eds), 1985The Brenner Debate (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
2.
BardhamPSrinivisanT, 1971, “Cropsharing tenancy in agriculture: a theoretical and empirical analysis”American Economic Review4148–64
3.
BarlowRTimmonsJ, 1950, “What has happened to the agricultural ladder?”Journal of Farm Economics3230–47
4.
BellC, 1977, “Alternative theories of sharecropping: some tests using evidence from Northeast India”Journal of Development Studies13317–346
BlundenG, 1995Work Relations and Forms of Production in New Zealand Agriculture unpublished PhD thesis, Department of Geography, University of Auckland, Auckland
7.
BradlyA, 1992Sharemilking unpublished Masters thesis, Department of Geography, University of Auckland, Auckland
ByresT J, 1983, “Historical perspectives on sharecropping”Journal of Peasant Studies10(2/3) 7–40
10.
CaballeroJ, 1983, “Sharecropping as an efficient system: further answers to an old puzzle”Journal of Peasant Studies10107–119
11.
CheungS N S, 1968, “Private property rights and sharecropping”Journal of Political Economy761107–1122
12.
CheungS N S, 1969The Theory of Share Tenancy (Chicago University Press, Chicago, IL)
13.
ChevalierJ, 1983, “There is nothing simple about simple commodity production”Journal of Peasant Studies10154–186
14.
Department of Statistics, 1986New Zealand Census of Population and Dwellings, Labour Force—Part 2 Series C, report 5 (Department of Statistics, Wellington)
15.
Department of Statistics, various years Agricultural Statistics (Department of Statistics, Wellington)
16.
FriedmannH, 1978a, “Simple commodity production and wage labour on the American plains”Journal of Peasant Studies671–100
17.
FriedmannH, 1978b, “World market, state, and family farm: social bases of household production in the era of wage labour”Journal of Comparative Studies20545–586
18.
FriedmannH, 1980, “Household production and the national economy: concepts for the analysis of agrarian formations”Journal of Peasant Studies7158–184
19.
FujimotoA, 1983Income Sharing Among Malay Peasants: A Study of Land Tenure and Rice Production (Singapore University Press, Singapore)
20.
GilbertJAkorR, 1988, “Increasing structural divergence in U.S. dairying: California and Wisconsin since 1950”Rural Sociology5356–72
21.
GoodmanDRedcliftM, 1985, “Capitalism, petty commodity production and the farm enterprise”Sociologia Ruralis25231–247
22.
GoodmanDSorjBWilkinsonJ, 1987From Farming to Biotechnology: A Theory of Agro-industrial Development (Basil Blackwell, Oxford)
23.
GossKRodefeldRButtelF, 1980, “The political economy of class structure in U.S. agriculture: a theoretical outline”, in The Rural Sociology of Advanced Societies Eds ButtelFNewbyH (Allanheld, Osmun, Montclair, CA) pp 83–132
24.
GrantW, 1991The Dairy Industry: An International Comparison (Dartmouth, Aldershot, Hants)
25.
GreenwoodJ, 1990, The Inter generational Transfer of Family Farms unpublished Masters thesis, Department of Geography, University of Auckland, Auckland
26.
GreganP, 1983Sharemilking in the Northland Dairy IndustryDepartment of Geography, University of Auckland, Auckland
27.
HamburgerT, 1978, “Sharecroppers, once backbone of state, now almost extinct”, in Change in Rural America: Causes, Consequences and Alternatives Eds RodefeldRFloraJVothDFujimotoIConverseJ (Mosby, Saint Louis, MO) pp 142–144
28.
HiggsH, 1894, “‘Métayage’ in western France”The Economic Journal41–13
29.
HsiaoJ C, 1975, “The theory of share tenancy revisited”Journal of Political Economy831023–1032
30.
JohnsonD, 1950, “Resource allocation under share contracts”Journal of Political Economy58111–123
31.
KloppenburgJGeislerC, 1985, “The agricultural ladder: agrarian ideology and the changing structure of U.S. agriculture”Journal of Rural Studies159–72
32.
LemW, 1988, “Household production and reproduction in rural Languedoc: social relations of petty commodity production in Murviel-lès-Béziers”Journal of Peasant Studies15500–529
33.
LIC, 1985–95Dairy StatisticsLivestock Improvement Corporation, Private Bag 3016, Hamilton
34.
LoweG, 1985Entry into Dairying in Waipa County unpublished Masters thesis, Department of Geography, University of Auckland, Auckland
35.
LoveridgeA, 1991Class and Occupational Mobility Among Farm Employees unpublished PhD thesis, Department of Sociology, University of Auckland, Auckland
36.
LysonTGeislerC, 1990, “Towards a second industrial divide: the restructuring of American agriculture”, DP, Department of Rural Sociology, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY
37.
MannS, 1990Agrarian Capitalism in Theory and Practice (University of North Carolina Press, Chapel Hill, NC)
38.
MannS ADickinsonJ M, 1978, “Obstacles to the development of a capitalist agriculture”Journal of Peasant Studies5466–481
39.
MarshallA, 1961Principles of Economics (Macmillan, London)
40.
Martinez-AlierJ, 1971Labourers and Landowners in Southern Spain (Allen and Unwin, London)
41.
MaughanCLoweKRidlerB, 1980, “Sharemilking: a position paper 1980”, Technical Discussion paper No. 16, Palmerston North, Department of Agricultural Economics and Farm Management, Massey University, Palmerston North
42.
MooneyH P, 1986, “The political economy of credit in American agriculture”Rural Sociology51449–470
43.
MooneyH P, 1988My Own Boss: Class, Rationality, and the Family Farm (Westview Press, Boulder, CO)
44.
MoranWBlundenGGreenwoodJ, 1993, “The role of family farming in agrarian change”Progress in Human Geography1722–42
45.
NewberyD, 1977, “Risk sharing, sharecropping and uncertain labour markets”Review of Economic Studies4585–594
46.
NZDB, 198358th Farm Production ReportFarm Production Division, New Zealand Dairy Board, Pastoral House, 25 The Terrace, PO Box 417, Wellington
47.
New Zealand Dairy Exporter1990a, “New sharemilking contracts under new order” March, page 25
48.
New Zealand Dairy Exporter1990b, “Sharemilking's most radical lower order change in 50 years” April, pages 37–41
49.
New Zealand Government, 1937Sharemilking Agreements Act (Government Printer, Wellington)
50.
New Zealand Government, 1989An Act to Amend the Sharemilking Agreements Act 1937 (Government Printer, Wellington)
51.
New Zealand Government, 1991Local Government Act 1991 (New Zealand Government, Wellington)
52.
New Zealand Government, 1992Local Government Amendment Act 1992 (New Zealand Government, Wellington)
53.
OvertonJ, 1989, Land and Differentiation in Rural Fiji (National Centre for Development Studies, Australian National University, Canberra)
54.
OvertonJ, 1994Sharecropping and Sharefarming: Widening the Perspective Proceedings of the Inaugural Conference of the New Zealand Geographical Society and the Institute of Australian Geographers, University of Auckland, January 1992
55.
PearceR, 1983, “Sharecropping: towards a Marxist view”Journal of Peasant Studies10(2/3) pp 42–70
56.
ReidJ, 1973, “Sharecropping as an understandable market response: the Post-Bellum South”The Journal of Economic History33106–130
57.
ReidJ, 1976, “Sharecropping and agricultural uncertainty”Economic Development and Cultural Change24549–576
RobertsonA, 1987The Dynamics of Productive Relationships: African Share Contracts in Comparative Perspective (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
61.
SmithR, 1965Sharemilking in New Zealand: a Geographic Appraisal unpublished Masters thesis, Department of Geography, University of Auckland, Auckland
62.
SpillmanW, 1919, “The agricultural ladder”American Economic Review9170–179
63.
StiglitzJ, 1974, “Incentives and risk sharing in agriculture”Review of Economic Studies41219–255
64.
Tasman Agriculture Limited, 1992Tasman Agriculture Limited Presentation to the New Zealand Society of Investment Analysts unpublished document Tasman Agriculture Limited, Level 10, Otago House, PO Box 1378, Dunedin
65.
WellsM, 1984, “The resurgence of sharecropping: historical anomaly or political strategy?”American Journal of Sociology901–29
66.
WehrweinC F, 1958, “An analysis of agricultural ladder research”Land Economics34329–337
