The author examines the contributions of linguistic analysis and rational choice analysis to understanding the urban policy process, with the aid of the issue of air-quality management and a specific case study of metropolitan London. She argues that these theories can complement each other in providing empirically grounded analyses at the urban level. By means of the rational choice approach, she considers the choice situation facing local and central government in dealing with urban air pollution. However, forestalling some central criticisms made of the rational choice approach, she also considers the way in which the problem of urban air quality is constructed and the rhetorical structure of the policy solutions that can be discussed. It is shown how the constrained-choice situation of key policy actors meshes with the construction of the problem as one of urban air-quality management and the preferred policy solution of enhanced monitoring. This is characterised as diversionary and symbolic policy action which devolves much policy responsibility to the level of the individual—a potentially contradictory strategy for government.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbellP, 1992, “Is rational choice theory a rational choice of theory?”, in Rational Choice Theory: Advocacy and Critique Eds ColemanJSFararoTJ, (Sage, London) pp 183–206
2.
BohmanJ, 1992, “The limits of rational choice explanation”, in Rational Choice Theory: Advocacy and Critique Eds ColemanJSFararoTJ, (Sage, London) pp 207–228
3.
BradbyH, (Ed.), 1990Dirty Words: Writings on the History and Culture of Pollution (Earthscan, London)
4.
DoE, 1994Improving Air QualityDepartment of the Environment, Eland House, Bressenden Place, London SW1E 5DU
5.
DoE, 1995aAir Quality: Meeting the ChallengeDepartment of the Environment, Eland House, Bressenden Place, London SW1E 5DU
6.
DoE, 1995b, “Wintertime smog—how to help to prevent it”, Department of the Environment, Eland House, Bressenden Place, London SW1E 5DU
7.
DoE, 1995c, “Summertime smog—how to help to prevent it”, Department of the Environment, Eland House, Bressenden Place, London SW1E 5DU
8.
DoE, 1996Digest of Environmental Statistics number 18, Department of the Environment (The Stationary Office, London)
9.
DouglasM, 1966Purity and Danger: An Analysis of the Concepts of Pollution and Taboo (Routledge, London)
10.
DowdingK, 1991Rational Choice and Political Power (Edward Elgar, Aldershot, Hants)
11.
DowdingK, 1995The Civil Service (Routledge, London)
12.
DowdingK, 1996Power (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN)
13.
DryzekJ, 1990Discursive Democracy (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
14.
DryzekJ, 1996Democracy in Capitalist Times (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
15.
DunleavyD, 1991Democracy, Bureaucracy and Public Choice: Economic Explanations in Political Science (Harvester Wheatsheaf, Hemel Hempstead, Herts)
16.
ElsomD, 1996Managing Urban Air Quality (Earthscan, London)
17.
ElsterJ, 1982, “Belief, bias and ideology”, in Rationality and Relativism Eds HollisMLukesS, (Basil Blackwell, Oxford) pp 103–132
18.
ElsterJ, 1993Political Psychology (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
19.
FischerFForesterJ, (Eds), 1993The Argumentative Turn in Planning and Policy Analysis (UCL Press, London)
20.
FoE, 1994, “Transport-related atmospheric pollution in London: Submission to House of Commons Transport Committee”, Friends of the Earth, 26 Underwood Street, London N1 7SQ
HajerM, 1995The Politics of Environmental Discourse: Ecological Modernization and the Policy Process (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
23.
HeapSP HargreavesVaroufakisY, 1995Game Theory: A Critical Introduction (Routledge, London)
24.
HarrisonCBurgessJ, 1994, “Social construction of nature: A case study of conflicts over the development of Rainham Marshes”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series19291–310
25.
HarrisonRHobergG, 1991, “Setting the environmental agenda in Canada and the US: The cases of dioxin and radon”Canadian Journal of Political Science243–27
26.
Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Pollution, 1993An Assessment of the Effects of Industrial Releases of Nitrogen Oxides in the East Thames CorridorHer Majesty's Inspectorate of Pollution, now Environment Agency, Rio House, Waterside Drive, Aztec West, Almondsbury, Bristol BS12 4UO
27.
HindessB, 1989Political Choice and Social Structure (Edward Elgar, Aldershot, Hants)
28.
House of Commons Transport Committee, 1994Transport-related Air Pollution in London 6th report (session 1993–94) (HMSO, London)
29.
KingdonJ, 1984Agendas, Alternatives and Public Policies (Little Brown, Boston, MA)
30.
LBA, 1990Capital Killer: Air Pollution for Road VehiclesLondon Boroughs Association, College House, Great Peter Street, London SW1P 3LN
31.
LBA, 1993Capital Killer IILondon Boroughs Association, College House, Great Peter Street, London SW1P 3LN
32.
MajoneG, 1989Evidence, Argument and Persuasion in the Policy Process (Yale University Press, New Haven, CT)
33.
MyersonGRydinY, 1996The Language of Environment: A New Rhetoric (UCL Press, London)
34.
NozickR, 1993The Nature of Rationality (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
35.
OlsonM, 1965The Logic of Collective Action (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
36.
OstromE, 1990Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
37.
Planning1996, “Leicester in pricing test” 15 March, page 7
38.
RCEP, 1995Transport and the Environment first published in 1994 by HMSO, Royal Commission on Environmental Pollution (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
39.
ScheffT, 1992, “Rationality and emotion: Homage to Norbert Elias”, in Rational Choice Theory: Advocacy and Critique Eds ColemanJSFararoTJ, (Sage, London) pp 101–119
40.
The Scotsman1996, “Scottish Office's car stance under fire”, 1 June, page 12
41.
UdehnL, 1996The Limits of Public Choice (Routledge, London)
42.
UngarS, 1992, “The rise and (relative) decline of global warming as a social problem”The Sociological Quarterly33483–501
43.
YoungM, 1995, “How to fight the fug”Evening Standard 5 June, page 31
