In this paper we argue that as models of profitability and growth within the Marxist tradition have become more formal, they have relied increasingly upon assumptions of equilibrium. An alternative single-region, single-commodity model is proposed in which output, demand, and capital accumulation are independently determined and therefore potentially in disequilibrium. In the short run this means that profitability can be rising or falling, depending upon the rates of growth of demand, supply, and net exports, the rate of capital accumulation, the rate of change of unit costs of production, and the initial starting position of the economy. In the longer run, though, output is limited by the capacity of capital to produce and by the size of the labour force, and demand cannot exceed supply. These constraints place an upper bound on the rate of profit and its growth, a bound that depends on the rate of change in the unit costs of production and on the rate of growth of the labour force. In the longest term, net exports cannot continue to grow, and certain regulatory conditions are deduced: if those conditions are met as equalities then the rate of profit is constant; if they are met as inequalities, the rate of profit falls.
References
1.
AgliettaM, 1979A Theory of Capitalist Regulation (New Left Books, London)
2.
AlberroJPerskyJ, 1979, “The simple analytics of falling profit rates, Okishio's theorem and fixed capital”Review of Radical Political Economics1137–41
3.
BarroRJ, 1991, “Economic growth in a cross section of countries”Quarterly Journal of Economics106407–443
4.
BlaugM, 1960, “Technical change and Marxian economics”Kyklos13495–509
5.
BluestoneBHarrisonB, 1982The Deindustrialization of America (Basic Books, New York)
6.
BoddyRCrottyJ, 1975, “Class conflict and macro-policy: The political business cycle”Review of Radical Political Economics71–19
7.
BurmeisterE, 1980Capital Theory and Dynamics (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
8.
BIE, 1992Recent Developments in the Theory of Economic Growth: Policy Implications Bureau of Industry Economics (AGPS, Canberra, Australia)
9.
CarneyJHudsonRLewisJ (Eds), 1980Regions in Crisis: New Perspectives in European Regional Theory (Croom Helm, London)
10.
DebreuG, 1959Theory of Value (Yale University Press, New Haven, CT)
11.
DevineJN, 1988, “Falling profit rates and the causes of the 1929–33 collapse: Towards a synthesis”Review of Radical Political Economics2087–93
12.
DumenilGLevyD, 1994The Economics of the Profit Rate (Edward Elgar, Aldershot, Hants)
13.
DunfordMGeddesMPerronsD, 1981, “Regional policy and the crisis in the UK: A long-run perspective”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research5337–410
14.
EnglanderASMittelstadtA, 1988, “Total factor productivity: Macroeconomic and structural aspects of the slowdown”OECD Economic Studies107–56
15.
FarjounEMachoverM, 1983Laws of Chaos: A Probabilistic Account of Political Economy (Verso, London)
16.
FischerS, 1988, “Symposium on the slowdown in productivity growth”Journal of Economic Perspectives2(4) 3–7
17.
FlaschelPSemmlerW, 1987, “Classical and neoclassical competitive adjustment processes”Manchester School of Economic and Social Studies5515–37
18.
GibsonKDHorvathRJ, 1983, “Aspects of a theory of transition within the capitalist mode of production”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space1121–138
19.
GlynASutcliffeB, 1972British Capitalism, Workers and the Profit Squeeze (Penguin Books, Harmondsworth, Middlesex)
20.
GoldsteinJP, 1985, “The cyclical profit squeeze: A Marxian Microfoundation”Review of Radical Political Economics17103–128
21.
GrilichesZ, 1988, “Productivity puzzles and R&D: Another nonexplanation”Journal of Economic Perspectives2(4) 9–21
22.
GrossmanGMHelpmanE, 1991Innovation and Growth in the Global Economy (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)
23.
GrossmanGMHelpmanE, 1994, “Endogenous innovation in the theory of growth”Journal of Economic Perspectives823–44
24.
HahnelRShermanH, 1982, “Note: The rate of profit over the business cycle”Cambridge Journal of Economics6185–194
25.
HarveyD, 1982The Limits to Capital (Chicago University Press, Chicago, IL)
26.
HendersonJCastellsM (Eds), 1987Global Restructuring and Territorial Development (Sage, London)
27.
HenleyA, 1987, “Labour's shares and profitability crisis in the United States”Cambridge Journal of Economics315–330
28.
HodgsonG, 1974, “The theory of the falling rate of profit”New Left Review8455–82
29.
HolmesJ, 1983, “Industrial reorganization, capital restructuring and locational change: An analysis of the Canadian automobile industry in the 1960s”Economic Geography59251–271
30.
LaibmanD, 1982, “Technical change, the real wage and the rate of exploitation: The falling rate of profit reconsidered”Review of Radical Political Economics1495–105
LipietzA, 1986, “Behind the crisis: The exhaustion of a regime of accumulation. A ‘regulation school’ perspective on some French empirical work”Review of Radical Political Economics1813–32
33.
LipietzA, 1987Mirages and Miracles: The Crisis of Global Fordism (Verso, London)
34.
de LongJBSummersLH, 1991, “Equipment investment and economic growth”Quarterly Journal of Economics106445–502
35.
LucasRE, 1988, “On the mechanics of economic development”Journal of Monetary Economics223–42
36.
MacEwanATabbWK (Eds), 1989Instability and Change in the Global Economy (Monthly Review Press, New York)
37.
MaddisonA, 1987, “Growth and slowdown in advanced capitalist economies: Techniques of quantitative assessment”Journal of Economic Literature25649–698
38.
MahonR, 1984The Politics of Industrial Restructuring: Canadian Textiles (University of Toronto Press, Toronto)
39.
MandelE, 1978Late Capitalism (Verso, London)
40.
MankiwNGRomerDWeilDN, 1992, “A contribution to the empirics of economic growth”Quarterly Journal of Economics107407–437
41.
MarxK, 1967Capital3 Volumes (Penguin, London)
42.
MasseyD, 1981, “The U.K. electrical engineering and electronics industries: The implications of the crisis for the restructuring of capital and locational change”, in Urbanization and Urban Planning in Capitalist Society Eds DearMJScottAJ (Methuen, London) pp 199–230
43.
MasseyDMeeganR, 1982The Anatomy of Job Loss (Methuen, London)
44.
MattickP, 1969Marx and Keynes: The Limits of the Mixed Economy (Peter Sargent, Boston, MA)
45.
MoseleyF, 1990, “The decline in the rate of profit in the postwar United States economy”Review of Radical Political Economics2217–37
46.
NakataniT, 1980, “The law of the falling rate of profit and the competitive battle: Comment on Shaikh”Cambridge Journal of Economics465–68
47.
von NeumannJ, 1945, “A model and general economic equilibrium”Review of Economic Studies131–19
48.
NikaidoH, 1977, “Refutation of the dynamic equalization of profit rates in Marx's scheme of reproduction”, WP 7722, Modelling Research Group, Department of Economics, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, California
49.
NikaidoH, 1978, “Do profit rates equalize by movement of money capital in Marx's scheme of reproduction?”, WP 7812, Modelling Research Group, Department of Economics, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, California
50.
OkishioN, 1961, “Technical changes and the rate of profit”Kobe University Economic Review786–96
51.
PackH, 1994, “Endogenous growth theory: Intellectual appeal and empirical shortcomings”Journal of Economic Perspectives855–72
52.
van ParijsP, 1980, “The falling rate of profit theory of crisis: A rational reconstruction by way of obituary”Review of Radical Political Economics121–16
53.
PeetR (Ed.), 1987International Capitalism and Industrial Restructuring (Allen and Unwin, London)
54.
PioreMJSabelCF, 1984The Second Industrial Divide: Possibilities for Prosperity (Basic Books, New York)
55.
ReutenG, 1991, “Accumulation of capital and the foundation of the tendency of the rate of profit to fall”Cambridge Journal of Economics1579–93
56.
RigbyDL, 1990, “Technical change and the rate of profit: An obituary for Okishio's theorem”Environment and Planning A221039–1050
RoemerJE, 1977, “Technical change and the ‘tendency of the rate of profit to fall’”Journal of Economic Theory16403–425
59.
RoemerJE, 1978, “The effect of technological change on the real wage and Marx's falling rate of profit”Australian Economic Papers17152–166
60.
RoemerJE, 1979, “Continuing controversy on the falling rate of profit: Fixed capital and other issues”Cambridge Journal of Economics3379–398
61.
RomerPM, 1986, “Increasing returns and long-run growth”Journal of Political Economy941002–1037
62.
RomerPM, 1990, “Endogenous technical change”Journal of Political Economy98S71–S102
63.
RomerPM, 1994, “The origins of endogenous growth”Journal of Economic Perspectives83–22
64.
SalvadoriN, 1981, “The falling rate of profit with a constant real wage. An example”Cambridge Journal of Economics559–66
65.
ShaikhA, 1978, “Political economy and capitalism: Notes on Dobb's theory of crisis”Cambridge Journal of Economics292–99
66.
ShaikhA, 1980, “Marxian competition versus perfect competition: Further comments on the so-called choice of technique”Cambridge Journal of Economics475–83
67.
ShaikhA, 1982, “Neo-Ricardian economics—a wealth of algebra, a poverty of theory”Review of Radical Political Economics1467–83
ShermanHJ, 1990, “Cyclical behavior of the labor share”Review of Radical Political Economics2292–112
70.
SolowR, 1957, “A contribution to the theory of economic growth”Quarterly Journal of Economics7065–94
71.
SraffaP, 1960The Production of Commodities by Means of Commodities (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
72.
SteedmanI, 1980, “A note on the ‘choice of technique’ under capitalism”Cambridge Journal of Economics461–64
73.
SweezyPM, 1970The Theory of Capitalist Development (Modern Reader, New York)
74.
WebberMJ, 1986, “Regional production and the production of regions: The case of steeltown”, in Production, Work, Territory: The Geographical Anatomy of Industrial Capitalism Eds ScottAJStorperM (Allen and Unwin, Boston, MA) pp 195–224
75.
WebberMJ, 1989, “Capital flows and rates of profit”Review of Radical Political Economics21113–135
76.
WebberMJ, 1990, “Profitability and capital accumulation in Canadian manufacturing industries”Environment and Planning A221051–1071
77.
WebberMJ, 1996, “Profitability and growth in multi-region systems: Theory and a model”Economic Geography72335–352
78.
WebberMJ, 1997, “Profitability and growth in multiregion systems—prologue to a historical geography”Economic Geography73405–426
79.
WebberMJRigbyDL, 1986, “The rate of profit in Canadian manufacturing, 1950–1981”Review of Radical Political Economics1833–55
80.
WebberMJRigbyDL, 1996The Golden Age Illusion: Rethinking Postwar Capitalism (Guilford Press, New York)
81.
WeisskopfTE, 1979, “Marxian crisis theory and the rate of profit in the postwar US economy”Cambridge Journal of Economics3341–378
82.
WolffEN, 1986, “The productivity slowdown and the fall in the US rate of profit 1947–1976”Review of Radical Political Economics1887–110
83.
WrightEO, 1979Class, Crisis and the State (Verso, London)
84.
YaffeD, 1973, “The Marxian theory of crisis, capital and the state”Economy and Society2186–232
85.
YoungA, 1991, “Learning by doing and the dynamic effects of international trade”Quarterly Journal of Economics106369–405
