Aspects of the Interrelationships of Attitudes and Behaviour as Illustrated by a Longitudinal Study of British Adults: 3. Variation in Individuals' Attitudes over Time and a Cross-Temporal Ecological Fallacy
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online October, 1999
Aspects of the Interrelationships of Attitudes and Behaviour as Illustrated by a Longitudinal Study of British Adults: 3. Variation in Individuals' Attitudes over Time and a Cross-Temporal Ecological Fallacy
In most models of the links between attitudes and behaviour it is assumed (implicitly if not explicitly) that people have stable predispositions to act in particular ways. This assumption has rarely been tested in studies of British voting behaviour which show, as in the first two papers of this series, strong links between measured attitudes and party choice when a longitudinal data set is used. Investigations of the respondents' attitudes over time show substantial inconsistency, however, which suggests a cross-temporal ecological fallacy and raises serious questions regarding the traditionally employed models of voting behaviour.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AlwinD F, 1991, “Research on survey quality”Sociological Methods and Research153–29
2.
AlwinD FKrosnickJ A, 1991, “The reliability of survey attitude measurement”Sociological Methods and Research15139–181
3.
AlkerH R, 1969, “A typology of ecological fallacies”, Quantitative Ecological Analysis in the Social Sciences Eds DoganMRokkanS (The MIT Press, Cambridge, MA) pp 69–86
4.
BartleJ, 1998, “Left—right position matters, but does social class? Causal models of the 1992 British general election”British Journal of Political Science28501–530
5.
GrofmanB, 1995, “New methods for valid ecological inference”, in Spatial and Contextual Models in Political Research Ed. EaglesM (Taylor and Francis, London) pp 127–149
6.
HeiseD R, 1969, “Separating reliability and stability in test—retest corruption”American Sociological Review3493–101
JohnstonR JPattieC J, 1998, “Inconsistency within consistency: Changing attitudes and electoral behavior in Great Britain”Genetic, Social and General Psychological Monographs120121–143
9.
JohnstonR JPattieC J, 1999a, “Aspects of the interrelationships of attitudes and behaviour as illustrated by a longitudinal study of British adults: 1. Interactions among attitudes and changing voting intentions”Environment and Planning A31899–923
10.
JohnstonR JPattieC J, 1999b, “Aspects of the interrelationships of attitudes and behaviour as illustrated by a longitudinal study of British adults: 2. Predicting voting intention, strength of party identification, and change in both”Environment and Planning A311279–1294
11.
KingG, 1997A Solution to the Ecological Inference Problem: Reconstructing Individual Behavior from Aggregate Data (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
12.
RobinsonW S, 1950, “Ecological correlations and the behavior of individuals”American Sociological Review15351–357
