In North America, competition for land has often been conceptualized as being driven by growth machines whereby those with common stakes in development form coalitions of local elites to influence government in pursuit of their goals. The inequitable benefits of growth have been challenged more recently by the introduction of growth-management practices that heighten the role of local residents in land-use decisions. In this paper, the concepts of the ‘growth machine’ and ‘growth management’ are applied to an examination of the resort community of Whistler, British Columbia. This approach transforms previous theorizations of resort formation which draw upon Butler's (1980) life-cycle model, by focusing on the social and political dynamics of growth. Whistler is seen to progress through a phase of uncontested growth-machine dominance, to a phase of local contestation that is then moderated by the introduction of growth-management practices. The evolutionary process is seen as a cumulative one in which, over time, social and environmental imperatives are imposed upon the economic imperatives of the growth machine.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AgarwalS, 1997, “The public sector: planning for renewal?”, in The Rise and Fall of British Coastal Resorts Eds ShawGWilliamsA (Mansell, London) pp 137–158
2.
AgarwalS, 1999, “Restructuring and local economic development: implications for seaside resort regeneration in southwest Britain”Tourism Management20511–522
3.
ApJCromptonJ L, 1993, “Residents' strategies for responding to tourism impacts”Journal of Travel Research32(1) 47–50
4.
BennettT, 1986, “Hegemony, ideology, pleasure: Blackpool”, in Popular Culture and Social Relations Eds BennettTMercerCWoollacottJ (Open University Press, Milton Keynes) pp 137–154
5.
BianchiR, 1994, “Tourism development and resort dynamics: an alternative approach”, in Progress in Recreation and Hospitality ManagementVolume 5 Eds CooperC PLockwoodA (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex) pp 194–208
British Columbia, Ministry of Muncipal Affairs, 1996, “A guide to British Columbia's mountain resort association acts”, pamphlet; copy available from Ministry of Municipal Affairs, Communcations branch, PO Box 9490, Victoria, BC, VSW 9N7
8.
ButlerR W, 1980, “The concept of a tourism area cycle of evolution: implications for the management of resources”Canadian Geographer245–12
9.
CananPHennessyM, 1989, “The growth machine, tourism, and the selling of culture”Sociological Perspectives32227–243
10.
ChapinF SJrKaiserE J, 1979Urban Land Use Planning (University of Illinois Press, Champaign, IL)
11.
ChoyD J L, 1992, “Life cycle models of Pacific island destinations”Journal of Travel Research30(3) 26–31
12.
CoxKMairA, 1988, “Locality and community in the politics of local economic development”Annals of the Association of American Geographers78307–325
13.
CoxKMairA, 1989, “The urban growth machine and the politics of local economic development”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research13137–146
14.
CulbertsonKKolbergJ, 1991, “Worker housing in resorts: Aspen's experience”Urban Land50(4) 12–15
15.
DebbageK G, 1990, “Oligopoly and the resort cycle in the Bahamas”Annals of Tourism Research17513–527
16.
DouglasN, 1997, “Applying the life cycle model to Melanesia”Annals of Tourism Research241–22
17.
EdgingtonD W, 1995, “The search for paradise: Japanese property investment in North America”Journal of Property Research12240–261
18.
GetzD, 1992, “Tourism planning and the destination life cycle”Annals of Tourism Research19752–770
19.
GillA M, 1996, “Rooms with a view: informal settings for public dialogue”Society and Natural Resources9633–643
20.
GillA MClarkP, 1992, “Second-home development in the resort municipality of Whistler, British Columbia”, in British Columbia: Geographical Essays in Honour of A MacPherson Ed. KoroscilP M (Department of Geography, Simon Fraser University, Burnaby, British Columbia) pp 281–294
GirardT CGartnerW C, 1993, “Second home, second view: host community perceptions”Annals of Tourism Research20685–700
23.
GreenG P, 1995, “Structuring locality: economic development and growth management in Wisconsin cities and villages”, in Local Economic Development: Incentives and International Trends Ed. WalzerN (Westview Press, Boulder, CO) pp 159–180
24.
HallC M, 1994Tourism and Politics: Policy, Power and Place (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex)
25.
HawkinsA, 1987, “A carrying capacity model for resort planning and management with preliminary application to Whistler, Canada”, unpublished Masters of Natural Resources Management report, Simon Fraser University, Burnaby, BC V5A 1S6
26.
HaywoodK M, 1986, “Can the tourist-area life cycle be made operational”Tourism Management7154–167
27.
HillK QDurandR, 1988, “The ‘growth machine’ revisited: public and private sector elites' assessments of growth and growth politics”Social Science Quarterly69737–745
28.
InnesJ E, 1992, “Group processes and the social construction of growth management”Journal of the American Planning Association58440–453
29.
JacobsB D, 1995, “The bureau-politics of economic development and urban renewal in Britain”, in Local Economic Development: Incentives and International Trends Ed. WalzerN (Westview Press, Boulder, CO) pp 31–52
30.
JamalT BGetzD, 1995, “Collaboration theory and community tourism planning”Annals of Tourism Research22186–204
31.
KeatingM, 1993, “The politics of economic development: political change and local development policies in the United States, Britain and France”Urban Affairs Quarterly28373–396
KingB, 1994, “Research on resorts: a review”, in Progress in Recreation and Hospitality ManagementVolume 5 Eds CooperC PLockwoodA (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex) pp 165–180
34.
LankfordSHowardD, 1994, “Developing a tourism impact attitude scale”Annals of Tourism Research21121–139
35.
LewisS, 1991, “Building affordable housing in unaffordable places”Planning5724–27
36.
LoganJ RMolotchH, 1987Urban Fortunes: The Political Economy of Place (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
37.
LongPPerdueRAllenL, 1990, “Rural resident tourism perceptions and attitudes by community level of tourism”Journal of Travel Research29(3) 3–9
38.
McCoolSMartinS, 1994, “Community attachment and attitudes toward tourism development”Journal of Travel Research32(3) 29–34
39.
MadrigalR, 1995, “Residents' perceptions and the role of government”Annals of Tourism Research22(1) 86–102
40.
MarkusenA R, 1985Profit Cycles, Oligopoly and Regional Development (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)
41.
MolotchH, 1976, “The city as a growth machine”American Journal of Sociology82309–330
42.
MolotchH, 1993, “The political economy of growth machines”Journal of Urban Affairs1529–53
43.
MooreCPierreJ, 1988, “Partnerships or privatisation?: the political economy of local economic restructuring”Policy and Politics16(3) 169–178
44.
PierreJ, 1995, “When the going gets tough: changing local economic development strategies in Sweden”, in Local Economic Development: Incentives and International Trends Ed. WalzerN (Westview Press, Boulder, CO) pp 53–72
45.
RademanM, 1987, “Ski town predictions: obstacles ahead”Planning5317–21
46.
ReedM G, 1997, “The provision of environmental goods and services by local nongovernmental organizations: an illustration from the Squamish Forest District, Canada”Journal of Rural Studies13177–196
47.
Resort of Whistler, 19961996 Annual Community and Resort Monitoring Program (RMOW, Whistler, BC)
48.
RMOW, 1997Whistler Affordable Housing Study pamphlet; copy available from Resort Municipality of Whistler, 4325 Blackcomb Way, Whistler, BC, VON 1B4
49.
RMOW, 1998a1998 Resort and Community Monitoring Report pamphlet; copy available from Resort Municipality of Whistler, 4325 Blackcomb Way, Whistler, BC, VON 1B4
50.
RMOW, 1998bVisioning Report pamphlet; copy available from Resort Municipality of Whistler, 4325 Blackcomb Way, Whistler, BC, VON 1B4
51.
RowleyB, 1991, “Escape to the mountains”Snow Country Magazine July/August issue, pages 51–61
52.
SchneiderM, 1992, “Undermining the growth regime: the missing link between local economic development and fiscal payoffs”Journal of Politics54214–230
53.
SchneiderMTeskeP, 1993, “The antigrowth entrepreneur: challenging the ‘equilibrium’ of the growth machine”Journal of Politics55720–736
54.
ScottR WBrowerD JMinerD D, 1975Management and Control of Growththree volumes (The Urban Land Institute, Washington, DC)
55.
SimmonsD, 1994, “Community participation in tourism planning”Tourism Management1598–108
56.
StokowskiP, 1996Riches and Regrets: Betting on Gambling in Two Colorado Mountain Towns (University Press of Colorado, Boulder, CO)
57.
VogelR KSwansonB E, 1989, “The growth machine versus the antigrowth coalition: the battle for our communities”Urban Affairs Quarterly2563–85
58.
WarnerKMolotchH, 1995, “Power to build: how development persists despite local controls”Urban Affairs Review30378–406
59.
WarrenR L, 1977Social Change and Human Purpose (Rand McNally, Chicago, IL)
60.
WilliamsA MShawGGreenwoodJ, 1989, “From tourist to tourism entrepreneur, from consumption to production: evidence from Cornwall, England”Environment and Planning A211639–1653
61.
WolfeR I, 1983, “Recreational travel, the new migration revisited”Ontario Geography19103–124
62.
ZovanyiG, 1998Growth Management for a Sustainable Future: Ecological Sustainability as the New Growth Management Focus for the 21st Century (Praeger, New York)
