I attempt in this paper to conceptualize a notion of spatial justice in order to point to the dialectical relationship between (in)justice and spatiality, and to the role that spatialization plays in the production and reproduction of domination and repression. I argue that the city provides a productive ground for the formation of a spatially informed ethics of political solidarity against domination and repression. A ‘triad’ is articulated to inform such politics, which brings together three notions: the spatial dialectics of injustice, the right to the city, and the right to difference. The notion of spatial justice is employed as a theoretical underpinning to avoid abusive interpretations of Lefebvrian rights in a liberal framework of individual rights. The case of French urban policy is used for illustrative purposes. Finally, the notion of égaliberté is introduced as a moral ground on which the triad may be defended.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BalibarÉ, 1991, Comments in the minutes of a seminar, in “Loi d'orientation pour la ville: Séminaire chercheurs décideurs” Recherches 20.
2.
BalibarÉ, 1997La crainte des masses: Politique et philosophie avant et après Marx[The fear of masses: Politics and philosophy before and after Marx] (Galilée, Paris).
3.
BaudouïR, 2000, “Bâtir la ville du troisième me millénaire: Regards sur les politiques urbaines françaises et la question du multiculturalisme” [Building the city of the third millennium: Thoughts on French urban policies and the question of multiculturalism], paper presented at the Cities and Cultural Diversity in France and the Francophone World Symposium, organized by the French Department of University of California, Los Angeles; a translated version also appeared in Critical Planning 7(2), 117–126.
4.
BéharD, 1995, “Banlieues ghettos, quartiers populaires ou ville éclatée? L'espace urbain à l'épreuve de la nouvelle question sociale” [Ghetto suburbs, working class neighborhoods or fragmented city? Urban space put to test by the new social question] Les Annales de la recherche urbaine68 – 697–14.
5.
BéharD, 1999, “En finir avec la politique de la ville?” [Putting an end to urban policy?] Esprit258209–218.
6.
BélandDHansenR, 2000, “Reforming the French welfare state: Solidarity, social exclusion and the three crises of citizenship”West European Politics23(1) 47–64.
7.
BerthoA, 1996La Crise de la politique: Du désarroi militant à la politique de la ville [A crisis in policymaking: From militant disarray to urban policy] (L'Harmattan, Paris).
8.
BerthoA, 1999Contre l'État, la politique [Policymaking against the state] (La Dispute, Paris).
9.
BourdieuP, 1999, “Site effects”, in The Weight of the World: Social Suffering in Contemporary Society Ed. BourdieuP, translated by FergusonP PEmanuelSJohnsonJWarynS T, (Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA) pp 123–129.
10.
originally published in 1993 asLa misère du monde (Éditions du Seuil, Paris).
11.
BoyneGPowellM, 1991, “Territorial justice: A review of theory and evidence”Political Geography Quarterly10263–281.
12.
ByrneD, 1999Social Exclusion (Open University Press, Buckingham).
13.
ChalineC, 1998Les politiques de la ville [Urban policies] 2nd edition (Presses Universitaires de France, Paris).
14.
Circulaire no. 91–57 relative à la loi d'orientation pour la ville no. 91–662 du 13 juillet 1991 [Letter no. 91–57 relative to the urban development act no. 91–662 13 July 1991] Ministère de l'équipement, des transports et du logement, Direction de l'architecture et de l'urbanisme, Direction de la Construction (Paris: 31 juillet 1991).
15.
CresswellT, 1996In Place/Out of Place: Geography, Ideology, and Transgression (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN).
16.
DaviesB, 1968Social Needs and Resources in Local Services (Michael Joseph, London).
17.
DikeçM, 2001, “Geography and social justice: Three decades later”, manuscript, Department of Urban Planning, University of California, Los Angeles, CA.
18.
DikeçM, forthcoming, “Pera peras poros: Longings for spaces of hospitality”Theory, Culture and Society.
19.
DimockW C, 1997Residues of Justice: Literature, Law, Philosophy (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA).
20.
FaberJ, 2000Les indésirables: L'intégration à la française [The undesirables: Integration in the French way] (Grasset, Paris).
21.
FlustyS, 1994Building Paranoia: The Proliferation of Interdictory Space and The Erosion of Spatial Justice (LA Forum for Architecture and Urban Design, West Hollywood, CA).
22.
GarberJ A, 2000, “The city as a heroic public sphere”, in Democracy, Citizenship and the Global City Ed. IsinE, (Routledge, London) pp 257–274.
23.
GleesonB, 1998, “Justice and the disabling city”, in Cities of Difference Eds FincherRJacobsJ M, (Guilford Press, New York) pp 89–119.
24.
HallTHubbardP, 1996, “The entrepreneurial city: New urban politics, new urban geographies?”Progress in Human Geography20153–174.
25.
HarveyD, 1973Social Justice and the City (Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD).
26.
HarveyD, 1989The Urban Experience (Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD).
27.
HarveyD, 1992, “Social justice, postmodernism and the city”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research16588–601.
28.
HarveyD, 1996Justice, Nature and the Geography of Difference (Blackwell, Malden, MA).
29.
HolstonJAppaduraiA, 1996, “Cities and citizenship”Public Culture8(2) 187–204.
30.
IsinE, 1999, “Introduction: Cities and citizenship in a global age”Citizenship Studies3(2) 165–172.
31.
Journal Officiel de la République Française [Official Journal of the French Republic] 19 Juillet 1991.
32.
KantI, 1970, “Perpetual peace: A philosophical sketch”, in Kant's Political Writings Ed. ReissH, translated by NisbetH B, (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 93–130; first published 1795.
33.
KatznelsonI, 1997, “Social justice, liberalism and the city: Considerations on David Harvey, John Rawls and Karl Polanyi”, in The Urbanization of Injustice Eds MerrifieldASwyngedouwE, (New York University Press, New York) pp 45–64.
34.
KeithM, 1997, “Street sensibility? Negotiating the political by articulating the spatial”, in The Urbanization of Injustice Eds MerrifieldASwyngedouwE, (New York University Press, New York) pp 137–160.
LefebvreH, 1976aThe Survival of Capitalism: Reproduction of the Relations of Production translated by BryantF, (Allison and Busby, London); first published 1973.
38.
LefebvreH, 1976b, “Reflections on the politics of space”Antipode830–37.
39.
LefebvreH, 1981Critique de la vie quotidienne III: De la modernité au modernisme (Pour une métaphilosophie du quotidien) [Critique of everyday life III. From modernity to modernism (for a metaphilosophy of the everyday)] (L'Arche éditeur, Paris).
40.
LefebvreH, 1986Le Retour de la Dialectique [The return of dialectics] (Messidor/Éditions sociales, Paris).
41.
LefebvreH, 1991The Production of Space (Blackwell, Oxford); first published 1974.
42.
LefebvreH, 1993, “The right to the city”, in Architecture Culture 1943 – 1968: A Documentary Anthology Ed. OckmanJ, (Rizzoli, New York) pp 428–436; first published 1968.
43.
LefebvreH, 1996Writings on Cities translated by KofmanELebasE, (Blackwell, Cambridge, MA).
44.
LégéB, 1995, “Réhabilitation et désenclavement symbolique: La justice spatiale est-elle possible?” [Rehabilitation or symbolic disenclavement: Is social justice possible?] Les Annales de la recherche urbaine68 – 6934–42.
45.
LelévrierC, 1999, “Renaissance or the end of urban policy?”Les Cahiers de l'IAURIF12335–41.
46.
LenoirR, 1974Les exclus: Un français sur dix [The excluded: One French out of ten] (Le Seuil, Paris).
47.
LerouxL, 2001, “A Marseille, les anciens de l'immigration, oubliés de la rénovation urbaine” [In Marseille former immigrants left out of urban renovation] Le Monde 22 juin, page 11.
48.
LojkineJ, 1977Le marxisme, l'état et la question urbaine [Marxism, state and the urban question] (Presses Universitaires de France, Paris).
49.
MadanipourA, 1998, “Social exclusion and space”, in Social Exclusion in European Cities: Processes, Experiences, and Responses Eds MadanipourACarsGAllenJ, (Jessica Kingsley, London) pp 75–89.
50.
MerrifieldA, 1997, “Social justice and communities of difference: A snapshot from Liverpool”, in The Urbanization of Injustice Eds MerrifieldASwyngedouwE, (New York University Press, New York) p 200–222.
51.
MerrifieldASwyngedouwE, 1997, “Social justice and the urban experience: An introduction”, in The Urbanization of Injustice Eds MerrifieldASwyngedouwE, (New York University Press, New York) pp 1–17.
MouffeC, 1992, “Democratic citizenship and the political community”, in Dimensions of Radical Democracy: Pluralism, Citizenship, Community Ed. MouffeC, (Verso, London) pp 225–239.
54.
PerecG, 1997Species of Spaces and Other Pieces edited and translated by SturrockJ, (Penguin Books, Harmondsworth, Middx); first published 1974.
55.
PirieG H, 1983, “On spatial justice”Environment and Planning A15465–473.
56.
RancièreJ, 1995, “Politics, identification, and subjectivization”, in The Identity in Question Ed. RajchmanJ, (Routledge, London) pp 63–70.
57.
RawlsJ, 1971A Theory of Justice (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA).
58.
RawlsJ, 1993Political Liberalism (Columbia University Press, New York) Recherches 20, “Loi d'orientation pour la ville: Séminaire chercheurs décideurs” [Urban development act: Seminar with researchers and decisionmakers] Ministère de l'équipement, des transports et du logement (Paris, 1991).
59.
SandelM J, 1982Liberalism and the Limits of Justice (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
60.
SimonP, 1995, “La politique de la ville contre la ségrégation: Ou l'idéal d'une ville sans divisions” [Urban policy against segregation: Or the ideal of a city without divisions] Les Annales de la recherche urbaine68 – 6927–33.
61.
SkinnerQ, 1992, “On justice, the common good and the priority of liberty”, in Dimensions of Radical Democracy: Pluralism, Citizenship, Community Ed. MouffeC, (Verso, London) pp 211–224.
62.
SmithD M, 1994Geography and Social Justice (Blackwell, Oxford).
63.
SmithD M, 1997, “Back to the good life: Towards an enlarged conception of social justice”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space1519–35.
64.
SmithD M, 2000, “Social justice revisited”Environment and Planning A321149–1162.
65.
SmithN, 1997, “Social justice and the new American urbanism: The revanchist city”, in The Urbanization of Injustice Eds MerrifieldASwyngedouwE, (New York University Press, New York) pp 117–136.
66.
SojaE, 1989Postmodern Geographies: The Reassertion of Space in Critical Social Theory (Verso, London).
67.
SojaE, 2000Postmetropolis: Critical Studies of Cities and Regions (Blackwell, Oxford).
68.
TouraineA, 1991, “Face à l'exclusion”Esprit1697–13.
69.
Voltaire, 1961Mélanges (Gallimard, Paris); first published 1761.
70.
Wihtol de WendenC, 1992, “Question de citoyenneté” [The question of citizenship] Espaces et sociétés6837–45.
71.
YoungI M, 1990Justice and the Politics of Difference (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ).
72.
YoungI M, 1999, “Residential segregation and differentiated citizenship”Citizenship Studies3(2) 237–252.
