The shopping mall as a part of the recent transformations in Turkish urban lifestyle is the focus of this research. Characteristics of the Turkish way of using shopping malls, and their social and spatial consequences, are investigated and analyzed through a case study in Ankara, the capital of Turkey. The field survey was carried out in Bilkent Shopping Center, a newly built shopping mall in a suburban area which was also established recently as a high-income housing settlement. This shopping mall is an appropriate example of spatial transformations under the influence of global forces, which may also give clues about changes in urban lifestyle. A field survey was carried out through user surveys, and various observations are used to enrich the analysis. The results indicate that the shopping mall as a postmodern site matched the changing shopping and consumption requirements of Turkish urban citizens. The development of the shopping mall turns out to be timely for the Turkish urban citizen searching for modernity through new identity components in consumption patterns. Some benefit from this development more than others, for example, working women, indicating the process of feminization of the flaneur. However, these sites simultaneously produce a new arena of negotiation and conflict as well, creating new forms of exclusion—particularly for the urban poor. Although malls appear more public and democratic than the streets for the time being, the potential for segregation is implicit in their private character.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbazaM, 2002, “Shopping malls, consumer culture and the reshaping of public space in Egypt”Theory, Culture and Society1897–122
2.
AkselB, 2000, “Is a commercial complex an urban center? A case study: Bilkent Center, Ankara”, unpublished master's thesis, Middle East Technical University, Ankara
3.
AksoyARobinsK, 1994, “Istanbul between civilization and discontent”New Perspectives on Turkey1057–74
4.
AktasC, 2000, “Kamusal Alanda Islamci Kadin ve Erkeklerin Iliskilerindeki Degisim uzerine: Bacidan Bayana” [On the transformation of the relationship between Islamist women and men in public space; from ‘Baci’ (sister) to ‘Bayan’ (lady, miss)]Birikim13736–47
5.
AlbrowM, 1997, “Travelling beyond local cultures: socioscapes in a global city”, in Living the Global: Globalization as Local Process Ed. EadeJ (Routledge, London) pp 37–55
6.
AratY, 1998, “Turkiye'de Modernlesme Projesi ve Kadinlar” [Modernisation project and women in Turkey], in Turkiye'de Modernlesme ve Ulusal Kimlik Eds BozdoganSKasabaR (Tarih Vakfi, Istanbul) pp 82–98
7.
AyataA, 1997, “The emergence of identity politics in Turkey”New Perspectives on Turkey1759–73
8.
AyataS, 1989, “Toplumsal Cevre olarak Gecekondu ve Apartman” [Squatter and apartment block as social environment]Toplum ve Bilim46/47101–127
9.
AyataS, 1993, “Continuity and change in Turkish culture: some critical remarks on Modern Mahrem”New Perspectives on Turkey9137–148
BoraT, 1996, “Insa Doneminde Turk Milli Kimligi” [The constitution of Turkish national identity]Toplum ve Bilim7168–194
12.
BozdoganS, 1994, “Architecture, modernism and nation-building in Kemalist Turkey”New Perspectives on Turkey1037–55
13.
BozdoganS, 1998, “Turk Mimari Kulturunde Modernizm: Genel bir Bakis” [Modernism in the Turkish culture of architecture: an overview], in Turkiye'de Modernlesme ve Ulusal Kimlik Eds BozdoganSKasabaR (Tarih Vakfi, Istanbul) pp 118–135
14.
BuffoniL, 1997, “Rethinking poverty in globalized conditions”, in Living the Global: Globalization as Local Process Ed. EadeJ (Routledge, London) pp 110–126
15.
Cizre-SakalliogluUYeldanE, 2000, “Politics, society and financial liberalization: Turkey in the 1990s”Development and Change31481–508
16.
CelikZ, 1994, “Istanbul: urban preservation as a theme park, the case of Sogukcesme Street”, in Streets: Critical Perspectives on Public Space Eds CelikZFavroDIngersollR (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA) pp 83–92
17.
CrangP, 1996, “Displacement, consumption, and identity”Environment and Planning A2841–67
18.
CrawfordM, 1992, “The world in a shopping mall”, in Variations on a Themepark Ed. SorkinM (Noonday Press, New York) pp 3–30
19.
DemirelT, 2001, “Turkey's troubled democracy: bringing the socioeconomic factors back in”New Perspectives on Turkey24105–140
20.
DIE, 19971994 Household Consumption Expenditures Survey ResultsState Institute of Statistics, Ankara
21.
DIE, 19981994 Household Income Distribution SurveyState Institute of Statistics, Ankara
DrummondL B W, 2000, “Street scenes: practices of public and private space in urban Vietnam”Urban Studies372377–2391
24.
DurrschmidtJ, 1997, “The delinking of locale and milieu: on the situatedness of extended milieux in a global environment”, in Living the Global; Globalization as Local Process Ed. EadeJ (Routledge, London) pp 56–72
25.
EadeJ, 1997, “Introduction”, in Living the Global: Globalization as Local Process Ed. EadeJ (Routledge, London) pp 1–19
EllinN (Ed.), 1997Architecture of Fear (Princeton Architectural Press, New York)
28.
ErgunH, 1997, “Ankara Ne Degildir?” [What Ankara is not?]Birikim10289–91
29.
ErkipF, 2002, “The rise of the shopping mall in Turkey: an analysis of the factors affecting the use and appeal of the mall through a case in Ankara”, WP, Faculty of Art, Design and Architecture, Bilkent University, Ankara
30.
Erkip (Beler)F, 1997, “The distribution of urban public services: the case of parks and recreational services in Ankara”Cities14353–361
31.
ErmanT, 1998, “Becoming ‘urban'or remaining ‘rural’: the views of Turkish rural-to-urban migrants on the ‘integration’ question”International Journal of Middle East Studies30541–561
32.
ErmanT, 2001, “The politics of squatter (gecekondu) studies in Turkey: the changing representations of rural migrants in the academic discourse”Urban Studies38983–1002
33.
FeatherstoneM, 1998, “The flaneur, the city and virtual public life”Urban Studies35909–925
34.
FiratE, 2001, “Tuketim Egilimleri: Kadin Etkisi” [Consumption trends: the influence of women]Capital984–88
35.
GiddensA, 1990The Consequences of Modernity (Polity Press, Cambridge)
36.
GiddensA, 1991Modernity and Self-identity: Self and Identity in the Late Modern Age (Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA)
37.
Globus2002, “Kredi Karti Pazari Tam Gaz” [Credit card market is on its way] 3 (March) 25–26
38.
GokarikselB, 2001, “Istanbul'un Kulturel Haritasinda Galleria, Akmerkez ve Capitol'un Yeri: Mekan-Insan-Kultur Cozumlemesi Uzerine bir Deney” [The place of Galleria, Akmerkez and Capitol in Istanbul's cultural map: an experiment on the analysis of space–people–culture]Toplumbilim14105–113
39.
GoleN, 1998, “Modernlesme baglaminda Islami Kimlik Arayisi” [The search for an Islamist identity in the context of modernisation], in Turkiye'de Modernlesme ve Ulusal Kimlik Eds BozdoganSKasabaR (Tarih Vakfi, Istanbul) pp 70–81
40.
GoleN, 2000Islam ve Modernlik Uzerine Melez Desenler [Hybrid patterns on Islam and modernity] (Metis, Istanbul)
HarveyD, 1989The Condition of Postmodernity (Blackwell, Oxford)
43.
Helsinki Citizens Assembly, Turkey, 2001Modernity and Multiculturalism (Iletisim, Istanbul)
44.
HelvaciogluB, 2000, “Globalization in the neighbourhood: from the nation-state to Bilkent Center”International Sociology15326–342
45.
JacksonP, 1998, “Domesticating the street: the contested spaces of the high street and the mall”, in Images of the Street: Planning, Identity and Control in Public Space Ed. FyfeN R (Routledge, London) pp 176–191
46.
JacksonP, 1999, “Consumption and identity; the cultural politics of shopping”European Planning Studies725–39
47.
JacksonPThriftN, 1995, “Geographies of consumption”, in Acknowledging Consumption Ed. MillerD (Routledge, London) pp 204–237
48.
JewellN, 2001, “The fall and rise of the British mall”The Journal of Architecture6317–377
49.
KasabaR, 1998, “Eski ile Yeni Arasinda Kemalizm ve Modernizm” [Kemalism and modernism between old and new], in Turkiye'de Modernlesme ve Ulusal Kimlik Eds BozdoganSKasabaR (Tarih Vakfi, Istanbul) pp 12–28
50.
KelesR, 2000Kentlesme Politikasi [Politics of urbanisation], 5th edition (Imge, Ankara)
51.
KeyderC, 1998, “1990' larda Turkiye'de Modernlesmenin Dogrultusu” [The direction of modernisation in Turkey in the 1990s], in Turkiye'de Modernlesme ve Ulusal Kimlik Eds BozdoganSKasabaR (Tarih Vakfi, Istanbul) pp 29–42
52.
KeyderC, 2000, “Arka Plan” [Background], in Istanbul, Kuresel ile Yerel Arasinda Ed. KeyderC (Metis, Istanbul)
53.
KeymanF, 1997, “Kemalizm, Modernlik ve Gelenek” [Kemalism, modernity and tradition]Toplum ve Bilim7284–101
54.
KorayM, 2001, “Gerceklerin ‘Stilize’ Edildigi bir Dunyada ‘Otekilesen’ Yoksulluk” [Poverty becoming ‘otherness’ in a world of stylised reality]Toplum ve Bilim89218–241
55.
LangmanL, 1992, “Neon cages; shopping for subjectivity”, in Lifestyle Shopping: The Subject of Consumption Ed. ShieldsR (Routledge, London) pp 40–82
56.
LewisD G, 1990, “Community through exclusion and illusion: the creation of social worlds in an American shopping mall”Journal of Popular Culture24121–136
57.
LewisDBridgerD, 2000The Soul of the New Consumer: Authenticity—What We Buy and Why in the New Economy (Nicholas Brealey Publishing, London)
58.
MasseyD, 1994Space, Place and Gender (Polity Press, Cambridge)
59.
MillerD, 1995, “Consumption as the vanguard of history: a polemic by way of introduction”, in Acknowledging Consumption Ed. MillerD (Routledge, London) pp 1–57
60.
MillerDJacksonPThriftNHolbrookBRowlandsM, 1998Shopping, Place and Identity (Routledge, London)
61.
MitchellK, 2000, “The culture of urban space”, progress report Urban Geography21443–449
62.
MommaasH, 1996, “Modernity, postmodernity and the crisis of social modernization: a case study in urban fragmentation”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research20196–216
63.
OdekanA, 2001, “Istanbul'da Yaya Hakki Var mi?” [Are there pedestrian rights in Istanbul?]Istanbul3748–51
64.
OnderZ, 2000, “High inflation and returns on residential real estate: evidence from Turkey”Applied Economics32917–931
65.
OtnesCMcGrathM A, 2001, “Perceptions and realities of male shopping behavior”Journal of Retailing77111–137
66.
PhilipsD, 1999, “Narrativised spaces: the functions of story in the theme park”, in Leisure/Tourism Geographies: Practices and Geographical Knowledge Ed. CrouchD (Routledge, London) pp 91–108
67.
PollockG, 2000, “Excerpts from ‘Modernity and the Spaces of Feminity’”, in Gender Space Architecture Eds RendellJPennerBBordenI (Routledge, London) pp 154–167
68.
Radikal2001a, “Moda ve Alisveris” [Fashion and shopping], special supplement, 29 November
69.
Radikal2001b, “Sales (fire) are not put out”, 3 December
70.
Radikal2001c, “Exported by Carrefour”, 5 December
71.
Radikal2001d, “(They) are coming with the (credit) cards”, 7 December
72.
Radikal2002, “Crisis cost 53 billion dollars”, 1 April
73.
RitzerG, 1999Enchanting a Disenchanted World: Revolutionizing the Means of Consumption (Pine Forge Press, Thousand Oaks, CA)
74.
RobertsonR, 1995, “Glocalization: time–space and homogeneity and heterogeneity”, in Global Modernities Ed. FeatherstoneM (Sage, London) pp 25–44
75.
RobinsK, 1996, “Interrupting identities, Turkey/Europe”, in Questions of Cultural Identity Eds HallSDuGuyP (Sage, London) pp 61–86
76.
SassenS, 1991The Global City: New York, London, Tokyo (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
77.
SavageMWardE A, 1993Urban Sociology, Capitalism and Modernity (MacMillan, London)
78.
SchorJ, 2000Do Americans Shop too Much? (Beacon Press, Boston, MA)
79.
SenolF, 1998, “Iktidar Mucadelesinin Savas Meydani Mekan: Cumhuriyet'in Ilk Yillarinda Ankara'da Eglence Mekanlari” [Battlefield of power struggle: space–entertainment facilities in Ankara at the beginning of the Republic]Toplum ve Bilim7686–104
80.
ShieldsR, 1992, “Spaces for the subject of consumption”, in Lifestyle Shopping: The Subject of Consumption Ed. ShieldsR (Routledge, London) pp 1–20
81.
Soysal, 2001Turkiye Perakende Katalogu [Retail catalogue Turkey]Soysal Egitim Danismanlik, M Pehlivan Street 20/2 Gayrettepe, 80290 Istanbul), http://www.soysal.com.tr/
82.
SunerA, 2001, “Bir Baglanti Koparma Araci olarak Turkiye'de Cep Telefonu: Kriz, Goc ve Aidiyet” [Mobile phones in Turkey as a tool for disconnection: crisis, migration and belongingness]Toplum ve Bilim90114–130
83.
TekeliI, 1982, “Baskent Ankara'nin Oykusu” [The story of the Capital Ankara], in Turkiye'de Kentlesme Yazilari Ed. TekeliI (Turhan Kitabevi, Ankara) pp 49–81
84.
TekeliI, 1998, “Turkiye'de Cumhuriyet Doneminde Kentsel Gelisme ve Kent Planlamasi” [Urban development and planning in Turkey in the Republican period], in 75 Yilda Degisen Kent ve Mimarlik Ed. SeyY (Turkiye Ekonomik ve Topiumsal Tarih Vakfi, Istanbul) pp 1–24
85.
TekeliI, 2000, “Bir Modernite Projesi Olarak Turkiye'de Kent Planlamasi” [Urban planning in Turkey as a project of modernity], in Modernite Asilirken Kent Planlamasi Ed. TekeliI (Imge, Ankara) pp 9–34
86.
TokatliN, 1999, “A comparative report on the profiles of retailing in the emerging markets of Europe: Turkey, Poland, Hungary, Portugal and Greece”Journal of Euromarketing875–105
87.
TokatliNBoyaciY, 1998, “The changing retail industry and retail landscapes: the case of post-1980 Turkey”Cities15345–359
88.
TokatliNErkipF, 1998, “Foreign investment in producer services: the Turkish experience in the post-1980 period”Third World Planning Review2087–106
89.
TokmanA, 2001, “Negotiating tradition, modernity and identity in consumer space: a study of a shopping mall and revived coffeehouse”, unpublished master's thesis, Bilkent University, Ankara
90.
ToprakZ, 1995, “Tuketim Oruntuleri ve Osmanli Magazalari” [Consumption patterns and Ottoman stores]Cogito525–28
91.
VanderbeckR MJohnsonJ H, 2000, “That's the only place where you can hang out: urban young people and the space of the mall”Urban Geography215–25
92.
WilliamsD RKaltenbornB P, 1999, “Leisure places and modernity; the use and meaning of recreational cottages in Norway and the USA”, in Leisure/Tourism Geographies: Practices and Geographical Knowledge Ed. CrouchD (Routledge, London) pp 214–230
93.
WilsonE, 1992, “The invisible flaneur”New Left Reviewnumber 191, 90–110
94.
ZukinS, 1995The Cultures of Cities (Blackwell, Oxford)
95.
ZukinS, 1997, “Cultural strategies of economic development and the hegemony of vision”, in The Urbanization of Injustice Eds MerryfieldASwyngedouwE (New York University Press, New York) pp 223–243
96.
ZukinS, 1998, “Urban lifestyles: diversity and standardization in spaces of consumption”Urban Studies35825–839
