Assessments of environmental and territorial justice are similar in that both assess whether empirical relations between the spatial arrangement of undesirable hazards (or desirable public goods and services) and sociodemographic groups are consistent with notions of social justice, evaluating the spatial distribution of benefits and burdens (outcome equity) and the process that produces observed differences (process equity). Using proximity to major highways in New York City as a case study, we review methodological issues pertinent to both fields and discuss choice and computation of exposure measures, but focus primarily on measures of inequity. We present inequity measures computed from the empirically estimated joint distribution of exposure and demographics and compare them with traditional measures such as linear regression, logistic regression, and Theil's entropy index. We find that measures computed from the full joint distribution provide more unified, transparent, and intuitive operational definitions of inequity and show how the approach can be used to structure siting and decommissioning decisions.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AlesinaABaqirREasterlyW, 1999, “Public goods and ethnic divisions”The Quarterly Journal of Economics391243–1284.
2.
AnselinL, 1995, “Local indicators of spatial association—LISA”Geographic Analysis2793–115.
3.
AntunesG EPlumleeJ P, 1977, “The distribution of an urban public service: Ethnicity, socioeconomic status, and bureaucracy as determinants of the quality of neighborhood streets”Urban Affairs Quarterly12313–332.
4.
BeenV, 1994, “Locally undesirable land uses in minority neighborhoods: Disproportionate siting or market dynamics?”Yale Law Review1031383–1422.
5.
BeenVGuptaF, 1997, “Coming to the nuisance or going to the barrios? A longitudinal analysis of environmental justice claims”Ecology Law Quarterly241–56.
6.
BhattacharyaNMahalanobisB, 1967, “Regional disparities in household consumption in India”Journal of the American Statistical Association62143–161.
7.
BolotinF LCingranelliD L, 1983, “Equity and urban policy: The underclass hypothesis revisited”The Journal of Politics45209–219.
8.
BorjasG J, 1995, “Ethnicity, neighborhoods, and human-capital externalities”The American Economic Review85365–390.
9.
BoschkenH L, 1998, “Upper-middle class influence on developmental policy outcomes: The case of transit infrastructure”Urban Studies35627–647.
10.
BoyleJJacobsD, 1982, “The intracity distribution of services: A Multivariate analysis”The American Political Science Review76371–379.
11.
BoyneGPowellM, 1991, “Territorial justice: A Review of theory and evidence”Political Geography Quarterly10263–281.
12.
BugayevskiyL MSnyderJ P, 1995Map Projections: A Reference Manual (Taylor and Francis, London).
13.
ChakrabortyJArmstrongM P, 1997, “Exploring the use of buffer analysis for the identification of impacted areas in environmental equity assessment”Cartography and Geographic Information Systems24145–157.
14.
CingranelliD L, 1981, “Race, politics, and elites: Testing alternative models of municipal service distribution”American Journal of Political Science25664–692.
15.
ClevelandW S, 1993Visualizing Data (Hobart Press, Summit, NJ).
16.
ConceicaoPGalbraithJ K, 1998, “Constructing long and dense time-series of inequality using the Theil index”, WP1, University of Texas Inequality Project, University of Texas, Austin, TX.
17.
ConceicaoPBradfordPGalbraithJ K, 2000, “The Theil index in sequences of nested and hierarchical grouping structures”, WP15, University of Texas Inequality Project, University of Texas, Austin, TX.
18.
CutlerD MGlaeserE L, 1997, “Are ghettos good or bad?”The Quarterly Journal of Economics37827–872.
19.
DaviesB P, 1968Social Needs and Resources in Local Services (Michael Joseph, London).
20.
EfronB, 1978, “Regression and ANOVA with zero–one data: Measures of residual variation”Journal of the American Statistical Association73113–121.
21.
FrickerR DHengartnerN W, 2001, “Environmental equity and the distribution of Toxic Release Inventory and other environmentally undesirable sites in Metropolitan NYC”Environmental and Ecological Statistics833–52.
22.
GeertmanSCMVan EckJ R, 1995, “GIS and models of accessibility potential: An application in planning”International Journal of Geographical Information Systems967–80.
23.
GetisAOrdJ K, 1992, “The analysis of spatial association by use of distance statistics”Geographical Analysis24189–206.
24.
HainingR, 2003Spatial Data Analysis: Theory and Practice (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
25.
KnoxP L, 1980, “Measures of accessibility as social indicators: A Note”Social Indicators Research7367–377.
26.
KottasAGelfandA, 2001, “Bayesian semiparametric median regression modeling”Journal of the American Statistical Association961458–1468.
27.
LiuF, 1997, “Dynamics and causation of environmental equity, locally unwanted land uses, and neighbourhood changes”Environmental Management21643–656.
28.
McMasterR BLeitnerHSheppardE, 1997, “GIS-based environmental equity and risk assessment: Methodological problems and prospects”Cartography and Geographic Information Systems24172–189.
29.
MargaiF L, 2001, “Health risks and environmental inequity: A Geographical analysis of accidental releases of hazardous materials”The Professional Geographer53422–434.
30.
MasseyD SDentonN A, 1993American Apartheid: Segregation and the Making of the Underclass (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA).
31.
MitchellJ TThomasDSKCutterS L, 1999, “Dumping in Dixie revisited: The evolution of environmental injustices in South Carolina”Social Science Quarterly80229–243.
32.
MladenkaK R, 1989, “The distribution of an urban public service: The changing role of race and politics”Urban Affairs Quarterly24556–583.
33.
OakesJ MAndertonD LAndersonA B, 1996, “A longitudinal analysis of environmental equity in communities with hazardous waste facilities”Social Science Research25125–148.
34.
OpenshawS, 1984Concepts and Techniques in Modern Geography 38. The Modifiable Area Unit Problem (GeoAbstracts, Norwich).
35.
OrdJ KGetisA, 1995, “Local spatial autocorrelation statistics: Distributional issues and an application”Geographical Analysis27.
36.
OuisD, 2001, “Annoyance from road traffic noise”Journal of Environmental Psychology21101–120.
37.
PastorM, 2001, “Racial/ethnic inequality in environmental-hazard exposure in Metropolitan Los Angeles”, Brief 13, California Policy Research Center, University of California, Berkeley, CA.
38.
PearsonR LWachtelHEbiK L, 2000, “Distance-weighted traffic density in proximity to home is a risk factor for leukemia and other childhood cancers”Journal of the Air and Waste Management Association50175–180.
39.
PopeC ABurnettR TThunM JCalleE EKrewskiDItoKThurstonG D, 2002, “Lung cancer, cardiopulmonary mortality, and long-term exposure to fine particulate air pollution”Journal of the American Medical Association2871132–1141.
40.
PregibonD, 1981, “Logistic regression diagnostics”Annals of Statistics9705–724.
41.
ScottM SCutterS L, 1997, “Using relative risk indicators to disclose toxic hazard information to communities”Cartography and Geographic Information Systems24158–171.
42.
TalenE, 1997, “The social equity of urban service distribution: An exploration of park access in Pueblo, Colorado, and Macon, Georgia”Urban Geography18521–541.
43.
TalenEAnselinL, 1998, “Assessing spatial equity: An evaluation of measures of accessibility to public playgrounds”Environment and Planning A30595–613.
44.
TalihMFrickerR D, 2002, “Effects of neighbourhood demographic shifts on findings of environmental injustice: A New York City case-study”Journal of the Royal Statistical Society A165375–397.
45.
TheilH, 1967Economics and Information Theory (Rand McNally, Chicago, IL).
46.
United Church of Christ Commission for Racial Justice, 1987Toxic wastes in the United States: A national report on the racial and socioeconomic characteristics of communities with hazardous waste sites (United Church of Christ, New York).
47.
WallaceR, 1990, “Urban desertification, public health and public order: ‘planned shrinkage’, violent death, substance abuse and AIDS in the Bronx”Social Science and Medicine31801–813.
48.
WallerL ALouisT ACarlinB P, 1997, “Bayes methods for combining disease and exposure data in assessing environmental justice”Environmental and Ecological Statistics4267–281.
49.
WallerL ALouisT ACarlinB P, 1999, “Environmental justice and statistical summaries of differences in exposure distributions”Journal of Exposure Analysis and Environmental Epidemiology956–65.
