While urban disamenities and pollution sources have received considerable attention in environmental justice research, few studies have examined sociospatial inequities associated with the distribution of desirable land uses. In this paper we focus on addressing this limitation by investigating the environmental equity implications of street trees—an important publicly financed amenity that provides several direct and indirect benefits to urban residents. The specific objective was to determine if the spatial distribution of public right-of-way trees is equitable with respect to race and ethnicity, income, and housing tenure in the city of Tampa, Florida, USA. We seek to extend research on equity analysis of urban amenities through several methodological innovations, including: (a) accounting for the heterogeneity of urban land use; (b) utilizing high-resolution remote sensing techniques to quantify parcel-specific tree cover; and (c) using multivariate regression models that control for spatial dependence within the data. The results support the inequity hypothesis by indicating a significantly lower proportion of tree cover on public right-of-way in neighborhoods containing a higher proportion of African-Americans, low-income residents, and renters. These findings have important implications for local public investment and policy strategies.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AndersonL MCordellH K, 1988, “Influence of trees on residential property values in Athens, Georgia (USA): A survey based on actual sales prices”Landscape and Urban Planning15153–164
AnselinLBeraA K, 1998, “Spatial dependence in linear regression models with and introduction to spatial econometrics”, in Handbook of Applied Economic Statistics Eds UllahAGilesD E A (Marcel Dekker, New York) pp 237–289
6.
ArnoldH F, 1980Trees in Urban Design (Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York)
7.
BeenV, 1994, “Locally undesirable land uses in minority neighborhoods—disproportionate siting or market dynamics”Yale Law Journal1031383–1422
8.
BooneCModarresA, 2006City and Environment (Temple University Press, Philadelphia, PA)
9.
BooneC GBuckleyG LGroveJ HSisterC, 2009, “Parks and people: An environmental justice inquiry in Baltimore, Maryland”Annals of the Association of American Geographers forthcoming
10.
BowenW MSailingM JHaynesK ECyranE J, 1995, “Toward environmental justice: Spatial equity in Ohio and Cleveland”Annals of the Association of American Geographers85641–663
11.
BrainardJ SJonesA PBatemanI JLovettA AFallonP J, 2002, “Modelling environmental equity: Access to air quality in Birmingham, England”Environment and Planning A34695–716
12.
BrownC J, 2000Tampa in Civil War and Reconstruction (University of Tampa Press, Tampa, FL)
13.
CadenassoM LPickettS T ASchwarzK, 2007, “Spatial heterogeneity in urban ecosystems: Reconceptualizing land cover and a framework for classification”Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment580–88
14.
ChakrabortyJ, 2006, “Evaluating the environmental justice impacts of transportation improvement projects in the US”Transportation Research Part D—Transport and Environment11315–323
15.
ChakrabortyJArmstrongM P, 1997, “Exploring the use of buffer analysis for the identification of impacted areas in environmental equity assessment”Cartography and Geographic Information Systems24145–157
16.
ClintonW J, 1994, “Federal actions to address environmental justice in minority populations and low-income populations: Executive Order 12898 of February 11, 1994”Federal Register7629–7633
17.
ComberABrunsdonCGreenE, 2008, “Using a GIS-based network analysis to determine urban greenspace accessibility for different ethnic and religious groups”Landscape and Urban Planning86103–114
18.
CovingtonD J W, 1957The Story of Southwestern Florida (Lewis Historical Publishing Company, New York)
19.
CutterS L, 1995, “Race, class and environmental justice”Progress in Human Geography19111–122
20.
DuanyAPlater-ZyberkESpeckJ, 2000Suburban Nation: The Rise of Sprawl and the Decline of the American Dream (North Point Press, New York)
21.
DuryeaM LBlakesleeG MHubbardW GVasquezR A, 1996, “Wind and trees: A survey of homeowners after Hurricane Andrew”Journal of Arboriculture2244–50
22.
GoetzS JWrightR KSmithA JZineckerESchaubE, 2003, “IKONOS imagery for resource management: Tree cover, impervious surfaces, and riparian buffer analyses in the mid-Atlantic region”Remote Sensing of Environment88195–208
23.
GreyG WDenekeF J, 1986Urban Forestry (John Wiley, New York)
24.
GroveJ M, 1996The Relationship Between Patterns and Processes of Social Stratification and Vegetation of an Urban–Rural Watershed. PhD dissertation, Department of Social Ecology, Yale University, New Haven, CT
25.
GroveJ MTroyA RO'Neil-DunneJ P MBurchW RCadenassoM LPickettS T A, 2006a, “Characterization of households and its implications for the vegetation of urban ecosystems”Ecosystems9578–597
26.
GroveJ MCadenassoM LBurchW RJrPickettS T ASchwarzKO'Neil-DunneJWilsonMTroyABooneC, 2006b, “Data and methods comparing social structure and vegetation structure of urban neighborhoods in Baltimore, Maryland”Society and Natural Resources19117–136
27.
HCCCPC, 2008, “Tampa Comprehensive Plan update 2nd draft: January, 2008”, Hillsborough County City–County Planning Commission, Tampa, FL, http://plan2025.org/
28.
HCPA, 2007, “Hillsborough County parcel layer”, Hillsborough County Property Appraiser, Tampa, FL, ftp://209.26.172.71/
29.
HewkoJSmoyer-TomicK EHodgsonM J, 2002, “Measuring neighbourhood spatial accessibility to urban amenities: Does aggregation error matter?”Environment and Planning A341185–1206
30.
HeynenN C, 2002The Social Processes Contributing to Urban Environmental Change: Indianapolis' Inner-city Urban Trees, 1962–1993PhD dissertation, Department of Geography, Indiana University, Bloomington, IN
31.
HeynenN, 2006, “Green urban political ecologies: Toward a better understanding of inner-city environmental change”Environment and Planning A38499–516
32.
HeynenN CLindseyG, 2003, “Correlates of urban forest canopy cover: Implications for local public works”Public Works Management and Policy833–47
33.
HeynenNPerkinsH ARoyP, 2006, “The political ecology of uneven urban green space—the impact of political economy on race and ethnicity in producing environmental inequality in Milwaukee”Urban Affairs Review423–25
34.
JacobsJ, 1993The Death and Life of Great American Cities (Random House, New York)
35.
JacobsonJ OHengartnerN WLouisT A, 2005, “Inequity measures for evaluations of environmental justice: A case study of close proximity to highways in New York City”Environment and Planning A3721–43
36.
JensenRGatrellJBoultonJHarperB, 2004, “Using remote sensing and geographic information systems to study urban quality of life and urban forest amenities”Ecology and Society9(5), http://www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol9/iss5/art5/
37.
JimC YLiuH H T, 1997, “Storm damage on urban trees in Guangzhou, China”Landscape and Urban Planning3845–59
38.
KisslingW DCarlG, 2008, “Spatial autocorrelation and the selection of simultaneous autoregressive models”Global Ecology and Biogeography1759–71
39.
KuoF ESullivanW C, 2001a, “Aggression and violence in the inner city—effects of environment via mental fatigue”Environment and Behavior33543–571
40.
KuoF ESullivanW C, 2001b, “Environment and crime in the inner city—does vegetation reduce crime?”Environment and Behavior33343–367
41.
KweonB-SSullivanW CWileyA R, 1998, “Green common spaces and the social integration of inner-city older adults”Environment and Behavior30832–858
42.
LaurianL, 2008, “Environmental injustice in France”Journal of Environmental Planning and Management5155–79
43.
LindseyGMarajMKuanS, 2001, “Access, equity, and urban greenways: An exploratory investigation”The Professional Geographer53332–346
44.
LiuF, 1997, “Dynamics and causation of environmental equity, locally unwanted land uses, and neighborhood changes”Environmental Management21643–656
45.
LiuF, 2001Environmental Justice Analysis: Theories, Methods and Practice (Lewis Publishers, Boca Raton, FL)
LovasiG SQuinnJ WNeckermanK MPerzanowskiM SRundleA, 2008, “Children living in areas with more street trees have lower prevalence of asthma”Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health62647–649
48.
McPhersonE G, 1994, “Energy-saving potential of trees in Chicago”, in Chicago's Urban Forest Ecosystem: Results of the Chicago Urban Forest Climate Project Eds McPhersonE GNowakD JRowntreeR A (US Department of Agriculture, Radnor, PA) pp 95–113
49.
MaioTFulceBMohlmanGCapannaD, 1998, “Hillsborough County historic resources survey report”, Hillsborough County Planning and Growth Management, Tampa, FL
50.
MartinC AWarrenP SKinzigA P, 2004, “Neighborhood socioeconomic status is a useful predictor of perennial landscape vegetation in residential neighborhoods and embedded small parks of Phoenix, AZ”Landscape and Urban Planning69355–368
51.
MennisJ LJordanL, 2005, “The distribution of environmental equity: Exploring spatial nonstationarity in multivariate models of air toxic releases”Annals of the Association of American Geographers95249–268
MohaiPBryantB, 1992, “Environmental racism: Reviewing the evidence”, in Race and the Incidence of Environmental Hazards: A Time for Discourse Eds MohaiPBryantB (Westview Press, Boulder, CO) pp 163–175
54.
MorminoG RPozzettaG E, 1998The Immigrant World of Ybor City: Italians and their Latin Neighbors in Tampa, 1885–1985 (University Press of Florida, Gainesville, FL)
55.
NowakD J, 1994, “Air pollution removal by Chicago's urban forest”, in Chicago's Urban Forest Ecosystem: Results of the Chicago Urban Forest Climate Project Eds McPhersonE GNowakD JRowntreeR A (US Department of Agriculture, Radnor, PA) pp 63–81
56.
NowakD JDwyerJ F, 2007Understanding the Benefits and Costs of Urban Forest Ecosystems (Springer, New York)
57.
OkeT R, 1989, “The micrometeorology of the urban forest”Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, Series B: Biological Sciences324335–349
58.
PastorMSaddJHippJ, 2001, “Which came first? Toxic facilities, minority move-in, and environmental justice”Journal of Urban Affairs231–21
59.
PastorMMorello-FroschRSaddJ L, 2005, “The air is always cleaner on the other side: Race, space, and ambient air toxics exposures in California”Journal of Urban Affairs27127–148
60.
PearceJKinghamSZawar-RezaP, 2006, “Every breath you take? Environmental justice and air pollution in Christchurch, New Zealand”Environment and Planning A38919–938
61.
PedlowskiM ADa SilvaV A CAdellJ J CHeynenN C, 2002, “Urban forest and environmental inequality in Campos dos Goytacazes, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil”Urban Ecosystems69–20
62.
PerkinsH AHeynenNWilsonJ, 2004, “Inequitable access to urban reforestation: The impact of urban political economy on housing tenure and urban forests”Cities21291–299
63.
PulidoL, 2000, “Rethinking environmental racism: White privilege and urban development in southern California”Annals of the Association of American Geographers9012–40
SwyngedouwEHeynenN C, 2003, “Urban political ecology, justice and the politics of scale”Antipode35898–918
71.
TakanoTNakamuraKWatanabeM, 2002, “Urban residential environments and senior citizens' longevity in megacity areas: The importance of walkable green spaces”Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health56913–918
72.
TalarchekG M, 1990, “The urban forest of New-Orleans—an exploratory analysis of relationships”Urban Geography1165–86
73.
TalenE, 1997, “The social equity of urban service distribution an exploration of park access in Pueblo, Colorado, and Macon, Georgia”Urban Geography18521–541
74.
TalenEAnselinL, 1998, “Assessing spatial equity: An evaluation of measures of accessibility to public playgrounds”Environment and Planning A30595–613
75.
TroyA RGroveJ MO'Neil-DunneJ P MPickettS T ACadenassoM L, 2007, “Predicting opportunities for greening and patterns of vegetation on private urban lands”Journal of Environmental Management40394–412
76.
TyrvainenLMiettinenA, 2000, “Property prices and urban forest amenities”Journal of Environmental Economics and Management39205–223
77.
United Church of Christ, 1987Toxic Wastes and Race in the United StatesUnited Church of Christ, Commission for Racial Justice, New York
US General Accounting Office, 1983Siting of Hazardous Waste Landfills and the Correlation with Racial and Economic Status of Surrounding Communities (Government Printing Office, Washington, DC)
