There has been little discussion on urban Indigenous identity in post-settler societies. However, in the scarce works which exist on this issue there are some remarkably common traits. For most Indigenous people, identity has primarily involved kinship ties associated with their perceived place of origin. In the city, Indigenous people encounter other Indigenous people who cannot be identified through kinship ties; in this situation, organizations dealing with Indigenous issues provide ways of connecting nonrelated Indigenous people, in line with a notion of ‘pan-Indigeneity’. This pan-Indigeneity is not only based on their experience in the city, but also is influenced by the ‘antique’ image of Indigenous people created through contact with European settlers as well as the common cultural mores and traits which Indigenous people share. With these different kinds of identities, urban Indigenous identity has been described as ‘fluid’ or ‘ambiguous’. The relationship between these identities has not been much examined. This paper explores the ambiguous and dynamic nature of Aboriginal identity in southwestern Sydney. Even though they are not related, Aboriginal people can usually recognize each other as ‘Aboriginal’ through certain cultural mores and traits. However, there are some who, although claiming to be Aboriginal, who do not share these cultural mores and traits. Their presence gives rise to tension and conflict revolving around the concept of Aboriginality. Through an ethnographical examination of the process of accommodating nonrelated Aboriginal people, this paper reveals how different kinds of identities are related to each other in urban situations.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ABS, 1971Population CensusAustralian Bureau of Statistics.
AndersonK, 1998, “Reflections on Redfern”, in Urban Life Urban Culture: Proceedings of the Conference Hosted by the Goolangullia Centre, University of Western Sydney, Macarthur, November 27–29 1997 Ed. MorganG (University of Western Sydney, Campbelltown) pp 200–214.
4.
AoyagiM, 1999, “Gyogyohosho to Toshi no Maori tachi: Iwi wo Meguru Ronso”, in Senjumin to Toshi: Jinruigaku no Atarashii Chihei Eds AoyagiKMatsuyamaT (Aoki Shoten, Tokyo) pp 59–77.
5.
ArissR, 1988, “Writing black: The construction of an Aboriginal discourse”, in Aborigines and Change Ed. BerndtR M (Australian Institute of Aboriginal Studies, Canberra) pp 131–146.
6.
Bankstown City Council, 2004Strong Communities Better Living: Bankstown City Council Social PlanBankstown City Council, Bankstown.
7.
BarwickD, 1964, “The self-conscious people of Melbourne”, in Aborigines Now: New Perspective in the Study of Aboriginal Communities Ed. ReayM (Angus and Robertson, Sydney) pp 20–31.
8.
BarwickD, 1988 [1971], “Aborigines of Victoria”, in Being Black: Aboriginal Cultures in ‘Settled’ Australia Ed. KeenI (Aboriginal Studies Press, Canberra) pp 27–32.
9.
BeasleyP, 1970, “The Aboriginal household in Sydney”, in Attitudes and Social Conditions Eds TaftRDawsonJLMBeasleyP (Australian National University Press, Canberra) pp 137–187.
10.
BeckettJ, 1988, “The past in the present; the present in the past: Constructing a national Aboriginality”, in Past and Present: The Construction of Aboriginality Ed. BeckettJ (Aboriginal Studies Press, Canberra) pp 191–217.
11.
BerndtR M, 1977, “Aboriginal identity: Reality or mirage”, in Aborigines and Change Ed. BerndtR M (Australian Institute of Aboriginal Studies, Canberra) pp 1–12.
12.
BrodyH, 1971Indians on Skid RowOttawa Department of Indian Affairs, Ottawa.
13.
Campbelltown City Council, 2004aCampbelltown City Council: Aboriginal Service Plan 2003–2007Campbelltown City Council, Campbelltown.
14.
Campbelltown City Council, 2004bCampbelltown City Social Plan December 2004—November 2009Campbelltown City Council, Campbelltown.
15.
CapellA, 1970–71, “Aboriginal languages in the South Central Coast, New South Wales: Fresh discoveries”Oceania41 (1) 20–27.
16.
CarterJ D, 1988, “Am I too black to go with you?”, in Being Black: Aboriginal Cultures in ‘Settled’ Australia Ed. KeenI (Aboriginal Studies Press, Canberra) pp 65–76.
17.
CollinsJPoyntingS, 2000, “Introduction: Communities, identities and inequalities in western Sydney”, in The Other Sydney: Communities, Identities and Inequalities in Western Sydney Eds CollinsJPoyntingS (Common Ground, Melbourne) pp 19–33.
18.
CookeMBelangerD, 2006, “Migration theories and First Nations mobility: Towards a systems perspective”The Canadian Review of Sociology and Anthropology43141–151.
19.
CrickM, 1981, “Aboriginal self-management organisations, cultural identity and the modification of exchange”Canberra Anthropology4 (1) 52–81.
20.
DanzigerE J, 1991Survival and Regeneration: Detroit's American Indian Community (Wayne State University Press, Detroit, MI).
21.
DelbridgeABernardJRLBlairDButlerSPetersPYallopC, 2001The Macquarie Dictionary: Australia's National Dictionary (Macquarie Library, North Ryde).
22.
EadesD K, 1976The Dharawal and Dhurga Languages of the New South Wales South Coast (Australian Institute of Aboriginal Studies, Canberra).
23.
EverettK, 2006Impossible Realities: The Emergence of Traditional Aboriginal Cultural Practices in Sydney's Western Suburbs PhD thesis, Department of Anthropology, Macquarie University, North Ryde, NSW.
24.
Fairfield City Council, 1999Fairfield Community Profile 1999Fairfield City Council, Wakeley.
25.
Fairfield City Council, 2003State of the Community Report November 2003Fairfield City Council, Wakeley.
26.
FenelonJ V, 1998, “Discrimination and Indigenous identity in Chicago's native community”American Indian Culture and Research Journal22273–303.
27.
FinkR, 1957, “The caste barrier—an obstacle to the assimilation of part-Aborigines in North West New South Wales”Oceania28 (2) 100–110.
28.
GaleF, 1972Urban Aborigines (Australian National University Press, Canberra).
29.
GaleF, 1981No Relation, Poor Fella—The City Aborigines'DilemmaNorthern Territory University Planning Authority, Darwin.
30.
GaleFWundersitzJ, 1982Adelaide Aborigines: A Case Study in Urban Life 1966–1981 (Australian National University, Canberra).
31.
GonzaresA, 2001, “Urban (transformations: Changes in the meaning and use of American Indian identity”, in American Indians and the Urban Experience Eds LoboSPetersK (Altamira Press, New York) pp 169–185.
32.
GoverK, 2002, “Urban Maori in Aotearoa/New Zealand”Indigenous Affairs3/460–70.
33.
GuilleminJ, 1975Urban Renegades: The Cultural Strategy of American Indians (Columbia University Press, New York).
34.
InglisJ, 1961, “Aborigines in Adelaide”The Journal of the Polynesian Society70200–218.
35.
InglisJ, 1964, “Dispersal of Aboriginal families in South Australia (1860–1960)”, in Aborigines Now: New Perspective in the Study of Aboriginal Communities Ed. ReayM (Angus and Robertson, Sydney) pp 115–132.
36.
JacksonD D, 1998, “‘This hole in our heart’: Urban Indian identity and the power of silence”American Indian Culture and Research Journal22227–254.
37.
JacobsJ, 1988, “The construction of identity”, in Past and Present: The Construction of Aboriginality Ed. BeckettJ (Aboriginal Studies Press, Canberra) pp 31–43.
38.
JordanD, 1988, “Aboriginal identity: Uses of the past, problems for the future?”, in Past and Present: The Construction of Aboriginality Ed. BeckettJ (Aboriginal Studies Press, Canberra) pp 109–130.
39.
KawharuI H, 1968, “Urban immigrants and Tangata Whenua”, in The Maori People in the Nineteen-sixties: A Symposium Ed. SchwimmerE (Blackwood and Janet Paul, Auckland).
40.
KeatingC J, 1995On the Frontier: A Social History of Liverpool (Hale and Iremonger, Sydney).
41.
KishigamiN, 2002, “Urban Inuit in Canada: A case from Montreal”Indigenous Affairs3–454–59.
42.
LambertC, 1986, “Aboriginal ethnicity in a Canadian urban context”, in Ethnicity and Multiculturalism in Canada: An Anthropological Study Ed. AyabeT (University of Tsukuba, Ibaragi) pp 3–32.
43.
LiebowE B, 1991, “Urban Indian institutions in Phoenix: Transformation from headquarters city to community”Journal of Ethnic Studies181–27.
44.
Liverpool City Council, 2003Liverpool City Council, Social Plan 1999–2003Liverpool City Council, Liverpool.
45.
Liverpool City Council, 2005Liverpool City Council Social Plan 2004–2005Liverpool City Council, Liverpool.
46.
LoboS, 2001, “Is urban a person or a place?”, in American Indians and the Urban Experience Eds LoboSPetersK (Altamira Press, New York) pp 73–84.
47.
MaakaRCA, “The new tribe—conflicts and continuities in the social organizations of urban Maori”The Contemporary Pacific6311–336.
48.
MacdonaldG, 1986The Koori Way PhD dissertation, Department of Anthropology, University of Sydney.
49.
MathewsR H, 1901, “The Thurrawal language”Journal of the Proceedings of the Royal Society of New South Wales35127–160.
50.
MetgeJ A, 1964New Maori Migration: Rural and Urban Relations in Northern New Zealand (The Athone Press, London).
51.
MorganG, 2000Broadacre Assimilation: Aboriginal Australians and Urban Migration PhD dissertation, Department of Sociology, Macquarie University, North Ryde.
52.
MorganG, 2006Unsettled Places: Aboriginal People and Urbanisation in New South Wales (Wakefield Press, Kent Town, SA).
53.
MorganS, 1987My Place (Fremantle Arts Centre Press, Fremantle, WA).
54.
MorrisB, 1988a, “Dhan-Gadi resistance to assimilation”, in Being Black: Aboriginal Culture in ‘Settled’ Australia Ed. KeenI (Aboriginal Studies Press, Canberra) pp 33–64.
55.
MorrisB, 1988b, “The politics of identity: From Aborigines to the first Australian”, in Past and Present: The Construction of Aboriginality Ed. BeckettJ (Aboriginal Studies Press, Canberra) pp 63–85.
56.
NaglerM, 1970Indians in the City: A Study of the Urbanization of Indians in Toronto (St. Paul University, Ottawa).
57.
NewhouseDPetersE (Eds), 2003Not Strangers in These Parts: Urban Aboriginal PeoplesPolicy Research Initiative, Ottawa.
PetersE, 2005, “Indigeneity and marginalisation: Planning for and with urban Aboriginal communities in Canada”Progress in Planning63327–404.
60.
Peters-LittleF, 2000The Community Game: Aboriginal Self-Definition at the Local Level (Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies, Canberra).
61.
PiersonJ C, 1977, “Voluntary organisations and Australian Aboriginal urban adaptations in Adelaide”Oceania4846–58.
62.
PiersonJ C, 1982, “Aboriginal power and self determination in Adelaide”, in Aboriginal Power in Australian Society Ed. HowardM (University of Queensland Press, St. Lucia) pp 184–213.
63.
PlaterD, 1993Other Boundaries: Inner-city Aboriginal Stories: Part One of an Aboriginal History of the Leichhardt Municipality of SydneyLeichhardt Municipal Council, Leichhardt.
64.
PlaterD, 1995, “Aboriginal people and ‘community’ in the Leichhardt municipality”, in Minorities: Cultural Diversity in Sydney Eds FitzgeraldSWotherspoonG (State Library of New South Wales Press, Sydney) pp 35–49.
65.
ProulxC, 2003Reclaiming Aboriginal Justice, Identity, and Community (Purich Publishing, Sakatoon).
66.
ReadP, 1982The Stolen Generations: The Removal of Aboriginal Children in New South Wales 1883 to 1969 (Government Printer, Sydney).
ReidC, 2002, “Urban Aboriginal communities in Canada”Indigenous Affairs3/448–53.
69.
RowleyC D, 1971The Remote Aborigines (Australian National University Press, Canberra).
70.
RowseT, 2002Indigenous Futures: Choice and Development for Aboriginal and Islander Australia (University of New South Wales, Sydney).
71.
SansomB, 1982, “The Aboriginal commonality”Aboriginal Sites, Rights, and Resource Development Ed. BerndtR M (University of Western Australia Press, Nederlands) pp 117–138.
72.
SchwabJ, 1988, “Ambiguity, style and kinship in Adelaide Aboriginal identity”, in Being Black: Aboriginal Cultures in ‘Settled’ Australia Ed. KeenI (Aboriginal Studies Press, Canberra) pp 77–96.
73.
ShoemakerN, 1988, “Urban Indians and ethnic choices: American Indian organizations in Minneapolis, 1920–1950”The Western History Quarterly19431–447.
74.
SissonsJ, 2004, “Maori tribalism and post-settler nationhood in New Zealand”Oceania7519–31.
75.
SmithH MBiddleE H, 1975Look Forward, Not Back: Aborigines in Metropolitan Brisbane 1965–1966 (Australian National University Press, Canberra).
Statistics New Zealand20062006 CensusStatistics New Zealand, Wellington.
78.
StaveleyMOF, 1993Redfern Religion: Aboriginal Identity in Christian Practice MPhil dissertation, Department of Anthropology, University of Sydney.
79.
TaksaL, 1999, “Technology, work, gender and citizenship at the Eveleigh railway workshops precinct: An historical interpretation of landscape, identity and mobilisation”Labour History76153–162.
80.
TapsellP, 2002, “Marae and tribal identity in urban Aotearoa/New Zealand”Pacific Studies25141–171.
81.
TindaleN B, 1974Aboriginal Tribes of Australia (Australian National University Press, Canberra).
Van MeijlT, 2006, “Multiple identifications and the dialogical self: Urban Maori youngsters and the cultural renaissance”Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute12917–933.
84.
von StunnerJ, 1981, “Talking with Aborigines”Australian Institute of Aboriginal Studies Newsletter New Series 1513–30.
85.
WaddellJWatsonR (Eds), 1971American Indian in Urban Society (Little, Brown, Boston, MA).
86.
WebsterS, 2002, “Maori retribalization and treaty rights to the New Zealand fisheries”Contemporary Pacific14341–376.
87.
Weibel-OrlandoJ, 1991Indian Country, LA: Maintaining Ethnic Community in Complex Society (University of Illinois Press, Urbana, IL).
