This study examines changes in enforcement styles among environmental enforcement officials in the context of China's rapidly changing institutional environments, using panel data collected in Guangzhou in 2000 and 2006. Altogether, five enforcement style elements were examined—accommodation, prioritization, educational, formalism, and coercion. It was found that in 2006 respondents reported greater reliance on education, formalism, and coercion than in 2000. During the same period 2000–06, no significant changes were found for the enforcement styles of accommodation and prioritization or in the respondents' perceptions of their organization's enforcement effectiveness. From regression models in which enforcement styles were used to predict perceived organizational enforcement effectiveness, it was observed that the coefficient for formalism had changed substantially over this period, from being significantly negative to significantly positive, which may be evidence of a general shift from ‘rule by man’ to ‘rule by law’ in China. This study has benefited from the concept of regulatory enforcement style elements, as it allows for an empirical understanding of regulatory enforcement beyond the common and normative dichotomy of deterrence versus cooperation.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AlfordW PLiebmanB L, 2001, “Clean air, clean processes? The struggle over air pollution law in the People's Republic of China”Hastings Law Journal52703–748
2.
AyresIBraithwaiteJ, 1992Responsive Regulation: Transcending the Deregulation Debate (Oxford University Press, New York)
3.
BardachEKaganR, 1982Going by the Book: The Problem of Regulatory Unreasonableness (Temple University Press, Philadelphia, PA)
4.
BeckerG S, 1968, “Crime and punishment, an economic approach”Journal of Political Economy76169–217
5.
BraithwaiteJWalkerJGraboskyP, 1987, “An enforcement taxonomy of regulatory agencies”Law and Policy9323–351
6.
BurnsJ P, 1999, “Changing environmental impacts on civil service systems: The cases of China and Hong Kong”, in Handbook of Comparative Public Administration in the Asia-Pacific Basin Eds WongHChanH S (Marcel Dekker, New York) pp 179–219
7.
ChanH SCheungK CLoJ M K, 1993, “Environmental control in the PRC”, in Public Policy in China Eds NagelS SMillsM K (Greenwood Press, Westport, CT) pp 63–83
8.
ChanH SWongK-KCheungK CLoJ M-K, 1995, “The implementation gap in environmental management in China, the case of Guangzhou, Zhengzhou, and Nanjing”Public Administration Review55333–340
9.
DasguptaSWheelerD, 1997Citizen Complaints as Environmental Indicators: Evidence from China (World Bank, Washington, DC)
10.
DasguptaSLaplanteBMaminguNWangH, 2000, “Industrial environmental performance in China: The impact of inspections”, World Bank Policy Research WP 2000
11.
Ecological Environment and Protection, 2001, “The investment on environmental protection increased every year in the ‘Ninth Five-Year Plan’ period”56 (in Chinese)
12.
EconomyE, 2004The River Runs Black: The Environmental Challenge to China's Future (Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY)
13.
FerrisR JJrZhangH J, 2002, “The challenges of reforming an environmental legal culture: Assessing the status quo and looking at post-admission WTO challenges for the People's Republic of China”Georgetown International Environmental Law Review14429–460
14.
FrankNLombnessM, 1988, “Gaining regulatory compliance: Law enforcement and power in an interactionist perspective”Administration and Society2071–91
15.
GormleyW TJr, 1998, “Regulatory enforcement styles”Political Research Quarterly51363–383
16.
GrayWScholzJ T, 1991, “Analyzing the equity and efficiency of OSHA enforcement”Law and Policy13185–214
17.
CunninghamN, 1987, “Negotiated non-compliance: A case study of regulatory failure”Law and Policy969–91
18.
CunninghamNNorberryJMcKillopS (Eds), 1992Environmental Crime (Australian Institute of Criminology, Griffith, ACT)
19.
HawkinsK, 1984Environment and Enforcement: Regulation and the Social Definition of Pollution (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
20.
HoP, 2001, “Greening without conflict? Environmentalism, NGOs and civil society in China”Development and Change32893–921
21.
HoPEdmondsR L, 2008China's Embedded Activism: Opportunities and Constraints of a Social Movement (Routledge, London)
22.
HutterB M, 1989, “Variations in regulatory enforcement styles”Law and Policy11153–174
23.
JahielA R, 1997, “The contradictory impact of reform and environmental protection”The China Quarterly14981–103
24.
JahielA R, 1998, “The organization of environmental protection in China”The China Quarterly156757–787
25.
KaganR A, 1994, “Regulatory enforcement”, in Handbook of Regulation and Administrative Law Eds RosenblumDSchwarzR (Marcel Dekker, New York) pp 383–422
26.
KaganR A, 2000, “Introduction: Comparing national styles of regulation in Japan and the United States”Law and Policy22225–244
27.
KaganR AScholzJ T, 1984, “The criminology of the corporation and regulatory enforcement styles”, in Enforcing Regulation Eds HawkinsKThomasJ (Kluwer-Nijhoff, Boston, MA) pp 67–95
28.
LangbeinL I, 2002, “Responsive bureaus, equity, and regulatory negotiation: An empirical view”Journal of Policy Analysis and Management21449–465
29.
LoC W H, 1994, “Environmental management by law in China: The Guangzhou experience”The Journal of Contemporary China639–58
30.
LoC W HChungS S, 2003, “China's green challenges in the 21st century”, in China's Challenges in the Twenty-First Century Ed. ChengJ Y S (City University of Hong Kong Press, Hong Kong) pp 719–769
31.
LoC W HFryxellG E, 2003, “Environmental styles among environmental officials in China”Journal of Public Policy2381–115
32.
LoC W HFryxellG E, 2005, “Governmental and societal support for environmental enforcement in China: An empirical study in Guangzhou”The Journal of Development Studies41558–589
33.
LoC W HLeungS W, 2000, “Environmental agency and public opinion in Guangzhou: The limits of a popular approach to environmental governance”The China Quarterly163677–704
34.
LoC W HTangS Y, 2006, “Institutional reform, economic changes and local environmental management”Environmental Politics15190–210
35.
LoC W HFryxellG EWongW W-H, 2006, “Effective regulations with little effect? The antecedents of the perceptions of environmental officials on enforcement effectiveness in China”Environmental Management38388–410
36.
MaXOrtolanoL, 2000Environmental Regulation in China: Institutions, Enforcement, and Compliance (Rowman and Littlefield, Totowa, NJ)
37.
MayP JWinterS, 1999, “Regulatory enforcement and compliance: Examining Danish agro-environmental policy”Journal of Policy Analysis and Management18625–651
38.
MayP JWoodR S, 2003, “At the regulatory front lines: Inspectors' regulatory styles and regulatory compliance”Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory13117–139
39.
OECD, 2007OECD Environmental Performance Reviews: China (OECD, Paris)
40.
PalmerM, 1998, “Environmental regulation in the People's Republic of China: The face of domestic law”The China Quarterly156788–808
41.
Pearl River Environment News2006, “Constructing harmony, pursuing excellence: The first special issue on the original record of the Guangzhou classic on achieving a model city”, Guangzhou Environmental Education and Publicity Centre, Guangzhou (in Chinese)
42.
PeerenboomR, 2002China's Long March toward Rule of Law (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
43.
ReissAJr, 1984, “Selecting strategies of social control over organizational life”, in Enforcing Regulation Eds HawkinsKThomasJ (Kluwer-Nijhoff, Boston, MA)
44.
RichardsonGOgusABurrowsP, 1983Policing Pollution: A Study of Regulation and Enforcement (Oxford University Press, New York)
45.
ScholzJ T, 1984, “Cooperation, deterrence and the ecology of regulatory enforcement”Law and Society Review18601–646
46.
ScholzJ TGrayW B, 1997, “Can government facilitate cooperation? An informational model of OSHA enforcement”American Journal of Political Science41693–717
47.
ScholzJ TTomblyT JHeadrickB, 1991, “Street level political controls over federal bureaucracy”American Political Science Review85829–850
48.
SinkuleBOrtolanoL, 1995Implementing Environmental Policy in China (Praeger, New York)
49.
StalleyPYangD N, 2006, “An emerging environmental movement in China?”The China Quarterly186333–356
50.
State Environmental Protection Administration, 2000–2006China Environment Statistical Report 2000–2006(Zhongguo Huanjing Kexue Chubanshe, Beijing) (in Chinese)
51.
SwansonK EKuhnR GXuWei, 2001, “Environmental policy implementation in rural China: A case study of Yuhang, Zhejiang”Environmental Management27481–491
52.
TangS-YLoC W HCheungK-CLoJ M-K, 1997, “Institutional constraints on environmental management in urban China: Environmental impact assessment in Guangzhou and Shanghai”China Quarterly152863–874
53.
TangS YLoC W HFryxellG E, 2003, “Enforcement styles, organizational commitment, and enforcement effectiveness: An empirical study of local environmental protection officials in urban China”Environment and Planning A3575–94
54.
TiltB, 2007, “The political ecology of pollution enforcement in China: A case of Sichuan's rural industrial sector”China Quarterly192915–933
55.
Van RooijB, 2002, “Implementing Chinese environmental law through enforcement, the shiwu xiao and shuangge dabiao campaigns”, in The Implementation of Law in the People's Republic of China Eds ChenJLiYOttoJ M (Kluwer Law International, The Hague) pp 149–178
56.
Van RooijB, 2003, “Environmental law enforcement in Sichuan: Organization and procedure in comparative perspective”China Information1736–65
57.
Van RooijB, 2006Regulating Land and Pollution in China, Lawmaking, Compliance, and Enforcement; Theory and Cases (Leiden University Press, Leiden)
58.
WangHWheelerD, 2000, “Endogenous enforcement and effectiveness of China's pollution levy system”, World Bank Policy Research Working Paper
59.
WangHMamingiNLaplanteBDasguptaS, 2003, “Incomplete enforcement of pollution regulation: Bargaining power of Chinese factories”Environmental and Resource Economics24245–262
60.
WarwickMOrtolanoL, 2007, “Benefits and costs of Shanghai's environmental citizen complaints system”China InformationXXI237–269
61.
WoodD, 1988, “Principals, bureaucrats, and responsiveness in clean air enforcement”American Political Science Review82213–237
62.
WoodDWatermanR W, 1991, “The dynamics of political control of the bureaucracy”American Political Science Review85801–828
63.
YangG, 2005, “Environmental NGOs and institutional dynamics in China”China Quarterly18146–66
64.
ZhangL, 2002Ecologizing Industrialization in Chinese Small TownsPhD thesis, Wageningen University, Wageningen
