Chinese cities are undergoing massive transformation. One after another, inner-city neighbourhoods of pre-1949 origin and work-unit compounds built in the socialist period are being torn apart, giving way to glossy office towers and luxurious condominiums. Millions of people have been uprooted and forced to be relocated. Mass media and research based on case studies generally convey a message of widespread grievance among the displaced residents. Based on a survey of 1200 households conducted in Shanghai in 2006, the present study provides a systematic account of the profiles of the displaced residents, juxtaposed against other resident groups of the city. The major conclusion is that, irrespective of all the criticisms concerning unregulated demolitions and forced evictions, the housing conditions of displaced residents are somewhat better than those of other Shanghai residents, both objectively and in terms of subjective evaluations.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbramsonD, 1998, “Juzhuqu gaizao zuowei yige wenhua wenti: Cong xifang de jiaodu kan Beijing de jiucheng gaizao” [Neighbourhood redevelopment as a cultural problem: A Western perspective on current plans for the Old City of Beijing]Jianzhu Xuebao [Journal of Architecture]247–49, 68
2.
CartierC, 2002, “Transnational urbanism in the reform-era Chinese city: Landscapes from Shenzhen”Urban Studies391513–1532
3.
ChenY, 1997, “Jiucheng gaizao yao jiaqiang chengshi guihua de hongguan tiaokong zuoyong” [Urban reconstruction needs to strengthen the macro-control function of city planning]Chengshi Guihua Huikan [City Planning Forum]240–45
4.
DaiC, 1999, “Jiucheng lao linliqu gengxin gaizao de zhengti sixiang-guanyu juzhu huanjing xieji guannian de sikao” [The overall thinking on the renewal and reconstruction of old neighbourhoods in the old city: Thoughts on residential environmental design]Chengshi Yanjiu (Urban Research)343–47
5.
DavisD S (Ed.), 2000The Consumer Revolution in Urban China (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
6.
ElsingaMHoekstraJ, 2005, “Homeownership and housing satisfaction”Journal of Housing and the Built Environment20401–424
7.
FangKZhangY, 2003, “Plan and market mismatch: Urban development in Beijing during a period of transition”Asia Pacific Viewpoint44149–162
8.
FangY, 2006, “Residential satisfaction, moving intention and moving behaviours: A study of redeveloped neighbourhoods in inner-city Beijing”Housing Studies21671–694
9.
FangZ, 2001, “Duoyuan de gongsheng: Lishi diduan gaizao gengxin de xianshi daolu–yi Shanghai Shi linong zhuzhai de jiuqu gaizao weili” [Multisymbiosis: Realistic path of renewal of historical districts—an example of lane housing district reconstruction in Shanghai City]Tongji Daxue Xuebao [Tongji University Academic Journal]417–21, 56
10.
GuJLiuF, 1997, “Shanghai dongcaiqian wenti yanjiu” [A study on resettlement and demolition in Shanghai]Shanghai Shehui Kesheyuan Jikan [Quarterly of the Shanghai Academy of the Social Sciences]3140–148
11.
HeSWuF, 2005, “Property-led redevelopment in post-reform China: A case study of Xintiandi redevelopment project in Shanghai”Journal of Urban Affairs271–23
12.
HeSWuF, 2007, “Socio-spatial impacts of property-led redevelopment on China's urban neighbourhoods”Cities24194–208
13.
HuangY QClarkW A V, 2002, “Housing tenure choice in transition China: A multilevel analysis”Urban Studies397–32
14.
LiS-M, 2005, “China's changing urban geography: A review of major forces at work”Issues and Studies4167–106
15.
LiZ, 1997, “Shiying shichang jingji fazhan tuijin chengshi fangwu chaiqian” [Adjust to market economy and promote demolition of urban housing]Changjiang Jianshe [Yangtze Construction]64–5
16.
LiZWuF, 2006, “Socio-spatial differentiation and residential inequalities in Shanghai: A case study of three neighbourhoods”Housing Studies21695–717
17.
LiuZGuiGChenZ, 2007Chengshi Duihua: Guojixing Dadushi Jianshe yu Zhufang Tanjiu [City dialogue: An inquiry of construction and housing in international metropolises] [Enterprise Management Publishing House, Beijing]
18.
LoC P, 1987, “Socialist ideology and urban strategies in China”Urban Geography8440–458
19.
LoganJ RMolotchH L, 1987Urban Fortunes: The Political Economy of Place (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
20.
LuJ, 1997, “Beijing's old and dilapidated housing renewal”Cities14(2) 59–69
21.
MaL J CWuF (Ed.), 2005Restructuring the Chinese City: Changing Society, Economy and Space (Routledge, London)
22.
McCreaRStimsonRWesternJ, 2005, “Testing a moderated model of satisfaction with urban living using data for Brisbane–South East Queensland, Australia”Social Indicators Research72121–152
23.
MurdieR A, 1976, “Factorial ecology of Metropolitan Toronto 1951–1961”, RP 116, Department of Geography, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL
24.
ParkesAKearnsAAtkinsonR, 2002, “What makes people dissatisfied with their neighbourhoods?”Urban Studies392413–2438
25.
QiuJ, 2002, “Junshenhua yundong dui woguo jiucheng gengxin de qishi” [Implications of gentrification for urban renewal in our country]Redai Dili [Tropical Geography]22(2) 30–34
Shanghai Ministry of Construction, 2005, unpublished document
28.
StoneC N, 1993, “Urban regime and the capacity to govern: A political economy approach”Journal of Urban Affairs151–28
29.
TangW S, 1994, “Urban land development under socialism: China between 1947 and 1997”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research18395–415
30.
WangDLiS, 2004, “Housing preferences in a transitional housing system: The case of Beijing, China”Environment and Planning A3669–87
31.
WangDLiS, 2006, “Housing reform, socio-economic differentials, and stated housing preferences in Guangzhou, China”Habitat International30305–326
32.
WangJ, 2000, “Chengshi caiqian shehui wenti qineng yicai liaozhi?” [Can the social problems of urban demolition and resettlement be demolished away?]Liaowang Xinwen Zhoukan [Liaowang News Weekly]458–9
33.
WangL, 2003, “Beijing fajia qigao de lixing fenxi” [Rational analysis of the abnormally high housing prices in Beijing]Zhongguo Shehui Jingji Yanjiuzuohttp://ie.cass.cn/yjw/
34.
World Bank, 1993, “China involuntary resettlement”, Report No. 11641-CHA, China and Mongolia Department, World Bank, Washington, DC
35.
WuF, 2001, “Housing provision under globalization: A case study of Shanghai”Environment and Planning A331741–1764
36.
WuF, 2004, “Residential relocation under market-oriented redevelopment: The process and outcomes in urban China”Geoforum35453–470
37.
WuF, 2007, “Beyond gradualism: China's urban revolution and emerging cities”, in China's Emerging Cities: The Making of New Urbanism Ed. WuF (Routledge, London) pp 3–25
38.
Xinhuanet2003, “Zhongguo zaoyu xinfang hongfeng, xin lingdaoren mianlin feichang kaoyan” [China encountered with peak of letter-writing and visiting, new leaders grilled by extreme challenges], 8 December http://big5.china.com.cn/chinese/2003/Dec/457238.htm
YehA C OWuF, 1996, “The new land development process and urban development process and urban development in Chinese cities”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research20330–353
42.
YuanJ, 1998, “Dui woguo jiucheng gaizao de ruogan sikao” [Some thoughts on urban reconstruction in our country]Jingji Dili [Economic Geography]18(3) 25–29
43.
ZhangF, 1998, “Chengshi fangwu caiqianzhong de wenti ji qi duice” [The problems during demolition of urban housing and their policy response]Zhongguo Fangdichan [China Real Estate]21367–70
44.
ZhangYFangK, 2004, “Is history repeating itself? From urban renewal in the United States to inner-city redevelopment in China”Journal of Planning Education and Research23286–298
45.
ZhaoHZhaoA, 1998, “Lun wanshan woguo chengshi fangwu caiqian zhidu de ruogan wenti” [On how to perfect the system of urban housing demolition in our country]Falu Shiyong [Law Applications]412–14, 21
46.
ZhuJ, 1999, “Local growth coalition: The context and implications of China's gradualist reforms”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research23534–548
47.
ZhuJ, 2005, “A transitional institution for the emerging land market in urban China”Urban Studies421369–1390
48.
ZhuY, 2006, “Patterns of population and employment change in Shanghai in the 1990s: A zonal analysis with international comparisons”International Development Planning Review28287–209
