The author argues that migrant place-making can become counterproductive for migrant communities for a variety of reasons. Existing place-making literature is often optimistic about the ability of places to offer migrants common identities and means of mobilising collectively. The author constructs a four-stage general model of migrant place-making to examine the potential pathologies of migrant organisational strategies at each of these four stages. In order to demonstrate the use of this model, an analysis of post-2004 Polish migration to the UK, drawing upon forty-two semistructured interviews with Polish migrants and domestic service providers, is presented. Although earlier migration displayed a number of the ideal characteristics of positive place-making described in the ideal four-stage model, centring around the Polish Catholic churches of England and Wales, post-2004 migration has introduced a series of problems that illustrate the various pathologies that can occur. The author concludes by calling for (i) a greater appreciation of the role of host organisations in the production of successful and unsuccessful place-making, and (ii) a recognition that place-making as a migrant settlement strategy is deeply fallible at various stages of its development.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AmithJ, 2005, “Place making and place breaking: Migration and the development cycle of community in colonial Mexico”American Ethnologist1159–179
2.
BackLKeithMKhanAShukraKSolomosS, 2002, “The return of assimilationism: Race, multiculturalism and New Labour”Sociological Research Online7(2)
3.
BoydM, 1989, “Family and personal networks in international migration: Recent developments and new agendas”International Migration Review23638–670
4.
BurrellK, 2003, “Small-scale transnationalism: Homeland connections and the Polish ‘community’ in Leicester”International Journal of Population Geography9323–355
5.
BurrellK (Ed.), 2009Polish Migration in the UK in the New European Union: After 2004 (Ashgate, Aldershot, Hants)
6.
CantleT, 2005Community Cohesion: A New Framework for Race and Diversity (Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants)
7.
CarrierJMillerD, 1998Virtualism: A New Political Economy (Berg, Oxford)
8.
CastlesS, 2006, “Guestworkers in Europe: A resurrection?”International Migration Review40741–766
9.
CastlesSDavidsonA, 2000Citizenship and Migration: Globalization and the Politics of Belonging (Routledge, London)
10.
CastlesSMillerM, 2003The Age of Migration (Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants)
11.
ConradsonDLathamA, 2005, “Friendship, networks and transnationality in a world city: Antipodean transmigrant in London”Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies31287–305
DrinkwaterSEadeJGarapichM, 2006, “Poles apart? EU enlargement and the labour market outcomes of immigrants in the UK”, IZA DP 2410, Institute for the Study of Labor, Bonn
14.
DrozdzewskiD, 2007, “A place called ‘Bielany’: Negotiating a diasporic Polish place in Sydney”Social and Cultural Geography8853–869
15.
EadeJ, 2000Placing London: From Imperial Capital to Global City (Berghahn Books, New York)
16.
EalhamC, 2005, “An imagined geography: Ideology, urban space, and protest in the creation of Barcelona's ‘Chinatown’, c. 1835–1936”International Review of Social History50373–397
GarapichG, 2007, “Odyssean refugees, migrants and power—construction of ‘other’ within the Polish ‘community’ in the UK”, in Citizenship, Political Engagement, and Belonging: Immigrants in Europe and the United States Eds Reed-DanahayDBrettellC (Rutgers University Press, Piscataway, NJ) pp 124–143
19.
GarciaC, 2005, “Buscando trabajo: Social networking among immigrants from Mexico to the United States”Hispanic Journal of Behavioral Sciences27(3) 3–22
HallS, 2008, “New cultures for old?”, in The Cultural Geography Reader Eds OakesTPriceP (Routledge, London) pp 264–274
22.
HarneyN, 2006, “The politics of urban space: Modes of place-making by Italians in Toronto's neighbourhoods”Modern Italy11(1) 27–44
23.
HaugS, 2008, “Migration networks and migration decision-making”Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies34585–605
24.
HirschmanC, 2008, “The role of religion in the origins and adaptation of immigrant groups in the United States”International Migration Review381206–1233
25.
HooksB, 1990Yearning: Race, Gender and Cultural Politics (Between the Lines, Toronto, ON)
26.
IglickaK2000, “Mechanisms of migration from Poland before and during the transition period”Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies2661–73
27.
IpD, 2005, “Contesting Chinatown: Place-making and the emergence of ‘ethnoburbia’ in Brisbane, Australia”Geo Journal6463–74
28.
JamoulLWillsJ, 2008, “Faith in politics”Urban Studies452035–2066
29.
JonesR, 2008, “Relocating nationalism: On the geographies of reproducing nations”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series33319–334
30.
JuanK, 2005, “Staying Vietnamese: Community and place in Orange County and Boston”City and Community4(1) 37–65
31.
KeithM, 2005After the Cosmopolitan? Multicultural Cities and the Future of Racism (Routledge, London)
32.
LefebvreH, 1974The Production of Space translated by Nicholson-SmithD (Blackwell, Oxford)
33.
MazumdarSMazumdarS, 2009, “Religious placemaking and community building in diaspora”Environment and Behaviour41307–337
34.
MoneyJ, 1999Fences and Neighbors: The Political Geography of Immigration Control (Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY)
35.
RyanLSalesRTilkiMSiaraB, 2008, “Social networks, social support and social capital: The experiences of recent Polish migrants in London”Sociology42672–690
36.
SennettR, 1991The Conscience of the Eye: The Design and Social Life of Cities (Faber and Faber, London)
37.
SiaraB, 2009, “UK Poles and the negotiation of gender and ethnic identity in cyberspace”, in Polish Migration in the UK in the New European Union: After 2004 Ed. BurrellK (Ashgate, Aldershot, Hants) pp 167–188
38.
SiemiatyckiMIsinE, 1998, “Immigration, diversity and urban citizenship in Toronto”Canadian Journal of Regional ScienceXX(1–2) 73–102
39.
SkeggsBMoranLTyrerPBinnieJ, 2004, “Queer as folk: Producing the real of urban space”Urban Studies411839–1856
40.
SmithR, 2003, “Diasporic memberships in historical perspective: Comparative insights from the Mexican, Italian and Polish cases”The International Migration Review37724–759
41.
SojaE, 1996Thirdspace: Journeys to Los Angeles and Other Real-and-imagined Places (Blackwell, Oxford)
42.
SpenserSRuhsMAndersenBRogalyB, 2007Migrants’ Lives Beyond the Workplace: The Experiences of Central and East Europeans in the UK (Joseph Rowntree Foundation, York)
43.
StenningA, 2005, “Out there and in here: Studying Eastern Europe in the West”Area37378–383
44.
TempleB, 1999, “Diaspora, diaspora space and Polish women”Women's Studies International Forum2217–24
45.
The Polish Catholic Mission, 2005, “The Polish Catholic mission in England and Wales”, Polish Benevolent Fund, London
46.
VeronisL, 2007, “Strategic special essentialism: Latin Americans’ real and imagined geographies of belonging in Toronto”Social and Cultural Geography8455–473
47.
VertovecS, 1999Migration and Social Cohesion (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos)
48.
VertovecS, 2001, “Transnational social formations: Towards conceptual cross-fertilisation”, WP TC-01-16, Transnational Communities, Oxford
49.
VertovecSCohenR, 2002Conceiving Cosmopolitanism: Theory, Context, and Practice (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
50.
Von Hugel Institute, 2007, “The ground of justice: A draft report of a pastoral research enquiry into the needs of migrants in London's Catholic community”, Von Hugel Institute, St Edmund's College, University of Cambridge
51.
WerbnerP, 2002Imagined Diasporas among Manchester Muslims: The Public Performance of Pakistani Transnational Identity Politics (James Currey, Oxford and School of American Research Press, Santa Fe, NM)
52.
WerbnerP, 2004, “Theorising complex diasporas: Purity and hybridity in the South Asian public sphere in Britain”Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies30895–911
53.
WhiteARyanL, 2008, “Polish ‘temporary’ migration: The formation and significance of social networks”Europe-Asia Studies601467–1502
54.
WillsJ, 2005, “The geography of union organising in low paid service industries in the UK: Lessons from the T&G campaign to unionise Dorchester Hotel, London”Antipode37139–159
55.
WoodJ, 1997, “Vietnamese American place making in northern Virginia”The Geographical Review8758–72
56.
YehE, 2007, “Exile meets homeland: Politics, performance, and authenticity in the Tibetan diaspora”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space25648–667
