It appears that recent debates within human geography, and the broader social sciences, concerning the more-than-rational constitution of human decision making are now being paralleled by changes in the ways in which public policy makers are conceiving of and addressing human behaviour. This paper focuses on the rise of so-called Behaviour Change policies in public policy in the UK. Behaviour Change policies draw on the behavioural insights being developed within the neuro-sciences, behavioural economics, and psychology. These new behavioural theories suggest not only that human decision making relies on a previously overlooked irrational component, but that the irrationality of decision making is sufficiently consistent to enable effective public policy intervention into the varied times and spaces that surround human decisions. This paper charts the emergence of Behaviour Change policies within a range of British public policy sectors, and the political and scientific antecedents of such policies. Ultimately, the paper develops a geographically informed, ethical critique of the contemporary Behaviour Change regime that is emerging in the UK. Drawing on thirty in-depth interviews with leading policy executives, and case studies that reflect the application of Behaviour Change policies on the design and constitution of British streets, the analysis claims that current strategies are predicated on a partial reading of new behavioural theories. We argue that this partial reading of human cognition is leading to the construction of public policies that seek to arbitrarily decouple the rational and emotional components of human decision making with deleterious social and political consequences.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AkerlofG AShillerR J, 2009Animal Spirits: How Human Psychology Drives the Economy and Why it Matters for Global Capitalism (Princeton University Press, Oxford).
2.
AllenJ, 2003The Lost Geographies of Power (Wiley-Blackwell, Oxford).
3.
AllenJ, 2006, “Ambient power: Berlin's Potsdamer Platz and the seductive logic of public spaces”Urban Studies43441–455.
4.
AndersonB, 2009, “Affective atmospheres”Emotion, Space and Society277–81.
5.
AndersonB, 2010, “Morale and the affective geographies of the ‘War on Terror’”Cultural Geographies17219–236.
6.
AndersonBHarrisonP, 2010Taking-place: Non-representational Theories and Human Geography (Ashgate, Farnham, Surrey).
7.
ArielyD, 2008Predictably Irrational: The aidden Forces that Shape our Decisions (HarperCollins, London).
8.
BarnettC, 2008, “Political affects in public space: Normative blind-spots in non-representational ontologies”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series33186–200.
9.
BeckerG, 1962, “Irrational action and economic theory”Journal of Political Economy70153–168.
CairncrossA, 1996Economic Ideas and Government Policy: Contributions to Contemporary Economic History (Routledge, London).
12.
Centre d'analyse stratégique, 2010Improving Public Health Prevention with Behavioural, Cognitive and Neuroscience (Centre d'analyse stratégique, Paris).
13.
COI, 2009, “Making behaviour change pay for itself”, The Mix Winter 2009/2010, Central Office of Information, London.
14.
ConnollyW, 2005, “The evangelical—capitalist resonance machine”Political Theory33869–886.
15.
DamasioA, 1995Descartes' Error: Emotion, Reason, and the Human Brain (Picador, London).
16.
DCMS, Department for Culture, Media and Sport 2001Gambling Review Report Department for Culture, Media and Sport (The Stationery Office, London).
DEFRA, 2007A Framework for Pro-Environmental BehavioursDepartment for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, London.
19.
DETR, 2000Tomorrow's Roads—Safer for Everyone. The Government's Road Safety Strategy and Casualty Reduction Targets for 2010Department of Environment, Transport and the Regions, London.
20.
DfT, 2007Manual for Streets Department for Transport (Thomas Telford Publishing, London).
21.
DH, 2004Choosing Health. Making Healthy Choices Easier Department of Health (The Stationery Office, London).
22.
DolanPHallsworthMHalpernDKingDVlaevI, 2010Mindspace. Influencing Behaviour Through Public PolicyThe Institute for Government and Cabinet Office, London.
23.
DWP, Department for Work and Pensions 2006aPersonal Accounts: A New Way to Save (The Stationery Office, London).
24.
DWP, Department for Work and Pensions 2006bSecurity in Retirement. Towards a New Pensions System (The Stationery Office, London).
25.
ElliottM AMcCollV AKennedyJ V, 2003Road Design Measures to Reduce Drivers' Speed via ‘Psychological’ Processes: A Literature Review (TRL Publications, London).
26.
FoucaultM, 2008The Birth of Biopolitics: Lectures at the Collège de France 1978–1979 translated by BurchellG (Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants).
27.
FrankT, 1997The Conquest of Cool: Business Culture, Counterculture, and the Rise of Hip Consumerism (Chicago University Press, London).
Gambling Commission, 2008Licensing Conditions and Codes of PracticeGambling Commission, Birmingham.
30.
GladwellM, 2000Tipping Point (Little Brown, London).
31.
GladwellM, 2005Blink: The Power of Thinking without Thinking (Penguin Books, London).
32.
HallP (Ed.), 1989The Political Power of Economic Ideas: Keynesianism Across Nations (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ).
33.
HalpernDBatesCMulganGAldridgeSBealesGHeathfieldA, 2004Personal Responsibility and Changing Behaviour: The State of Knowledge and Its Implications for Public Policy (Strategy Unit, London).
34.
HuxleyM, 2006, “Spatial rationalities: Order, environment, evolution, and government”Social and Cultural Geography7771–787.
35.
JonesRPykettJWhiteheadM, 2010, “Big society's little nudges: The changing politics of health care in an age of austerity”Political Insight1 (3) 85–87.
36.
JonesRPykettJWhiteheadM, 2011, “Governing temptation: Changing behaviour in an age of libertarian paternalism”Progress in Human Geography35483–501.
37.
KahnemanDSlovicPTverskyA, 1982Judgment Under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
PicaDSormaniPStrebelISwanLTaylorA SWattsLWeilenmannA, 2008, “Driving and passengering: Notes on the ordinary organisation of car travel”Mobilities31–23.
55.
ProkhovnikR, 1999Rational Woman. A Feminist Critique of Dichotomy (Routledge, London).
56.
RoseGDegenMBasdasB, 2010, “More on ‘big things’: Building events and feelings”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series35334–349.
57.
ShillerR J, 2005 [2000] Irrational Exuberance (Princeton University Press, Oxford).
58.
SimonH A, 1955, “A behavioural model of rational choice”Quarterly Journal of Economics5599–118.
59.
SimonH A, 1982Models of Bounded Rationality Volume 1: Economic Analysis and Public Policy (MIT Press, London).
60.
ThalerR HSunsteinC R, 2008Nudge: Improving Decisions About Health, Wealth and Happiness (Yale University Press, London).
61.
ThompsonLPearceJBarnettR, 2007, “Moralising geographies: Stigma, smoking islands and responsible subjects”Area39508–517.
62.
ThriftN J, 2000, “Still life in nearly present time: The object of nature”Body and Society6 (3/4) 34–57.
