When considering householder responses to flood risk, researchers and policy makers have perhaps focused too much on the influence of risk perceptions and concerns about material costs and benefits. Using secondary analysis of survey data from UK households who had experienced flooding or who were at risk of flooding, this paper presents evidence to suggest that protective behaviour may be influenced less by material and financial considerations than by concerns about feelings of anxiety and insecurity. It also looks at the role of beliefs about protection and flooding in mediating the impacts of flood experience and suggests that experience reduces confidence in the ameliorative capacity of insurance and promotes the belief that protective measures increase anxiety about flooding. The paper concludes that more research should be carried out on the role of anticipated emotions in risk response and that policy makers and the designers of protection products should pay more attention to the emotional barriers and incentives to adaptation.
AtmanC JBostromAFischoffBMorganM G, 1994, “Designing risk communications: completing and correcting mental models of hazardous processes—part 1”Risk Analysis14 (5) 779–788
6.
BagozziR PBaumgartnerHPietersRZeelenbergM, 2000, “The role of emotions in goal-directed behaviour”, in The Why of Consumption: Contemporary Perspectives on Consumer Motives, Goals, and Desires Eds RatneshwarSMickD GHuffmanC (Routledge, New York) pp 36–58
7.
BakerT, 2002, “Risk, insurance and the social construction of responsibility”, in Embracing Risk: The Changing Culture of Insurance and Responsibility Eds BakerTSimonJ (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL) pp 33–51
8.
BanduraA, 1982, “Self-efficacy mechanism in human agency”American Psychologist37122–147
9.
BlumbergS JLukeJ V, 2007, “Coverage bias in traditional telephone surveys of low-income and young adults”Public Opinion Quarterly71734–749
10.
BohrnstedtG WKnokeD, 1994Statistics for Social Data Analysis3rd edition (F E Peacock, Itasca, IL)
11.
BondiL, 2005, “Making connections and thinking through emotions: between geography and psychotherapy”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series30433–448
12.
BostromAFischoffBMorganG M, 1992, “Characterising mental models of hazardous processes: a method and its application to radon”Journal of Social Issues48 (4) 85–100
13.
BreakwellG M, 2007The Psychology of Risk (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
14.
BrewerN TChapmanG BGibbonsF XGerrardMMcCaulK DWeinsteinN D, 2007, “Meta-analysis of the relationship between risk perception and health behaviour: the example of vaccination”Health Psychology26136–145
15.
BrownJ DDameryS L, 2002, “Managing flood risk in the UK: towards an integration of social and technical perspectives”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series27412–426
16.
BurninghamK, 2008, “A noisy road or noisy resident? A demonstration of the utility of social constructionism for analysing environmental problems”The Sociological Review46536–563
17.
CialdiniR BGoldsteinN J, 2004, “Social influence: compliance and conformity”Annual Review of Psychology55591–621; doi:10.1146/annurev.psych.55.090902.142015
18.
CutterS L, 2006, “Moral hazard, social catastrophe: the changing face of vulnerability along the hurricane coasts”The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science604102–112
Defra, Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, London2005Making Space for Water: Taking Forward a New Government Strategy for Flood and Coastal Erosion Risk Management in England
21.
Defra, Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, London2008Resilience Grants Pilot Projects, Executive Summary
22.
Defra, Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, London2009Government Grants to Local Authorities for Household-level Flood Protection—Guidance
DuvalT SMulilisJ P, 1999, “A person-relative-to-event (PrE) approach to negative threat appeals and earthquake preparedness: a field study”Journal of Applied Social Psychology29495–516
25.
Environment Agency, 1993Strategy for Flood and Coastal Defence in England and Wales: Executive SummaryEnvironment Agency, Bristol
EvansEAshleyRHallJPenning-RowsellESaulASayersPThorneCWatkinsonA, 2004aForesight, Future Flooding. Scientific Summary Volume 1. Future Risks and their DriversOffice of Science and Technology, London
28.
EvansEAshleyRHallJPenning-RowsellESaulASayersPThorneCWatkinsonA, 2004bForesight, Future Flooding. Scientific Summary Volume 2. Managing Future RisksOffice of Science and Technology, London
29.
FestingerL, 1957A Theory of Cognitive Dissonance (Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA)
30.
FieldA, 2005Discovering Statistics Using SPSS2nd edition (Sage, London)
31.
FlynnJSlovicPMertzC K, 1994, “Gender, race, and perception of environmental health risks”Risk Analysis141101–1108
32.
GoffmanE, 1959The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life (Doubleday, Garden City, NY)
33.
GoldsteinN JCialdiniR BGriskeviciusV, 2008, “A room with a viewpoint: using normative appeals to motivate environmental conservation in a hotel setting”Journal of Consumer Research35472–482
34.
GreenC, 1988The Relationships Between the Magnitudes of Flooding, Stress and HealthFlood Hazard Research Centre, Enfield, London
35.
GriceP, 1975, “Logic and conversation”, in Syntax and Semantics, 3: Speech Acts Eds ColePMorganJ (Academic Press, New York) pp 121–133
36.
GrothmannTReusswigF, 2006, “People at risk of flooding: why some residents take precautionary action while others do not”Natural Hazards381–2
37.
GrubelH G, 1971, “Risk, uncertainty and moral hazard”The Journal of Risk and Insurance3899–106
38.
Guha-SapirDVosFBelowRPonserreS, 2011Annual Disaster Statistical Review 2010—The Numbers and TrendsCentre for Research on the Epidemiology of Disasters, Brussels
39.
HarriesT, 2008aHouseholder Responses to Flood Risk: The Consequences of the Search for Ontological Security PhD thesis, University of Middlesex, London
40.
HarriesT, 2008b, “Feeling secure or being secure? Why it can seem better not to protect yourself against a natural hazard”Health, Risk and Society10479–490
41.
HarriesTPenning-RowsellE, 2011, “Victim pressure, institutional inertia and climate change adaptation: the case of flood risk”Global Environmental Change21188–197
42.
HomanJ, 2001, “A culturally sensitive approach to risk: ‘natural’ hazard perception in Egypt and the UK”Australian Journal of Emergency Management Winter, 14–18
43.
JohnsonCPriestS, 2008, “Flood risk management in England: a changing landscape of risk responsibility?”International Journal of Water Resources Development24513–525
44.
JohnsonCTunstallSPenning-RowsellE, 2005, “Floods as catalysts for policy change: historical lessons from England and Wales”Water Resources Development21561–575
45.
JohnsonE JHersheyJMeszarosJKunreutherH, 1993, “Framing, probability distortions and insurance decisions”Journal of Risk and Uncertainty735–51
46.
JonesEBerglasS, 1978, “Control of attributions about the self through self-handicapping strategies: the appeal of alcohol and the role of underachievement”Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin4200–206
47.
KatesR W, 1976, “Experiencing the environment as hazard”, in Experiencing the Environment Eds WapnerSCohenSKaplanB (Plenum Press, New York) pp 133–156
48.
KrasnerS, 1988, “Sovereignty: an institutional perspective”Comparative Political Studies2166–94
49.
KreibichA HThiekenHGrunenbergK USommerT, 2009, “Extent, perception and mitigation of damage due to high groundwater levels in the city of Dresden, Germany”National Hazards and Earth System Sciences91247–1258
50.
KunreutherHHealG, 2003, “Interdependent security”Journal of Risk and Uncertainty26231–249
51.
KunreutherHSlovicP, 1986, “Decision making in hazard and resource management”, in Geography, Resources and Environment—Volume 2: Themes from the Work of Gilbert F White Eds KatesR WBurtonI (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL) pp 155–187
52.
LaskaS, 1990, “Homeowner adaptation to flooding: an application of the general hazards coping theory”Environment and Behavior22320–357
53.
LazarusR S, 1966Psychological Stress and the Coping Process (Academic Press, New York)
54.
LindellM KPerryR W, 2000, “Household adjustment to earthquake hazard: a review of research”Environment and Behavior32461–501
LoewensteinG F, 1996, “Out of control: visceral influences on behavior”Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes65272–292
57.
MortonT ARabinovichAMarshallDBretschneiderP, in press, “The future that may (or may not) come: how framing changes responses to uncertainty in climate change communications”Global Environmental Change
NolanJ MSchultzP WCialdiniR BGoldsteinN JGriskeviciusV, 2008, “Normative social influence is underdetected”Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin34913–923
60.
ONS, 20012001 Census: Standard Area Statistics (England and Wales) [computer file], Office for National Statistics, ESRC/JISC Census Programme, Census Dissemination Unit, MIMAS, University of Manchester
OhlC ATapsellS M, 2000, “Flooding and human health: the dangers posed are not always obvious”British Medical Journal3211167–1168
63.
O'RiordanT, 1986, “Coping with environmental hazards”, in Geography, Resources and Environment—Volume 2: Themes from the Work of Gilbert F White Eds KatesR WBurtonI (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL) pp 272–309
64.
ParkerD JPenning-RowsellEGreenC H, 1983Swalecliff Coast Protection Proposals: Evaluation of Potential BenefitsFlood Hazard Research Centre, Enfield, London
65.
PatonDSmithLJohnstonD, 2005, “When good intentions turn bad: promoting natural hazard preparedness”The Australian Journal of Emergency Management2025–30
66.
Penning-RowsellETapsellSJohnsonSWilsonT, 2006Development of Economic Appraisal Methods for Flood Management and Coastal Erosion Protection FD2014/TR2, Department for the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, London
67.
PittM, 2008Learning Lessons from the 2007 Floods: An Independent Review by Sir Michael PittCabinet Office, London
68.
RabinovichAMortonT A, 2010, “Who says we are bad people? The impact of criticism source and attributional content on responses to group-based criticism”Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin36524–536
69.
Risk & Policy Analysts Ltd, Flood Hazard Research Centre, EFTEC (Economics for the Environment Consultancy), CASPAR, 2004The Appraisal of Human-related Intangible Impacts of FloodingDepartment for the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, London
70.
RoseN, 1999Powers of Freedom (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
71.
RundmoT, 2002, “Associations between affect and risk perception”Journal of Risk Research5119–135
72.
SattlerD NKaiserK NHittnerJ B, 2000, “Disaster preparedness: relationships among private experience, personal characteristics, and distress”Journal of Applied Social Psychology30396–1420
73.
SchwarzNSudmanS, 1996Answering Questions: Methodology for Determining Cognitive and Communicative Processes in Survey Research (Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CA)
74.
SiegristMGutscherH, 2008, “Natural hazards and motivation for mitigation behavior: people cannot predict the affect evoked by a severe flood”Risk Analysis28771–778
75.
SiudakM, 2001, “Role of education in reducing flash flood effects”, in Coping with Flash Floods Eds GrundfestEHandmerJ (Kluwer Academic, London) pp 15–18
76.
SlovicP, 2000, “Introduction and overview”, in The Perception of Risk Ed. SlovicP (Earthscan, London) pp xxi–xxxvii
77.
SocherMBöhme-KornG, 2008, “Central European floods 2002: lessons learned in Saxony”Journal of Flood Risk Management1123–129
78.
TerpestraTGuttelingJ M, 2008, “Households' perceived responsibilities in flood risk management in The Netherlands”Water Resources Development24555–565
79.
ThriftN, 2004, “Intensities of feeling: towards a spatial politics of affect”Geografiska Annaler, Series B8657–78
80.
ThurstonNFinlinsonBBreakspearRWilliamsNShawJChattertonJ, 2008Developing the Evidence Base for Flood Resilience, FD2607/TRDepartment for the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, London
81.
TobinG A, 1995, “The levee love affair: a stormy relationship”Water Resources Bulletin31359–367
82.
TourangeauRRipsJ RRasinskiK, 2000The Psychology of Survey Response (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
83.
TuckelPO'NeillH, 2002, “The vanishing respondent in telephone surveys”Journal of Advertising Research42 (5) 26–48
84.
TunstallSTapsellSGreenCFloydPGeorgeC, 2006, “The health effects of flooding: social research results from England and Wales”Journal of Water and Health4365–380
85.
TykocinskiOPittmanT, 1998, “The consequences of doing nothing: inaction inertia as avoidance of anticipated counterfactual regret”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology75607–616
86.
van der PligtJ, 1996, “Risk perception and self-protective behaviour”European Psychologist134–43
WeinsteinN D, 1989, “Effects of personal experience on self-protective behaviour”Psychological Bulletin10531–50
89.
WhiteG, 1973, “Natural hazards research”, reprinted in 1986 in Geography, Resources and Environment—Volume 1: Selected Writings of Gilbert F White Eds KatesR WBurtonI (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL) pp 324–347
90.
WhitmarshL, 2008, “Are flood victims more concerned about climate change than other people? The role of direct experience in risk perception and behavioural response”Journal of Risk Research11351–374
91.
WitteKAllenM, 2000, “A meta-analysis of fear appeals: implications for effective public health campaigns”Health Education and Behaviour27591–615
92.
ZaalbergRMiddenCMeijndersAMcCalleyT, 2009, “Prevention, adaptation, and threat denial: flooding experiences in the Netherlands”Risk Analysis291759–1778
93.
ZeelenbergMvan den BosKvan DijkEPietersR, 2002, “The inaction effect in the psychology of regret”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology82314–327
