Toward a New Countermovement: A Framework for Interpreting the Contradictory Interventions of Migrant Civil Society Organizations in Urban Labor Markets
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online December, 2011
Toward a New Countermovement: A Framework for Interpreting the Contradictory Interventions of Migrant Civil Society Organizations in Urban Labor Markets
Low-wage migrant workers in the United States confront a perilous labor market, where wages are low, the risk of injury on the job is high, and the fear of apprehension by immigration authorities is widespread. There is increasing empirical evidence that civil society organizations are becoming involved in mediating labor-market problems, but work remains to be done in developing a robust theoretical conception of why such organizations are involved in this arena and how we might evaluate the impacts of their interventions. This paper presents a framework for interpreting the role of migrant civil society organizations as labor-market intermediaries, by extending Karl Polanyi's theory of the ‘double movement’ and more recent writing to neoliberalism and precarious work. On the basis of data collected from migrant nonprofit organizations in Chicago, I theorize migrant civil society organizations as part of the creation of a new countermovement that protects the interests of both workers and employers from the destructive nature of an unregulated labor market, as predicted by Polanyi. I catalogue organizations' responses to precarious work and create a generalizable framework for evaluating the contingent outcomes of their strategies. Organizations' work is interpreted as complex and sometimes contradictory: the potential to shield workers and advocate for progressive change is in constant tension with the neoliberal patterns of state and economic restructuring that such organizations can support.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Aspen Institute, 2003, “The informal economy and microenterprise in the United States”, Aspen Institute FIELD Forum, Washington, DC, March, Issue 14.
2.
BennettLSmithJ LWrightP A (Eds), 2006Where Are Poor People to Live?: Transforming Public Housing Communities (M E Sharpe, Armonk, NY).
3.
BensmanDLynchR, 1987Rusted Dreams: Hard Times in a Steel Community (McGraw-Hill, New York).
4.
BernhardtAMcGrathS, 2005. “Trends in eage and hour rnforcement by the U.S. Department of Labor, 1975–2004”, Economic Policy Brief, Brennan Center for Justice, New York City.
5.
BernhardtA, 2009, “Broken laws, unprotected workers: Violations of labor and employment laws in America's cities”, Center for Urban Economic Development, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, IL.
6.
BirchfieldV, 1999, “Contesting the hegemony of market ideology: Gramsci's ‘good sense’ and Polanyi's ‘double movement’”Review of International Political Economy6 (1) 27–54.
7.
BlockF, 2003, “Karl Polanyi and the writing of The Great Transformation”Theory and Society32275–305.
BlytheM, 2002Great Transformations: Economic Ideas and Institutional Change in the Twentieth Century (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
10.
BondP, 2005, “Gramsci, Polanyi and impressions from Africa on the Social Forum phenomenon”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research29433–440.
11.
BrennerNTheodoreN, 2002, “Cities and the geographies of ‘actually existing’ Neoliberalism”, in Spaces of Neoliberalism: Urban Restructuring in North America and Western Europe Eds BrennerNTheodoreN (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 349–379.
12.
BurawoyM, 2003, “For a sociological marxism: The complementary convergence of Antonio Gramsci and Karl Polanyi”Politics and Society31193–261.
13.
CarréFHeckscherC, 2006, “Strength in networks? Employment rights organizations and the problem of coordination”British Journal of Industrial Relations44605–628.
14.
CastreeN, 2005, “The epistemology of particulars: Human geography, case studies, and ‘context’”Geoforum36541–544.
CopeM, 2001, “Between welfare and work: The roles of social service organizations in the social regulation of labor markets of the poor”Urban Geography22391–406.
17.
Cordero-GuzmánH R, 2005, “Community-based organizations and migration in New York City”Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies31880–909.
18.
Cordero-GuzmánH RQuiroz-BecerraV, 2007, “Cracking the safety net: Latina/o access to health and social programs in the post-welfare era”, in Latinos in a Changing Society Eds Montero-SieburthMMelendezE (Praeger, Westport, CT) pp 200–227.
19.
Cordero-GuzmánH RMartinNQuiroz-BecerraVTheodoreN, 2008, “Voting with their feet: Nonprofit organizations and immigrant mobilization”American Behavioral Scientist52598–617.
20.
DeFilippisJFisherRShraggeE, 2006, “Neither romance nor regulation: Reevaluating community”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research30673–689.
21.
De GenovaN, 2005Working the Boundaries: Race, Space, and ‘Illegality’ in Mexican Chicago (Duke University Press, Durham, NC).
22.
DeVerteuilGWiltonR, 2009, “Spaces of abeyance, care, and survival: The addiction treatment system as a site of ‘regulatory richness’”Political Geography28463–472.
DoussardMPeckJTheodoreN, 2009, “After deindustrialization: Uneven growth and economic inequality in ‘postindustrial’ Chicago”Economic Geography85 (2) 183–207.
25.
ElwoodS, 2006, “Beyond cooptation or resistance: Urban spatial politics, community organizations, and GIS-based spatial narratives”Annals of the Association of American Geographers96323–341.
26.
FabricantM BFisherR, 2002Settlement Houses under Siege: The Struggle to Sustain Community Organizations in New York (Columbia University Press, New York).
27.
FineJ, 2005, “Community unionism and the revival of the American labor movement”Politics and Society33 (1) 153–199.
28.
FineJ, 2006Worker Centers: Organizing Communities at the Edge of the Dream (Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY).
29.
GordonJ, 2005Suburban Sweatshops: The Fight for Immigrant Rights (Jarvard Belknap, Cambridge, MA).
30.
GronbjergKSalamonL M, 2002, “Devolution, marketization, and the changing shape of government—nonprofit relations”, in The State of Nonprofit America Ed SalamonL M (Brookings Institution Press, Washington, DC) pp 447–470.
31.
GuthmanJ, 2007, “The Polanyian way? Voluntary food labels as neoliberal governance”Antipode39456–478.
32.
HackworthJ, 2007The Neoliberal City: Governance, Ideology, and Development in American Urbanism (Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY).
33.
INCITE! Women of Color Against Violence (Eds), 2007The Revolution Will Not Be Funded: Beyond the Non-profit Industrial Complex (South End Press, Cambridge, MA).
34.
JayaramanSNessI (Eds), 2005New Urban Immigrant Workforce: Innovative Models for Labor Organizing (M E Sharpe, Armonk, NY).
35.
JessopB, 2002, “Liberalism, neoliberalism, and urban governance: A state-theoretical perspective”Antipode34452–472.
KatzM B, 1996In the Shadow of the Poorhouse: A Social History of Welfare in America (Basic Books, New York).
38.
KornblumW, 1974Blue Collar Community (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL).
39.
KovalJ PBennettLBennettM IDemissieFGarnerR (Eds), 2006The New Chicago: A Social and Cultural Analysis (Temple University Press, Phildelphia, PA).
40.
LeitnerHPeckJSheppardE (Eds), 2007Contesting Neoliberalism: Urban Frontiers (Guilford Press, New York).
41.
LipmanP, 2008, “Mixed-income schools and housing: Advancing the neoliberal urban agenda”Journal of Education Policy23119–134.
42.
MacLeodG, 1997, “Globalizing Parisian thought-waves: Recent advances in the study of social regulation, politics, discourse and space”Progress in Human Geography21530–553.
43.
MartinN, 2010, “The crisis of social reproduction among migrant workers: Interrogating the role of migrant civil society”Antipode42127–151.
44.
MarwellN P, 2007Bargaining for Brooklyn: Community Organizations in the Entrepreneurial City (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL).
45.
MayerM, 2007, “Contesting the neoliberalization of urban governance”, in Contesting Neoliberalism: Urban Frontiers Eds LeitnerHSheppardEPeckJ (Guilford Press, New York) pp 90–115.
46.
MehtaCTheodoreNMoraIWadeJ, 2002, “Chicago's undocumented immigrants: An analysis of wages, working conditions, and economic contributions”, Center for Urban Economic Development, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, IL.
47.
MehtaCTheodoreNHincapieM, 2003, “Social security administration's No-match Letter Program: Implications for immigration enforcement activities”, Center for Urban Economic Development, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, IL.
48.
MoyaJ, 2005, “Immigrants and associations: A global and historical perspective”Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies31833–864.
49.
MunckR, 2004, “Globalisation, labor, and the Polanyi problem, or the issue of counter-hegemony”Labor History45251–269.
50.
NessI, 2005Immigrants, Unions, and the New U.S. Labor Market (Temple University Press, Philadelphia, PA).
51.
OffeC, 1985Disorganized Capitalism: Contemporary Transformations of Work and Politics (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA).
52.
PacygaD A, 2003Polish Immigrants and Industrial Chicago: Workers on the South Side, 1880–1922 (The University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL).
53.
PainterJGoodwinM, 1995, “Local governance and concrete research: Investigating the uneven development of regulation”Economy and Society24334–356.
54.
PallaresAFlores-GonzálezN (Eds), 2010&lexcl;Marcha!: Latino Chicago and the Immigrant Rights Movement (University of Illinois Press, Champaign, IL).
55.
PasselJCohnD, 2009A Portrait of Unauthorized Immigrants in the United StatesPew Hispanic Center of the Pew Research Center, Washington, DC, http://pewhispanic.org/files/reports/107.pdf.
56.
PeckJ, 1994, “Regulating labour: The social regulation and reproduction of local labour-markets”, in Globalization, Institutions and Regional Development in Europe Eds AminAThriftN (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 147–176.
57.
PeckJ, 1996Work-place: The Social Regulation of Labor Markets (Guilford Press, New York).
58.
PeckJ, 2001Workfare States (Guilford Press, New York).
59.
PeckJTickellA, 2002, “Neoliberalizing space”, in Spaces of Neoliberalism: Urban Restructuring in North America and Western Europe Eds BrennerNTheodoreN (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 33–57.
60.
PicchioA, 1992Social Reproduction: The Political Economy of the Labor Market (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
61.
PolanyiK, 1944The Great Transformation: The Political and Economic Origins of Our Time (Beacon Press, Boston, MA).
62.
PortesA (Ed.), 1995The Economic Sociology of Immigration: Essays on Networks, Ethnicity, and Entrepreneurship (Russell Sage Foundation, New York).
63.
SalamonL M, 1992America's Nonprofit Sector: A Primer (Foundation Center, New York).
64.
SchrockG R, 2010Taking Care of Business?: Connecting Workforce and Economic Development in Chicago PhD dissertation, College of Urban Planning and Policy, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, IL.
65.
SmithB EWindersJ, 2008, “‘We're here to stay’: Economic restructuring, Latino migration and place-making in the US South”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series3360–72.
66.
SmithJ M, 2010, “‘Re-stating’ theories of urban development: The politics of authority creation and intergovernmental triads in post-industrial Chicago”Journal of Urban Affairs32425–448.
67.
SmithR, 2008, “Legal protections and advocacy work for contingent or ‘casual’ workers in the United States: The case of day laborers”Social Indicators Research88197–213.
68.
TheodoreNMartinN, 2007, “Migrant civil society: New voices in the struggle over community development”Journal of Urban Affairs29269–287.
69.
TheodoreNMeléndezEValenzuelaA, 2009, “Defending labor standards for migrant workers in the informal economy”International Journal of Manpower30422–436.
70.
TrudeauD, 2008, “Junior partner or empowered community? The role of non-profit social service providers amidst state restructuring in the US”Urban Studies452805–2827.
71.
US Census Bureau, 2005, “2005 American Community Survey. Place of Birth for the Foreign Born Population (US Census Bureau, Washington, DC).
72.
VoskoL, 2000The Gendered Rise of a Precarious Employment Relationship (University of Toronto Press, Toronto).
73.
WaldingerR DLichterM I, 2003How the Other Half Works: Immigration and the Social Organization of Labor (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA).
74.
WebsterELambertRBezuidenhuitA, 2008Grounding Globalization: Labour in the Age of Insecurity (Blackwell, Malden, MA).
75.
WillsJ, 2008, “Making class politics possible: Organizing contract cleaners in London”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research32305–323.
76.
WilsonD, 2004, “Toward a contingent urban neoliberalism”Urban Geography25771–783.
77.
WindersJ, 2006, “‘New Americans’ in a ‘new-South’ city: Immigrant and refuges politics in a new south city”Social and Cultural Geography7421–435.
78.
WolchJ R, 1990The Shadow State: Government and Voluntary Sector in Transition (The Foundation Center, New York).
