This paper explores the system-wide impact of graduates on the regional economy. Graduates enjoy a significant wage premium, often interpreted as reflecting their greater productivity relative to nongraduates. If this is so there is a clear and direct supply-side impact of higher education institution (HEI) activities on regional economies. We use an HEI-disaggregated computable general equilibrium model of Scotland to estimate the impact of the growing proportion of graduates in the Scottish labour force that is implied by the current participation rate and demographic change, taking the graduate wage premium in Scotland as an indicator of productivity enhancement. While the detailed results vary with alternative assumptions about the extent to which wage premia reflect productivity, they do suggest that the long-term supply-side impacts of HEIs provide a significant boost to regional GDP. Furthermore, the results suggest that the supply-side impacts of HEIs are likely to be more important than the expenditure impacts that are the focus of most HEI impact studies.
AcemogluD, 2002, “Technical change, inequality, and the labour market”Journal of Economic Literature407–72
2.
AcemogluDAutorD, 2012, “What does human capital do? A review of Goldin and Katz's The race between education and technology'”Journal of Economic Literature50426–463
3.
AcsZJ, 2009, “Jaffe–Feldman–Varga: The search for knowledge spillovers”, in Universities, Knowledge Transfer and Regional Development Ed. VargaA, (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos) pp 36–56
4.
AnderssonMGrasjoUKarlssonC, 2009, “The role of higher education and university R&D for industrial R&D location”, in Universities, Knowledge Transfer and Regional Development Ed. VargaA, (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos) pp 36–56
5.
AnselinLVargaAAcsZJ, 1997, “Geographic and sectoral characteristics of academic knowledge spillovers”Journal of Urban Economics79422–448
6.
AnselinLVargaAAcsZJ, 2000, “Geographic and sectoral characteristics of academic knowledge externalities”Papers in Regional Science79435–443
7.
ArmingtonP, 1969, “A theory of demand for products distinguished by place of production”LMF Staff Papers16159–178
8.
BadingerHTondlG, 2003, “Trade, human capital and innovation: The engines of European regional growth in the 1990s”, in European Regional Growth Ed. FingletonB, (Springer, Berlin) pp 215–240
9.
BattuHSloanePJ, 2004, “Over-education and ethnic minorities in Britain”The Manchester School72535–559
10.
BattuHFinchJHNewlandsD, 1998, “Integrating knowledge effects into university impact studies: A case study of Aberdeen University”, WP 98-08, Department of Economics, University of Aberdeen
11.
BeckerGS, 1964Human Capital: A Theoretical and Empirical Analysis, with Special Reference to Education (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL)
12.
BeckerGS, 1975Human Capital: A Theoretical and Empirical Analysis, with Special Reference to Education2nd edition (NBER Books, Cambridge, MA)
13.
BlackDASmithJA, 2004, “How robust is the evidence on the effects of college quality? Evidence from matching”Journal of Econometrics12199–124
14.
BlakeCMcDowellS, 1967, “A local input output table”Scottish Journal of Political Economy14227–242
15.
BlundellRDeardrenL, 2000, “The returns to higher education in Britain: Evidence from a British cohort”Economic Journal110F82–F99
16.
BlundellRDeardenLSianesiB, 2005, “Evaluating the effect of education on earnings: Models, methods and results from the National Child Development Survey”Journal of the Royal Statistical Society A168473–512
17.
BradleySTaylorJ, 1996, “Human capital formation and local economic performance”, Regional Studies301–14
18.
BrownSSessionsJG, 2004, “Signalling and screening”, in International Handbook on the Economics of Education Eds JohnesGJohnesJ, (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos) pp 58–100
19.
BrownriggM, 1973, “The economic impact of a new university”Scottish Journal of Political Economy20123–139
20.
CardD, 2001, “Estimating the return to schooling: Progress on some persistent econometric problems”Econometrica691127–1160
21.
ChecchiD, 2006The Economics of Education: Human Capital, Family Background and Inequality (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
DaleSBKruegerAB, 2002, “Estimating the payoff to attending a more selective college: An application of selection on observables and unobservables”Quarterly Journal of Economics1171491–1527
24.
D'AmatoMMookherjeeD, 2012, “Educational signalling, credit constraints and inequality dynamics”, WP 311, Centre for Studies in Economics and Finance (CSEF), Department of Economics, University of Naples
25.
FaggianAMcCannP, 2006, “Human capital flows and regional knowledge assets: A simultaneous equation approach”Oxford Economic Papers58475–500
26.
FaggianAMcCannP, 2009, “Human capital and regional development”, in Handbook of Regional Growth and Development Theories Eds CapelloRNijkampP, (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos) pp 133–151
27.
FischerMVargaA, 2003, “Spatial knowledge spillovers and university research: Evidence from Austria”Annals of Regional Science31303–322
28.
FloraxR, 1992The University: A Regional Booster? (Avebury, Aldershot, Hants)
29.
FreemanS, 1996, “Equilibrium income inequality among identical agents”Journal of Political Economy1041047–1064
30.
GalorOZeiraJ, 1993, “Income distribution and macroeconomics”Review of Economic Studies6035–52
31.
GasteenAHoustonJ, 2007, “Employability and earnings returns to qualifications in Scotland”Regional Studies41443–451
GieseckeJMaddenJ, 2006, “CGE evaluation of a university's effects on a regional economy: An integrated assessment of expenditure and knowledge impacts”Review of Urban and Regional Development Studies18229–251
34.
GoldinCKatzL, 2007, “Long-run changes in the wage structure: Narrowing, widening, polarizing”Brookings Papers on Economic Activity2135–165
35.
GoldsteinHA, 2009, “What we know and what we don't know about the regional economic impacts of universities”, in Universities, Knowledge Transfer and Regional Development Ed. VargaA, (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos) pp 11–35
36.
HarmonCWalkerI, 2003, “The returns to education: Microeconomics”Journal of Economic Surveys17115–153
37.
HarriganFMcGregorPPermanRSwalesKYinYP, 1991, “AMOS: A macro-micro model of Scotland”Economic Modelling8424–479
38.
HarrisR, 1989The Growth and Structure of the UK Regional Economy 1963–1985 (Avebury, Aldershot, Hants)
39.
HarrisRLiQCMoffatJ, 2010a, “The impact of higher education institution-firm knowledge links on firm-level productivity in Britain”, Strathclyde Discussion Papers in Economics, 10–17, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow
40.
HarrisRLiQCMoffatJ, 2010b, “The impact of higher education institution-firm knowledge links on establishment-level productivity in British regions”, Strathclyde Discussion Papers in Economics, 10–18, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow
HermannssonKLisenkovaKMcGregorPGSwalesK, 2010a, “An HEI-disaggregated input-output table for Scotland”, Strathclyde Discussion Papers in Economics, 10–14, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow
43.
HermannssonKLisenkovaKMcGregorPGSwalesK, 2010b, “The expenditure impacts of individual HEIs and their students on the Scottish economy: Homogeneity or heterogeneity?”, Strathclyde Discussion Papers in Economics, 10–16, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow
44.
HermannssonKLisenkovaKMcGregorPLeccaPSwalesK, 2012, “The system-wide impacts of the external benefits to higher education on the Scottish economy: An exploratory ‘micro-to-macro’ approach”, Strathclyde Discussion Papers in Economics 12-04, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow
45.
HermannssonKLisenkovaKMcGregorPGSwalesK, 2013a, “‘Policy scepticism’ and the impact of Scottish higher education institutions (HEIs) on their host region: Accounting for regional budget constraints under devolution”Regional Studies iFirst, doi: 10.1080/00343404.2012.697139
46.
HermannssonKLisenkovaKMcGregorPGSwalesJK, 2013b, “The expenditure impacts of individual higher education institutions and their students on the Scottish economy under a regional government budget constraint: Homogeneity or heterogeneity?”Environment and Planning A45710–727
47.
HicksJR, 1932The Theory of Wages (Macmillan, London)
48.
JaffeAB, 1989, “Real effects of academic research”American Economic Review79957–970
49.
KellyUMcNicollIMcClellanD, 2004, “The impact of the University of Strathclyde on the economy of Scotland and the City of Glasgow”, Project Report, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow
50.
LangeFTopelRH, 2006, “The social value of education and human capital”, in Handbook of the Economics of Education 1 Eds HanushekEWelchF, (Elsevier, Oxford) pp 459–509
51.
LayardRNickellSJackmanR, 1991Unemployment: Macroeconomic Performance and the Labour Market (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
52.
LayardRNickellSJackmanR, 2005Unemployment: Macroeconomic Performance and the Labour Market2nd edition (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
53.
LeccaPMcGregorPGSwalesJK, 2010, “Balanced budget government spending in a small open regional economy”, Strathclyde Discussion Paper in Economics, 10–20, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow
54.
LeccaPMcGregorPGSwalesJK, 2011, “Forward-looking versus myopic regional computable general equilibrium models: How significant is the distinction?”, Strathclyde Discussion Paper in Economics, 11–33, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow
55.
LoveJMcNicollI, 1990, “The economic impact of university funding cuts”Higher Education194481–495
56.
LundvallBA, 2008, “Higher education, innovation and economic development”, in Higher Education and Development Eds LinJYPlescovicB, (The World Bank, Washington, DC) pp 201–228
57.
McGregorPSwalesKYinYP, 1996, “A long-run interpretation of regional input-output analysis”Journal of Regional Science36479–501
McGuinnessS, 2006, “Overeducation in the labour market”Journal of Economics Surveys20387–118
60.
MachinS, 2004, “Skill-biased technical change and educational outcomes”, in International Handbook on the Economics of Education Eds JohnesGJohanesJ, (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos) pp 189–210
61.
MachinSMcNallyS, 2007, “Tertiary education systems and labour markets”, Education and Training Policy Division Report, OECD, Paris
62.
MachinSMarieOVujićS, 2011, “The crime reducing effect of education”Economic Journal121463–484
63.
McMahonWW, 2004, “The social and external benefits of education”, in International Handbook on the Economics of Education Eds JohnesGJohnesJ, (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos) pp 211–259
64.
McMahonW, 2009Higher Learning, Greater Good: The Private and Social Benefits of Higher Education (Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD)
65.
MincerJ, 1958, “Investment in human capital and personal income distribution”Journal of Political Economy66281–302
66.
MookherjeeDRayD, 2003, “Persistent inequality”Review of Economic Studies70369–394
67.
O'LearyNCSloanePJ, 2005, “The changing wage return to an undergraduate education”, DP 1549, IZA, Bonn
68.
ParkerDDZilbermanD, 1993, “University technology transfers: Impacts on local and U.S. economies”Contemporary Economic Policy1187–99
69.
PsacharopoulosGPatrinosHA, 2004, “Human capital and rates of return”, in International Handbook on the Economics of Education Eds JohnesGJohnesJ, (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos) pp 1–7
70.
RoyD, 1951, “The distribution of earnings and of individual output”Economic Journal60489–505
71.
SattingerM, 1993, “Assignment models of the distribution of earnings”Journal of Economic Literature31831–880
72.
SchultzTW, 1960, “Capital formation by education”Journal of Political Economy68571–583
73.
SpenceAM, 1973, “Job market signalling”Quarterly Journal of Economics87355–374
74.
StiglitzJE, 1975, “The theory of ‘screening’: Education, and the distribution of income”American Economic Review65283–300
75.
TinbergenJ, 1951, “Some remarks on the distribution of labour incomes”International Economic Papers1195–207
76.
TinbergenJ, 1956, “On the theory of income distribution”Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv77155–173
77.
ThurowLC, 1975Generating Inequality (Basic Books, New York)
78.
van OursJCRidderG, 1995, “Job matching and job competition: Are lower educated workers at the back of job queues?”European Economic Review391717–1731
79.
VargaASchalkA, 2004, “Knowledge spillovers, agglomeration and macroeconomic growth: An empirical approach”Regional Studies38977–989
