Population projection models that introduce uncertainty are a growing subset of projection models in general. In this paper we focus on the importance of decisions made with regard to the model specifications adopted. We compare the forecasts and prediction intervals associated with four simple regional population projection models: an overall growth rate model, a component model with net migration, a component model with in-migration and out-migration rates, and a multiregional model with destination-specific out-migration rates. Vector autoregressive models are used to forecast future rates of growth, birth, death, net migration, in-migration and out-migration, and destination-specific out-migration for the North, Midlands, and South regions in England. They are also used to forecast different international migration measures. The base data represent a time series of annual data provided by the Office for National Statistics from 1976 to 2008. The results illustrate how both the forecasted subpopulation totals and the corresponding prediction intervals differ for the multiregional model in comparison to other simpler models, as well as for different assumptions about international migration. The paper ends with a discussion of our results and possible directions for future research.
AbelG JBijakJRaymerJ, 2010a, “A comparison of official population projections with Bayesian time series forecasts for England and Wales”Population Trends14195–114
2.
AbelG JBijakJForsterJ JRaymerJSmithP W F, 2010b, “What do Bayesian methods offer population forecasters?” Centre for Population Change Working Paper 6/2010, ESRC Research Centre for Population Change, University of Southampton
3.
AhlburgD A, 1987, “Population forecasts for South Pacific nations using autoregressive models 1985–2000”Journal of Population Research4157–167
AlhoJSpencerB, 2005Statistical Demography and Forecasting (Springer, New York)
6.
BongaartsJBulataoRA, (Eds), 2000Beyond Six Billion: Forecasting the World's Population (National Academy Press, Washington, DC)
7.
BoothH, 2006, “Demographic forecasting: 1980 to 2005 in review”International Journal of Forecasting22(3) 547–581
8.
ChatfieldC, 2004The Analysis of Time Series: An Introduction6th edition (Chapman and Hall/CRC, Boca Raton, FL)
9.
GenzABretzF, 2009Computation of Multivariate Normal and t Probabilities (Springer, Heidelberg)
10.
GenzABretzFMiwaTMiXLeischFScheiplFBornkampBHothornT, 2010, “mvtnorm: Multivariate Normal and t Distributions”, R package, Version 0.9–94, http://CRAN.R-project.org/package=mvtnorm
11.
GullicksonA, 2001, “Multiregional probabilistic forecasting”, paper presented at the Young Scientists Summer Program Midsummer Workshop, International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis, Laxenburg, http://www.demog.berkeley.edu/∼aarong/papers.php
12.
GullicksonAMoenJ, 2001, “The use of stochastic methods in local area population forecasts”, paper presented at the annual meeting of the Population Association of America, Washington, DC, http://www.demog.berkeley.edu/∼aarong/papers.php
13.
KnudsenCMcNownRRogersA, 1993, “Forecasting fertility: An application of time series methods to parameterized model schedules”Social Science Research221–23
14.
LeeR D, 1998, “Probabilistic approaches to population forecasting”Population and Development Review24 (Supplement: Frontiers of Population Forecasting) 156–190
15.
LeeR DTuljapurkarS, 1994, “Stochastic population projections for the United States: Beyond high, medium and low”Journal of the American Statistical Association89(428) 1175–1189
LütkepohlH, 2005New Introduction to Multiple Time Series Analysis (Springer, Berlin)
18.
LutzW, (Ed.), 1996The Future Population of the World: What Can We Assume Today? (Earthscan Publications, London)
19.
LutzWGoldsteinJ R, 2004, “Introduction: How to deal with uncertainty in population forecasting?”International Statistical Review72(1) 1–4
20.
McNownRRogersA, 1989, “Forecasting mortality: A parameterized time series approach”Demography26645–660
21.
McNownRRogersALittleJ, 1995, “Simplicity and complexity in extrapolative population forecasting models”Mathematical Population Studies5235–257
22.
Office for National Statistics, 2010, “2008-based subnational population projections for England”, Statistical Bulletin, Office for National Statistics, Titchfield, Hants
23.
PfaffB, 2008a, “VAR, SVAR and SVEC models: Implementation within R package vars”Journal of Statistical Software27(4) 1–32
24.
PfaffB, 2008bAnalysis of Integrated and Cointegrated Time Series with R2nd edition (Springer, New York)
25.
PflaumerP, 1992, “Forecasting US population totals with the Box—Jenkins approach”International Journal of Forecasting8329–338
26.
PlaneD A, 1993, “Requiem for the fixed transition probability migrant”Geographical Analysis25211–223
27.
R Development Core Team, 2010, “R: A language and environment for statistical computing”, R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna
28.
ReesP, 1997, “Problems and solutions in forecasting geographical populations”Journal of the Australian Population Association14145–166
29.
RogersA, 1976, “Shrinking large-scale population projection models by aggregation and decomposition”Environment and Planning A8515–541
30.
RogersA, 1986, “Parameterized multistate population dynamics and projections”Journal of the American Statistical Association81(393) 48–61
31.
RogersA, 1990a, “Requiem for the net migrant”Geographical Analysis22283–300
32.
RogersA, 1990b, “The multistate stable population model with immigration”Mathematical Population Studies2313–324
van ImhoffEvan der GaagNvan WissenLReesP, 1997, “The selection of internal migration models for European regions”International Journal of Population Geography3157–159
38.
WilsonTBellM, 2007, “Probabilistic regional population forecasts: The example of Queensland, Australia”Geographical Analysis391–25
39.
WilsonTReesP, 2005, “Recent developments in population projection methodology: A review”Population, Space and Place11337–360
