This paper explores the dynamics of institutional change in periods of instability in the global capitalist system. Two recent bodies of literature—actor-centered institutionalism and the ‘policy mobilities’ approach—emphasize how contextual and historical specificities drive transformation as institutions move across space. However, scholars in both traditions give less attention to the systematic patterns of social conflict that influence how policies move and mutate. Drawing on the case of a standards war in the global cotton trade from 1870 to 1945, I build on these literatures by linking them to a neo-Polanyian theory of social conflict within periods of market-led development. From this view, we must understand institutions, their mobilities, and mutations as constituted by and constitutive of struggles over how the global capitalist system should be organized and in whose interests. This requires building on, but also deepening Polanyi's analysis. While Polanyi emphasized the destructive effects of liberal market projects that generate social conflict, the ‘push-backs’ against liberal market projects are more diverse than Polanyi suggested, and social conflict can also emerge out of the creative moments of liberal market expansion.
AlchonG, 1985The Invisible Hand of Planning (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
2.
ArrighiG, 1994The Long Twentieth Century (Verso Books, New York)
3.
ArrighiGSilverB, 2001, “Capitalism and world (dis)order”Review of International Studies27257279
4.
BartelsR, 1951, “Influences on the development of marketing thought”The Journal of Marketing16(1) 117
5.
BlockF, 2003, “Karl Polanyi and the writing of The Great Transformation”Theory and Society32275306
6.
BlockF, 2007, “Understanding the diverging trajectories of the United States and Western Europe”Politics and Society35333
7.
BouillyR, 1975The Development of American Cotton Exchanges, 1870–1916 PhD dissertation, Department of History, University of Missouri-Columbia
8.
BrandCJ, 1923, “Compulsory cotton standards in the U.S. under the New Cotton Standards ActInternational Cotton Bulletin1(2) 36769, International Federation of Master Cotton Spinners' and Manufacturers' Associations, Manchester, 10 March
9.
BrennerN, 2004New State Spaces (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
BurawoyM, 1979Manufacturing Consent (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL)
12.
BurawoyM, 2003, “For a sociological Marxism: The complementary convergence of Antonio Gramsci and Karl Polanyi”Politics and Society31193261
13.
CampbellJL, 2004Institutional Change and Globalization (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
14.
CochoyF, 1998, “Another discipline for the market economy: Marketing as a performative knowledge and know-how for capitalism”, in The Laws of the Markets Ed. CallonM (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 194221
15.
CrononW, 1991Nature's Metropolis: Chicago and the Great West (W W Norton, New York)
16.
DaleG, 2008, “Karl Polanyi's The Great Transformation: Perverse effects, protectionism and Gemeinschaft”Economy and Society37495524
17.
DaleG, 2010, “Social democracy, embeddedness and decommodification”New Political Economy15369393
18.
DjelicM-LQuackS, 2003a, “Introduction: Governing globalization—bringing institutions back in”, in Globalization and Institutions Eds DjelicM-LQuackS (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos) pp 114
19.
DjelicM-LQuackS, 2003b, “Theoretical building blocks for a research agenda linking globalization and institutions”, in Globalization and Institutions Eds DjelicM-LQuackS (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos) pp 1536
20.
DjelicM-LQuackS, 2007, “Overcoming path dependencies: Path generation in open systems”Theory and Society36161186
21.
DjelicM-LSahlin-AnderssonK, 2006, “Introduction: A world of governance: The rise of transnational regulation”, in Transnational Governance Eds DjelicM-LSahlin-AnderssonK (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 128
22.
DumbellS, 1926, “The cotton market in 1799”Economic History1141148
23.
EllisonT, 1968 [1886] The Cotton Trade of Great Britain (Frank Cass, London)
24.
FarnieDA, 1979The English Cotton Industry and the World Market, 1815–1896 (Clarendon Press, Oxford)
25.
FlemingLJr, 1966Growth of the Business of Anderson, Clayton & CoGulf Coast Historical Association Publication Series, Houston, Texas
26.
Fourcade-GourinchasMBabbSL, 2002, “The rebirth of the liberal creed: Paths to neoliberalism in four countries”American Journal of Sociology108533579
GilbertJ, 2000, “Eastern urban liberals and Midwestern agrarian intellectuals: Two group portraits of progressives in the New Deal Department of Agriculture”Agricultural History74162180
29.
HallPASoskiceDW (Eds), 2001Varieties of Capitalism (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
30.
HallidayTCCarruthersBG, 2009Bankrupt: Global Lawmaking and Systemic Financial Crisis (Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA)
31.
HalperinR, 1984, “Polanyi, Marx, and the institutional paradigm in economic anthropology”, in Research in Economic Anthropology, Volume 6 Ed. IsaacB L (JAI Press, Greenwich)
32.
HessM, 2004, “‘Spatial’ relationships? Towards a reconceptualization of embeddedness”Progress in Human Geography28165185
33.
HobsbawmEJ, 1975The Age of Capital, 1848–1875 (Weidenfeld and Nicolson, London)
34.
House of Representatives, 1908Report of the Commissioner of Corporations on Cotton Exchanges Document No. 949, 60th Congress, 1st Session, May 4, 1908
35.
HugillPJ, 2009, “The American challenge to British hegemony, 1861–1947”Geographical Review99403425
36.
HungH-F, 2009, “Introduction: The three transformations of global capitalism”, in China and the Transformation of Global Capitalism Ed. HungH-F (Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD) pp 121
37.
IFMCSMA, 1907Official Report: Second International Conference of Cotton Growers, Spinners, and Manufacturers, Atlanta, Georgia, October 7–9 International Federation of Master Cotton Spinners' and Manufacturers' Associations (Taylor, Garnett, Evans & Co, Manchester)
38.
International Cotton Bulletin1923, “The United States Cotton Standards Act”1(June) 417422
39.
JonesDGBMoniesonDD, 1990, “Early development of the philosophy of marketing thought”The Journal of Marketing54(1) 102113
40.
KillickJR, 1974, “Bolton Ogden & Co.: A case study in Anglo-American trade, 1790–1850”The Business History Review48501519
41.
KillickJR, 1981, “The transformation of cotton marketing in the late nineteenth century”The Business History Review55143169
42.
KrasnerSD, 1984, “Approaches to the state: Alternative conceptions and historical dynamics”Comparative Politics16223246
43.
LarnerW, 2003, “Neoliberalism?”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space21509512
44.
LipartitoJJ, 1983, “The New York Cotton Exchange and the development of the cotton futures market”The Business History Review575072
45.
McCannEJ, 2008, “Expertise, truth, and urban policy mobilities”Environment and Planning A40885904
46.
McCannE, 2011, “Urban policy mobilities and global circuits of knowledge”Annals of the Association of American Geographers101107130
47.
McCannEWardK, 2010, “Relationality/territoriality: Toward a conceptualization of cities in the world”Geoforum41175184
48.
McMichaelP, 1987, “State formation and the construction of the world market”Political Power and Social Theory6187237
49.
MansfieldB, 2004, “Rules of privatization: Contradictions in neoliberal regulation of North Pacific fisheries”Annals of the Association of American Geographers94565584
50.
MarshAR, 1911, “Cotton exchanges and their economic functions”Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science38253280
51.
MarxK, 1976 [1867] Capital, Volume I (Penguin, London)
52.
MeadowsWR, 1921, “Preliminary manufacturing tests of the official cotton standards of the United States for color for upland tinged and stained cotton”, 20 October, United States Department of Agriculture, Bulletin 990
53.
MeadowsWRBlairWG, 1921, Comparative spinning tests of meade and sea island cottons”, 21 February, United States Department of Agriculture, Bulletin 946
54.
MontgomeryRH, 1929The Cooperative Pattern in Cotton (Macmillan, New York)
55.
NobleDF, 1977America by Design (Alfred A Knopf, New York)
56.
PalmerAW, 1961The Growth of Cotton Fiber Science in the United States Publication 4452, Smithsonian Institute, Washington, DC
57.
PeckJ, 2004, “Geography and public policy”Progress in Human Geography28392405
58.
PeckJ, 2011, “Geographies of policy: From transfer—diffusion to mobility—mutation”Progress in Human Geography35773797
PolanyiK, 1957 [1944] The Great Transformation (Beacon Press, Boston, MA)
62.
QuarkAA, 2008, “Toward a new theory of change: Socio-natural regimes and the historical development of the cotton textiles commodity chain”Review: A Journal of the Fernand Braudel CenterXXXI(1) 137
63.
RandlesS, 2003, “Issues for a neo-Polanyian research agenda in economic sociology”International Review of Sociology13409434
64.
RansomRLSutchR, 1972, “Debt peonage in the cotton South after the Civil War”The Journal of Economic History 32 641669
65.
RobertsTParksB, 2006A Climate of Injustice (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)
66.
RothsteinM, 1983, “The New South and the international economy”Agricultural History57385402
67.
RussellE, 2011Evolutionary History (Cambridge University Press, New York)
68.
SaloutosT, 1960Farmer Movements in the South, 1865–1933 (University of Nebraska Press, Lincoln, NE)
69.
SchumpeterJ, 1942 [1976] Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy (Harper and Brothers, New York)
70.
SchwartzM, 1976Radical Protest and Social Structure (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL)
71.
SheppardELeitnerH, 2010, “Quo vadis neoliberalism? The remaking of global capitalist governance after the Washington Consensus”Geoforum41185194
72.
SilverB, 2003Forces of Labor (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
73.
SilverBJArrighiG, 2003, “Polanyi's ‘double movement’: The belle epoques of British and US hegemony compared”Politics and Society31325355
74.
SmithN, 2005The Endgame of Globalization (Routledge, London)
75.
StreeckWThelenK, 2005, “Introduction: Institutional change in advanced political economies”, in Beyond Continuity: Institutional Change in Advanced Political Economies Eds StreeckWThelenK (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 139
76.
TennyLS, 1925, “Universal cotton standards”The American Review of ReviewsLXXII(August) 184188
77.
TennyLS, 1947, “The Bureau of Agricultural Economics: The early years”Journal of Farm Economics2910171026
78.
TickellAPeckJ, 2003, “Making global rules: Globalization or neoliberalization?”, in Remaking the Global Economy Eds PeckJYeungH Wai-Chung (Sage, London) pp 163181
79.
USDA, United States Department of Agriculture, Washington, DC1922Universal Standards for American Cotton with a Brief History of the Movement to Secure Universal Cotton Standards
80.
1923Report of Conference called at Washington, D.C. for the consideration of Tentative Regulations of the Secretary of Agriculture under the U.S. Cotton Standards Act, April 9–10, 1923Bureau of Agricultural Economics
81.
1924The United States Cotton Standards Act and the Universal Standards: Essential Provisions of the United States Cotton Standards ActBureau of Agricultural Economics, Service and Regulatory Announcements 82, March
82.
1935National Standards for Farm ProductsBureau of Agricultural Economics, Circular 8
83.
WallersteinI, 1974The Modern World-system I (Academic Press, New York)
84.
WinderG, 2006, “Webs of enterprise 1850–1914”Annals of the Association of American Geographers96788806
85.
YangH-T, 1937Development of The United States Cotton Standards PhD dissertation, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY
