In this paper, aspects of four areas of controversy which have recently surrounded the development and application of Q-analysis are examined. It is suggested that the difficulties over which the controversy has been generated are underpinned by important substantive problems, which those wishing to utilise the approach should be aware of, but that further development and application of the style of analysis afforded by Q-analysis and related methods should continue.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AtkinR H, 1974Mathematical Structure in Human Affairs (Heinemann Educational Books, London)
2.
AtkinR H, 1975–1977, “The methodology for Q-analysis” research reports 5–10, Department of Mathematics, University of Essex, Colchester
3.
CouclelisH, 1983, “On some problems in defining sets in Q-analysis”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design10423–438
4.
CullenI, 1983, “Q-analysis and the theory of social scientific knowledge”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design10393–401
5.
GouldP, 1981, “Letting the data speak for themselves”Annals of the Association of American Geographers71166–176
6.
GouldP, 1983, “Reflective distanciation from a metamethodological perspective”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design10381–392
7.
GriffithsH B, 1983, “Using mathematics to simplify Q-analysis”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design10403–422
8.
GriffithsH BEvansP J, 1981, “Atkin's Q-analysis: A critique and reformulation”Department of Mathematics, University of Southampton, Southampton, Hants
9.
HarveyD, 1973Social Justice and the City (Edward Arnold, London)
10.
HoY S, 1982a, “The planning process: A formal model”Environment and Planning B9377–386
11.
HoY S, 1982b, “The planning process: Fundamental issues”Environment and Planning B9387–395
12.
HoY S, 1982c, “The planning process: Structure of verbal descriptions”Environment and Planning B9397–420
JohnsonJ H, 1981a, “Some structures and notation of Q-analysis”Environment and Planning B873–86
15.
JohnsonJ H, 1981b, “Q-discrimination analysis”Environment and Planning B8419–434
16.
JohnsonJ H, 1982a, “Ordinal scales in Q-discrimination analysis”Environment and Planning B9491–492
17.
JohnsonJ H, 1982b, “Q-transmission in simplicial complexes”International Journal of Man-Machine Studies16351–377
18.
JohnsonJ H, 1983b, “Hierarchical set definition by Q-analysis, part I: The hierarchical backcloth”International Journal of Man-Machine Studies18337–359
19.
JohnsonJ H, 1983c, “Hierarchical set definition by Q-analysis, part II: Traffic on the hierarchical backcloth”International Journal of Man-Machine Studies18467–487
20.
JohnsonJ H, 1983a, “A survey of Q-analysis 1: The past and present” paper presented to Seminar on Q-analysis and the Social Sciences, University of Leeds, September 1983; copy available from the author at Centre for Configurational Studies, The Open University, Milton Keynes, England
21.
JohnstonR J, 1983, review of A Search for Common Ground edited by GouldPOlssonG, Environment and Planning A15561–562
22.
MacgillS M, 1982, “A consideration of Johnson's Q-discrimination analysis”Environment and Planning B9315–330
23.
MacgillS M, 1983a, “Cluster analysis and Q-analysis”International Journal of Man-Machine Studies (forthcoming)
24.
MacgillS M, 1983b, “Q-analysis and the social sciences”: A report on the SSRC-sponsored Seminar on Q-analysis and the Social Sciences, University of Leeds, September 1983; copy obtainable from the author
25.
MacgillS M, 1983c, “Q-discrimination analysis: Further observations”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design10239–240
26.
MarchL, 1982, “On Ho's methodological approach to design and planning”Environment and Planning B9421–427
27.
MarchL, 1983, “Designs in a universe of chance: A Piercian construction”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design10471–484
28.
PorteousH, 1983, “A critique of q-analysis” paper presented to Seminar Q-analysis and the Social Sciences, University of Leeds, September 1983; copy obtainable from the author at Department of Mathematics, Sheffield City Polytechnic, Sheffield S1 1WB
29.
SeidmanS, 1983, “Rethinking backcloth and traffic: Perspectives from social network analysis and Q-analysis”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design10439–456
30.
Social Science Research Council, 1983, “Q-analysis”; copy obtainable from 1 Temple Avenue, London EC4
31.
StewartI, 1978Concepts of Modern Mathematics (Penguin Books, Harmondsworth, Middx)
