Planning for Open Storage of Containers in a Major International Container Trade Centre: An Analysis of Hong Kong Development Control Statistics Using Probit Modelling
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online August, 2002
Planning for Open Storage of Containers in a Major International Container Trade Centre: An Analysis of Hong Kong Development Control Statistics Using Probit Modelling
The authors describe the nature of the planning policies relating to the container industry of Hong Kong, a major international container trade centre, at territorial and district planning levels. Informed by the concepts of transaction costs, the authors attempt to ascertain whether the planning permission system in Hong Kong is promarket, antimarket, or market-neutral with respect to the container industry, and whether the stated statutory district planning policy of permitting and concentrating open storage in specifically designated Open Storage (OS) zones has been followed. A probit model is developed to evaluate 195 sets of nonaggregate and cross-sectional data regarding planning applications to the Town Planning Board for the years 1991 to 1998. The evaluation is conducted in terms of two refutable empirical hypotheses regarding the container industry. The findings suggest that the Hong Kong planning permission mechanism is market neutral towards the container industry and that the statutory district forward planning policy for that industry has not been followed in the development control process.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AlexanderD EFairbridgeR W (Eds), 1999The Encyclopaedia of Environmental Science (Kluwer, Dordrecht)
2.
AlexanderE R, 1992, “A transaction cost theory of planning”Journal of the American Planning Association58, 190–200
3.
AlexanderE R, 1994, “To plan or not to plan, that is the question: Transaction cost theory and its implications for planning”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design21, 341–352
4.
BrothertonD I, 1982, “Development pressures and control in the national park 1966–1981”Town Planning Review53, 439–459
5.
BrothertonD I, 1992a, “On the quantity and quality of planning applications”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design19, 337–357
6.
BrothertonD I, 1992b, “On the control of development by planning authorities”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design19, 465–478
7.
BullerHHoggartK, 1985, “Non-decision making and community power: Residential development control in rural areas”Progress in Planning25, 137–203
8.
Census and Statistics Department, various years Annual Digest of Statistics (Government Printer, Hong Kong)
9.
ChengL KWongR Y C, 1998Port Facilities and Container Handling Services (City University of Hong Kong Press, Hong Kong)
10.
CheungS N S, 1974, “A theory of price control”Journal of Law and Economics17, 53–71
11.
CoaseR H, 1960, “The problem of social cost”Journal of Law and Economics4, 1–44
12.
CuthbertA R, 1998, “Genesis of landuse planning and urban development”, in Land-use Transport Planning in Hong Kong: The End of an Era: A Review of Principles and Practice Eds DimitriousH TCookA H S (Ashgate, Aldershot, Hants) pp 35–54
13.
FechnerG T, 1860Elemente der Psychophysik (Breitkof und Hartel, Leipzig)
14.
FinneyD J, 1952Probit Analysis (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
15.
FischelW A, 1995Regulatory Takings: Law, Economics and Politics (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
16.
JimC Y, 1996, “Proliferation of nonconforming land uses in agricultural envelope of urban Hong Kong”Environmental Management20, 461–474
17.
LaiL W C, 1991, “Some economic aspects of agriculture in the New Territories”Planning and Development7, 42–44
18.
LaiL W C, 1992, “Planning for container storage in Hong Kong”Planning and Development8, 14–16
19.
LaiL W C, 1994, “The economics of land-use zoning: A literature review and analysis of the work of Coase”Town Planning Review65, 77–98
20.
LaiL W C, 1997a, “Evolution of the contractual nature of land use control in Hong Kong”, in Political Order and Power Transition in Hong Kong Ed. LiP K (Chinese University Press, Hong Kong) pp 231–253
21.
LaiL W C, 1997bTown Planning in Hong Kong: A Critical Review (City University of Hong Kong Press, Hong Kong)
22.
LaiL W C, 1998a, “The leasehold system as a means of planning by contract: The case of Hong Kong”Town Planning Review69, 249–275
23.
LaiL W C, 1998b, “Hong Kong: Political economy aspects of the port and airport development strategy”Ekistics65, 146–159
24.
LaiL W C, 1999Town Planning in Hong Kong: A Review of Planning Appeal Decisions (University of Hong Kong Press, Hong Kong)
25.
LaiL W C, 2002, “Fifty years no change: Planning and development in Hong Kong under constitutional capitalism”China's Hong Kong into 21st Century: Crisis and Transformations in the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region Eds ChanMSoE (M E Sharpe, Armonk, NY) forthcoming
26.
LaiL W CAuE W K, 1990, “The rule of two to three: The optimal building construction expenditure in Hong Kong in the PADS age”Asian Journal of Public Administration12, 69–100
27.
LaiL W CFongK, 2000Planning Practice in Hong Kong: Context, Procedures and Statistics (University of Hong Kong Press, Hong Kong)
28.
LaiL W CHoW K O, 2001a, “A probit analysis of development control: A Hong Kong case study on residential zones”Urban Studies38, 2425–2437
29.
LaiL W CHoW K O, 2001b, “Small is beautiful: A probit analysis of development control of small houses in Hong Kong”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design28, 611–622
30.
LaiL W CHoW K O, 2001c, “Low-rise residential developments in green belts: A Hong Kong empirical study of planning applications”Planning Practice and Research16, 321–335
31.
LaiL W CHoW K O, 2001d, “Zone separation: A probit analysis of Hong Kong planning application statistics”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design28, 923–932
32.
LaiL W CLamK K H, 1999, “The evolution and future of pond and marine fish culture in Hong Kong”Aquaculture Economics and Management3, 254–266
33.
LarkhamP J, 1986, “The role of estate agents in the development process: A wider perspective”Land Development Studies3, 181–139
34.
LarkhamP J, 1988, “Changing conservation areas in the English Midlands: Evidence from local planning records”Urban Geography9, 445–465
35.
LeeL FTrostR P, 1978, “Estimation of some limited dependent variable models with application to housing demand”Journal of Econometrics8, 357–382
36.
McNamaraPHealeyP, 1984, “The limitations of development control data in planning research: A comment on Ian Brotherton's recent study”Town Planning Review55, 91–97
37.
MaddalaG S, 1992Introduction to Econometrics (Macmillan, New York)
38.
NorthD CThomasR P, 1973The Rise of the Western World: A New Economic History (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, MA)
Port International2001, “Save the best until last”1, 43
42.
PosnerR, 1992 Economics Analysis of Law (Little, Brown, Boston, MA)
43.
PreeceR, 1990, “Development control studies: Scientific method and policy analysis”Town Planning Review61, 59–74
44.
SellgrenJ, 1990, “Development-control data for planning research: The use of aggregated development-control records”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design17, 23–37
45.
StaleyS, 1994Planning Rules and Urban Economic Performance (Chinese University Press, Hong Kong)
46.
StaleyS, 2000, “Ballot box zoning, transaction costs and urban growth”Journal of American Planning Association67, 25–31
47.
TangB SChoyL H T, 2000, “Modelling planning control decisions”Cities17, 219–225
48.
TangB STangR M H, 1999, “Development control, planning incentive and urban redevelopment: Evaluation of a two-tier plot ratio system in Hong Kong”Land Use Policy16, 33–43
49.
TangB SChoyL H TWatJ K F, 2000, “Certainty and discretion in planning control: A case study of office decentralisation”Urban Studies37, 2465–2493
50.
TheilH, 1971Principles of Econometrics (John Wiley, New York)
51.
TobinJ, 1975Essays in Economics, Volume 2: Consumption and Econometrics (North-Holland, Amsterdam)
52.
WangJ J, 1998, “A container load centre with a developing hinterland: A case study of Hong Kong”Journal of Transport Geography6, 187–201
WillisK G, 1995, “Judging development control decisions”Urban Studies32, 1065–1079
55.
YuenM F, 2001, “Future development of the port of Hong Kong”, in Modern Transport of Hong Kong for the 21st Century Eds YehA G OHillP RNgS K W (Centre of Urban Planning and Environmental Management, Hong Kong) pp 49–60
