The authors analyze the cultural, economic, and political background of new gated housing estates in the Arab world with the aid of case studies in Lebanon and Riyadh. Their question is to what extent these developments represent a reappearance of the fragmented settlement patterns in many of the old towns. On the one hand, new compounds of several villas and common facilities housing extended families in Riyadh may be interpreted as a revival of certain sociospatial settings in the old town, in which extended families often shared a common courtyard. The compounds for Western foreigners in Saudi Arabia follow the principle of spatial seclusion of social groups with different cultural and religious backgrounds—a principle of the sociospatial organization of many old towns in the Arab world. The emergence of gated housing estates in Lebanon, on the other hand, has obvious and specific sociopolitical origins in the 20th century. The failure of public regimentation and provision created a gap, which was partially filled by the private sector. For their mostly wealthy clientele, gated housing estates offer private small-scale solutions to nationwide problems.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abu-LughodJ, 1987, “The Islamic city—historic myth, Islamic essence, and contemporary relevance”International Journal for Middle Eastern Studies19155–176
2.
ACS (Ed.), 1997, “Le mohafazat du Mont-Liban et 1996: résultats du recensement des immeubles et des établissements” [The mohofazat (district) of Mount Lebanon 1996: results of the census of the buildings and the establishments], Études Statistiques 6, Administration Centrale de la Statistique, Beirut, www.cas.gov.lb
3.
Al HathloulS, 1981The Arab Muslim City: Tradition, Continuity and Change in the Physical Environment PhD thesis, Department of Architecture, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA
4.
AnchassiR, 2001, “Back to ‘realty’: developers see revival of apartment market”Lebanon Opportunities March, pages 10–15
5.
AvelineN, 2000, “Marchés fonciers et immobiliers à Beyrouth” [Land and real estate markets in Beirut], document 6, Centre d'Études et de Recherche sur le Moyen-Orient Contemporain, PO Box 2691 Beirut
6.
AwadaF, 1988Les gestion des services urbains à Beyrouth pendant la guerre 1975–1985 [The management of urban services in Beirut during the war] (Pratiques Urbaines, Paris)
7.
BarthH LSchliephakeK, 1998Saudi-Arabien (Klett-Perthes, Stuttgart)
8.
BombacciN, 1998, “Ségrégation, trafic de papiers, expulsions: préférence nationale à la saoudienne” [Segregation, traffic of permits, expulsion: national preference in the Saudi-Arabian way]Le Monde diplomatique October, page 10
9.
BourgeyA, 1987, “Les emirates du Golfe sont-elles encore des villes arabes?” [The Gulf Emirates—are they still Arab cities?]Cahier d'études arabes17–26
10.
DajaniN H, 1990, “The role of urban institutions in the management of daily conflicts in Beirut”, paper presented at the round-table meeting on “Les espaces publics de Beyrouth en 1990”, Maison de l'Orient Méditerranean, Lyon; copy available from URBAMA, University of Tours, Tours
11.
DenisE, 1998, “La Nahda umraniya figure de la libéralisation: la déclinaison locale, au Caire, d'un nouveau mode d'habiter des élites métropolitaines” [The nahda ‘umraniya’ as a figure of liberalization: the local variation of a new kind of elite living in Cairo], paper presented at the workshop on “La dispense et/ou la redistribution des processus distributifs et normatifs: la part du local”, Cairo, copy available from the author, Centre d'Études et de Documentation Économiques, Juridiques et Sociales, PO Box 392, Muhhammad Farid, Cairo
12.
EickelmanD F, 1974, “Is there an Islamic City? The making of a quarter in a Moroccon town”International Journal of Middle East Studies5274–294
13.
FadanY, 1983The Development of Contemporary Housing in Saudi Arabia (1950–1983): A Study in Cross-cultural Influence under Conditions of Rapid Change unpublished PhD thesis, Department of Architecture, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA
14.
GatesC L, 1998The Merchant Republic of Lebanon: Rise of an Open Economy (Tauris, London)
15.
GhorraC M-F, 1975Les centres résidentiels suburbains dans la croissance de Beyrouth [Suburban residential complexes in the expansion of Beirut] unpublished PhD thesis, Department of Geography, Université de Toulouse le Mirail, Toulouse
16.
GlaszeG, 2001, “Geschlossene Wohnkomplexe (gated communities) als Enklaven des Wohlbefindens in der wirtschaftsliberalen Stadt” [Guarded residential complexes (gated communities) as enclaves of well-being in the deregulated city], in Stadt—der Lebensraum der Zukunft? Gegenwärtige raumbezogene Prozesse in Verdichtungsräumen der Erde Ed. RoggenthinH, Mainzer Kontaktstudium Geographie 7, Geographisches Institut der Universität Mainz, Mainz, pp 41–57
17.
HermannUNeuberthR, 1998, “Gemeinwohl als Produkt gesellschaftlicher Austauschprozesse betrachtet—ein Ausblick” [Public interest seen as product of social discourses—an outlook], in Gemeinwohl—mehr als gut gemeint? Klärungen und Anstöße Eds FetzerJGerlachJ (Gütersloher Verlagshaus, Gütersloh) pp 49–50
18.
KhalafS, 1985, “Social structure and urban planning in Lebanon”, in Property Social Structure and Law in the Modern Middle East Ed. MauerE (State University of New York Press, New York) pp 213–235
19.
MeyerG, 1991, “Arbeitsmigration in die Golfregion und die Folgen des irakischen Überfalls auf Kuwait” [Workers' migration in the Gulf region and the consequences of the Iraqi aggression against Kuwait]Die Erde12281–96
20.
NahasCh, 1999, “Économie foncière et immobilière au Liban” [Land and real estate markets in Lebanon], paper presented at the Centre Culturel Français de Beyrouth, Beirut, January; copy available from document 6, Centre d'Études et de Recherche sur le Moyen-Orient Contemporain, PO Box 2691 Beirut
21.
PapeH, 1977Er Riad: Stadtgeographie und Stadtkartographie der Hauptstadt Saudi-Arabiens [Riyadh: urban geography and urban cartography of the capital of Saudi Arabia] (Ferdinand Schöningh, Paderborn)
22.
Peißker-MeyerC F, 2001Heimat auf Zeit: Deutsche, britische und holländische Frauen in Damaskus [A temporary ‘Heimat’: German, British and Dutch women in Damascus] unpublished PhD thesis, Geographisches Institut der Universität Mainz, Mainz
23.
RaymondA, 1989, “Espaces publics et espaces privés dans les villes arabes traditionnelles” [Public spaces and private spaces in traditional Arab cities]Maghreb Machrek123194–202
24.
RaymondA, 1994, “Islamic city, Arab city: orientalist myths and recent views”British Journal of Middle Eastern Studies213–18
25.
Riyadh High Development Authority (Ed.), 1999Atlas of Arriyadh (in Arabic) (King Saud University Press, Riyadh)
26.
TalibK, 1984Shelter in Saudi Arabia (St Martin's Press, New York)
27.
WirthE, 1991, “Zur Konzeption der Islamischen Stadt: Privatheit im islamischen Orient versus Öffentlichkeit in Antike und Okzident” [On the conception of the Islamic city: privacy in the Islamic Orient versus public sphere in antiquity and occident]Die Welt des Islam3150–92
28.
WirthE, 2000Die orientalische Stadt im islamischen Vorderasien und Nordafrika [The oriental city in the Islamic Middle East and North Africa] (Philip von Zabern, Mainz)
