Previous research had introduced a genetic algorithm procedure for creating alternative policy options for municipal solid waste (MSW) management planning. These alternatives were generated during the design phase of planning, with the final policy determined in subsequent comparative analysis. However, because of the many uncertain factors that exist within MSW systems, this earlier procedure cannot be applied to situations containing such stochastic components. In this paper, it is shown that a generic algorithm approach can be simultaneously combined with simulation to incorporate these stochastic elements in the policy option generation phase; thereby permitting uncertainty to be directly integrated into the construction of the alternatives during the planning-design phase. This procedure is applied to case data taken from the Regional Municipality of Hamilton–Wentworth in the Province of Ontario, Canada. It can be shown that this procedure extends the earlier approach and provides many practical planning benefits for problems when uncertain conditions are present.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AzadivarFTompkinsG, 1999, “Simulation optimization with qualitative variables and structural model changes: a genetic algorithm approach”European Journal of Operational Research113169–182
2.
BaetzB W, 1990, “Optimization/simulation modeling for waste management capacity planning”ASCE Journal of Urban Planning and Development116(2) 59–79
3.
BassBHuangG HRussoJ, 1997, “Incorporating climate change into risk assessment using grey mathematical programming”Journal of Environmental Management49107–124
4.
BodnerR MCassellAAndrosP J, 1970, “Optimal routing of refuse collection vehicles”ASCE Journal of the Sanitary Engineering Division96893–903
5.
BrillE D, 1979, “The use of optimization models in public sector planning”Management Science25413–422
6.
BrillE DChangS YHopkinsL D, 1981, “Modelling to generate alternatives: the HSJ approach and an illustration using a problem in land use planning”Management Science27314–325
7.
BrownR VKahrA SPetersonC, 1974Decision Analysis for the Manager (Holt, Rinehart and Winston, New York)
8.
BudnickF SMcLeaveyD MMojenaR, 1988Principles of Operations Research for Management (Richard D Irwin, Homewood, IL)
9.
CaudillMButlerC, 1990Naturally Intelligent Systems (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)
10.
ChangN BWangS F, 1995, “A grey nonlinear programming approach for planning coastal wastewater treatment and disposal systems”Water Science and Technology3219–29
11.
ChangN BWenC GYongY C, 1996, “A grey fuzzy multiobjective programming approach for optimal planning of a reservoir watershed”Water Research302329–2334
12.
ChangS YBrillE DHopkinsL D, 1980, “Efficient random generation of feasible alternatives: a land use planning example”, Staff Paper 12, Institute for Environmental Studies, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Urbana, IL
13.
ChangS YBrillE DHopkinsL D, 1982, “Use of mathematical models to generate alternative solutions to water resources planning problems”Water Resources Research1858–64
14.
CoyleR G, 1973, “Computer-based design for refuse collection systems”, in Models for Environmental Pollution Control Ed. DeningerR (Ann Arbor Science, Ann Arbor, MI) pp 307–325
15.
DibbleCDenshamP J, 1993, “Generating interesting alternatives in GIS and SDSS using genetic algorithms”, in Proceedings of GIS/LIS 1993 American Society for Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing/American Congress on Surveying and Mapping, 5410 Grosvenor Lane, Bethesda, MD 20814–2160
16.
FalkenauerE, 1998Genetic Algorithms and Grouping Problems (John Wiley, New York)
17.
FalkenhausenK, 1979, “Facility location planning for regional waste treatment systems by branch and bound vs. evolution strategy concepts”, paper presented at the ORSA/TIMS Milwaukee Conference
18.
FontaniliFVincentAPonsonnetR, 2000, “Flow simulation and genetic algorithm as optimization tools”International Journal of Production Economics6491–100
19.
FouldsLThachenkaryC, 2001, “Empower to the people”OR/MS Today28(3) 32–37
20.
GalTGreenbergH J (Eds), 1997Advances in Sensitivity Analysis and Parametric Programming (Kluwer Academic, Boston, MA)
21.
GidleyJ SBariM F, 1986, “Modellkng to generate alternatives”ASCE Water Forum '86 pp 1366–1373
22.
GoldbergD E, 1989Genetic Algorithms in Search Optimization and Machine Learning (Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA)
23.
GoldbergD E, 1991Genetic Algorithms (Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA)
24.
GottingerH W, 1986, “A computational model for solid waste management with applications”Applied Mathematical Modelling10330–338
25.
GreyS, 1995Practical Risk Assessment (John Wiley, New York)
26.
HarrisB, 1983, “Positive and normative aspects of modelling large-scale social systems”, in Systems Analysis in Urban Policy-making and Planning Eds BattyMHutchinsonB (Plenum Press, New York) pp 475–490
27.
HasitYWarnerD B, 1981, “Regional solid waste planning with WRAP”ASCE Journal of Environmental Engineering107511–525
28.
HaynesL, 1981, “A systems approach to solid waste management planning”Conservation and Recycling4(2) 67–78
29.
HollandJ H, 1992Adaptation in Natural and Artifical Systems2nd edition (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)
30.
HuangG H, 1994Grey Mathematical Programming and Its Application to Waste Management Planning Under Uncertainty PhD dissertation, Department of Civil Engineering, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario
31.
HuangG H, 1996, “IPWM: an interval parameter water quality management model”Engineering Optimization2679–103
32.
HuangG HBaetzB WPatryG G, 1994a, “A grey chance-constrained programming approach for waste management planning under uncertainty”, in Effective Environmental Management for Sustainable Development Eds HipelK WFangL (Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht) pp 267–280
33.
HuangG HBaetzB WPatryG G, 1994b, “Grey dynamic programming for solid waste management planning under uncertainty”ASCE Journal of Urban Planning and Development120132–156
34.
HuangG HBaetzB WPatryG G, 1995, “A grey integer programming approach for waste management planning”European Journal of Operational Research83594–620
35.
HuangG HCohenS JYinY YBassB, 1996a, “Incorporation of inexact integer programming and fuzzy relation analysis for integrated environment impact assessment and adaptation study under uncertainty”Journal of Environmental Management4845–68
36.
HuangG HBaetzB WPatryG G, 1996b, “A grey hop, skip and jump method for generating decision alternatives: planning for the expansion/utilization of waste management facilities”Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering231207–1219
37.
HuangG HJorgensenS EXuYGuoH C, 1997Integrated Environmental Planning for Sustainable Development in Lake Erhai Basin—with a Diagnostic Study for Local Environmental ConcernsUnited Nations Environment Programme, Nairobi, Kenya
HuangG HYeomansJ SYoogalingamR, 2001, “Combining simulation with evolutionary algorithms for optimal planning under uncertainty: an application to municipal solid waste management planning in the Regional Municipality of Hamilton – Wentworth”, working paper, Schulich School of Business, York University, Toronto, Ontario
40.
InuiguchiMIchihashiHTanakaH, 1990, “Fuzzy programming: a survey of recent developments”, in Stochastic versus Fuzzy Approaches to Mathematical Programming under Uncertainty Eds SlowinskiRTeghemJ (Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht) pp 45–70
41.
KeeneyR LRaiffaH, 1976, “Decision with Multiple Objectives: Preferences and Value Tradeoffs” (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
42.
KleindorferP RKunreutherH CSchoemakerP J H, 1993Decision Sciences: An Integrative Perspective (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
43.
LiebmanJ C, 1975, “Models in solid waste management”, in A Guide to Models in Governmental Planning and Operations Eds GassSSissonR (Sauger Books, Potomac, MD) chapter 5
44.
LundJ R, 1990, “Least cost scheduling of solid waste recycling”ASCE Journal of Environmental Engineering116182–197
45.
LundJ RTchobanoglousGAnexR PLawverR A, 1994, “Linear programming for analysis of material recovery facilities”ASCE Journal of Environmental Engineering1201082–1094
46.
MacDonaldM, 1996, “Bias issues in the utilization of solid waste indicators”Journal of the American Planning Association62236–242
47.
MarksD HLiebmanJ C, 1971, “Location models: solid waste collection example”ASCE Journal of Urban Planning and Development97(1) 15–30
OpenshawB WWhiteheadP, 1985, “A Monte Carlo simulation approach to solving multicriteria optimization problems related to plan making, evaluation, and monitoring in local planning”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design12321–334
50.
PierrevalHTautouL, 1997, “Using evolutionary algorithms and simulation for the optimization of manufacturing systems”IIE Transactions29(3) 181–189
51.
RavindranAPhillipsD TSolbergJ J, 1987Operations Research—Principles and Practice (John Wiley, New York)
52.
ReevesC R, 1993Modern Heuristic Techniques for Combinatorial Problems (John Wiley, New York)
53.
ReynoldsA PMcKeownG P, 1999, “Scheduling a manufacturing plant using simulated annealing and simulation”Computers and Industrial Engineering3763–67
54.
Rubenstein-MontanoBZandiI, 1999, “Application of a genetic algorithm to policy planning: the case of solid waste”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design26893–907
55.
TchobanoglousGThiesenHVigilS, 1993Integrated Solid Waste Management: Engineering Principles and Management Issues (McGraw-Hill, New York)
WalkerW E, 1976, “A heuristic adjacent extreme point algorithm for the fixed charge problem”Management Science22587–596
58.
WallaceS W, 2000, “Decision making under uncertainty: is sensitivity analysis of any use?”Operations Research48(1) 20–25
59.
WangF SRichardsonF ARichardsonA JCurnowR C, 1994, “SWIM-interactive software for continuous improvement of solid waste management”Journal of Resource Management and Technology22(2) 63–72
60.
WengerR BCruz-UribeB W, 1990, “Mathematical models in solid waste management: a survey”, paper presented at the TIMS/ORSA Las Vegas Conference
61.
YehS C, 1996Grey Linear Programming and Its Application to Water Resources Management PhD dissertation, School of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY
62.
YoogalingamR, 2001Applications of Evolutionary Algorithms and Simulation to Decision Making Under Uncertainty PhD dissertation proposal, Schulich School of Business, Toronto, Ontario
